A name question...

Posted By Message

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

A name question...

How would you feel if a very close friend of yours (your DH's BFF's wife, whom you hang out with on a VERY regular basis) named their DC the same name as your DC? Let's pretend that your DC is 3 years old and your friend had their baby this past week Chat Icon

Would you be like "What the what??? Of all the names in the world, why would they choose the same as my DC?" Or would you be like, "That's cool, no worries" Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 11:08 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: A name question...

Posted by scarletbegonia
"That's cool, no worries"



this is how I would feel...I would not mind at all

Posted 12/15/09 11:08 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: A name question...

Ill admit, I would think ...***, but I certainly wouldnt say anything bc I also understand that I dont own the name. I would realize that something about that name drew me to it, and the same thing is happening for them.

Would I for a second think, "oh come on....really??" of course I would, but Id get over it and not make an issue of it.

Posted 12/15/09 11:10 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: A name question...

I think that no one can dictate what someone else names their child.

-Signed a mother to a "Christopher" which has been the second most popular name for like 50 yearsChat Icon

PS-Things like this always remind me of Charlotte on SATC with the name "Shaylee"

Posted 12/15/09 11:10 AM
 

Salason
♥

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: A name question...

No worries, especially if it's a relatively common name. If it were family, I might find it a little annoying but certainly not a friend. You never know why people name their kids what they do or what names run in families even though someone else got to it first!

In fact, our friends (not super close but same circle) just named their son Andrew a couple of weeks ago. We're naming DC#2 that if its a boy and decided on that months ago before we knew that (they dotn even know that) so it didnt make us question it at all!

Posted 12/15/09 11:14 AM
 

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

Re: A name question...

I asked because this happened this past week and one of our other friends (not either of the moms with DC of the same name) is making a stink abut it and getting bent. I'm like "dude - this has absolutely NO bearing on your life whatsoever!"

I was just wondering what the general public's opinion was on it Chat Icon


Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 11:14 AM
 

mcd01
Life is good : )

Member since 3/09

1932 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: A name question...

Posted by KateDevine

I think that no one can dictate what someone else names their child.

-Signed a mother to a "Christopher" which has been the second most popular name for like 50 yearsChat Icon

PS-Things like this always remind me of Charlotte on SATC with the name "Shaylee"

my grand daughter is shaylee Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 11:15 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: A name question...

When I first named my child, it would have bothered me.

Then DH's BF did name their child that...and I got over it.

Posted 12/15/09 11:15 AM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: A name question...

Hmm I think I'd have to be "no worries" about it, it's not like they're gonna change it now Chat Icon. I'm not overly sensitive about this kind of thing, many people just "know" what name they want long before they even have kids, KWIM? Or it may be a "family" name honoring a relative, etc.
I think to be upset it would have to be a "closer" relationship; if my sister named her kid the same name as my DS that would be weird Chat Icon.
But on the flip side if someone had a DC whose name I loved and was going to use, I'd probably let them know ahead of time, "I've always loved that name and we're thinking about it for Chat Icon" that just seems like the right thing to do...

Posted 12/15/09 11:15 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: A name question...

I would never be able to do it - but if a close friend named their DS Luca I'd be flattered!

Posted 12/15/09 11:17 AM
 

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

Re: A name question...

Posted by colette


I think to be upset it would have to be a "closer" relationship; if my sister named her kid the same name as my DS that would be weird Chat Icon.
..



OMG - I have the mother of all stories about that! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Not going to post it because you never know who reads these things. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 11:17 AM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: A name question...

Posted by scarletbegonia

Posted by colette


I think to be upset it would have to be a "closer" relationship; if my sister named her kid the same name as my DS that would be weird Chat Icon.
..



OMG - I have the mother of all stories about that! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Not going to post it because you never know who reads these things. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon




hahahaha SMART. If Jessica Simpson names her 1st kid "Bronx Mowgli" you know there will be a catfight!!!!

PS: EXCELLENT USE of random emoticons, V!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-12-15 11:20:13.240000.

Posted 12/15/09 11:19 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: A name question...

I wouldn't really be upset but I would probably wonder why they would want to use the same name if it's someone you see frequently. But then again, you can't help the name you like even if someone else has already chosen it.

When my 2 aunts had their kids my one aunt always loved the name Eric and my other aunt always loved the name Derek. Neither one of them would consider a different name so I have my cousins Eric and Derek and it's all good and both aunts were happy. Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 11:19 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: A name question...

If it was a really really really unusual name that I had made up, I might be annoyed. But if its a run of the mill name, no, it wouldn't annoy me.

One of the Mummies in my Mummy groups took almost the full 42 days to name her son, and guess what she named him...Noah. I laughed and laughed about it. in the end imitation is the most sincere form of flattery!!!!

Posted 12/15/09 11:30 AM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: A name question...

i wouldnt have a problem with it at all... even if it were a family name. in my DH & I family there are at least 16 Anthony's, cousins, 2nd cousins, cousins kids.

fathers, sons, (even pets)

Posted 12/15/09 11:52 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: A name question...

It wouldn't bother me and we chose a pretty uncommon name; it would just reinforce that we are pretty spectacular when it comes to naming Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 11:57 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: A name question...

I would never do it just because I wouldn't want to deal with the whole thing through the years for ex:
Mike... who? My Mike. No. My Mike etc...

Posted 12/15/09 12:07 PM
 

pig22seal
LOVE MY 2 BOYS!

Member since 5/07

1877 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: A name question...

IMO - I wouldn't mind. My nieces name is Savannah and if I was having a girl...I want to name her Hannah. Both names are very similar and they would be cousins. My SIL didn't mind at all! Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 12:08 PM
 

MrsDrMatt
Live and RUN like a Ninja!

Member since 5/06

3104 total posts

Name:
MrsDrMatt

Re: A name question...

that's cool no worries

Posted 12/15/09 12:09 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: A name question...

Posted by mommyonli

fathers, sons, (even pets)



Okay, I'll admit, I might be a teensy bit weirded out if someone close to me named their dog or turtle Luca Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 12:09 PM
 

FrankiesGirl107
My Girls

Member since 12/06

3642 total posts

Name:
Amee

Re: A name question...

I guess it would depend on how special the name was to me....and to that person....If it really had special meaning to them, I am fine with it...if it was just "I like it"...it might bug me a little, but I'd never say so...

DH and I have a similar discussion frequently because if there is a name that is common among our circle of friends, or that someone just used, I personally feel it's off limits...unless it is REALLY special meaning....DH is more a "pick the name you like, who cares how many there are" kind of guy...

Posted 12/15/09 12:11 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: A name question...

Posted by mommyonli

i wouldnt have a problem with it at all... even if it were a family name. in my DH & I family there are at least 16 Anthony's, cousins, 2nd cousins, cousins kids.

fathers, sons, (even pets)



I'm guessing you guys are Norwegian??Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/09 12:11 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: A name question...

i wouldnt care. In fact, id probably like it because it would mean they like her name.

Posted 12/15/09 12:24 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: A name question...

I wouldn't care

We named Tyler - Tyler (obviously) and one of my good friends has a Tyler also. I kind of told her the name was in the running. We see her MAYBE 4 times a year and I have 16 nephews that I really couldn't name my son after so I wasn't about to cut out friends kids names who I hardly ever see.

Posted 12/15/09 12:27 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I just have one question.... JenniferEver 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Follow up to allergy question DramaQueen 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
BabyBoy question for you TAD 5/11/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
STAR question sasha96 5/11/05 2 Home
Silly Reality Question Redhead 5/11/05 19 Families Helping Families ™
I got a question fakie1 5/10/05 86 Families Helping Families ™