.
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
. Message edited 2007-04-09 15:52:46.920000. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:24 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) I have the same issue with my Mom. Is your Mom depressed? I think that plays a big part in it. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) I can answer you very well. I lived it myself and I watch it happen with certain members of my family as well as friends. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) I wouldn't tell her she needs to lose weight - she knows. You could try suggesting things that would encourage weight loss like go for walks or things like that. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) i'm having the exact same problem. my mom is obese and is having major health problems. she's 58 going on 80! she has back problems, high cholesterol, etc. Message edited 2007-04-09 10:44:42.123000. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) You're walking into dangerous territory here, but, I think it is something you have to do. Your mother is a very young woman to not be able to catch her breath the way you describe. Yes, her weight is a factor, but, I don't think it is the only problem. She could, very well, have problems with her lungs and her heart. I don't think you should approach this as a weight problem. You might try it as an overall health problem. You and your sister should sit down with and let her know what you've observed. Tell her how you feel and that you love her and need her to be around for a long time. Try to have her understand that life would be unbearable without her and that her grandchildren need to know her. She may make look at this as criticism and dig in her heels, but, you will have planted a seed. All you can do is try. The next step is up to her. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) absolutely NOT! you can't force people into losing weight, they have to be ready to make a change. all you will end up doing is hurting your Mom |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Posted by Goldi0218 I can answer you very well. I lived it myself and I watch it happen with certain members of my family as well as friends. My truth was that at 260 pounds, there was not a soul in the world who could convince me that I had to lose weight to save myself. It was something that had to come from within myself. I was (and still am) a smart and educated adult woman, who knew/knows full well what it takes to live a healthy existence. I didn't want to hear it from anyone else. It took me to have a long hard look at myself, re-evaluate my life and make a life altering decision to make myself well both physically and mentally. I didn't need people telling me I was fat. I already shopped in plus-size stores and wore a size 24. I have family members who are and have been in that danger zone of putting their lives on the line with excess weight. They ARE morbidly obese and have all sorts of medical problems DIRECTLY related to their weight. I used to have the denial myself so I know what it is like. No matter how much concern loved ones put forth, it often falls upon deaf ears. If you feel compelled to say something, do it in a subtle way and carefully. Express concern in a gentle way. "Attacking" is never the way to go. With someone who is older the battle is even harder. There are more years of bad memories and bad habits to fight. If she regularly visits her doctor, I would also suggest the following: call her doctor before her next visit and inform him of what you see her go through. s/he may or may not report back to you what he finds (because of privacy laws - unless you are her health care proxy)but at least you will get it out there. We do that all the time. I would also try to make yourself available to take your mother to her doctor's appointments. Sometimes people hear what they want to hear and do not heed doctor's advice when nobody is there to correct or help them. Good luck. It is not an easy fight. You may go back and forth with this for a while until it sinks in and again, it may not sink in at all. I never thought about calling the doctor...thats a great idea though. As long as she doesn't know though, she would be so upset if she knew. I would never attack her, I know it hurts to hear what you already know. But you are right when you say it falls upon deaf ears. But I can't help but be so angry. I see someone hurting herself and she has so much to live for. Depression may be a factor. She doesn't act very depressed, but I know she is sad. She went through a bad divorce, continues to be treated badly by my father, and her youngest child is leaving the house in a few months when she starts college. She goes from 6 kids to none in a matter of a few years. I know it's hard for her. I am very happy for you that you took steps to help yourself :) I know it must not have been easy...but in the end, it's the best thing you could have done. I admire that and hope my mother will take those measures. I want her to value herself more, and realize that she has a lot to live for. It makes me so, so sad. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Posted by SweetestOfPeas absolutely NOT! you can't force people into losing weight, they have to be ready to make a change. all you will end up doing is hurting your Mom ![]() See, it isn't so much though about telling someone "lost weight!". It's more about wanting them around...it was so scary to hear her complain of chest pains. 48 year olds should not have bad pain! Her knees too...it took her half an hour to catch her breath after walking up the stairs. It's just upsetting. I know what you're saying..people have to be ready, but maybe they need to hear it from their loves ones to get started. If we all ignore it, are we making the problem worse? Aren't we guilty as well for ignoring it?? she has 6 kids and none of us really talk about it except with one another.. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Posted by browneyedgirl i'm having the exact same problem. my mom is obese and is having major health problems. she's 58 going on 80! she has back problems, high cholesterol, etc. everything i say falls on deaf ears. she insists she could lose weight if she wanted to...and she COULD if she TRIED. my aunt and i tell her all the time that she won't be walking in a few years. she won't be able to play with her own future grandchildren. i've tried joining diets with her, asking her to go for a walk, etc but she always says no. unfortunately, she has to be the one to want to do it and it's heartbreaking to me. best of luck to you. ETA: i didn't even realize it was you maybebaby who posted this when i responded. i wish we could get our moms to do something together. then they could actually have some fun and lose weight with a friend. Lol! yep its me. will call you soon! Ummm and we've talked about our moms many times...carol, its so bad. I am so afraid she is going to actually have a heart attack. It was awful. To not say goodbye to us b/c she couldn't do the walk...very upsetting. I hope your mom takes care of herself soon too-they need to be around for their grandbabies!! |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Posted by melijane I have the same issue with my Mom. Is your Mom depressed? I think that plays a big part in it. If I ever say anything to my Mom she will turn it around(I am overweight) But I can walk, run, clean, walk up and down stairs, etc. I am healthy she is not. I don't really think there is an easy solution. What about getting her nutrisystem as a gift? Family members once got her a membership to WW b.c she talked about joining all the time but didn't have the $$. When they gave her ther membership and all the extras with it, she cried. She was so hurt and offended. So something like this would unfortunately not work for her...but thank you for the suggestion
|
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Like Goldi said, I think calling her doctor is an excellent idea. You may be able to fill him in on things that she chooses to not tell him/her. Message edited 2007-04-09 10:57:20.983000. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 10:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Posted by CoopersMom01 Like Goldi said, I think calling her doctor is an excellent idea. You may be able to fill him in on things that she chooses to not tell him/her. What if you suggest excersizing WITH her. Make it seem like you're the one who wants to get in better physical shape/condition and were wondering if she'd like to join you. The worst she can say is no, and you're not directly telling her that it's her that needs to be in better physical condition. I've never had to deal with this problem, but seems like it's something that needs to be handled with kid gloves. good luck! Thank you! I am 5 hours away (in VA) unfortunately. But when i lived home it didn't work. I actually joined WW in 2001, and lost 45 pounds and have kept it all off (except during pregnancy but am almost back at starting weight :) She would try it out for a week, and say it was too much to keep track of. It's only my little sister home now who can help her. My sister got her a yoga tape for christmas (my mom wanted it). Guess what is still unopened. My mom bought a treadmill, but it is basically a closet now. She used it maybe 2 times. I am out of ideas..I do NOT want to hurt my mom, I love her-even though we may argue...I just need something to happen. I don't want it taking a trip to the hospital to scare her, you know? |
|
Posted 4/9/07 11:05 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Have you told her how you feel? I know its treading on thin ice to talk to people about their health, but maybe if you told her you are scared of her having a heart attack, not being around to see her grandkids, etc. that might have some kind of an impact? |
|
Posted 4/9/07 11:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) I am overweight. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 11:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) I didn't mean this post to be about telling an overweight person she is overweight. It's not only weight. Its so much more. Of course no one wants to hear they need to lose weight! I needed to lose the 45 I gained in college and knew i needed to. So i did. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 11:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Posted by june262004 I am overweight. 1) my feelings would be EXTREMELY HURT!!!!!!!!!! 2) I KNOW I am OVERWEIGHT! No one has to tell me. 3) you telling her is not going to change her. She will do it for herself and only when she is ready. You saying something might even make it WORSE! TOTALLY agree. It would make me more upset and eat more. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 11:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) See I kinda disagree. I have been overweight my whole life, until recently that is. I didn't need anyone to tell me I was fat, I knew it. However, I think it was the duty of my loved ones (mostly my dad, sometimes my hubby and sister) to tell me I was hurting myself. Most of the time I didn't want to hear it, I dreaded those conversations and always got upset. But I still needed to hear it - they were right and I was hurting myself. For almost 20 years it fell on deaf ears. I would start diets, stop - I would exercise, then quit. It was so frustrating and then finally one day it hit. For me it was the realization that if I wanted to get pregnant and have a healthy baby I needed to lose weight first. I can happily say I went from a size 22 to a 12, I am still not at my goal weight but know I will get there (right now I am concentrating on my pregnancy). But my point is I understand why my dad would talk to me about this, he loved and cared for me and it was his duty! |
|
Posted 4/9/07 11:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) Posted by maybebaby I didn't mean this post to be about telling an overweight person she is overweight. It's not only weight. Its so much more. Of course no one wants to hear they need to lose weight! I needed to lose the 45 I gained in college and knew i needed to. So i did. But if a sibling saw ME struggling to breathe, complaining of chest pain, poor circulation etc...I would HOPE someone would talk to me. Not threatingly, not degrading...just talk. Thats all I meant. I can't sit and watch my mom like this. If she were 80 pounds overweight and HEALTHY i couldn't care less about the number. Its watching a 48 year old lady walk around like she's 80. That is the upsetting truth. But you don't think she knows she can't breathe when she walks up stairs
|
|
Posted 4/9/07 12:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) I have always been overweight and the only way I have ever been able to lose weight is to motivate myself, like Goldi said. |
|
Posted 4/9/07 12:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Have you/Would you speak up if someone in your immediate family was not taking care of themselves? (weight related) That's a tough call......I used to be very obese and I didn't need a reminder from anyone about something I obviously already knew.....I KNEW it was bad for my health -- reminding me would only make me more depressed.....but I understand your concern and love for your mother....it's a tough situation and I wish I had some better advice for you.... |
|
Posted 4/9/07 12:58 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hot Bod for Summer!!! Official Weight Loss Thread!!! - Come Join :-) | azoodie | 4/9/07 | 115 | Diet & Fitness |
| Nicole Kidman & Keith Urban: Easter Family Reunion in Sydney | MrsQ | 4/9/07 | 0 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| JENNA LOSING WEIGHT AND FANS | MrsQ | 4/9/07 | 0 | Celebrities & Entertainment |








i wish we could get our moms to do something together. then they could actually have some fun and lose weight with a friend. 








