Should I stay or should I go now?

Forum Opinion Poll
Go now, get a bigger place with everything you want 20 36.36%
Stay put and make this house work for you. 12 21.82%
Wait until after the baby comes to decide. 23 41.82%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

House dilemma -- what would you do?

Posted By Message

b2b777
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

4474 total posts

Name:

House dilemma -- what would you do?

I currently own a 3BR cape in a very desirable location in my neighborhood. The layout is a little funky. We have 2 bedrooms downstairs and 1 bedroom, a bathroom, and a loft upstairs. Right now the upstairs bedroom/bath is used for guests, and the loft is an office. We use one of the BR's downstairs for ourselves and the other for my child. We are expecting another child. The room where my child sleeps now is not big enough to share, nor is it big enough for my husband and I to use. So now I wont have enough bedrooms on the same floor for us all to be together. What currently makes the most sense is that we should move upstairs, have our own space and bathroom, and the kids can each have their own room downstairs, but i feel weird not being on the same floor as them.
My gut has been telling me to move, although we would be giving up our prime spot, and spending a fortune more for the added space. My DH says stay put and see how it goes.
This all being said, there are other drawbacks to my house -- like the size of the rooms all being small (terrible for family gatherings), and a few other small things that tick me off with the backyard layout. That being said, is it worth the trouble of selling, moving, etc while pregnant to a new place? What would you do?

Posted 4/5/16 1:57 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

House dilemma -- what would you do?

Can you make the loft area a bedroom? even if it is small. Then you can have the 2 kids up and you stay down.

Posted 4/5/16 2:23 PM
 

b2b777
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

4474 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

Posted by alli3131

Can you make the loft area a bedroom? even if it is small. Then you can have the 2 kids up and you stay down.



Unfortunately the loft is on the small side. I could probably make it work for a while...but i still would be apart from them...

My child is still in a crib and not on the move.
My concern is once he is in a toddler bed he will leave his room or come looking for me. Is that what happens? If im not near by it freaks me out.

Posted 4/5/16 2:56 PM
 

NYCGirl80
I love my kiddies!

Member since 5/11

10413 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I think you should/will ultimately decide to move. But I don't think there's a rush before the baby comes. What about keeping the baby in your room initially and seeing when it feels like the right time to move? Packing and moving while pregnant is not fun, trust me, I've done it!

It doesn't sound like you love your house, so it shouldn't be your forever house. I'm not in mine, either! But knowing that we will eventually move is enough to make my current house work for us...for now.

Posted 4/5/16 3:52 PM
 

MommaG
Yay Spring!

Member since 5/05

5133 total posts

Name:
Gloria

House dilemma -- what would you do?

If you really like the location, have you considered expanding your house? You can initially keep the baby in your room, and then with your other DC when they're young. Somewhere in there expand and maybe make it into a colonial or dormer front and back to expand the top floor, maybe remove some walls downstairs to give it a better flow.

Posted 4/5/16 4:24 PM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

House dilemma -- what would you do?

We're in a similar situation and have listed our house. Although, not in a major rush to sell because I figure they can share a room if it comes down to it. My DS's room is small but we'll make it work if we have to. It's only been a few weeks but we haven't gotten any offers on our home yet, so it's not looking great. :/

Posted 4/5/16 4:57 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

House dilemma -- what would you do?

I have a cape and we have 2 beds up and one downstairs. The bedroom for my son upstairs is tiny. 7x10. It's fine even with a twin. I'm in the room downstairs.

Once my son was in the twin we put a get across the stairs and set rules that he had to call us. It's fine we have never had a problem.

Posted 4/5/16 7:26 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I'd try to sell it. Selling, buying, and moving while pg probably won't be fun... But doing that with two little children was no picnic either. If your house is priced well it'll go fast, and home prices in a lot of neighborhoods have risen even from last year. Talk to a realtor and see!

Posted 4/5/16 8:08 PM
 

w8andsee
LIF Adult

Member since 10/09

1193 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I have the same house set up. We have our bedroom upstairs and the kids sleep on the first floor. I don't think its a big deal being on different floors because its just a staircase that is basically the length of hallway. With the monitors you hear everything.

My son is in a toddler bed. He knows to shout Mommy if he needs anything. I do close the bathroom door on the 1st floor because I don't want him using it in the middle of the night by himself. I also have a gate at the basement stairs. He has come upstairs in the middle of the night by himself. I guess its easier/safer going up than down.

All that to say, stay in your home and if you really don't like it take your time and look for something else. Also look into dormering. It may be worth it if you love your neighborhood.

Posted 4/5/16 8:35 PM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

House dilemma -- what would you do?

We have 2 bedrooms down and one bedroom up. Our master and nursery are downstairs and we decided to have our kids share. It's a small room but it works fine. We moved out the glider and added a toddler bed for dd1. I'm very glad to have them together and be on the same floor. We talked about putting dd1 upstairs when she turned 4 but she didn't want to be alone up there so they'll stay put.

Posted 4/6/16 8:08 AM
 

Momma2015
Mommax2

Member since 12/12

6656 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

This was a big concern of ours when we were house hunting. A lot of the houses had bedrooms on separate floors and that was a deal breaker for us. I'd sell if I could, yeah, it's not fun doing this all while pregnant, but at least if it takes awhile, you can keep the baby in your room with you for the time being. Otherwise, if there's any way to do an expansion on the house, I'd look into that.

Posted 4/6/16 8:42 AM
 

b2b777
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

4474 total posts

Name:

House dilemma -- what would you do?

Thank you all for your input -- especially those in the same boat. It is a help!

Posted 4/6/16 9:30 AM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I think I would wait until after the baby is here to see what happens, I know I personally wouldn't want to be house hunting while pregnant... is there a way for you to expand if you love your location? This is what my sister did (also had a cape, she did a whole new 2nd floor so now she has all bedrooms upstairs, like a colonial).

I am not a fan of having the kids downstairs while I would be upstairs. My BIL did this, he expanded his ranch, created a 2nd floor that is just used a master suite, and so his young kids are now on the bottom floor and he and his wife are upstairs. I personally would rather have the kids upstairs, and my bedroom downstairs if we couldn't be all on the same floor.

Posted 4/6/16 9:41 AM
 

nicopico13
that year flew!

Member since 11/09

3008 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I'm not PG, but we are currently going through the process. I would wait until after the baby because you don't know how fast your home will sell and you don't know how long it will take you to find a new home. You do not want to feel rushed! It took us over 6 months to sell our home and almost 2 years to find a new one! Good luck, it's not fun and we have no intention of going through this process again anytime soon!

Posted 4/6/16 11:17 AM
 

LuckyStar
LIF Adult

Member since 7/14

7274 total posts

Name:

House dilemma -- what would you do?

I'd sell. We have a similar set up and if we ever had a second kid we would sell. However, we also don't like where we live and plan to move before dd is in kindergarten anyway.

If you really love your area I'd maybe look into expanding.

Posted 4/6/16 10:12 PM
 

FirstMate
My lil cowboy

Member since 10/10

7790 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

Are you in a situation where you can blow out the house? We have friends that had a cape and they put a nice dormer on it and converted the downstairs into open space.

Posted 4/7/16 1:19 PM
 

queensgal
Smile

Member since 4/09

3287 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I think you need to get estimates on dormering and compare to cost of potentially moving.

Then compare for X you could fix the bedroom situation but still have other drawbacks vs selling and buying bigger.

Either option has pros and cons. I'd get the financial details and then make an informed decision

Posted 4/8/16 10:27 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

House dilemma -- what would you do?

I would try to sell. I, personally, would never want my little kids on a different floor than me.

Posted 4/8/16 3:44 PM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I would sell right after baby is born. I could never have small kids on a different floor.

Posted 4/8/16 4:16 PM
 

MerryChristmas
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/16

513 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I would try to sell now

Posted 4/8/16 5:39 PM
 

luvmotherhood
california dreamin'

Member since 2/13

1443 total posts

Name:
love my family!

House dilemma -- what would you do?

i have a cape two up and two down. i have two small children and we are all down stairs and they are sharing the room. one in a crib and one in a toddler bed. eventually i'll move them upstairs but i didn't want to be on a different floor from them either.
we also have talked about dormering upstairs to make another bedroom, but for now our situation works.
if you don't love your house, i bet you can sell quickly but if you can see yourself staying there you do have other options!

Posted 4/9/16 8:45 PM
 

Christine Braun - Signature Premier Properties
LIFamilies Business

Member since 2/11

3992 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

I agree that it's hard to say what you should do without getting more info.

Have you looked into what you can afford if you sell your current home? I would speak to a realtor to see how much you can expect to get for your current home in this market, and then speak to a mortgage professional to see how much you would qualify for in terms of a mortgage. Then crunch your own numbers to see where you want to keep your monthly payments, and try to figure out what you can afford to spend on your next house, if you move. Then consider if you want to stay in your area, and if not, what other areas you would consider moving to, and check out what is available in your price range. Look online, check out open houses, etc.

At the same time, I would look into what it would cost to expand your house (dormering, adding on, etc.).

Once you have all of that info, you can weigh out whether it makes sense to move or stay put. I think it's definitely something you want to research a bit and get all of the facts so you can make an informed decision.

Posted 4/10/16 5:52 PM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

House dilemma -- what would you do?

We had 2 bedrooms upstairs with a full bath - and very low ceilings.

We loved our location too so we re-dormered. We now have 3 good sized bedrooms upstairs, two full baths, laundry, small office nook and lots of closet space!

Posted 4/11/16 3:23 PM
 

mommy2Alex
3 babies for me :)

Member since 5/05

6683 total posts

Name:

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

We just sold our cape. We had 2 beds up and 2 beds down, but the one downstairs didn't even have a closet in it. It was fine for the littles ones but when our 3rd came along it was time for the same discussion you are having. We loved our block and neighbors but the cost of expanding was a lot and we already lost on the house because we bought at the height of the market. We took the loss and moved to a 5 bedroom colonial. I must say I miss the kids being up and us being down. As they get older the privacy of them being upstairs while you are down, is very nice. But overall we are very happy we made the move rather than living thru construction. We were lucky enough to have a house lined up and the sellers waited for us to sell our house because they didn't need a real estate agent.

Posted 4/12/16 10:48 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: House dilemma -- what would you do?

This is exactly my house - We renovated upstairs and made it a master suite with bathroom and walk in closets for both of us - It wouldn't have worked as 2 separate bedrooms .......

My deciding factor (b/c I was considering putting both boys upstairs to share that space) was 2 things:

1. It's nice for DH and I to have our 'own' space and bathroom .
2. I'd rather them come to the bottom of the stairs looking for me, and possibly climb UP, then HAVE to come DOWN the stairs in the middle of the night.

Ideally, I'd have a colonial w/ all bedrooms on one floor, but that doesn't happen unless we blow out the house, or sell - and it just wasn't enought of a priority for me to MOVE for .........Also, I'm in a prime spot, and the pros of my home outweigh the cons for US

My boys are 2 years apart, and both went directly into their cribs as babies. So, even as an infant, my second son was in his room, in his crib. - Once I got over the "I want to be on the same floor" thing - it was fine.

Posted 4/12/16 12:32 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
***My house is for Sale***UPDATED Price - OPEN HOUSE 10/28 MrsERod 10/19/07 39 Home
House in E. Northport For Sale $399k MrsJ 5/13/05 2 Home
Trying to find a house.... ajaysmom 5/13/05 18 Home
would you consider living with your bil and sil to own a decent house on li antoinette 5/12/05 7 Home
Ronald McDonald House MrsERod 5/11/05 0 Charity
House...countdown T minus 2hr, 7min Cocoa 5/10/05 9 Families Helping Families ™