A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by Mere09

The vendors should be working their best to make their customers happy and meet their needs. If they're not doing that and in result get a 'bad rating', then maybe that will trigger them to do a better job in the future. LIF should not be protecting them...I agree that it's not ethical.
I think a rating system is a FANTASTIC idea!



ITA agree! This is how business works! If you are a bad business person and word gets out you have two options - IMPROVE your business or get out. I completely agree that it is unethical for LIF to be protecting them and am confused why LIF would want to be associated with a business that people are unhappy with.

I think the rating system is a great tool to maintain the quality and respectability of the site.

Posted 9/20/09 9:22 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

sydniesmom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/08

700 total posts

Name:
susan

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I think its a wonderful idea!! Count me inChat Icon

Posted 9/20/09 10:14 PM
 

DomesticDeeva
Tiebreaker on deck!!!

Member since 11/08

2088 total posts

Name:
Dee

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I definately support it, here and on LIW, since I just got done with my wedding, and have some issues I would like to discuss in my review, however, I do not want it pulled.

Posted 9/20/09 11:07 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I've said it before and I will say it again. I would not be able to respond to either positive or negative reviews about my business because I am bound by confidentiality rules.

By having an internet presence as a lawyer, I put my name out there and I risk that someone can say something that I cannot respond to on a public forum. In some respects, I like the idea of a rating system but there would be no checks and balances for a law practice or a medical practice.

People get very annoyed if I do something as innocent as refusing to take their disability case, which can happen for a variety of reasons.

I know of no one on LIF who is looking to bash me but I must accept the fact that if it does happen, I would not be able to respond on LIF. I have to protect the confidentiality of anyone who even speaks to me about law.

Honestly, the vendors do not pay enough for Ron to provide a mediation service. I would have to go through other legal channels anyway.

LIF does not pull every single negative thread and let's face it, we all have a pretty good idea about the reputations of various vendors here.

I take pride in being an LIF vendor. Maybe a rating system is necessary for vendors to keep such pride but I have concerns as stated above.

I am sorry that some people are having bad experiences with a few vendors. We all may want to take a look at the business directory to see that a majority of the businesses have great reputations and most of them are not involved in any sort of "drama."

Posted 9/20/09 11:36 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Im all for it.

There are logistics that may not work but the alternative is to just stop using all vendors, period.

I was burned badly by a vendor and it wasn't the issue of being burned. We all take risk with businesses whether we find them here or on our own. My issue was that the site responded by taking sides (for a short while) As a result I trust none now.

I think keeping negative reviews factual and not emotional would help but thats next to impossible. However a simple anonymous grading of A-F with cumulative grade may be a good idea. No comment left, just an A-F status. If someone wants to know why a vendor has an overall D average they can post a thread (if you have used XYZ, please FM your comments)

Posted 9/21/09 9:13 AM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I'm all for a proper rating system if possible.

Posted 9/21/09 9:14 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

I've said it before and I will say it again. I would not be able to respond to either positive or negative reviews about my business because I am bound by confidentiality rules.



you do have to recognize, however, that you're in a unique situation, and not all vendors are bound by the same legal rules as you are.

in addition to the rating system, and if mediation is too expensive, then it really should not be to difficult for LIF to prevent users from "rating" a vendor who cannot defend themselves, such as someone like yourself.

and i will say this: i find it very telling (and this is not an attack on you at all Kerie) that there are several people posting on this thread who are vendors and will welcome a rating system - and there are several vendors who decline to comment at all on any thread regarding negative testimonials.

Posted 9/21/09 9:21 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I think it has come to a point that some clients are not happy and are basically not allowed to say so.

It leaves the rest of us with a sour taste in our mouth and now we feel that we might as well not hear the raves because we know they "could" be bad experiences.

I personally see many issues at hand.

- who gets to rate a vendor? I think only someone who had actually "purchase" a product should do so with documentation showing that they did indeed get such service.

- yes, vendors should have a chance to respond. But then Kerie who is a vendor will not be able to respond.

- should we trust LIF vendors because they are also posters or really think of them as vendors selling a business and do your homework?


Given the conflict of interests, I think it would be fair to be able to post a thread about a vendor and only ask for the answer to be FM.

Something like "if you have used X vendor, could you please FM me your feedback?" should be allowed.

That way, you get your feedback about a particular vendor, nobody is bashed publicly.

It will lean out the "looking for drama" people who have no intention to use some of those vendors anyway but "just want to know".

I think LIF does have to come clean on the issue though. It's not going to go away. And honestly, who is going to pay to join LIF?

Posted 9/21/09 9:27 AM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I am for it....

Posted 9/21/09 9:36 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by smdl

I think LIF does have to come clean on the issue though. It's not going to go away. And honestly, who is going to pay to join LIF?



i think this is what has a LOT of people very upset. vendor posts get pulled with no explanation. and although this debate has been going on for weeks LIF has yet to address it. we don't even have a set of rules to follow. and that upsets me.

i personally don't know if i would or would not pay for LIF. my inital reaction is no, but i've made so many good friends on here, and i know there are other people on here i'd like to get to know better, that i would miss it.

Posted 9/21/09 9:41 AM
 

MommyAgain
lovemygermies

Member since 6/08

3195 total posts

Name:

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system


and i will say this: i find it very telling (and this is not an attack on you at all Kerie) that there are several people posting on this thread who are vendors and will welcome a rating system - and there are several vendors who decline to comment at all on any thread regarding negative testimonials.


ITA..its usually that way.
(not for you keri, had no idea you were a vendor, and DO understand YOUR personal confidentiality issues.)

Posted 9/21/09 9:48 AM
 

SpencersMommy
I'm one lucky girl

Member since 11/07

3494 total posts

Name:
Melanie

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Spencersmommy

Posted 9/21/09 9:55 AM
 

Lucky09
2017!

Member since 1/06

7539 total posts

Name:
DW

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by dm24angel

I agree but here is how I think they will respond or basically how they feel and WHY this happens.

We don't pay to use this site....but it costs money and that money comes from the vendors fee's to advertise.

If everyone starts complaining about a certain vendor ( warrented or not) , or a vendor gets low ratings ....that vendors business from LIF members is going to go down...and then how does it pay that vendor to continue to pay to advertise on here , when they are not getting the same business as if they advertise somewhere else where theres no rating system?

Make sense?

So I think while it would be GREAT for us to be able to voice our opinions, the alternative to this is gonna be charging users to use this site so that they are still making money and I personally would rather not pay and just deal with the vendor frustration kwim?



I am all for a rating system, but unfortuantely I agree with the above.

Posted 9/21/09 10:08 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by Lucky09

Posted by dm24angel

I agree but here is how I think they will respond or basically how they feel and WHY this happens.

We don't pay to use this site....but it costs money and that money comes from the vendors fee's to advertise.

If everyone starts complaining about a certain vendor ( warrented or not) , or a vendor gets low ratings ....that vendors business from LIF members is going to go down...and then how does it pay that vendor to continue to pay to advertise on here , when they are not getting the same business as if they advertise somewhere else where theres no rating system?

Make sense?

So I think while it would be GREAT for us to be able to voice our opinions, the alternative to this is gonna be charging users to use this site so that they are still making money and I personally would rather not pay and just deal with the vendor frustration kwim?



I am all for a rating system, but unfortuantely I agree with the above.



I disagree with the above because a vendor (or ANY business whether on LIF or not) should make it a habit to provide good service, good quality, good product. If you're doing what you're suppose to be doing and providing the best possible product or service that you can then you as a vendor should have nothing to worry about. You should welcome any feedback, even negative, because it shows you where you can improve. I am a paying vendor on LIF and I would welcome a rating system and comments board with all feedback good or bad. I don't think the fact that I pay to advertise here should be "protection" from people's comments. I want to know what people have to say.

To the above post, if a vendors business goes down because of what people have to say about them then that is THEIR problem. For every junky vendor on here I'm sure there is a great one who will continue to pay to advertise on this site and get more business. IMO.........if there is a vendor that is so bad that all anyone does is provide negative feedback then maybe it's time that vendor rethink their business. It's NOT fair of LIF to only allow the praise and cheers for vendors on here without allowing the honest truth when someone isn't so happy with their vendor.

I don't see what us paying or not paying to be a member on LIF has do with wanting honest feedback. I think this whole thing lately is so ridiculous and honestly, if people can't be honest about their experiences here there are plenty of online review sites where they can and they will just direct the members here to those sites to let them know what they had to say. There is no way around it........people have a right to comment on any vendor, person, or business and instead of trying to stop it a better plan is to find a way to mange it effectively.

Posted 9/21/09 10:32 AM
 

GinaR
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

1976 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

great idea- but I doubt it will happen.

Posted 9/21/09 11:29 AM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by SpencersMommy

Spencersmommy



Chat Icon

Posted 9/21/09 12:01 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

I've said it before and I will say it again. I would not be able to respond to either positive or negative reviews about my business because I am bound by confidentiality rules.



you do have to recognize, however, that you're in a unique situation, and not all vendors are bound by the same legal rules as you are.

in addition to the rating system, and if mediation is too expensive, then it really should not be to difficult for LIF to prevent users from "rating" a vendor who cannot defend themselves, such as someone like yourself.

and i will say this: i find it very telling (and this is not an attack on you at all Kerie) that there are several people posting on this thread who are vendors and will welcome a rating system - and there are several vendors who decline to comment at all on any thread regarding negative testimonials.



I do recognize that my situation is different from many of the others. However, I am not the only attorney vendor on here, plus there are 3 fertility clincs on here now and probably some other businesses that have privacy concerns. None of them can respond about anyone's situation, yet many people here share personal information, including opinions about doctors.

Personally, I think that every vendor should step back to decide whether they should reveal customer information. It's one thing for a client to mention me. It's quite another for me to mention them. Even those not bound by rules should think about whether it is fair to talk about any specific customers. I'd rather not feel that any business is going to announce what I hired them for.

I would never ask anyone to come back here to the site to rave about me but it seems like some vendors do that. There, I said it!

I do not think that there are simple answers. All I ask for is that people acknowledge that it would not be so easy for LIF to just put their wishes into place. Also, take a step back to remember that the powers at LIF do a lot for the general community of posters. They don't just take care of vendors and forget everyone else.

I am not sure if I would want a rating system that excludes me. Not everyone would understand why and I think that would create the wrong impression. I do not want to appear to be above reproach. I'd probably enter the system and take my chances. I don't feel that I have skeletons in the closet anyway.

Message edited 2009-09-21 12:14:23.070000.

Posted 9/21/09 12:07 PM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I didn't want to get into logistics but since we did I'll add....

Think of how much MORE business vendors who are getting positive reviews will get when the users KNOW they are getting the WHOLE truth.

Everyone knows there's bound to be 1 or 2 bad experiences with ANY vendor but truthfully- there are some vendors with many more disatisifed customers than that but even more who probably are happy and will also "rate" them. Honestly, I believe the ratings would be a pretty accurate representation.

I LOVE the idea of categorizing the ratings:customer service, communication, turnaround time, etc.

If a vendor doesn't like this idea (aside from those with confidentiality issues such as kerie) then maybe they know their services are not where they should be.

I do not think most reviews would be negative.

As for doing your research/homework...maybe I am naive but I often come HERE as a source of my research/homework Chat Icon

I totally feel that it is unethical for LIF to like LB said not provide us with a set of clear rules and guidelines and not address this obvious issue.

Are we allowed to post a thread "If you've used xxxx FM me?" While it's a good idea and could be an option think about how much time is that going to take for everyone Chat Icon

Posted 9/21/09 12:09 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I still think, a star rating system would be a good compromise. Someone the other day suggested it broken down in several categories.

Customer Service
Quality
Overall satisfaction

(and whatever else) you can rate each on a scale of 1 - 5 stars.

However, to protect the vendors from complaints from people who have never really used their service, like on etsy or ebay, once your purchase is complete you will get an email or some notification that links to your purchase and you can then rate.

Then, I dont agree that complaints should be aired and disputed all over the board. I think next to each "rating" should be the LIF members name. You can then FM them if you so choose for more information of why they loved or hated the product/service.

Posted 9/21/09 12:12 PM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by Lucky09

Posted by dm24angel

I agree but here is how I think they will respond or basically how they feel and WHY this happens.

We don't pay to use this site....but it costs money and that money comes from the vendors fee's to advertise.

If everyone starts complaining about a certain vendor ( warrented or not) , or a vendor gets low ratings ....that vendors business from LIF members is going to go down...and then how does it pay that vendor to continue to pay to advertise on here , when they are not getting the same business as if they advertise somewhere else where theres no rating system?

Make sense?

So I think while it would be GREAT for us to be able to voice our opinions, the alternative to this is gonna be charging users to use this site so that they are still making money and I personally would rather not pay and just deal with the vendor frustration kwim?



I am all for a rating system, but unfortuantely I agree with the above.



I disagree with the above because a vendor (or ANY business whether on LIF or not) should make it a habit to provide good service, good quality, good product. If you're doing what you're suppose to be doing and providing the best possible product or service that you can then you as a vendor should have nothing to worry about. You should welcome any feedback, even negative, because it shows you where you can improve. I am a paying vendor on LIF and I would welcome a rating system and comments board with all feedback good or bad. I don't think the fact that I pay to advertise here should be "protection" from people's comments. I want to know what people have to say.

To the above post, if a vendors business goes down because of what people have to say about them then that is THEIR problem. For every junky vendor on here I'm sure there is a great one who will continue to pay to advertise on this site and get more business. IMO.........if there is a vendor that is so bad that all anyone does is provide negative feedback then maybe it's time that vendor rethink their business. It's NOT fair of LIF to only allow the praise and cheers for vendors on here without allowing the honest truth when someone isn't so happy with their vendor.

I don't see what us paying or not paying to be a member on LIF has do with wanting honest feedback. I think this whole thing lately is so ridiculous and honestly, if people can't be honest about their experiences here there are plenty of online review sites where they can and they will just direct the members here to those sites to let them know what they had to say. There is no way around it........people have a right to comment on any vendor, person, or business and instead of trying to stop it a better plan is to find a way to mange it effectively.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/21/09 12:15 PM
 

joenick
Us

Member since 6/06

9370 total posts

Name:
Valerie...aka...Do Me A Favor?

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by lorimarie

Posted by hbugal

As a vendor myself I am all for some type of rating system...

As Bops said, a chance for a vendor to be able to respond to said complaint might be the way to go...I just dont know how they would implement this..


As a vendor, my only concern, would be someone making a complaint, or rating my services who have NOT actually used my services...What would it take for someone to give my service poor marks when in reality they were never one of my clients?Chat Icon




I agree as I'm a vendor myself and have concerns and questions.

I always want my clients to be honest with me. I would be upset if a client wasn't happy, wrote a review and never addressed the issue with me. Or as Heather stated, someone who never used my services and gave me an unsatisfactory review.

There is also the issue of some people who are super hard to please. My father has been self employed for over 25 years and had one client that bashed him, put him thru heck and you know what, the job came out AMAZING and she still wasn't happy. He really went all out for her but it was never appreciated. If something like this was to arise and they wrote a negative review I'd be upset. How would something like this be dealt with? Obviously with a review, said person would like to state their concerns and if it was pulled they'd be upset and we'd be at the same point we are now.

I hope we can find a solution that makes our clients past and future happy yet protects us vendors.




As a fellow vendor, I agree.

Posted 9/21/09 12:27 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

I didn't want to make a quote longer, but to the vendors that are apprehensive, if you did things such as have only your customers rate you, not your friends, or people who did not receive your services, that would prevent random ratings to bring you down (or up).

And for those customers that you can never please, if you get a negative rating from them, and all your other ratings are GLOWING raves about you, we as consumers on LIF will see that there was a rotten apple in the bunch.

Consumers (at least I don't) don't decide on whether to use a vendor or service on just one review (good or bad). I use the majority. If your majority is positive, I'm more likely to use you. If the majority is negative, i'm not going to use you.

If you are doing your best by your customers, then it will be reflected in the ratings and we can certainly see that.

Posted 9/21/09 12:40 PM
 

joenick
Us

Member since 6/06

9370 total posts

Name:
Valerie...aka...Do Me A Favor?

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by neener1211

I didn't want to make a quote longer, but to the vendors that are apprehensive, if you did things such as have only your customers rate you, not your friends, or people who did not receive your services, that would prevent random ratings to bring you down (or up).

And for those customers that you can never please, if you get a negative rating from them, and all your other ratings are GLOWING raves about you, we as consumers on LIF will see that there was a rotten apple in the bunch.

Consumers (at least I don't) don't decide on whether to use a vendor or service on just one review (good or bad). I use the majority. If your majority is positive, I'm more likely to use you. If the majority is negative, i'm not going to use you.

If you are doing your best by your customers, then it will be reflected in the ratings and we can certainly see that.




I'm not really apprehensive...it's just that I'd hate to see it become a popularity contest. Chat Icon

With my business, my customers (at least 90% of them) come to my home to pick up their order. They immediately give me their feedback upon seeing their order...and that for me is thanks enough.

I am always so elated when a customer thanks me in person. When they say it looks so much better than they ever imagined. When they show their child their item and the child gets so excited. That's my rating system. Chat Icon

I actually asked customers NOT to give me a vendor rave on LIF, because I felt it was a Do Me A Favor overload. I didn't want people to get the feeling of "here we go again with joenick and her favors). Chat Icon

I believe that's why LIF started the Testemonials page...to alleviate the board of a million rave posts. I think that's why they added that feature, but I am just guessing.

To me...I wouldn't mind a rating system of sorts. I just find them unreliable. Whenever I shop for something online and read reviews, some people LOVE the item, while others hate it. Are the "lovers" easy to please or are the "haters" impossible to please? It's just VERY hard to get a good read.

Plus on LIF...some vendors are posters (like myself). Would it become a popularity contest? I'm not too sure.

Posted 9/21/09 12:51 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by joenick

Plus on LIF...some vendors are posters (like myself). Would it become a popularity contest? I'm not too sure.



I can actually see that totally happening.

"shy" vendors like yourself not looking to make much waves vs. go getter vendor "asking" their clients to go make a comment on how good they are.

Posted 9/21/09 12:57 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: A petition if you will for a rating system

Posted by joenick

Posted by neener1211

I didn't want to make a quote longer, but to the vendors that are apprehensive, if you did things such as have only your customers rate you, not your friends, or people who did not receive your services, that would prevent random ratings to bring you down (or up).

And for those customers that you can never please, if you get a negative rating from them, and all your other ratings are GLOWING raves about you, we as consumers on LIF will see that there was a rotten apple in the bunch.

Consumers (at least I don't) don't decide on whether to use a vendor or service on just one review (good or bad). I use the majority. If your majority is positive, I'm more likely to use you. If the majority is negative, i'm not going to use you.

If you are doing your best by your customers, then it will be reflected in the ratings and we can certainly see that.




I'm not really apprehensive...it's just that I'd hate to see it become a popularity contest. Chat Icon

With my business, my customers (at least 90% of them) come to my home to pick up their order. They immediately give me their feedback upon seeing their order...and that for me is thanks enough.

I am always so elated when a customer thanks me in person. When they say it looks so much better than they ever imagined. When they show their child their item and the child gets so excited. That's my rating system. Chat Icon

I actually asked customers NOT to give me a vendor rave on LIF, because I felt it was a Do Me A Favor overload. I didn't want people to get the feeling of "here we go again with joenick and her favors). Chat Icon

I believe that's why LIF started the Testemonials page...to alleviate the board of a million rave posts. I think that's why they added that feature, but I am just guessing.

To me...I wouldn't mind a rating system of sorts. I just find them unreliable. Whenever I shop for something online and read reviews, some people LOVE the item, while others hate it. Are the "lovers" easy to please or are the "haters" impossible to please? It's just VERY hard to get a good read.

Plus on LIF...some vendors are posters (like myself). Would it become a popularity contest? I'm not too sure.



See, this is where the issue is stemming from. It already IS a popularity contest. Friends are backing up their existing friends/vendors when someone posts a review about them.

I understand where you are coming from but that is already the problem that needs to be solved.

To address the testimonials, this is why this is an issue as well. There are ONLY positive testimonials on here, no negative when posters have said that they have put even the slightest negative feedback.

Chat Icon

Posted 9/21/09 1:01 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Snap and Go and Travel System? new2this 3/23/06 6 Pregnancy
Graco MetroLite Travel System ??? 04bride 3/22/06 7 Parenting
Major credit agencies adopt uniform credit scoring system LSP2005 3/14/06 0 Home
Did you register for a travel system and a mid-weight stroller... LIMOMx2 3/5/06 5 Pregnancy
Sleep system? BCK1029 2/12/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
Do you REALLY need a travel system? BaroqueMama 2/12/06 45 Pregnancy