.
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
. I think this post has run its course...thanks to those who responded! Message edited 2010-11-08 14:08:49.190000. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 7:14 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... I would ask the SIL to say something to her daughter. She's teaching her it's ok to be rude and not answer adults when they ask her questions. You aren't a stranger. You're mommy and daddy's friend. And she's had plenty of opportunities to 'warm up'. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 7:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... My best friends niece is like that. Even at age 8 today, she is still like that to most people. She is usually not corrected when she is being rude. At first I thought it was because she was shy, but my friend told me that she is just spoiled and that if someone doesn't give her something when they meet her, she won't talk to you. I was like, well, then she won't be talking to me.... I usually don't. But on my last visit to her family's house, she actually talked to me, but I think it was because DS was with me and she wanted to play with him. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 7:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... I dont know....shes three. Its not like she is seven and ignoring you. Three is a weird age sometimes, and maybe she is just shy? |
|
Posted 11/8/10 7:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... I think that because she is three I wouldn't be so upset about it. Three year olds are downright nutty. Message edited 2010-11-08 07:51:47.170000. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 7:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... I would never force her to hug me or talk to me....and i understand she is 3.. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:03 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Sad as it is, I would probably take a break from them personally. I don't know that I would be able to tolerate the brattiness or want my kids around it - so I would seperate myself a little bit. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:06 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Posted by eddiesmommy I dont know....shes three. Its not like she is seven and ignoring you. Three is a weird age sometimes, and maybe she is just shy? I was painfully shy as a kid, I had one Uncle I refused to talk to. In fact, I would lock myself in the den if he was over. I was really outgoing with all of my other family members bc I saw them all the time, so I was comfortable. This is uncle I saw once every few months, and was just being shy. I wasnt being rude, and my parents werent being bad parents with no parenting skills. Had they forced me to talk to him, when I wasnt ready bc I was being shy, I probably wouldve freaked out. I think it was great parenting on their part to let me come around on my own terms, when I was ready instead of forcing me to talk to someone I wasnt comfortable or ready to talk to. I personally dont believe in forcing your DC to speak to, or hug someone they dont want to. I think it send the message that I dont respect their boundaries and their comfort level with their own self. I think she is just being three, having a personality quirk and will come around. I dont think its cause to speak to her parents. I so wish it were shyness. THAT i could deal with in a heartbeat. It's not. She is a super super smart kid too...and very manipulative. SIL has used that word many times to describe her. She has her parents wrapped around her finger...but what made me happy was seeing my BIL recognize just how bad its become...I think the one day he was close to running away. I get nervous thinking about when she is older. It's not going to be pretty..and its sad to me
|
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Posted by Diana1215 Sad as it is, I would probably take a break from them personally. I don't know that I would be able to tolerate the brattiness or want my kids around it - so I would seperate myself a little bit. Unfortunately if she's THAT bratty now it will only get worse the older she gets. I have a similar situation with one of my cousins sons and to be honest, we have completely removed ourselves from them and only see them when we have to. The kid is so fresh, and such a brat, (and VERY rough with my boys) that I don't want to be around it at all. I am no help, sorry I know, i agree with you. What stinks is that my husband really adores (or rather adored his niece). We are the ONLY aunt and uncle she has. We try to make family very important. Kids all have their moments...believe me, we've been through it w.Johnny. It hasn't been easy all the time with him. But he is never mean and nasty. We don't tolerate it. SIL goes to me "he is so polite all the time, it's so cute". I wanted to be like "YES BECAUSE I TEACH MY KIDS PLEASE AND THANK YOU AND TO BE GRATEFUL". It's a very bad feeling to feel this way toward your niece. But i'm more angry at her parents. I don't see any get togethers in the future aside from christmas. Should be fun. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... I have a 3yr old who acts this way sometimes and it stresses me out to no end. I dont think you should be mad at her - she's 3. Honestly that helps nobody because my stepdad acts like this with my DS and it only exacerbates him not wanting to speak to him and gives me so much anxiety that I dont enjoy visits AT ALL. DH & I tend to go the opposite extreme from your SIL and fight with DS over it, time outs etc but I don't think that's helping either. I think it's social immaturity and in DS' case, shyness and social anxiety too. We have no idea why he's like this but we're not going to just accept it because it does come across as bratty. So we're doing a lot of work trying to figure out the problem and how to best approach it - talking to teachers, peds etc. I don't think your SIL can ignore it because I personally feel it will get worse. Maybe your SIL is too and just doesnt want to discuss it? It doesnt really sound like it but maybe if youre close enough to her, you can bring it up with her? Message edited 2010-11-08 08:50:35.147000. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Posted by Salason I have a 3yr old who acts this way sometimes and it stresses me out to no end. I dont think you should be mad at her - she's 3. Honestly that helps nobody because my stepdad acts like this with my DS and it only exacerbates him not wanting to speak to him and gives me so much anxiety that I dont enjoy visits AT ALL. DH & I tend to go the opposite extreme from your SIL and fight with DS over it, time outs etc but I don't think that's helping either. I think it's social immaturity and in DS' case, shyness and social anxiety too. We have no idea why he's like this but we're not going to just accept it because it does come across as bratty. So we're doing a lot of work trying to figure out the problem and how to best approach it - talking to teachers, peds etc. I don't think your SIL can ignore it because I personally feel it will get worse. Maybe your SIL is too and just doesnt want to discuss it? It doesnt really sound like it but maybe if youre close enough to her, you can bring it up with her? I am more upset with her parents, not her. I NEVER have felt this way about my niece. And I never try to feel frustration toward a child....god knows how many people have prob felt that towards johnny when he was acting horribly.. I am upset. I think that is the correct word. Upset that she is acting that way and no one is correcting it. Upset that it appears to be a control and manipulation thing on her part. It's weird. Her behavior is drastically different than it was at 2. Just to clarify...I never get angry at her or am mean towards her. If anything, I hug her or just rub her back and say "Mia, where is my good little mia??". In the past she would have smiled and then started laughing and talked to me a mile a minute. Now..she will keep coloring or playing and grit her teeth and run away or just ignore you altogether. The worst is poor Johnny trying to interact with her. he gets SO UPSET. He will yell her name and she turns her head away. I guess time will tell what is going on. I won't speak to SIL about it. Maybe DH can talk and ask if something is going on so we don't feel like its US you know?? I felt particularly bad b/c I bought plastic pumpkins that I filled with treats for all the kids...she would not say thank you. SIL Actually did approach that and yell at her to say thank you. She shook her head "no" and peeked in the bucket and walked away. I guess my candy and sparkly clips were no match for grandmas toys I have to find humor somewhere!! |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... At 3 years old my first instinct is to say it's a phase. Kids go through phases where they favor one person over another or they are not interested in someone at all and personally, I don't think forcing the issue with her is going to make it better. I'm sure in her own time she will come around. I know that with my DD (she's 2) she has had moments where she became completely disinterested in someone even though prior to that she was crazy about them. She went through a phase for a few months where she had no interest in my Dad and it was upsetting for him but it wasn't personal and one day she was just over it and she was back to playing with and loving him. I think it's common for a toddler to have these phases so I wouldn't really make an issue of it and hopefully in time it will pass. I don't necessarily feel that it's a parenting issue as much as it might be a personality issue/phase. Message edited 2010-11-08 08:56:13.297000. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Posted by Salason I have a 3yr old who acts this way sometimes and it stresses me out to no end. I dont think you should be mad at her - she's 3. Honestly that helps nobody because my stepdad acts like this with my DS and it only exacerbates him not wanting to speak to him and gives me so much anxiety that I dont enjoy visits AT ALL. DH & I tend to go the opposite extreme from your SIL and fight with DS over it, time outs etc but I don't think that's helping either. I think it's social immaturity and in DS' case, shyness and social anxiety too. We have no idea why he's like this but we're not going to just accept it because it does come across as bratty. So we're doing a lot of work trying to figure out the problem and how to best approach it - talking to teachers, peds etc. I don't think your SIL can ignore it because I personally feel it will get worse. Maybe your SIL is too and just doesnt want to discuss it? It doesnt really sound like it but maybe if youre close enough to her, you can bring it up with her? ETA: Sorry I just read your 2nd post and it sounds different... if anyone had taken away a toy from DS he'd have cried (it's really anxiety and fear for him) but not gritted his teeth. It sounds like she's got some anger issues that they need to address... It definitely sounds like your SIL needs to see how she's behaving in school and see what the peds says. Ugh, I know it's a difficult situation I'm sorry you're going through this sometimes with your DS. But i have to say..kudos to you for addressing it with him! If SIL did that, it would at least make everyone feel better... I am sure it will pass with your son. And I'm sorry your stepdad makes it worse. I think for older people especially its hard for them to accept a child acting that way. I try to be understanding...it just seems like its a different thing going on w/Mia. It comes across as pure brattiness and nastiness but who knows..I am sure its something! |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Posted by Hofstra26 At 3 years old my first instinct is to say it's a phase. Kids go through phases where they favor one person over another or they are not interested in someone at all and personally, I don't think forcing the issue with her is going to make it better. I'm sure in her own time she will come around. I know that with my DD (she's 2) she has had moments where she became completely disinterested in someone even though prior to that she was crazy about them. She went through a phase for a few months where she had no interest in my Dad and it was upsetting for him but it wasn't personal and one day she was just over it and she was back to playing with and loving him. I think it's common for a toddler to have these phases so I wouldn't really make an issue of it and hopefully in time it will pass. I don't necessarily feel that it's a parenting issue as much as it might be a personality issue/phase. I understand what you're saying..but 2 is much different than 3.5 My son had a lot of developmental issues but i would have been damned if he were downright nasty to his aunts/uncles/cousins and i didn't address it. I won't make it an issue with them, but I also have no desire to ever visit. Everyone is on edge from it. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Posted by maybebaby Posted by Hofstra26 At 3 years old my first instinct is to say it's a phase. Kids go through phases where they favor one person over another or they are not interested in someone at all and personally, I don't think forcing the issue with her is going to make it better. I'm sure in her own time she will come around. I know that with my DD (she's 2) she has had moments where she became completely disinterested in someone even though prior to that she was crazy about them. She went through a phase for a few months where she had no interest in my Dad and it was upsetting for him but it wasn't personal and one day she was just over it and she was back to playing with and loving him. I think it's common for a toddler to have these phases so I wouldn't really make an issue of it and hopefully in time it will pass. I don't necessarily feel that it's a parenting issue as much as it might be a personality issue/phase. I understand what you're saying..but 2 is much different than 3.5 My son had a lot of developmental issues but i would have been damned if he were downright nasty to his aunts/uncles/cousins and i didn't address it. I won't make it an issue with them, but I also have no desire to ever visit. Everyone is on edge from it. I hear ya. I edited my original post. I do see why you are upset and I agree with what you are saying.
Message edited 2010-11-08 08:57:28.120000. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... It is obvious you are upset with SIL, not your niece. I mean, she's three, she only knows what she's been taught or what she's allowed to get away with. And in this case, clearly she's ruling the roost. And unfortunately, you cannot overstep the boundary and tell someone else how to parent their child. I know it's upsetting, but it's how they're choosing to deal with it, right or wrong. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 8:58 AM
|
|
|
saraH
Member since 5/05 16555 total posts Name: |
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... I would say that it's age approrpriate, but the smirk thing makes me think she knows exactly what she is doing. |
Posted 11/8/10 9:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... I agree with the PPs, she's 3 and their personality is unpredicatable. but, at the same time, since the paretns arent doing anything to correct it, that worries me. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 9:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Thanks for the replies everyone.. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 9:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... My 3yo niece was like this. Family gatherings were painful bc she wouldn't even say hi to us. My Bro and SIL enrolled her in school 3 days a week and it helped her learn to socialize more. Is Mia around kids and other grown ups a lot? |
|
Posted 11/8/10 9:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... My DS is like that somethimes. It started around age 3+ and he is now almost 4 and a half and its getting better, but he still isn't out of it 100%. We do address the problem, but there is a fine line there. I tend to prepare him before hand and tell him when you see our friend you need to be polite and say hello. If he is already in the moment and refusing to talk to someone its hard to get him to say hello and ends up being a battle of wills. I usually remove him until he is ready to "be polite" When he goes to work with DH, DH gets frustrated that DS wont say hi to people etc and tries to force the subject and somethimes DS ends up thinking its some kind of game. We didn't see my brother and his wife and kids very often and he would always try to refuse to say hello to my brother and SIL (he always said hi to his cousins) I would tell him before we got there, I expect good manners, you need to say hi to uncle and aunt. Now my brother and his wife are taking a break so my brother is staying with my parents so we see him every week and there is no longer an issue. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 9:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior...
|
|
Posted 11/8/10 1:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... You sound really sad and I feel for you and I'm not in your shoes so I cant say too much of how I would act... |
|
Posted 11/8/10 2:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Very very frustrated/upset at my nieces behavior... Posted by dm24angel You sound really sad and I feel for you and I'm not in your shoes so I cant say too much of how I would act... But even if you see your niece everyday, you don't whats really going on? And at 3 yrs old, I just dont think I understand what the big deal is? If this is how they choose to deal with it, so be it...If she was 13 it might be different. Maybe they are embarrassed by her behavior, maybe someone told them to ignore it. Maybe your niece just simply doesn't want to talk to you. I don't think she should be forced to interact. Maybe it is a result of her spoiling, but I dont think its fair to vent about how horrible her Parents are for allowing this. You really cant know it all about what happens. I think my own 4 yr old niece gets away with murder, and she lives upstairs from us so I see her 15 times a day, but its not my place to do anything about it, or even to care unless she is being abused, its not my business end of story. I would rather her be more well behaved, but not my place. I hope this doesnt come off too attacking. I'm really not, I get how upset you are and its ok to vent, but thats my perspective and its a bit different so I shared it. Good luck regardless. I guess I find it a big deal when a 3.5 year old is allowed to treat her aunt, uncle and cousin like this. I do have a problem with it and I feel like most people would. And i'm sorry...but I should be allowed to vent about bad parenting because it IS. Not nipping something like this in the bud or talking to the child is a disservice to the child. It is teaching that being rude to family is OK. And since when is that ok? And call me crazy but isn't 3.5 seems an appropriate age to correct this behavior when it is happening. I would never let my kid act this way toward family. NEVER. It is hurtful and inappropriate. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 2:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: . I just wanted to offer some insight. My DD will be 4 next month and has, in the past year, begun to act in a similar way. MY daughter is NOT shy at all. However, sometimes in social situations she begins to act in a similar way (especially around my side of the family). IN my DD's case I think it is a bit of social anxiety when she does not fell 100% comfortable in a situation. But, an outsider would definately see it as bratty behavior. She will ignore some of my family members when they speak to her etc. She is not otherwise like this. I try to pull her aside and speak to her about it but I will NOT force her to speak to someone nor will I punish her for it. She is basically acting out because she is uncomfortable in a situation and I truly feel it is age appropriate behavior as they start to be more aware of social interaction. |
|
Posted 11/8/10 2:30 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| so upset and frustrated with DH- warning LONG | luckystar08 | 1/6/10 | 13 | TTC |
| SO FRUSTRATED/UPSET (SUper Long) | Holly | 9/18/07 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| so nervous, upset, annoyed, frustrated. UPDATED at bottom. | sfp0701 | 7/11/08 | 18 | Infertility |














