2 Godmothers?

Posted By Message

peabody
Love green icing!!!

Member since 5/05

4691 total posts

Name:

2 Godmothers?

Okay, so my brother asked me to be the godmother of his new baby girl along with his wife's friend. So we would both be godmothers.

Have you ever heard of that?

To be honest, my brother said he wanted me and my DH, but I guess my SIL said no, she wanted her friend.

I have really mixed feelings about this. I am trying to process it and figure out how I feel.

So basically my SIL doesn't want me to really be the godmother, which kinda hurts my feelings too.

Posted 8/17/10 11:06 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: 2 Godmothers?

At my church they actually cited the canon law and said there can only be one godmother and one godfather. Chat Icon

Posted 8/17/10 11:09 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: 2 Godmothers?

Is it just the 2 of you? Or your husband also.

I wanted to have two godfathers for my DS but we ended up not doing that. I was doing it because I thought I was only going to have 1 child and we both wanted our brothers as godfather.

Posted 8/17/10 11:10 PM
 

Dani77
It's FUN to be ONE

Member since 7/09

4363 total posts

Name:
Danicia

Re: 2 Godmothers?

Didn't think that was possible...

Posted 8/17/10 11:15 PM
 

peabody
Love green icing!!!

Member since 5/05

4691 total posts

Name:

Re: 2 Godmothers?

Posted by KerriSteve

Is it just the 2 of you? Or your husband also.

I wanted to have two godfathers for my DS but we ended up not doing that. I was doing it because I thought I was only going to have 1 child and we both wanted our brothers as godfather.



Yes, it would just be the 2 godmothers. No godfather.

Posted 8/17/10 11:21 PM
 

ThreeCats
Train Ride

Member since 5/05

3127 total posts

Name:
A

Re: 2 Godmothers?

my son has two godmothers and zero godfathers.

technically one person is the godmother and the other is a christian witness.


Posted 8/18/10 9:10 AM
 

Little-J-Mommy
I'm a Big Brother

Member since 5/06

8041 total posts

Name:
D

Re: 2 Godmothers?

in my church you must have a godfather and only one. they allowed us to have 2 godmothers who are my 2 sisters. I was happy to not have to choose between them. your situation seems different....i'd be hurt by sil tooChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/18/10 10:01 AM
 

lorich
.

Member since 6/05

9987 total posts

Name:
Grammie says "Lora Gina"

Re: 2 Godmothers?

I'm one of 2 Godmothers for my Niece AND Nephew.

I have absolutely no problem with it BUT DH wasn't in the picture when my Nephew was born & we had just started dating when my Niece was born, so that makes a big difference in our case.

Posted 8/18/10 10:05 AM
 

jam11308

Member since 11/07

7273 total posts

Name:

Re: 2 Godmothers?

Are you Catholic? We baptised our ds Episcopalian & we were allowed to have 2 "real" godfathers & a godmother for him, which is what we did. If he was a girl we were allowed 2 godmothers & a godfather. We both only have brothers so DS has DH's brother & his wife & my twin brother as his godparents Chat Icon

ETA:

Posted by peabody
So basically my SIL doesn't want me to really be the godmother, which kinda hurts my feelings too.


I wouldn't look at it that way - I think that she probably loves you both like sisters which is why she couldn't pick just one or 1 over the other. I'd try to look at it as a compliment Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-08-18 10:25:47.773000.

Posted 8/18/10 10:23 AM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: 2 Godmothers?

Posted by LoveyQ

At my church they actually cited the canon law and said there can only be one godmother and one godfather. Chat Icon



I think I remember this rule too from our baptism class. It must be one man and one woman

Posted 8/18/10 10:30 AM
 

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: 2 Godmothers?

Posted by LoveyQ

At my church they actually cited the canon law and said there can only be one godmother and one godfather. Chat Icon



mine too. They wouldn't even get into the christian witness thing.

Posted 8/18/10 10:31 AM
 

oneday
<3

Member since 5/05

4319 total posts

Name:
Pam

Re: 2 Godmothers?

Guess it really depends on the church. My neice has 2 godmothers and no godfather - it was in a Congregational church. DHs sister had her SIL and her best friend. I don't think she so much didn't want her SIL as she REALLY wanted her best friend. But her other daughter's godmother is her other SIL and they knew if the other SIL never got to be a godmother (they only plan on the 2 kids) that she would raise hell so this was an easier way to deal with it.

ETA - I think I made it sound like they HAD to include SIL not that they wanted to - they did want her as a godmother as well because they love her and wanted to honor her too - but she's easily offended too, so if they hadn't included her they would have felt bad AND she would have been angry.

Message edited 2010-08-18 11:36:44.077000.

Posted 8/18/10 11:07 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: 2 Godmothers?

Robbie has 2 godmothers and 1 godfather.

My sister actually got confirmed specifically so she could stand as Robbie's godmother. Rob asked his sister. I saw it as a spiritual guide - Rob looked at it as an 'honor' type thing.

It wasn't about not wanting one or the other.. it was sincerely about wanting BOTH... so I wouldn't feel hurt or immediately conclude that your SIL didn't want you.

If you want to be godmother, accept the role gracefully and don't worry about 'competing' - they obviously love you and want to show that you have a place of honor in their child's life. They obviously want to show the same to the friend. There is no insult - only love Chat Icon

As to the 'church' only one person could sign as godmother - but both got to stand up and participate in the ceremony. Since teh document is not 'official' and bears no meaning for guardianship or anything else - it really didn't matter to us who signed it. It also didn't matter to my sister - so my SIL signed it. Both women take their role as godparent seriously regardless of the paper.

Message edited 2010-08-18 11:32:27.413000.

Posted 8/18/10 11:30 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
in the catholic church, can you have 2 godmothers? TimeForOneMore 4/14/09 8 Parenting
godmothers or parents who bought a cross MamaNDaddyof3 7/28/08 13 Parenting
Godmothers...... DKF1016 6/18/08 6 Families Helping Families ™
2 godmothers? dcl08 9/17/07 9 Parenting
2 Godmothers??? Kotka 7/19/07 14 Parenting
Godmothers nhnic 2/7/07 6 Parenting