Alternative discipline -

Posted By Message

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Alternative discipline -

Aside from Time Outs how do you discipline DC? DS is 2.5 and while I think time outs are working (sometimes Chat Icon) what other methods have worked for you?

I think I need to change up my routine a bit.

TIA!

Posted 2/7/11 9:16 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Alternative discipline -

you do them like "super nanny"? just curious, not btdt, but I have no patience for anything and trying to prepare myself.

Posted 2/7/11 9:25 AM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Alternative discipline -

What type of behavior are you trying to change?

If DS doesn't want to clean up his toys - I tell him we'll throw them out of give them to his cousin

If he doesn't want to eat - I tell him no snacks for until the next meal

If he's fresh, I let him have his temper tantrum then got play with one of his toys and have a grand old time until he wants to be nice

Posted 2/7/11 9:35 AM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Alternative discipline -

I agree, it all depends upon the behavior. DS gets time outs for hitting and general aggressive behavior. The bad stuff--I don't use them that often actually.

On the other hand, he also hits people when he's happy and excited sometimes--not angry or aggressive at all really though still not what you want him to do. It's more a matter of innappropriate expression, so when he does that, I don't give him a time out. I show him a better way to show someone he likes them or to get their attention. We actually did use the time outs with this originally and got nowhere--then it struck me, he needs to know how to behave better in this case. He's not picking it up on his own.
And I agree with a PP, if they won't pick up toys, or if they are throwing a toy and don't listen, I take it away.

Posted 2/7/11 9:42 AM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: Alternative discipline -

Posted by nora101004

What type of behavior are you trying to change?

If DS doesn't want to clean up his toys - I tell him we'll throw them out of give them to his cousin

If he doesn't want to eat - I tell him no snacks for until the next meal

If he's fresh, I let him have his temper tantrum then got play with one of his toys and have a grand old time until he wants to be nice




This is an excellent question. There are a few things I am trying to correct.

When he yells at me or is being disrespectful. If I get down on his level and try to reason or explain something to him he jut yells louder and will be mean. Say things like "OUT MOMMY" or "NO MOMMMMMMMMMMYYYYYYY" Chat Icon

If I ask him to clean up all his cars and he ignores me. I have tried the "I'm going to put them in the garbage" and he didn't believe me. So I threw 2 out to teach him a lesson. What did he do? Threw out 2 more, but I think he thought he was "cleaning them up" even though he knows where they truly belong. He wasn't doing it to be fresh. Chat Icon

Food is never really an issue here.

Message edited 2011-02-07 09:46:41.230000.

Posted 2/7/11 9:42 AM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: Alternative discipline -

Also, if a friend is here and he is refusing to share. If I get on his level to explain he needs to share he will yell at me, tell me no, etc. So I will usually wind up doing a time out and that will band aid the situation.

But overall I am not feeling like he is "learning" from time outs.

Instead the time out is just allowing him a second to cool off and be more receptive to what I am telling him. But after months I haven't noticed it correcting the poor behavior. Does that make any sense?

Posted 2/7/11 9:45 AM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Alternative discipline -

I would ignore him if he is yelling, and tell him "We don't yell in this house. I will listen to you when you can speak nicely," or something to that effect. And don't do what he wants until he calms down and asks you nicely. DS gets this more or less now, but it takes a lot of repetition.

The toys, I would just keep repeating. I have never thrown out DSs toys, but I have put the toys in time outs, usually on top of our refrigerator where he can't get them. I tell him he can have them back when he calms down and shows me he's ready to play better. If he does this, he gets the toy back.

I think it's important to reward them somehow when they do modify their behavior to reinforce that is the good behavior you want to see. So that might be why throwing the toys out isn't working, though I'm not sure. Good luck!

Posted 2/7/11 9:47 AM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: Alternative discipline -

Posted by mommyIam

you do them like "super nanny"? just curious, not btdt, but I have no patience for anything and trying to prepare myself.




My patience have truly become limited since being pregnant with Chat Icon Chat Icon

But he knows where time out is. If I tell him to go to time out and he doesn't, I pick him up and put him there. He faces the wall and I stand with my back to him counting in my head. He never leaves time out unless I tell him he may. And before he does, I get down on his level and explain calmly why he was in time out and what he needs to do next time. Then he must apologize and give a hug/kiss.

Posted 2/7/11 9:48 AM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Alternative discipline -

Posted by sunflowerjesss

Also, if a friend is here and he is refusing to share. If I get on his level to explain he needs to share he will yell at me, tell me no, etc. So I will usually wind up doing a time out and that will band aid the situation.

But overall I am not feeling like he is "learning" from time outs.

Instead the time out is just allowing him a second to cool off and be more receptive to what I am telling him. But after months I haven't noticed it correcting the poor behavior. Does that make any sense?



You hit the nail on the head. I am not a fan of time outs for all misbehavior--I think it works best when a child is out of control and needs to calm down. But it doesn't show them how to share, etc.

Kids don't really get sharing for awhile, so I don't think it tells them much to say that you want them to share. I would model it, and try to find a game they can play together with turn-taking like tossing a ball or doing a puzzle together. Or if they are both fighting over the same toy, let them play with it individually for a short time. We used to clap and count to ten with this ride-on toy our kids would fight over (there was only one). They LOVED this, it became a big game, they learned to count better, and they didn't seem to notice they were sharing or didn't mind.

Posted 2/7/11 9:50 AM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: Alternative discipline -

Posted by cjik

You hit the nail on the head. I am not a fan of time outs for all misbehavior--I think it works best when a child is out of control and needs to calm down. But it doesn't show them how to share, etc.

Kids don't really get sharing for awhile, so I don't think it tells them much to say that you want them to share. I would model it, and try to find a game they can play together with turn-taking like tossing a ball or doing a puzzle together. Or if they are both fighting over the same toy, let them play with it individually for a short time. We used to clap and count to ten with this ride-on toy our kids would fight over (there was only one). They LOVED this, it became a big game, they learned to count better, and they didn't seem to notice they were sharing or didn't mind.



Thanks for all of the advice! I truly appreciate it. I just have my own hormones all over the map and dealing with a very difficult 2 year old is taking its toll on me. I keep saying to DH things need to change before the twins get here, but I know we have no control over that. I think I am just at the end of my rope. Its been a rough few weeks and I have seen no end in sight.

I am going to attempt this new approach of time outs less and just trying to use words to explain and such. I hope it works! Chat Icon

Posted 2/7/11 9:57 AM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Alternative discipline -

Sharing is really hard. I try to share my toys w/ DS. Since he is an only child, I'll buy 2 matchbox cars and one is mine. Then when we play, I'll share mine. I also share dinner or drinks.

I tell him that if he wants to go play w/ his friends or have his friends come over he has to share his toys. If he doesn't want to share a special toy we can put it away until "friend" leaves. But his friends won't want to play if he doesn't share.

We talk about it in the car - I think he is starting to get it.

Yesterday we went to the deli and got lunch. He got chips and wanted to get a bag for his "friend". Wasn't sure if he was being nice or so he didn't have to share his bag.

ETA: I've been told I talk to my son a lot... maybe b/c I'm bored in the car...anyway, I've explained to him that we have to stop at red lights b/c the other people have green lights and we all have to share... so, maybe if you can tell your DS about when you have to share it will help him share?

Not sure how you can use this but... my friend had 2 boys, 1 year apart - so they had to share a lot of toys. If they both wanted something, she'd set a timer and they each could play for 2-3 minutes then it was the other kids turn....

Message edited 2011-02-07 10:20:35.890000.

Posted 2/7/11 10:13 AM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Alternative discipline -

Posted by nora101004

What type of behavior are you trying to change?

If DS doesn't want to clean up his toys - I tell him we'll throw them out of give them to his cousin

If he doesn't want to eat - I tell him no snacks for until the next meal




I do the same.
I tell him I will throw out his toys, but then I also explain that he will never be able to play with them again, and we wont buy him any new toys!

Also if he is fresh, I send him to his room now. He hates that. I tell him to stay in there until he has calmed down and can be polite. He doesnt have any toys in there just books so sometimes he will sit and read the books other times he will just sit in the chair and cry until he yells "mommy I am done crying now"

Posted 2/7/11 10:20 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Alternative discipline -

Time outs.

Throw a toy out, put a toy in time out.

I turn off a show she is watching.

We won't go outside-she loves being outside.

I tell her we will have to leave, cancel a playdate, whatever is going on.


ETS: If she is having a tantrum and it's just us-I ignore her. If other people are over, I take her to a quiet place-bedroom usually-and tell her she can come back out when she calms down.

Message edited 2011-02-07 11:49:55.980000.

Posted 2/7/11 11:48 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Alternative discipline -

Throws something - I take it away.
If he misbehaves while tv is on, I will take away his tv time.
Time outs for the big stuff
I have also threaten him that he will go to bed if he doesn't do such and such.

So hard to disiplin a 2 year old.

Posted 2/7/11 12:47 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Alternative discipline -

Posted by LeShellem

Throws something - I take it away.
If he misbehaves while tv is on, I will take away his tv time.
Time outs for the big stuff
I have also threaten him that he will go to bed if he doesn't do such and such.

So hard to disiplin a 2 year old.



To each his own, but I was told not to punish w/ bed time b/c then bed time is like a punishment even if its a good day/regular bed time.

Posted 2/7/11 1:25 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Alternative discipline -

Time outs only work when you are removing something they find reinforcing as a consequences for their behavior. This is why they don't work when people say they don't work.....

As for discipline in general, the punishment fits the crime.

If he is throwing a toy and doesn't respond to no or stop, the toy gets taken away.

If he is watching a favorite show and is misbehaving, and can't be redirected, TV show gets turned off.

This all worked for me. Time outs only work when he is doing something inappropriate to get access to something or my attention. We also do this when we go out to playgrounds, restaurants, or stores. He hasn't had a time out in about six months. This is down from weekly when he was 18 mts to two years old.... Lol...

At three, I started a sticker chart for when he is caught being good. The sticker chart isn't a threat, and really, it is rarely mentioned until he is caught doing great listening. It takes him two weeks to a month to earn ten stickers, and then he gets a reward. He loves it and looks forward to planning what he wants for his ten stickers.

Posted 2/7/11 3:39 PM
 

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: Alternative discipline -

Posted by lipglossjunky73

Time outs only work when you are removing something they find reinforcing as a consequences for their behavior. This is why they don't work when people say they don't work.....




Can you explain this more?

I know I use time outs way too much and they are not working.

What kind of instances are appropriate for a time out?

Posted 2/7/11 4:12 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Alternative discipline -

I agree it depends on the behavior and why she is acting out. I believe that in order to feel secure children need some limits, boundaries and consequences for stepping outside the set rules. I also believe that many times there is a cause for the behavior and it is important to be emotionally aware of why a child may be acting out. I always start by explaining why we have to discipline her and how she can avoid the consequence in the future. In some circumstances I will reason with her and try not to use any other form of discipline if I can get her to apologize and correct the behavior.

Posted 2/7/11 4:50 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How would you discipline your toddler if he/she hits you, bites you and pinches you out of anger? adeline27 9/9/09 12 Parenting
Can you please share your form of discipline for your toddler ..... babybugsmum 7/22/09 5 Parenting
how can i educate myself on the different methods of discipline? bonitachyc 7/19/09 5 Parenting
tell me about your discipline techniques in your 16-18 month old... jes81276 5/25/09 3 Parenting
I'm upset right now (almost in tears) & need advice on how to discipline an 18 month old adeline27 4/4/09 13 Parenting
Do you allow other people to discipline your child? (kind of long story) greenybeans 2/14/08 9 Parenting