5th grade math help

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

2girlsforme
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3071 total posts

Name:
XXXXXXXXX

Re: 5th grade math help

Welcome to the common core. I have a 5 th grader and thank God everyday that my husband understands this crap.

Posted 9/18/13 9:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

5th grade math help

Mental
Abuse
To
Humans

Message edited 2013-09-18 21:21:00.343000.

Posted 9/18/13 9:19 PM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by LIMomma

TWO college degrees and we still can not figure this out

Multiple the tens.


293
x 9
____





9 x 9 tens = __________
Add the regrouped tens.
_____ tens + 2 tens = _____ tens
Write the tens and the regrouped hundreds.

WHY OH WHY can't they teach them to multiple 293 x 9 and be done????Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETA: the debate is 9 tens is 90 x 9 = 810 and then we loose it.



not sure if anyone is still working on this... but this is how i see it:

293
x 9
--------

9x9tens = 810 or 81 tens
Add the regrouped tens.
81tens + 2tens = 83tens
Write the tens and the regrouped hundreds.

9x20tens=1800 or 180tens
18hundreds + 8hundreds = 26 hundreds or 2600


i believe it's a way to teach ROUNDING or ESTIMATION... but i feel that the way it's presented SUCKS BALLS

Message edited 2013-09-18 21:30:02.077000.

Posted 9/18/13 9:28 PM
 

LIMomma
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/12

523 total posts

Name:
Momma

Re: 5th grade math help

Ok here's the answer I got

This was building on the ones, tens and hundreds
And NONE of the questions give you the answer I only
The place holder value.

9 x 3 ones = 27 ones (keep the 7)

The problem I had initially

9 x 9 tens = 81 tens

81 tens + 2 tens = 83 tens (keep the 3)

9 x 2 hundreds = 18 hundreds

18 hundreds + 8 hundreds = 26 hundreds (keep the 26)

use the numbers in the appropriate place holders

2637 which is the answer

Posted 9/18/13 9:42 PM
 

MammaItaliana
LIF Infant

Member since 4/10

174 total posts

Name:
Nicky

Re: 5th grade math help

This is what I tried...

9x9 tens = 810
81 tens + 2 tens (this comes from the 3x9=27 I believe)= 830
9×2 hundreds = 1800 or 18 hundreds
18 hundreds + 8 hundreds (from the 830)= 2600

That leaves an extimate of 2630, if that is what they want. Just think...it is only September.

Posted 9/19/13 12:01 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by LIMomma

Ok here's the answer I got

This was building on the ones, tens and hundreds
And NONE of the questions give you the answer I only
The place holder value.

9 x 3 ones = 27 ones (keep the 7)

The problem I had initially

9 x 9 tens = 81 tens

81 tens + 2 tens = 83 tens (keep the 3)

9 x 2 hundreds = 18 hundreds

18 hundreds + 8 hundreds = 26 hundreds (keep the 26)

use the numbers in the appropriate place holders

2637 which is the answer



Holy shit.

Mind BLOWN.

I'd be screwed if I was you. I sucked in math back in the day and I'd probably suck even more now.

That is beyond confusing. Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/13 12:14 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

Mental
Abuse
To
Humans




Yes!!!! Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/13 12:14 AM
 

tagkit
LIF Infant

Member since 10/12

361 total posts

Name:

5th grade math help

This is ridiculous!!! Oh its gonna be a looooong year!!!!

Posted 9/19/13 7:49 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by LIMomma

Ok here's the answer I got

This was building on the ones, tens and hundreds
And NONE of the questions give you the answer I only
The place holder value.

9 x 3 ones = 27 ones (keep the 7)

The problem I had initially

9 x 9 tens = 81 tens

81 tens + 2 tens = 83 tens (keep the 3)

9 x 2 hundreds = 18 hundreds

18 hundreds + 8 hundreds = 26 hundreds (keep the 26)

use the numbers in the appropriate place holders

2637 which is the answer



wait.. whoa..
isn't that how we already do math?

we just 'carried over' the other number and added it to the next equation?

ah hell and i LOVE math.. its my only good subject. but they said (infamous they) that I had ADD with math (who has ADD on only a subject? Chat Icon ) my answers were always right but my methodology was not standard and so i hated to 'show my work' since it didn't follow the 'rules' .. now if *I* broke the rules before and these are the 'new' rules I am soo screwed!

Posted 9/19/13 7:56 AM
 

SusiBee
. . . . .

Member since 3/09

8268 total posts

Name:
S

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by KarenG2003

This is how I teach it. It's called the "area model "......SO DUMB.....

200x9= 1800
90x9= 810
9x3=27

So you're decomposing 293 and multiplying each place value by the 9.

Then you add all of those products together:

1800+810+27= 2637



Isn't is quicker and with less steps to do it the old fashioned way ?

Posted 9/19/13 8:47 AM
 

luvmyReese
Hello Kitty

Member since 1/08

7542 total posts

Name:
Catt

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by SusiBee

Posted by KarenG2003

This is how I teach it. It's called the "area model "......SO DUMB.....

200x9= 1800
90x9= 810
9x3=27

So you're decomposing 293 and multiplying each place value by the 9.

Then you add all of those products together:

1800+810+27= 2637



Isn't is quicker and with less steps to do it the old fashioned way ?



ABSOLUTELY FREEK'N YES!!! but this is the "new" way of doing Math. Why change something that was NEVER broken or cause confusion. Kids have to show this new way on tests if its the "old" traditional way its wrong!! This generation is set up to fail.

Posted 9/19/13 9:05 AM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: 5th grade math help

What's awful to me is that the kids that show all this nonsense work but ultimately reach the WRONG answer can get the same, if not more credit than the kids who do it a different way (or God forbid in their head) and get the RIGHT answer...bc somehow that's fair?!?

I hope none of these kids grow up to be accountants or we're all screwed!

Posted 9/19/13 9:15 AM
 

2girlsforme
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3071 total posts

Name:
XXXXXXXXX

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by MrsDamonSalv7319

What's awful to me is that the kids that show all this nonsense work but ultimately reach the WRONG answer can get the same, if not more credit than the kids who do it a different way (or God forbid in their head) and get the RIGHT answer...bc somehow that's fair?!?

I hope none of these kids grow up to be accountants or we're all screwed!

v

Exactly. And again welcome to the common core. My concern is not that this ridiculous way of teaching will not be abandoned in the long run, but the damage it will do to children in the interim.

Posted 9/19/13 10:39 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by luvmyReese


ABSOLUTELY FREEK'N YES!!! but this is the "new" way of doing Math. Why change something that was NEVER broken or cause confusion. Kids have to show this new way on tests if its the "old" traditional way its wrong!! This generation is set up to fail.



Why are they changing it?

On a side note, please don't tell me we're also going to the metric system. Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/13 10:42 AM
 

PaddysGirl
Little princess is here!

Member since 4/07

5923 total posts

Name:
Crystal

5th grade math help

Dang! And I thought I had a hard time with decimals in 5th!

Posted 9/19/13 11:00 AM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: 5th grade math help

This blows my mind..
seriously

i had heard about this new way of doing math, but not actually seen it in practice.
I can't believe they're making you do more steps to reach the same answer. Isn't that making things more complicated than they used to be?

who's idea was this?? and why??

Posted 9/19/13 11:17 AM
 

PearlJamChick
No one sings like you anymore.

Member since 7/10

9264 total posts

Name:
Petticoated Swashbuckler

Re: 5th grade math help

Let me add this to my list of reasons to remain childfree...Chat Icon Chat Icon

My brain feels like scrambled eggs reading this!

Posted 9/19/13 11:29 AM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by KarenG2003

This is how I teach it. It's called the "area model "......SO DUMB.....

200x9= 1800
90x9= 810
9x3=27

So you're decomposing 293 and multiplying each place value by the 9.

Then you add all of those products together:

1800+810+27= 2637



I'm saving this post for five years from now when I want to shoot myself and I can figure it out.

What moron decided this was a great way to teach kids?Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/13 11:38 AM
 

YOLO13
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/08

669 total posts

Name:
Unlisted

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by neener1211

Posted by KarenG2003

This is how I teach it. It's called the "area model "......SO DUMB.....

200x9= 1800
90x9= 810
9x3=27

So you're decomposing 293 and multiplying each place value by the 9.

Then you add all of those products together:

1800+810+27= 2637



I'm saving this post for five years from now when I want to shoot myself and I can figure it out.

What moron decided this was a great way to teach kids?Chat Icon




Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/13 11:42 AM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: 5th grade math help

I have to be honest here.

I do think it is easier and faster doing it the old way.

However, I actually have a very good head for numbers and work in corporate finance and always have to do quick math in my head. This is actually how I do it in my head. I never knew it was called common core or had to do with the regrouping tens and stuff. My son's first grade teacher mentioned it to us at meet the teacher night this week and I was so confused as to what she was talking about with common core.

Anyway, people are constantly astonished at how I can do math so quickly in my head. I think it is just that I have my head trained to do it this way. It is just harder for me visualize in my head a multiplication like this doing it the same way I would do it on paper. Which, by the way, if I had to do it on paper I would do it the old way...OR i would just use a calculator.

Therefore I honestly think this is actually a different approach that is probably more aimed to make the students more logical thinkers than just mechanical thinkers or doers.

Furthermore, I think it helps those who say they are not "math people" to try and think about it logically when in the real world and asked to look at numbers. So maybe for grade school there is no practical application but I definately can say that it is very useful not only doing my job but also managing my household budget too. It is just a different way that they are trying to train the brain.

Posted 9/19/13 12:14 PM
 

hunnybunnyxoxo
this is what it's all about

Member since 11/07

3321 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by lbelle821

I have to be honest here.

I do think it is easier and faster doing it the old way.

However, I actually have a very good head for numbers and work in corporate finance and always have to do quick math in my head. This is actually how I do it in my head. I never knew it was called common core or had to do with the regrouping tens and stuff. My son's first grade teacher mentioned it to us at meet the teacher night this week and I was so confused as to what she was talking about with common core.

Anyway, people are constantly astonished at how I can do math so quickly in my head. I think it is just that I have my head trained to do it this way. It is just harder for me visualize in my head a multiplication like this doing it the same way I would do it on paper. Which, by the way, if I had to do it on paper I would do it the old way...OR i would just use a calculator.

Therefore I honestly think this is actually a different approach that is probably more aimed to make the students more logical thinkers than just mechanical thinkers or doers.

Furthermore, I think it helps those who say they are not "math people" to try and think about it logically when in the real world and asked to look at numbers. So maybe for grade school there is no practical application but I definately can say that it is very useful not only doing my job but also managing my household budget too. It is just a different way that they are trying to train the brain.



Chat Icon Chat Icon
i can't add in my brain for beans! but sometimes it helps if i add by grouping numbers.
here is a very basic simple ex. if i had to add 65 plus 32 i would add 60 + 30 and then add 5+2.. you can easily do this in your head but you get the point. if you can't add fast in your head, it is good to find ways around it.

Posted 9/19/13 3:53 PM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by hunnybunnyxoxo

Posted by lbelle821

I have to be honest here.

I do think it is easier and faster doing it the old way.

However, I actually have a very good head for numbers and work in corporate finance and always have to do quick math in my head. This is actually how I do it in my head. I never knew it was called common core or had to do with the regrouping tens and stuff. My son's first grade teacher mentioned it to us at meet the teacher night this week and I was so confused as to what she was talking about with common core.

Anyway, people are constantly astonished at how I can do math so quickly in my head. I think it is just that I have my head trained to do it this way. It is just harder for me visualize in my head a multiplication like this doing it the same way I would do it on paper. Which, by the way, if I had to do it on paper I would do it the old way...OR i would just use a calculator.

Therefore I honestly think this is actually a different approach that is probably more aimed to make the students more logical thinkers than just mechanical thinkers or doers.

Furthermore, I think it helps those who say they are not "math people" to try and think about it logically when in the real world and asked to look at numbers. So maybe for grade school there is no practical application but I definately can say that it is very useful not only doing my job but also managing my household budget too. It is just a different way that they are trying to train the brain.



Chat Icon Chat Icon
i can't add in my brain for beans! but sometimes it helps if i add by grouping numbers.
here is a very basic simple ex. if i had to add 65 plus 32 i would add 60 + 30 and then add 5+2.. you can easily do this in your head but you get the point. if you can't add fast in your head, it is good to find ways around it.




Exactly! And if they are trained to do it this way from a young age it won't be so difficult to them and I believe quite practical.

Posted 9/19/13 8:19 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: 5th grade math help

Posted by MsSissy

Posted by luvmyReese


ABSOLUTELY FREEK'N YES!!! but this is the "new" way of doing Math. Why change something that was NEVER broken or cause confusion. Kids have to show this new way on tests if its the "old" traditional way its wrong!! This generation is set up to fail.



Why are they changing it?

On a side note, please don't tell me we're also going to the metric system. Chat Icon



The metric system is much easier to understand than the imperial system. But I learned the imperial system, and because of that, it just makes sense to me. When reading, for example, a recipe in the metric system it is much easier to understand. Trying to convert the recipe from imperial to metric is annoying-- I mean 16 ounces to a pound and then fluid ounces and then 12 inches to a foot, etc. These measurements have no consistency! At least with metric it is based on 10s etc. There is some consistency.

And don't even talk to me about butter measurements! It makes no sense at all!

That being said, when doing math in my head, I group numbers. It's just easier. I group it in 10s. But this math problem? I don't understand it at all!

Posted 9/19/13 9:08 PM
 

Irishgrl13
Fingers Crossed...

Member since 6/09

1301 total posts

Name:
Colleen

Re: 5th grade math help

Holy crap.... My son is only three but i'm starting to thing I should get started on learning this stuff now.... Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon and I was always decent in math....

Posted 9/19/13 9:39 PM
 

nancy6485
So in love

Member since 10/05

3363 total posts

Name:
Nancy

Re: 5th grade math help

DS is in 4th grade and I have no idea how they do this stuff. I do it the good old fashioned way, confusing! (and I did well in school!)

Posted 9/19/13 10:18 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
need help from any teachers.. math question 5th grade janet 6/1/05 6 Families Helping Families ™
** Anyone teach 5th grade math in New York?! zuzuspetals 8/30/09 3 Teachers
A word to the wise for when your kids hit 5th grade! nrthshgrl 9/7/12 1 Parents of School-Aged Children
Teaching 3rd grade this year after teaching 5th for five years...help!! MrsRivera 9/4/10 7 Teachers
I got an interview and need a mini lesson 5th grade! Help! lovenature 6/24/09 0 Teachers
State Math Testing in 3rd Grade? Teachers? EmmaNick 2/21/08 6 Parenting