Re: Alternative discipline -
Posted 2/7/2011 9:50:52 AM by cjik


Posted by sunflowerjesss

Also, if a friend is here and he is refusing to share. If I get on his level to explain he needs to share he will yell at me, tell me no, etc. So I will usually wind up doing a time out and that will band aid the situation.

But overall I am not feeling like he is "learning" from time outs.

Instead the time out is just allowing him a second to cool off and be more receptive to what I am telling him. But after months I haven't noticed it correcting the poor behavior. Does that make any sense?



You hit the nail on the head. I am not a fan of time outs for all misbehavior--I think it works best when a child is out of control and needs to calm down. But it doesn't show them how to share, etc.

Kids don't really get sharing for awhile, so I don't think it tells them much to say that you want them to share. I would model it, and try to find a game they can play together with turn-taking like tossing a ball or doing a puzzle together. Or if they are both fighting over the same toy, let them play with it individually for a short time. We used to clap and count to ten with this ride-on toy our kids would fight over (there was only one). They LOVED this, it became a big game, they learned to count better, and they didn't seem to notice they were sharing or didn't mind.
Print Post      Close Window