Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list? My heart breaks for the poor brides family that is appealing to the public for a liver. But is it right? |
|
Posted 7/22/05 1:36 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list? Being that my father-in-law is on this list, I have to say NO - I don't think its fair that some people get to bypass the list. |
|
Posted 7/22/05 1:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list? Posted by Tracey Being that my father-in-law is on this list, I have to say NO - I don't think its fair that some people get to bypass the list. sorry about your FIL. But I do agree with you. If people don't have the resources and contacts and carry faith in the list, that should be enough.
|
|
Posted 7/22/05 1:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list? I'm undecided about that. |
|
Posted 7/22/05 1:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list? Posted by baghag I'm undecided about that. But I think the donor (assuming he/she is alive), can choose who to give donate to. Like if I wanted to donate a kidney, I could say who on the list I wanted to give it to, regardless of that persons # on the list. I would think that is fine, mainly since not too many people would be giving up kidneys to strangers. I think if it is a total donation as a gift than that should be okay. I can understand family. But on life support, it should just be given to next on the list. If anything the bride's family right now can be doing a large campaign for people to sign up to be donors. |
|
Posted 7/22/05 2:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list? VERY hard to say, I would like to say No, but what if it were a family member of mine and I had the means to bypass the list... |
|
Posted 7/22/05 10:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list? My father had a kidney transplant one month ago. My feeling is that if someone dies and their organs are harvested, they should go to the next person on the list. While I agree that is somewhat unfair for someone with a proactive family with a lot of resources to be able to get a live donor to donate a kidney, and hence jump the list, that is really the donor's choice. Honestly, if it were my family member, I would want to use whatever resources I had, too. |
|
Posted 7/22/05 10:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Organ Transplants-Should you be allowed to make direct appeals and bypass the list? I think this situation is somewhat unique because of the time considerations. Basically, from the time Shari's family found out she needed a new liver, she had one week to find one. Clearly, if she needed to wait on the list, she would die. |
|
Posted 7/22/05 11:04 PM
|
|




