A question that I've always wondered about

Posted By Message

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

A question that I've always wondered about

For the record this is NOT meant to start crap, I'm honestly asking this here because I feel this community is diverse enough to get accurate answers.

I will ask it by using examples

Mariah Carey
Alicia Keys
Tiger Woods
Barack Obama

When a person is bi-racial why does it seem more common for them to identify with being African American rather than the other component of their race even if they were not raised by the African American members of their bio-family?
My best friends niece is 10, my friend has raised the child. The child's bio-mom is Caucasian, the bio-dad is African American. The dad has never seen the child except one time when she was a few days old, he gave up custody and his extended family chose not to have vistitation. She has lived only with Caucasian members of her family and I've always wondered since race is not an issue for her family if she even considers herself both.
I'm wondering from adult LIFers that are bi-racial or have other insight how a person 'defines' themselves.
Is it based on how they look? Is it based on cultural values?
Now more than ever with our first African American (and Caucasian) president I'm really curious about how this works.
My hope for our country is that someday we will no longer be identified by our race.

Posted 11/5/08 8:55 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

janet
WITH LOVE MY ANGEL MISS YOU!!!

Member since 5/05

12823 total posts

Name:
janet

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

i am glad you posted this because i was wondering the same thing

Posted 11/5/08 9:02 AM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

I've had this discussion with many friends of mixed heritage and it seems that based on their expereince most of the African American community is more apt to embrace a child of mixed heritage so that is who they identify with. I have a caucasian friend who is raising her biracial daughter and makes a point to let her know that she is both heritages (black & white) BUT society will usually define her by her outside appearance (light skinned AA) so thats just how the child identifies herself as AA.

Message edited 2008-11-05 09:16:41.517000.

Posted 11/5/08 9:15 AM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

Ever since I came to the US I have wondered the sameChat Icon Especially now that Obama is a president. People (including himself) keep referring to him as a black man, when in fact he is black and whiteChat Icon I was always too embarrassed to ask the Q so thanks for posting this. Can''t wait to see the replies.

Posted 11/5/08 9:17 AM
 

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

great question

Posted 11/5/08 9:18 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

Posted by sometimesmommy

I've had this discussion with many friends of mixed heritage and it seems that based on their expereince most of the African American community is more apt to embrace a child of mixed heritage so that is who they identify with. I have a caucasian friend who is raising her biracial daughter and makes a point to let her know that she is both heritages (black & white) BUT society will usually define her by her outside appearance (light skinned AA) so thats just how the child identifies herself as AA.



thank you for the reply.
I personally think mixed race people are among the most beautiful & interesting people. I can't wait until the day we are all so 'mixed' that we aren't asked to define ourselves as anything other than HUMAN.
FTR I'm part American Indian but mostly caucasian, if I'm asked I always check both.

Posted 11/5/08 9:20 AM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

many african americans are already mixed, hence the difference in "shade" of skin color.

as somone who comes from a mixed world... i'm cuban/dominican. my backgroud is of all shades of color. all i can bring to the table is: no matter how far we've come in judging by the character of a person rather than what they look like... what they look like is how we describe them.

not too long ago, if you were 1/4 black, you were considered black... that's it. no questions asked.

i don't know if i've rambled or if i've made sense, but these are the first "gut" reaction/thoughts that cross my mind when i think of the question.

Posted 11/5/08 9:33 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

I think a lot of it also comes down to the way people appear from the outside.

I will say that from my experience, most people who would be considered both African American and White are going to have features that would make most people assume they are black just based on looking at them. So I would imagine that maybe (and I am just guessing here) if you have the darker skin tone and other features that people associate with being black, those individuals might identify stronger with being black.

On the flip side, however, I only have to look at my own DH to see the other side. His mother is white and his father is African American and Native American. Yet my DH is as white as I am. If you put him side by side with my FIL, they are night and day. So people looking at my DH would never assume that he is at all "black".

So for me, I think there are probably lots of other things that go into it, but I think appearance has a lot to do with it. Good old genetics.

Posted 11/5/08 9:34 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

Posted by libby2595

many african americans are already mixed, hence the difference in "shade" of skin color.

as somone who comes from a mixed world... i'm cuban/dominican. my backgroud is of all shades of color. all i can bring to the table is: no matter how far we've come in judging by the character of a person rather than what they look like... what they look like is how we describe them.

not too long ago, if you were 1/4 black, you were considered black... that's it. no questions asked.

i don't know if i've rambled or if i've made sense, but these are the first "gut" reaction/thoughts that cross my mind when i think of the question.



I must have been posting at the same time as you... with the exact same thoughts!!! Chat Icon

Posted 11/5/08 9:35 AM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

i think it has a lot to do with who they are raised by/how they are raised, and not so much what they look like. the whole nuture vs. nature thing...
my uncle is white, but married an African American women. ( she passed away from cancer about 1 1/2 years ago Chat Icon ). When they met, she already had a 3 year old daughter who is 100 % A.A. THEN, they had a daughter together- so she is 1/2 white, 1/2 AA
the oldest daughter who is AA is now 15... she has gone to private school with mostly white girls her whole time in school, so obviously most of her friends are white, and it seems like she identifies more with whites.
the younger one is 6 ( still makes me sad to think of a 6 year old without her mommy Chat Icon ).... its still too young to tell, but she goes to the same school as the older one, so i imagine she'll identify more with white people as well.

Message edited 2008-11-05 09:48:31.637000.

Posted 11/5/08 9:47 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

I was actually thinking about posting this too. I am curious if there is anyone here who is bi or multi racial to hear their opinion on it.

I remember Tiger Woods on Oprah when he was young & just being recognized in golf & he said that when he was a kid, he would call him self "Cablinasian"basically he mixed all his heritages together & made up his own word.

Oprah sort of cut him off & emphasized that he only thought that as a kid, and now identifes as black. I thought that was wrong. It was like she was speaking for him & making sure she didn't offend any black viewers.

I have read interviews with Mariah Carey where she says she was never really accepted by either group growing up.

Edited to add the word Tiger has used.

Message edited 2008-11-05 10:03:58.787000.

Posted 11/5/08 9:58 AM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

I wonder this too purely out of curiosity.

Posted 11/5/08 10:03 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

I maybe making assumptions here, so if anyone would like to correct me please do.
Alicia Keys was raised only by her white mother but grew up in NYC in a very diverse area so while she looks Caucasian (to me) I can see how she felt her life was influenced by AA culture & people.
President-elect Obama was raised primarily by his white grandparents and had very little connection to his AA family but his wife is AA so maybe he has embraced her family's culture.
I still wonder though, if I were his Grandmother that raised him if I would consider him AA OR bi-racial.
Even though I'm technically mixed race its not obivious by looking at me so my perceptions maybe totally off base.
I just personally never let go of my AI heritage, I never consider myself just white. I think Pres elect Obama has such a wonderful opportunity to bring races together by recognizing BOTH sides of his family background.

Message edited 2008-11-05 10:22:22.750000.

Posted 11/5/08 10:21 AM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

Posted by KellyFG

I maybe making assumptions here, so if anyone would like to correct me please do.
Alicia Keys was raised only by her white mother but grew up in NYC in a very diverse area so while she looks Caucasian (to me) I can see how she felt her life was influenced by AA culture & people.
President-elect Obama was raised primarily by his white grandparents and had very little connection to his AA family but his wife is AA so maybe he has embraced her family's culture.
I still wonder though, if I were his Grandmother that raised him if I would consider him AA OR bi-racial.
Even though I'm technically mixed race its not obivious by looking at me so my perceptions maybe totally off base.
I just personally never let go of my AI heritage, I never consider myself just white. I think Pres elect Obama has such a wonderful opportunity to bring races together by recognizing BOTH sides of his family background.



my thoughts:
obama's grandmother never saw him as black or white... she saw her grand-son. PERIOD. he could have been purple with green polka dots. he would have still received the love she had to give.

also, i think you kind of answered your own question. you never let go of you AI heritage and you will never consider yourself just white. even if they are raised by the white half of their family, they can not let go or ignore that there is more to them.

Posted 11/5/08 10:34 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

Posted by sometimesmommy

I've had this discussion with many friends of mixed heritage and it seems that based on their expereince most of the African American community is more apt to embrace a child of mixed heritage so that is who they identify with. I have a caucasian friend who is raising her biracial daughter and makes a point to let her know that she is both heritages (black & white) BUT society will usually define her by her outside appearance (light skinned AA) so thats just how the child identifies herself as AA.



I have had similar discussions and this is pretty much what I was told too. I have also heard people who have mixed race backgrounds say that white people treat them as black, so in some way that is what they identify themselves with.

Posted 11/5/08 10:38 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

Posted by libby2595

Posted by KellyFG

I maybe making assumptions here, so if anyone would like to correct me please do.
Alicia Keys was raised only by her white mother but grew up in NYC in a very diverse area so while she looks Caucasian (to me) I can see how she felt her life was influenced by AA culture & people.
President-elect Obama was raised primarily by his white grandparents and had very little connection to his AA family but his wife is AA so maybe he has embraced her family's culture.
I still wonder though, if I were his Grandmother that raised him if I would consider him AA OR bi-racial.
Even though I'm technically mixed race its not obivious by looking at me so my perceptions maybe totally off base.
I just personally never let go of my AI heritage, I never consider myself just white. I think Pres elect Obama has such a wonderful opportunity to bring races together by recognizing BOTH sides of his family background.



my thoughts:
obama's grandmother never saw him as black or white... she saw her grand-son. PERIOD. he could have been purple with green polka dots. he would have still received the love she had to give.

also, i think you kind of answered your own question. you never let go of you AI heritage and you will never consider yourself just white. even if they are raised by the white half of their family, they can not let go or ignore that there is more to them.



Agreed, but I don't put the focus on the part of me that I didn't have an opportunity to live with first hand. As much as I've tried to learn about my AI heritage and as much as I've tried to carry on some cultural traditions I don't consider myself MOSTLY AI.

Posted 11/5/08 10:41 AM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

Its based on how they look, IMO.

For instance, my husband is Pakistani. I'm Greek/Russian.

Two of our children look Pakistani, two do not. In the Desi community, they are far more accepting of the two that look like them (even though they still don't look 100% Pakistani). I wouldn't be surprised if my children identified more with that side of themselves, simply because of the look.

Posted 11/5/08 10:54 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: A question that I've always wondered about

Posted by sometimesmommy

BUT society will usually define her by her outside appearance (light skinned AA) so thats just how the child identifies herself as AA.



I think this is the gist of it right here.

Posted 11/5/08 11:28 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
closing question and walk through question? nancygrace 1/6/07 3 Home
Not a TTC question, but a personal question Ambersmom 12/26/06 5 TTC
First question....now 2nd question... dree 10/27/06 10 Parenting
Paint Question (2nd question in org. post) MrsSchwags 10/5/06 12 Home
I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) luvsbob4603 6/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question Shelly 4/10/06 11 Parenting