Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

Posted By Message

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

Does anyone (not Jewish) want to/try to give your DC an Easter basket? What do you say? My girlfriend had mentioned wanting to make Jordan a basket and I told her I'd prefer if she didn't. Not like he is going to "get it" at 15 months regardless but I guess I just don't want to start it. I know if we were visiting in NY my in-laws would give him a basket, but they've have difficulties respecting that I'm not their religion all alongChat Icon they're not Jewish.

I actually remember my Nana (Jewish) giving us chocolate bunnies when we were really young.Chat Icon

Posted 4/8/11 8:08 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

My parents let me take pics with the Easter Bunny in hopes of not having a melt down in the mall by there wonderfully behaved daughter that went to YeshivaChat Icon I wouldn't have a problem with a friend doing it, if it's in laws or relatives that weren't respecting my wishes it would be something else

Posted 4/8/11 8:13 AM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

Hmmm... that's tough. Maybe b/c I grew up in a predominantly reform Jewish area I never really wanted one. Although I LOVE Xmas time. I always celebrated Xmas with friend's families, but never brought it into my home. Decorate the tree and all too.

I think it's one thing to go and buy Easter candy (which I do b/c who doesn't love Starburst Jelly beans or Cadbury eggs), but to make a whole Easter basket is too much. I wouldn't want one for my son.

Although my MIL sent a Purim basket to DS (even though he's still young). Hamantashen isn't the same

Chat Icon

Posted 4/8/11 8:14 AM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

if your ILS are not Jewish, do they celebrate Easter? if so, i see nothing wrong with them giving your DS an Easter Basket, unless of course your DH is against it as well, and he has switched religions.

i grew up catholic, but celebrated all the jewish holidays, went to temple with my father and his side of the family. my mother respected that she married a man with a different faith and even though they agreed to raise my brother and I catholic, we still celebrated and respected the "other" faith.

so i see nothing wrong, because you even said your son wont understand, he is 15 months. and when he does, and the baskets continue, explain this is how others celebrate their religion and they are just wanting to give you a gift.

Posted 4/8/11 8:22 AM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

last year DS was 6 months for Easter and my MIL (Jewish, but my SFIL is not) wanted to get DS an Easter basket. I'm like...uh, no. Why would you give a Jewish kid an Easter basket?? I didn't mean to come off rude, but I've never had an Easter basket in my life and yet I still respect all holidays. But it's not MY holiday so why should my son (who's fully Jewish) get an Easter basket??

this year the daycare is doing an Easter breakfast on Sunday with the parents and grandparents. We're going and we'll celebrate, and DS will take home what they give him, but we will not be giving him an Easter basket. He'll learn that other people have holidays that we don't celebrate but it doesnt mean we can't join in their celebrations.

ETA about your ILs...since they're not Jewish (assuming your DH isn't either), maybe they just want Jordan to know their side? Even tho Jordan is Jewish, maybe he can understand how his dad grew up?

Message edited 2011-04-08 08:36:57.613000.

Posted 4/8/11 8:34 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

I don't see an issue with it since they are just including him in the celebration-especially for the inlaws.

This is a part of his heritage too and while I agree that if you and DH decided that you will raise your kids as Jewish that you wouldn't provide Easter basket or Christmas presents or a tree etc. I understand that completely-but for someone else to give him a basket or a Christmas present as a token of their holiday and well wishes, I don't have an issue with that-especially coming from his grandparents.

But, I'm not Jewish and I don't know what it is like to have to teach your children your faith in a world filled with bunnies and chicks and santa and elves. I could see not wanting to confuse your child.

Posted 4/8/11 9:49 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

I'm usually lax about most things, but for this kind of thing I'm not. Maybe when Alex was younger, and didn't understand, ok, but now that she's older and specifically in a jewish preschool where she's learning about jewish culture and religion, and comes home daily with questions about her identity, the jewish faith, the culture, etc., I am hell bent on helping her understand her background. At this age, she is ALREADY so incredibly confused about the difference between jewish and christian holidays and asks questions about it all the time, I want to avoid confusing her any further.

So, for example, when someone at work gave us an Easter book, I didn't bring it home. I'm trying, at this young impressionable age, to really filter in as much about jewish faith as I can before she goes to public school. Probably when she's older and has a firmer foundation in her own religion and culture, then I'll be ready to expose her more to other cultures, but not right now while I'm setting the foundation for her.

Posted 4/8/11 10:03 AM
 

haveaquestion
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

918 total posts

Name:

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

Posted by pickles16

My parents let me take pics with the Easter Bunny in hopes of not having a melt down in the mall by there wonderfully behaved daughter that went to YeshivaChat Icon I wouldn't have a problem with a friend doing it, if it's in laws or relatives that weren't respecting my wishes it would be something else


LOL. I'm Catholic and I never had my picture taken with the Easter bunny.

Posted 4/8/11 10:47 AM
 

Purplegirl77
i love my kids!

Member since 1/09

1963 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

I was brought up reform Jewish (both parents Jewish)MMMmy dad hung xmas stockings lol....DH is Catholic & we baptised DD...she will be primaly raised Catholic (DH is more religious than me) but will celebrate both holidays b/c that's what we are. For me it is more abt tradition. I love that DD gets both. She is only 18 months soshe def doesn't get it now but it makes DH & I happy doing both. Maybe your friend & inlaws can do the basket very basic? Or mixed w/ easter & passover stuff in it?

Posted 4/8/11 11:47 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Another Question for the Jewish Mommies - this time about Easter...

DS is 2 and this is the first time he'll be getting a small Easter basket. Although he'll be raised Jewish (my religion), he'll celebrate Christmas and Easter with DH's family. They're not religious at all. I personally don't mind if DS does an egg hunt, has a Christmas stocking at FIL's house, etc. If I didn't feel that way, I'd want our families to respect our wishes.

Posted 4/9/11 6:39 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Question for 1st time mommies HomeIsWithU 8/14/08 5 Pregnancy
a bed time question for twin mommies msrsfeb 1/8/08 13 Multiple Births
First time mommies - due date question... itsbabytime 6/12/07 2 Parenting
Question for the Jewish Mommies about Passover mrswask 4/8/11 12 Parenting
Jewish mommies - Passover question sunflowerjesss 3/30/10 2 Parenting
Jewish mommies - baby naming question spa118 3/16/10 6 Parenting