Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Another car buying question: WWYD?

If you were considering buying a brand new car that you liked but didn't love, and found a used car with 20,000 miles on it for the same price as the new car and that you liked better, which would you choose? I feel like for the amount we'd be spending it would be nice to have a brand new car with 0 miles and we'd get to pick the color and extra options and all, and have the peace of mind that we're the first owners. But 20,000 miles is pretty low, right? And we're ok with the color of the used car. Ok with it, don't love it but can live with it. And overall like the look and size of the used one better.

If it was your decision, which one would you buy?

Posted 2/26/14 12:01 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

FTM427
LIF Adult

Member since 1/12

1261 total posts

Name:

Another car buying question: WWYD?

20k is very low miles. Are the insurance rates the same for both? That might make a big difference. I'd probably go with the used

Posted 2/26/14 12:08 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Another car buying question: WWYD?

I'd always go with the new one. My family hasn't had the best experiences with used so I'm jaded.

Also, what's the warranty like on the used one? Why are they selling it with such low miles?

Posted 2/26/14 12:15 PM
 

ISpoilHim
I think I got this

Member since 11/10

1523 total posts

Name:
K

Another car buying question: WWYD?

Have you considered the MPG of both vehicles?

Posted 2/26/14 12:35 PM
 

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by ElizaRags35

I'd always go with the new one. My family hasn't had the best experiences with used so I'm jaded.

Also, what's the warranty like on the used one? Why are they selling it with such low miles?



It's off a lease.

But even with low miles it makes me a little nervous since we have no idea how the previous owner treated it.

Posted 2/26/14 12:36 PM
 

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by ISpoilHim

Have you considered the MPG of both vehicles?



That's the other thing, the used one gets worse mpg. So that's another factor we're weighing in making our decision.

Posted 2/26/14 12:37 PM
 

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by FTM427

20k is very low miles. Are the insurance rates the same for both? That might make a big difference. I'd probably go with the used



I'm pretty sure the insurance rates would be pretty close but we'll definitely double check. That's a good point.

Posted 2/26/14 12:41 PM
 

Maybe-Baybe
My Sunshine

Member since 7/12

3415 total posts

Name:
My only Sunshine

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

The new one.

Posted 2/26/14 12:42 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by LiveItUp

Posted by ElizaRags35

I'd always go with the new one. My family hasn't had the best experiences with used so I'm jaded.

Also, what's the warranty like on the used one? Why are they selling it with such low miles?



It's off a lease.

But even with low miles it makes me a little nervous since we have no idea how the previous owner treated it.



If you are serious about it, have a mechanic that you trust check it out. My sister's bf is looking for a used car and his mechanic has found things wrong that haven't shown up on any carfax and the sellers obviously didn't mention anything.

Posted 2/26/14 12:50 PM
 

olive98
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/12

791 total posts

Name:

Another car buying question: WWYD?

Message edited 2014-02-26 12:59:16.030000.

Posted 2/26/14 12:54 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Another car buying question: WWYD?

New one. I don't buy used cars because I don't want someone else issues.

Posted 2/26/14 1:18 PM
 

KevinNKristin8-15-08
Welcome to the world Chase

Member since 9/08

6162 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Another car buying question: WWYD?

Definitely the new one especially since you mention the used one gets worse mpg. I've had a slew of problems with used cars, so my opinion is biased. I don't want someone else's problem.

Posted 2/26/14 1:23 PM
 

KaKa2323
Got my miracle

Member since 9/11

1465 total posts

Name:
K

Another car buying question: WWYD?

Definitely the new one.

Posted 2/26/14 1:30 PM
 

jams92

Member since 1/12

6105 total posts

Name:

Another car buying question: WWYD?

i have had bad experiences with used cars so even though the mileage is low, i would opt for a new car
you never know about the previous owners, smoking, garage kept, repairs, maintenance etc
i brought a used car off a lease, and thankfully got a warranty bc i went through 4 transmissions! the car was a lemon; i am sure its not common, but it happened to me once so i wouldnt do it again

Posted 2/26/14 1:33 PM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

This is exactly what happened to us. We opted for a fairly used car with 23K miles on it that we LOVED and that had everything that we wanted.

Posted 2/26/14 4:02 PM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by MST9106

This is exactly what happened to us. We opted for a fairly used car with 23K miles on it that we LOVED and that had everything that we wanted.



We did the same - it saved us a lot of $$.

The only thing about CPO though is that the tires and brakes on the car are not new so you may have to replace them earlier than you would on a brand new car. Pilots need new tires approx every 30k (which is what the person at Honda told me - we got them around 45k.

Posted 2/26/14 4:13 PM
 

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by ali120206

Posted by MST9106

This is exactly what happened to us. We opted for a fairly used car with 23K miles on it that we LOVED and that had everything that we wanted.



We did the same - it saved us a lot of $$.

The only thing about CPO though is that the tires and brakes on the car are not new so you may have to replace them earlier than you would on a brand new car. Pilots need new tires approx every 30k (which is what the person at Honda told me - we got them around 45k.



I didn't know that about the tires needing to be replaced so often. Thanks, that's good to know.

Posted 2/26/14 4:29 PM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by LiveItUp

Posted by ali120206

Posted by MST9106

This is exactly what happened to us. We opted for a fairly used car with 23K miles on it that we LOVED and that had everything that we wanted.



We did the same - it saved us a lot of $$.

The only thing about CPO though is that the tires and brakes on the car are not new so you may have to replace them earlier than you would on a brand new car. Pilots need new tires approx every 30k (which is what the person at Honda told me - we got them around 45k.



I didn't know that about the tires needing to be replaced so often. Thanks, that's good to know.



We had the dealer give us new tires as part of the deal and we got new brakes about a year later. Other than that, we've been maintaining it regularly and its been treating us good thus far.

ETA: After buying this car I can tell you that I will never lease or buy a new car. For us, it would never make sense financially. Ours is also certified pre-owned.

Message edited 2014-02-27 11:32:24.157000.

Posted 2/26/14 4:41 PM
 

pumpkinmom
LIF Adult

Member since 5/12

2912 total posts

Name:

Another car buying question: WWYD?

I would only buy new after all the problems I had with the one used car I bought. I am having trouble picking my own new vehicle too. Nothing has all the features I want. : (

Posted 2/26/14 5:27 PM
 

LemonHead
Sour Girl

Member since 3/08

5271 total posts

Name:

Another car buying question: WWYD?

We always buy certified pre-owned from a dealership and have never had a problem. They come with a warranty if you but them from a dealership.

Posted 2/26/14 5:48 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by LemonHead

We always buy certified pre-owned from a dealership and have never had a problem. They come with a warranty if you but them from a dealership.



Us too

Posted 2/27/14 10:46 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

I swear i think this all depends on the make/model of the car.

We bought a Used 2005 toyota matrix in 2007 with like 25K miles on it. Its got 85Ki miles on it now 8 years later with nary a problem. toyotas are very reliable cars. as are Nissans. DH had a used nissan for about 8 years..never a problem.

However, my dad has bought used Mercury's & fords and even Dh had Ford Tempo, and they all had problems. One thing after another. DH's ford the engine just up and died one day.

FORD= Found on Road Dead..or at least thats always what we joked it stood for.

If you dont love either car, dont make a hasty decision. Used cars can be really good. Just a matter of finding the right one

Posted 2/27/14 11:07 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by Peainapod

I swear i think this all depends on the make/model of the car.

We bought a Used 2005 toyota matrix in 2007 with like 25K miles on it. Its got 85Ki miles on it now 8 years later with nary a problem. toyotas are very reliable cars. as are Nissans. DH had a used nissan for about 8 years..never a problem.

However, my dad has bought used Mercury's & fords and even Dh had Ford Tempo, and they all had problems. One thing after another. DH's ford the engine just up and died one day.

FORD= Found on Road Dead..or at least thats always what we joked it stood for.

If you dont love either car, dont make a hasty decision. Used cars can be really good. Just a matter of finding the right one



I would agree and go a step further depends on the car and the model and the year.

I NEVER EVER buy new. The depreciation is stupid! I always buy used with low mileage.

My 03 Mazda 6s I got with 8k miles and it was 2yrs old. It is 'just' about to roll over 89000.

My 01 Mazda Tribute was used in 05 with 36k miles on it. Now its over 136,000 and runs like a tank!

Among this, my friend got herself a brand new Mazda Protégé which I swear to god was cursed! Problems after problems after problems! It was crazy. Random electrical failures and strange things. She finally traded it in for a used Nissan Pilot. She was so happy she got a new Pilot to replace it later. She was scared of Mazda then went back and got a CX9 which she's thrilled with (new).

I have driven nothing but Mazdas since 1996 (when I got my 93 MX3) but that said I'm old enough to have driven a Ford, Mercury and Oldsmobile before that. Its all about how you care for the car, how you drive your car and what you expect out of it.

Ive turned down used cars because they were 'used'. The mileage was low but you could literally FEEL the abuse it had. We may be buying our first new car next year but I personally love used. They last so long, they are much easier to afford and given the right look over can be as good if not better than new!

Not having a car payment since 2009 has been WONDERFUL!

Id work on the price of that used car, if you like it and are happier with it, get it.

Message edited 2014-02-27 11:20:55.953000.

Posted 2/27/14 11:19 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by Peainapod

I swear i think this all depends on the make/model of the car.

We bought a Used 2005 toyota matrix in 2007 with like 25K miles on it. Its got 85Ki miles on it now 8 years later with nary a problem. toyotas are very reliable cars. as are Nissans. DH had a used nissan for about 8 years..never a problem.

However, my dad has bought used Mercury's & fords and even Dh had Ford Tempo, and they all had problems. One thing after another. DH's ford the engine just up and died one day.

FORD= Found on Road Dead..or at least thats always what we joked it stood for.

If you dont love either car, dont make a hasty decision. Used cars can be really good. Just a matter of finding the right one



I would agree with this. We almost needed a new car but were considering pre-owned. We would ONLY consider Hondas or Toyotas for preowned. However, because they are generally the most reliable doesn't mean that the previous owner didn't beat it up or cheap out on repairs or have an accident that wasn't reported. Luckily the issue with our car wasn't as bad as we anticipated and we didn't need a new or preowned one after all.

My sister's bf just had a Honda Accord w/ low mileage and an excellent carfax report inspected by his mechanic and apparently it had been in an unreported accident and had shoddy work done to it. It's being sold "in perfect condition" by a well known dealer on LI.

Posted 2/27/14 11:40 AM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Another car buying question: WWYD?

Posted by Peainapod

I swear i think this all depends on the make/model of the car.

We bought a Used 2005 toyota matrix in 2007 with like 25K miles on it. Its got 85Ki miles on it now 8 years later with nary a problem. toyotas are very reliable cars. as are Nissans. DH had a used nissan for about 8 years..never a problem.

However, my dad has bought used Mercury's & fords and even Dh had Ford Tempo, and they all had problems. One thing after another. DH's ford the engine just up and died one day.

FORD= Found on Road Dead..or at least thats always what we joked it stood for.

If you dont love either car, dont make a hasty decision. Used cars can be really good. Just a matter of finding the right one



I say new. We bought a 2 year old Nissan Murano back in 2006 and by 2008 had horrible issues with it to the tune of $7K in repairs. I think used cars are a crap shoot...you just never know.

Posted 2/27/14 11:54 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
WWYD? Car purchasing question Lina 2/10/11 4 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD? Car / bills / dog question greenfreak 7/27/09 18 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD: Car Question statusquoscreenname 6/25/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD? Buying a car nbc188 1/21/10 9 Parenting
Car buying question Preguntas 2/18/08 3 Families Helping Families ™
Another car buying question CaidensMommy 2/7/07 3 Families Helping Families ™