Is it better not to give anything?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Is it better not to give anything? DD is in third grade. Message edited 2022-12-13 01:11:59.580000. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 1:11 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Never heard of kids giving gifts in class and I think it’s rude to give more to some than others as they will probably open it up right in front of everyone and see that. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 3:40 AM
|
|
|
Is it better not to give anything? I would do the notepad, pencil and candy cane for everyone. Its all or nothing. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 5:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? My kids loved getting those gifts at that age. I agree though, do same for everyone, candy cane, pencil and notepad. I can't imagine it costs much more to get an extra pack of pencils or two to cover the rest of the class. But also, doing nothing is fine. I have never done gifts like that at xmas. Only valentines day. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 7:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Posted by lululu My kids loved getting those gifts at that age. I agree though, do same for everyone, candy cane, pencil and notepad. I can't imagine it costs much more to get an extra pack of pencils or two to cover the rest of the class. But also, doing nothing is fine. I have never done gifts like that at xmas. Only valentines day. Same and wasn't sure if that is what kids do now. Only Vday and then it was just a card and a lollipop or candy. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 7:50 AM
|
|
|
Is it better not to give anything? hmmm so its strange to give something out for Christmas? Message edited 2022-12-13 08:25:24.753000. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 8:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? I guess it depends on the school & area but I see nothing wrong with her gift idea, with the exception that everyone should get a pencil. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 8:40 AM
|
|
|
Is it better not to give anything? I think it's sweet that she wants to give her class something. Like others have said - I would give everything the same thing though. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 9:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Posted by newlywedT hmmm so its strange to give something out for Christmas? I can't remember that far back (40 years) but didn't kids give out candy canes during the holidays? So would she be considered "weird" if she gave the gift out? Should we tell her that people don't normally do it and she should not do that? Regarding the messages...its a group chat started by Kid A. One day kid L said "Hi" Kid A - Who is this? Kid L - its L Kid A - who invited you? Kid J - I invited her Kid A - Kid J I will message you about who you are allow to invite and then she kicked Kid L off the chat another time, Kid A asked for the homework questions. Kid C replied and gave it. Then another time Kid A asked for HW questions again. Kid C said - Again? how come you dont have it Kid A - gave some answer about not having it and for Kid C to just give it again and to stop questioning her Kid C - too bad, I'm not giving it this time this could be common conversations with kids these days, but I think its rude and messed up What kind of group chat is your wife on? Something with the school? Yes, sounds like 3rd graders. Did your child give out gifts in K, 1st and 2nd grade? |
|
Posted 12/13/22 9:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Posted by StaceyWill I think it's sweet that she wants to give her class something. Like others have said - I would give everything the same thing though. This 100%. My first thought was how nice and generous your DD is. If she wants to give something out I wouldn’t disappoint her by saying no. I would, however, give all the kids the same thing. As far as the kids, my DD is in second grade and the drama and meanness are insane. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 9:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Posted by windyweather21 Posted by newlywedT hmmm so its strange to give something out for Christmas? I can't remember that far back (40 years) but didn't kids give out candy canes during the holidays? So would she be considered "weird" if she gave the gift out? Should we tell her that people don't normally do it and she should not do that? Regarding the messages...its a group chat started by Kid A. One day kid L said "Hi" Kid A - Who is this? Kid L - its L Kid A - who invited you? Kid J - I invited her Kid A - Kid J I will message you about who you are allow to invite and then she kicked Kid L off the chat another time, Kid A asked for the homework questions. Kid C replied and gave it. Then another time Kid A asked for HW questions again. Kid C said - Again? how come you dont have it Kid A - gave some answer about not having it and for Kid C to just give it again and to stop questioning her Kid C - too bad, I'm not giving it this time this could be common conversations with kids these days, but I think its rude and messed up What kind of group chat is your wife on? Something with the school? Yes, sounds like 3rd graders. Did your child give out gifts in K, 1st and 2nd grade? It could be the moms. If you heard the moms of the girls in my DD’s class you wouldn’t be able to distinguish their behavior from a third grader. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 9:57 AM
|
|
|
Is it better not to give anything? The chat: |
|
Posted 12/13/22 10:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Posted by windyweather21 Posted by lululu My kids loved getting those gifts at that age. I agree though, do same for everyone, candy cane, pencil and notepad. I can't imagine it costs much more to get an extra pack of pencils or two to cover the rest of the class. But also, doing nothing is fine. I have never done gifts like that at xmas. Only valentines day. Same and wasn't sure if that is what kids do now. Only Vday and then it was just a card and a lollipop or candy. Apparently its a thing at my DD school. She came home with stuff every holiday at school last year. Its annoying Message edited 2022-12-13 12:33:36.000000. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 12:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Posted by RainyDay Posted by windyweather21 Posted by lululu My kids loved getting those gifts at that age. I agree though, do same for everyone, candy cane, pencil and notepad. I can't imagine it costs much more to get an extra pack of pencils or two to cover the rest of the class. But also, doing nothing is fine. I have never done gifts like that at xmas. Only valentines day. Same and wasn't sure if that is what kids do now. Only Vday and then it was just a card and a lollipop or candy. Apparently its a thing at my DD school. She came home with stuff every holiday at school last year. Its annoying It is and not fair to the children who can't afford to do it. I think the teacher should be the one who controls the class with gifts and such so no kids get left out or feel like they need to do something they can't or don't want to. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 12:35 PM
|
|
|
Is it better not to give anything? Kindness wins. If your daughter chooses to give out goody bags, go for it. Be sure to add a gift tag with your daughters name. I wouldn't personalize them with classmates names to make distribution faster. Class moms might also give something out, too. Parties are fun, but also a little chaos from the excitement in the air. I also think all goody bags should contain the same goodies. As far as group text, I would get her off there. There are too many kind kids in the world so she should find them. It's the age of catty groups and mean gestures to start, no need to be a part of it. Unnecessary. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 4:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? I'd give to all the same. Catty girls will be anyways. If they don't like the bag, bad for them; but good for your DD for being thoughtful about her class. I think it is a very sweet gesture. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 4:35 PM
|
|
|
Is it better not to give anything? I think it’s cute that she wants to give something. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 5:49 PM
|
|
|
Is it better not to give anything? I don't like the kids on the chat, but they are her "friends". |
|
Posted 12/13/22 6:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Posted by newlywedT I don't like the kids on the chat, but they are her "friends". They are in her class and she plays with them in the park after school. But they never ask her for play dates (in fact one of them had a party at her house and did not invite DD) I think she likes feeling included, which I think everyone will feel also. Sad as it doesn’t sound like friends to me. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 10:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Is it better not to give anything? Posted by newlywedT I don't like the kids on the chat, but they are her "friends". They are in her class and she plays with them in the park after school. But they never ask her for play dates (in fact one of them had a party at her house and did not invite DD) I think she likes feeling included, which I think everyone will feel also. I’m sorry. Your daughter sounds so sweet. You didn’t ask this but I wanted to share because we’ve had similar issues. I try to make sure my DD has lots of opportunities to develop friendships outside of school. Some school “communities” do not do a good job of making families feel welcome, but she has tons of friends from her after school program, camp, Girl Scouts so it doesn’t matter so much. |
|
Posted 12/13/22 11:32 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Which do you think is better - having an inferior daycare in the bldg that you work at or a better daycare that isn't in your building and a little out of your way? | Bridex100 | 6/11/09 | 19 | Parenting |
| So Excited for BIL...his band got signed to a better label! | sasha96 | 10/5/05 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Nutrisystem vs. Jenny Craig: Which has better food? | CathyB | 9/19/05 | 0 | Diet & Fitness |
| It is only 10:50 and Im having a bad day does it get better? (VENT) | TAD | 6/23/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Kelly Ripa....and others who "look" better after kids? | btrflygrl | 6/17/05 | 8 | Pregnancy |
| Please help ease my mind that things WILL get better.... UPDATED With Question. | KittyCat | 6/13/05 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |







