Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: "Reborn Babies"

Posted by hbugal

Posted by donegal419

Posted by BabySammie

If it helps someone cope with the grieving of having lost a baby.. then i say its a wonderful thing.



i have to disagree. I am not a psychologist or anything, but i would have to think that this would actually impede the healing process. How does one get through it and "move on" (I know move on is not the best way to say that, because a baby's death is something you never get over) but i would think that "playing" with a real baby keeps you "stuck" in a place that realistically you're no longer in. That cannot be healthy.

I also feel that it doesn't show much respect or value human life. you wouldn't treat a real baby like a doll, so why are you going to make a doll like a real baby? And like everything else, people will want to buy the baby that they "want" (i.e. blonde, blue-eyed 100% healthy and normal) and not what would realistically be born.

Odd, odd, odd, IMO.



You wouldnt understand unless you lost a child....



I agree...I think that unless you are in that situation, you have NO idea how you would feel...try to be less judgemental

Posted 7/21/08 8:45 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LaurenExp
Waiting patiently for baby sis

Member since 8/06

11613 total posts

Name:
L-Diddy EDD 11/11/11 :)

Re: "Reborn Babies"

Posted by stephanief

Posted by hbugal

Posted by donegal419

Posted by BabySammie

If it helps someone cope with the grieving of having lost a baby.. then i say its a wonderful thing.



i have to disagree. I am not a psychologist or anything, but i would have to think that this would actually impede the healing process. How does one get through it and "move on" (I know move on is not the best way to say that, because a baby's death is something you never get over) but i would think that "playing" with a real baby keeps you "stuck" in a place that realistically you're no longer in. That cannot be healthy.

I also feel that it doesn't show much respect or value human life. you wouldn't treat a real baby like a doll, so why are you going to make a doll like a real baby? And like everything else, people will want to buy the baby that they "want" (i.e. blonde, blue-eyed 100% healthy and normal) and not what would realistically be born.

Odd, odd, odd, IMO.



You wouldnt understand unless you lost a child....



I agree...I think that unless you are in that situation, you have NO idea how you would feel...try to be less judgemental



Exactly. I lost my son. I would wake up in the middle of the night cradling a pillow, crying. You have no idea what its like to lose a child. I would hold my cats in a cradling position just to feel the warmth next to my body. It was an awful experience and I would never want anyone to have to live it. I don't know that I would buy one of these dolls, because the temptation would be to great to never let go, but I would never think it odd or weird that someone did do this. To each their own. If it helps them cope, then they should do what is best for them. Chat Icon

Posted 7/21/08 8:55 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: "Reborn Babies"

Posted by LaurenExp

If it helps them cope, then they should do what is best for them. Chat Icon



exactly. I am so sorry for your loss Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/21/08 8:58 AM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: "Reborn Babies"

Cuddling and holding on to a doll because it helps with a loss or makes you feel same, normal. Like a security blanket.

Collecting dolls - I can see it as normal.

However, treating a dolll like a real baby and buying it clothes and carriages and taking it for a walk and acting like it is real is creepy to me.

I do think they were cute dolls as gift. If they werent so expensive i would get it for my niece to help her prepare for her new sibling.

Posted 7/21/08 9:35 AM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: "Reborn Babies"

Posted by stephanief

I agree...I think that unless you are in that situation, you have NO idea how you would feel...try to be less judgemental



i am not being judgemental... God, this board sometimes is just too much. no one can just take someone's opinion and leave it at that.

all i said was that I didn't think it would be healthy for a grieving mother... like a below poster said, she would never get a doll like that because it would be too hard to let go! a doll can never replace the beautiful baby that was lost, so why try? i would imagine even having the doll would be just too painful.

Posted 7/21/08 10:34 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: "Reborn Babies"

Posted by donegal419

Posted by stephanief

I agree...I think that unless you are in that situation, you have NO idea how you would feel...try to be less judgemental



i am not being judgemental... God, this board sometimes is just too much. no one can just take someone's opinion and leave it at that.

all i said was that I didn't think it would be healthy for a grieving mother... like a below poster said, she would never get a doll like that because it would be too hard to let go! a doll can never replace the beautiful baby that was lost, so why try? i would imagine even having the doll would be just too painful.



don't take things too personal Chat Icon

I just think until you are in that situation, it is easy to say what you would do or what you think is healthy vs not-healthy

that is what I was saying...claws away now Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/21/08 10:36 AM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: "Reborn Babies"

Posted by stephanief

don't take things too personal Chat Icon

I just think until you are in that situation, it is easy to say what you would do or what you think is healthy vs not-healthy

that is what I was saying...claws away now Chat Icon Chat Icon



sorry--- i didn't mean too sound so mean. you're right, i don't know what i would do in that situation, but i do feel that every time I post something on here, no one can just leave it at that. i get accussed of being judgemental and that's not fair. sorry! Chat Icon

Posted 7/21/08 10:42 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: "Reborn Babies"

Posted by donegal419

Posted by stephanief

don't take things too personal Chat Icon

I just think until you are in that situation, it is easy to say what you would do or what you think is healthy vs not-healthy

that is what I was saying...claws away now Chat Icon Chat Icon



sorry--- i didn't mean too sound so mean. you're right, i don't know what i would do in that situation, but i do feel that every time I post something on here, no one can just leave it at that. i get accussed of being judgemental and that's not fair. sorry! Chat Icon



I am sorry if you felt I was attacking you, that was not my intention. I just think people (not JUST you) are always so quick to say what they would do or what they *think* the right thing to do. Maybe judgemental was not the right word Chat Icon

Posted 7/21/08 10:50 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Our babies Diana1215 3/22/06 6 Pets
I read that at this stage of pregnancy, babies sleep 90-95% of the time MrsJ 3/20/06 10 Pregnancy
Babies and cats Disneygirl 3/15/06 7 Parenting
Just wanted to share- for babies with sleep issues sunny 3/13/06 2 Parenting
Moms of 4-6 mo old babies... Melbernai 3/12/06 6 Parenting
Babies r' us Coupons DebG 3/12/06 11 Pregnancy