How much of a tax return do you get?

Forum Opinion Poll
We end up owing 13 11.71%
Break even - $1000 6 5.41%
$1001-$4999 29 26.13%
$5K-$9999 36 32.43%
$10K-$14,999 21 18.92%
Over $15K 6 5.41%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Please help settle a debate with someone. I think we get a decent tax return every year. I also think, that's not necessarily good. We should get something for sure - we're a 2 income family, homeowners, 2 kids, and they're in daycare, and do home renovations annually that contribute to our return, etc. But I don't believe in getting major tax returns b/c that means something is not right.

Obviously there are a ton of variables in getting your return. But my DH seems to think other families in similar situations are getting a LOT more back than us and perhaps our accountant is doing something wrong.

So, if you don't mind participating in a poll....

Message edited 2011-02-17 10:01:45.060000.

Posted 2/17/11 9:57 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

we were in your situation. The daycare really made a huge difference in our tax return. We got a lot more money back when DS was in daycare. we still have a decent amount of money back but we also declare no dependent. I just can't think that I may owe so we essentially overpay all year in our paycheck tax deduction.

Posted 2/17/11 10:14 AM
 

lullabella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2246 total posts

Name:

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Whar do home rennovations have to do with your tax return? What can you claim?

Posted 2/17/11 10:14 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

I think you are doing something right if you are getting modest refunds. Huge refunds just mean you are giving the gov't an interest free loan with money you could have saved, invested or spent during the year. If someone else is getting much higher refund then you guys, it's because they pay much more then they need to in advance. Like you said, everyone's situation is different even if they appear to be the same on the surface.

Message edited 2011-02-17 10:19:48.570000.

Posted 2/17/11 10:15 AM
 

caps612
In love with my little guys!!

Member since 8/10

5108 total posts

Name:

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

I am guessing you mean tax "refund"? Its so hard to compare, everyone takes different exemptions to take more upfront and get a refund later or withhold less and end up owing or getting less of a refund. Everyone also has different taxes, mortage interest, credits, etc!

Posted 2/17/11 10:15 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

When we got married we saw a big change - turns out my payroll dept. wasn't taking a lot out (around 11%) so we owed. I changed my W4 so we'll see what happens this year. I don't think our accountant is missing anything... he tried to get us all the deductions we are entitled to but it's not like he's going to make stuff up, KWIM?

Posted 2/17/11 10:17 AM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by lullabella

Whar do home rennovations have to do with your tax return? What can you claim?



New door, new windows, etc. Things that improve the energy efficiency I believe. I think it's a $1500 cap though.

Posted 2/17/11 10:17 AM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Just because people are getting more of a refund does not mean they are are making out better than you. It just means that they had more taken out during the year in their paychecks and had more deductions credits that they qualified for.

Technically, you are giving the gov't a loan of your money until refund time if you get money back.

Posted 2/17/11 10:19 AM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by neener1211

Just because people are getting more of a refund does not mean they are are making out better than you. It just means that they had more taken out during the year in their paychecks and had more deductions credits that they qualified for.

Technically, you are giving the gov't a loan of your money until refund time if you get money back.




yep. if you claim single 0 but are married w/ 3 kids of course you will get a lot back bc you paid too much during the year.

Posted 2/17/11 10:19 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by SweetCaroline

Posted by lullabella

Whar do home rennovations have to do with your tax return? What can you claim?



New door, new windows, etc. Things that improve the energy efficiency I believe. I think it's a $1500 cap though.




Yes --- there are Residential Energy credits you can claim on improvements, but they must meet standards according to the IRS. So it's not like you can say "I got a new boiler and I should get that back on my taxes." It would have to be one that is particular to the standards of the energy credit form.

Posted 2/17/11 10:22 AM
 

lullabella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2246 total posts

Name:

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by SweetCaroline

Posted by lullabella

Whar do home rennovations have to do with your tax return? What can you claim?



New door, new windows, etc. Things that improve the energy efficiency I believe. I think it's a $1500 cap though.



Oh ok, didnt realize that.

Posted 2/17/11 10:22 AM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by MrsPJB2007

Posted by SweetCaroline

Posted by lullabella

Whar do home rennovations have to do with your tax return? What can you claim?



New door, new windows, etc. Things that improve the energy efficiency I believe. I think it's a $1500 cap though.




Yes --- there are Residential Energy credits you can claim on improvements, but they must meet standards according to the IRS. So it's not like you can say "I got a new boiler and I should get that back on my taxes." It would have to be one that is particular to the standards of the energy credit form.




Right, obviously there are certain things that meet the requirements.

Posted 2/17/11 10:24 AM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by Meaghan729

Posted by neener1211

Just because people are getting more of a refund does not mean they are are making out better than you. It just means that they had more taken out during the year in their paychecks and had more deductions credits that they qualified for.

Technically, you are giving the gov't a loan of your money until refund time if you get money back.




yep. if you claim single 0 but are married w/ 3 kids of course you will get a lot back bc you paid too much during the year.



Right, I agree. And I know that this is comparing apples to oranges - we have no idea what another family claims or their arrangements, etc. Personally, I'd rather see my money when I need it - in my paychk!

Posted 2/17/11 10:25 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Well I owe. For the first time in 20yrs!!!

I just bought a house in 2010, AJ is in daycare, I have a 401k too.

Why do I owe? I made 3K back the year before and that's with NY filing too!


Oh that's because every year I adjust my withholding for about half a year to use the money instead. That is to say that I usually have 0 then use a higher number if I need to. Like when I bought my house, I needed that cash. Normally it works out since I let them take so much out and never zero out my fed withholdings for more than 5m.

Oh but wait.. who forgot about "making work pay" ?? that would be me!

Because the fed withholding was less last year I didn't have enough put aside. Even tho I left hubby's alone, my adjustment hurt us. Even with the house and all of our credits and deductions. I owe.

Chat Icon

*sigh* I know. My fault, blah blah but it doesn't mean I can't be upset about it.

Oh and making work pay expired so our fed withholding is back up again. Chat Icon


PS: I just adjusted my W4 again to stop fed withholding from my check. I'm using that extra cash to pay for my taxes! Ah the irony!

Posted 2/17/11 10:27 AM
 

Peaches77
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

993 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

It's really comparing apples and oranges when you compare yourself to other people "in the same situation" as yourselves.

Yes. You might be in the same situation. In terms of children, daycare, owning a home, etc.

However, unless you know specific details about these other people, it is very hard to say that you're in a similar situation.

You may claim Married, so many dependents on your W-9. They may claim Single, O and therefore, will get a larger refund.

There other deductions (i.e. daycare expenses, mortgage interest, real estate taxes) could be significantly different than yours although you both have them.

There are just so many other factors and each tax situation is unique. Don't think your accountant is doing a bad job based on a comparison to someone else. You should look at your accountant and assume they are doing a bad job based on your situation and your situation alone.

Posted 2/17/11 10:29 AM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

We get a very large refund every year but we both claim 0 Single and have 2 kids, daycare, home, student loans etc. I understand that we are giving the govt our money interest free for the year. People tell us all the time we are crazy but this is what works for US.

I know that if we changed it the extra money each paycheck would be lost in the mix. Doing it this way allows us to save for things like a new fence or washer and dryer. I know there are other ways for us to do this put again we are doing what works for our family.

Posted 2/17/11 10:30 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

My DH is just like yours... he hears that his brother is getting 5, 6, 7k back and he doesn't own a home, has 2 kids but not in day care and he wonders why not us.. although I have no idea what we're getting back this year.

Hopefully with DS as our new addition we'll get a bit of a windfall because I could use it right now.. and then I'll go adjust my exemptions for next year because I really need it in MY pocket and not the governments.

Posted 2/17/11 10:31 AM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

we get a decent amount back.

but you never want to get any money back, really. it's giving the government a tax free loan.

Posted 2/17/11 10:33 AM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by saraH

we get a decent amount back.

but you never want to get any money back, really. it's giving the government a tax free loan.



DH and I live very frugally, so we save a lot every month. I would prefer to get the money in our weekly paychecks.

But for some people, its almost a forced savings. They use that money for a vacation, a home reno, etc. So depending on your lifestyle, I can see both ways working.

Posted 2/17/11 10:52 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

i think there are a lot of variables that contribute to getting a refund..income & the tax bracket you are in, what you claim on your w4, deductions etc.

I will say that now that we own a house and write off the mortgage interest and property taxes is a huge benefit to us.

I think this year we will wind up with about $2000 back from fed. Its sometimes more, but I took a 401Kloan that was distributed out of there when I quit my job, so there are penalties involved in that.

If you get huge refunds, then someone is probably taking out way more taxes than need be from their checks every week.

Posted 2/17/11 11:12 AM
 

skinny
3 boys and a princess!

Member since 11/08

8178 total posts

Name:
Momma

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

I didn't change my exemptions when the boys were born so we are getting a lot back.

Posted 2/17/11 11:16 AM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by Peainapod

If you get huge refunds, then someone is probably taking out way more taxes than need be from their checks every week.



Exactly. OP, you're right in thinking that big refunds are not necessarily a good thing. I mean, sure it's a thrill to see a large lump sum of money once a year, but as others have already pointed out, it also means you could've been getting that cash incrementally in your paycheck all along.

Posted 2/17/11 11:28 AM
 

TreAnt427
-

Member since 8/06

8652 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

Posted by Katareen


But for some people, its almost a forced savings. They use that money for a vacation, a home reno, etc. So depending on your lifestyle, I can see both ways working.




That is what I see it as. The reason we get a big return is b/c we both still claim 0 and have a pretty new mortgage that we pay a lot of interest on. This was also the first year claiming DD and daycare.

Every year we take our return and do something to the house with it. This year we plan on doing a PVC fence, IG sprinklers and re-siding our garage.

Sure, I can claim married and 1 dependant and get less back, but I would never be able to do any renovations to my house.

Yes, they are geting an interest free loan from me, but I know I wouldn't save it otherwise. And the IRS also gave us an interest free loan when I got the $7500 rebate.

It's all a matter of preference to me. And I prefer to let them hold my money and get more back.

Posted 2/17/11 11:42 AM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

You have FM!

Posted 2/17/11 11:42 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Another Tax Return Question (Poll)

we have no kids just a house and we got back 4K .

Posted 2/17/11 12:26 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Tax return question - regarding debt.. Bluepixie 3/22/09 2 Families Helping Families ™
Have a Tax Return question julz33 2/9/09 4 Families Helping Families ™
tax return question want2beamom 12/30/08 3 Home
Tax Return Question. Pumpkin 6/11/07 2 Families Helping Families ™
another tax return question klingklang77 1/5/07 5 Families Helping Families ™
random tax return question DDB336 4/10/06 5 Families Helping Families ™