Would You Lie on the Stand?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes 31 21.38%
No 114 78.62%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

A Moral Question - With Poll

In light of the testimony in the Casey Anthony trial:

If your child was on trial for a capital crime (if convicted they could face the death penalty) and even though you suspected they were guilty of said crime, would you perjure yourself, aka lie, to "muddy the waters" and try to create reasonable doubt so as to potentially save your child from being found not guilty?

Posted 6/24/11 12:43 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

No. I would be incredibly mortified that I raised someone that would kill my grandchild. As much as I would want to protect my child, she would have to pay for her crime.

Posted 6/24/11 12:45 PM
 

Lola64
She is my heart!

Member since 1/11

1110 total posts

Name:

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted by Domino
would you perjure yourself, aka lie, to "muddy the waters" and try to create reasonable doubt so as to potentially save your child from being found not guilty?



I said no...their fate is their fate. If there was a decent amount of reasonable doubt, that's the lawyers job to bring it to light and hammer it into the jury.

Posted 6/24/11 12:46 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

I have NO idea. Chat Icon I really can't answer that. To be totally honest I think I would be crying too hard to testify.

Posted 6/24/11 12:49 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

I would pray with all my might. I would get her the best lawyer out there. I would not volunteer any extra information. But I don't think I could lie. . . .

ETA: This is if she committed a crime NOT if she murdered her child! OMG then I would have to pray for her soul and let her go.

Message edited 2011-06-24 12:56:06.313000.

Posted 6/24/11 12:52 PM
 

Dee0522
And then there were four...

Member since 6/09

2088 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

I honestly don't think anyone can really answer this question without being in the situation. I would like to say no, I absolutely wouldn't no matter what... but if, God forbid, the situation ever presented itself I might think differently, depending on the circumstances. If I were Cindy Anthony however... in light of how many lies her daughter has told her and the allegations she is making against her father and brother... I'd really have to think long and hard about lying for her. Unless the entire family is in on this molestation story as a way to get her off. That could very well be!

Posted 6/24/11 12:53 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

No way. I think I would know in my heart if my child did such a thing - and there is no way I would get taint the waters.

ETS: But I agree you never know until you're there. It must be a surreal experience.

Message edited 2011-06-24 12:55:45.760000.

Posted 6/24/11 12:55 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted by headoverheels

I have NO idea. Chat Icon I really can't answer that. To be totally honest I think I would be crying too hard to testify.



ditto to this...

Posted 6/24/11 12:55 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted by headoverheels

I have NO idea. Chat Icon I really can't answer that. To be totally honest I think I would be crying too hard to testify.



Me too. It is hard to say what I would do because I am not in that situation and I just don't know. I *think* I would remain truthful to bring some justice to my Granddaughter.

ETS: Cindy is in the worst situation imaginable. Her daughter may have killed her grandbaby and is accusing her Son and Husband of molestation. If she goes one way her daughter may die, if she goes another way she may get off. I really feel for her and I would not wish that on anyone. The don't think I could go on like that.

Message edited 2011-06-24 13:00:53.430000.

Posted 6/24/11 12:58 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Message edited 2011-07-03 10:49:35.663000.

Posted 6/24/11 12:59 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted by bicosi

Posted by headoverheels

I have NO idea. Chat Icon I really can't answer that. To be totally honest I think I would be crying too hard to testify.



ditto to this...



Same here.

Posted 6/24/11 1:00 PM
 

FrankiesGirl107
My Girls

Member since 12/06

3642 total posts

Name:
Amee

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted by Tilde

I would pray with all my might. I would get her the best lawyer out there. I would not volunteer any extra information. But I don't think I could lie. . . .




I agree with this.

Posted 6/24/11 1:07 PM
 

-Lisa-
---------------

Member since 5/05

6530 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

[when talking about this trial with my sister] my mother, who loves me dearly, said that she would be the first one on the phone to the police if I harmed her precious grandchildren. So I know where I stand with her!

Posted 6/24/11 1:12 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted by bicosi

Posted by headoverheels

I have NO idea. Chat Icon I really can't answer that. To be totally honest I think I would be crying too hard to testify.



ditto to this...



same here.

While I am so sad that Cindy lied, I cannot even begin to imagine what it's like to walk in her shoes for even a moment.

Posted 6/24/11 1:16 PM
 

Juliet
Family is Complete!

Member since 5/05

5913 total posts

Name:
Juliet

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted by -Lisa-

[when talking about this trial with my sister] my mother, who loves me dearly, said that she would be the first one on the phone to the police if I harmed her precious grandchildren. So I know where I stand with her!




I get the feeling my mom would do the same. There are times I think my mom may love my DD more than me (well, not really, but that grandparent love is intense).

Posted 6/24/11 1:16 PM
 

Juliet
Family is Complete!

Member since 5/05

5913 total posts

Name:
Juliet

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

As for me, I think I would have to tell the truth. I would be devastated but I don't think I could continue to look my child in the eye if I knew she did something like this.

Posted 6/24/11 1:17 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

I don't know. I really don't. I'd like to think I wouldn't, that I'm that moral of a person, but I don't know what I would do for my own child.

Posted 6/24/11 1:20 PM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

I don't think that parents should be asked to testify against their child, the same way that a husband or wife does not have to testify against their spouse.

Posted 6/24/11 1:23 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

I think part of being a good parent is having your child pay the consequences for their actions. This is a whole different ballgame though. I'd like to believe that I would NOT, but like others you never know what you would actually do when put in this situation.

Posted 6/24/11 1:26 PM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Just thinking about this hurts my heart.
I would like to think I would tell the truth, BUT if I saw my daughter sitting on the other side of that table with her life on the line, I really don't know. I mean that is my child. No matter how old she is. I don't know if I could live with myself, knowing my truth helped send her to jail and possibly to her death.Chat Icon

Posted 6/24/11 1:27 PM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

I honestly don't know. DH and I have actually been talking about this the past few days. He said he would do everything in his power to protect DCs. The mom in me says there is no way I could testify against my child, or turn them in. But at the same time if g-d forbid either of my children did a heinous crime, I feel they should face the consequences.

Posted 6/24/11 1:27 PM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

Posted by lululu

I don't think that parents should be asked to testify against their child, the same way that a husband or wife does not have to testify against their spouse.



I absolutely agree 100%!

Posted 6/24/11 1:28 PM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

This is the time when "other" would work. I don't know. I would like to say I wouldn't lie, but honestly It would probably depend on the situation, the crime, etc.

Posted 6/24/11 1:31 PM
 

DirtyBlonde
*****

Member since 11/07

7344 total posts

Name:

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

I have no idea.

This is something you can't know unless you're living this hell.

Posted 6/24/11 1:32 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: A Moral Question - With Poll

no idea.

awful awful awful. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/24/11 1:36 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Moral / legal question... CouponKT 3/16/10 40 Families Helping Families ™
Interesting Moral Question-Deleted Domino 2/17/09 3 Infertility
What do you do when you're stumped about fairy tale moral questions?? Rycois 2/7/11 4 Parenting
spinoff to my own broadway show poll--my big fat moral dilemma!!! browneyedgirl 4/21/08 27 Families Helping Families ™
I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) luvsbob4603 6/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question Shelly 4/10/06 11 Parenting