The Walking Dead- spoilers!

I can't believe he left Carol!

The Walking Dead- spoilers!

I know, right? I still think Carol is covering for that kid. Did you notice that she didn't even cough or seem sick at all? Something is up with that!

Re: The Walking Dead- spoilers!

I could not believe that either!!! Who stabbed and dragged that person who was coughing in the very beginning? It didn't look as though the person had turned yet..was it Glen?

Re: The Walking Dead- spoilers!

So annoyed with the whole Carol scene! Really Rick?! He just met those other people and she was just trying to protect everyone else ugh!

The Walking Dead- spoilers!

Maybe Carol sent the little girl in to kill people? Like as a test. I have been racking my brain.

The Walking Dead- spoilers!

considering everyone turned against Shane as they discovered he killed Randall against the grp's decision in season 2, this seemed right - in line with the grp's morality and previous actions
But still - bring back Carol! he better get her back. wtf???

Re: The Walking Dead- spoilers!

That whole scene at the end did not sit well with me

Rick has no right to judge Carol like that and impose that sort of sentence on her when she really was acting just like him. Throughout the entire show, he's done whatever is necessary to keep the group safe and protected - including killing people and leaving random strangers to be killed. Ever since last season, he's been struggling with his leadership role and not wanting to be so violent to teach Carl that there are other ways to survive. I get that..
But he had no right to judge Carol for essentially doing what he's done all along. Yes, she murdered those two, which was wrong. But she was doing it for a good reason, and deserved the option of going back to the group and having them vote on what to do with her.
She did not deserve Rick to be judge and jury and just turn her out like that. He should have brought her back and had the council decide what her fate was.

That was so wrong to me.. and i can't even imagine what Darryl is going to say/do to him when he gets back!

Re: The Walking Dead- spoilers!

if you really think about it he didnt really force her to leave. She can go right back to the prison if she really wanted to who will stop her. She has a car. I dont know if i agreed on the decision he made if it should have been a joint decision my thinking is he knows that the guy is going to want to kill her (cant remember his name right now) and having a group decision may just rip the group apart.

Also i see her going back for those girls anyway.

Re: The Walking Dead- spoilers!

I don't really see that Carol did anything wrong. She said so herself that they were bleeding out. It should have been brought up to the council.

There is nothing she wants that she left at the prison? Also IMO, those little girls (one of which I agree she's covering for), should have some say if they want to go with her. Their dad asked Carol to look out for them.

Can't wait to see what Darryl has to say about it.

He has a rolling sense of morality. It's ok for Carl to shot an unarmed kid in the woods but Carol allegedly kills infected people on the brink of turning into zombies & she's out?

Also if Tyrese knew they were turning, he'd probably be more understanding about it.

Message edited 11/4/2013 2:26:47 PM.

The Walking Dead- spoilers!

Honestly, I don't think that Rick decision was so black and white. First, Carol took the law into her own hands by killing those two people, so she herself already went outside the counsel's decision making process. Next, I think he was trying to protect her because he knew that Tyrese would kill her and he didn't want that to happen. Finally, I found the underlying theme of the whole show to be moving to be moral and civilized, and the new "Carol" wasn't in line with those goals.