Who owns these photos?

Forum Opinion Poll
Company 4 7.27%
Photographer 51 92.73%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Photo Ownership Question

Posted By Message

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Photo Ownership Question

OKay here's the scenario:

Employee takes pictures at a work party (for fun). The professional pictures taken at this party did not turn out well for one reason or another and so work asks employee if they can use the photos that employee took to post on a bulletin board in the office. Employee consents, photos are posted.

Next party, employee is asked for photos again. Employee consents, photos are posted.

Next party, employee is asked prior to party to take photos at the party. Employee is given no compensation/reimbursement and uses their own equipment, however party is during company time. Employee is given no restrictions and signs no waivers of any kind, nor does the company.

Who owns the photos? Are the photos the property of the company employee works for or property of the person who took the photos?

I'm trying to sound as unbiased as I can, but you know me well enough, so you probably all know where I stand. I have no idea if I'm right or wrong and I want to genuinely know.

Posted 2/8/12 4:30 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

The photographer owns the photos.

I'm assuming by "giving the photos", to the company it is for a limited use.

Also the photographer should consider getting model releases if he/she is going to use the for business purposes.

Message edited 2012-02-08 16:34:14.247000.

Posted 2/8/12 4:32 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by nrthshgrl

The photographer owns the photos.



Despite the fact that the photos were taken on company property by an employee on company time?

Posted 2/8/12 4:34 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

The photographer owns the photos.



Despite the fact that the photos were taken on company property by an employee on company time?



yes - the company has ZERO right to them

Posted 2/8/12 4:35 PM
 

ModDot
PUMPKIN ALL THE THINGS

Member since 8/11

2196 total posts

Name:
Trissy

Re: Photo Ownership Question

photographer as the "artist" owns creative rights to the photos.

For example: Even after your wedding, if you receive a disk of images you may have personal rights to the photos, but ultimately the company you hired owns the rights to them. Meaning they can post them or sell them or give them to anyone they wish.
You can't sell them to your florist, or even give them to your florist without permission from the person who took the photo. It's also not permitted for someone to re-edit images when they don't own them.


if you wanted, you could ask the company to give you photo credit. But it depends on the purposes of the images. I take photos for my husbands magic dinner dance every year as a favor to them. I don't need the images for anything, so I don't really care what happens to them.
But if I shot a wedding, for instance, and I found an image on someone elses blog/store window/re-edited without credit or permission I'd be pissed and have the right to submit a cease and desist.
I hope that breaks it down Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-02-08 16:41:20.877000.

Posted 2/8/12 4:35 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

The photographer owns the photos.



Despite the fact that the photos were taken on company property by an employee on company time?



Absolutely.

I'll try to find the legalease to back me up. Ah, con calls...so much gets done during them Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/12 4:38 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Photo Ownership Question

I'm the photographer, which I'm sure you gathered by the post. I don't have a business, I'm completely amateur, but I posted a few photos on facebook (as per the request of the people in the photos) and was asked to remove them by my company. I begrudgingly removed them though the whole thing does make me Chat Icon but I did bristle a little bit when my boss informed me that this was because the photos are exclusive property of the company and not myself.

Thank you all for the information! This has been extremely helpful! Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/12 4:38 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

The photographer owns the photos.



Despite the fact that the photos were taken on company property by an employee on company time?



Absolutely.

I'll try to find the legalease to back me up. Ah, con calls...so much gets done during them Chat Icon



Haha legalese would be fantastic since it is a law firm I work for! Chat Icon It's not important and trust me, I agree with you wholeheartedly, but I just want to know that I'm right. I even questioned my boss when she said that and cited my wedding photos and the release Duet signed giving me rights to print and post the photos where I chose and she still disagreed. I just smiled and said "Then we can agree to disagree."

Posted 2/8/12 4:40 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by jilliibabii

I'm the photographer, which I'm sure you gathered by the post. I don't have a business, I'm completely amateur, but I posted a few photos on facebook (as per the request of the people in the photos) and was asked to remove them by my company. I begrudgingly removed them though the whole thing does make me Chat Icon but I did bristle a little bit when my boss informed me that this was because the photos are exclusive property of the company and not myself.

Thank you all for the information! This has been extremely helpful! Chat Icon



She's completely wrong but depending on your company policy, what you post on FB is subject to scrutiny.

As I've posted before employers can & do have social media policies. First thing I'd do is take any references to my company off FB & the photo album & block your co-workers & your boss.

Posted 2/8/12 4:42 PM
 

ModDot
PUMPKIN ALL THE THINGS

Member since 8/11

2196 total posts

Name:
Trissy

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

The photographer owns the photos.



Despite the fact that the photos were taken on company property by an employee on company time?



Absolutely.

I'll try to find the legalease to back me up. Ah, con calls...so much gets done during them Chat Icon



Haha legalese would be fantastic since it is a law firm I work for! Chat Icon It's not important and trust me, I agree with you wholeheartedly, but I just want to know that I'm right. I even questioned my boss when she said that and cited my wedding photos and the release Duet signed giving me rights to print and post the photos where I chose and she still disagreed. I just smiled and said "Then we can agree to disagree."




were they pictures of her or someone else who maybe didn't want them up on the web? It's all fuzzy, bc if it was done during working hours they can say that you acted as an employee of the company etc and were technically paid. I think they're just being pains in the asses

Message edited 2012-02-08 16:43:39.357000.

Posted 2/8/12 4:43 PM
 

ModDot
PUMPKIN ALL THE THINGS

Member since 8/11

2196 total posts

Name:
Trissy

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by jilliibabii

I'm the photographer, which I'm sure you gathered by the post. I don't have a business, I'm completely amateur, but I posted a few photos on facebook (as per the request of the people in the photos) and was asked to remove them by my company. I begrudgingly removed them though the whole thing does make me Chat Icon but I did bristle a little bit when my boss informed me that this was because the photos are exclusive property of the company and not myself.

Thank you all for the information! This has been extremely helpful! Chat Icon



She's completely wrong but depending on your company policy, what you post on FB is subject to scrutiny.

As I've posted before employers can & do have social media policies. First thing I'd do is take any references to my company off FB & the photo album & block your co-workers & your boss.

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/12 4:44 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by jilliibabii

I'm the photographer, which I'm sure you gathered by the post. I don't have a business, I'm completely amateur, but I posted a few photos on facebook (as per the request of the people in the photos) and was asked to remove them by my company. I begrudgingly removed them though the whole thing does make me Chat Icon but I did bristle a little bit when my boss informed me that this was because the photos are exclusive property of the company and not myself.

Thank you all for the information! This has been extremely helpful! Chat Icon



She's completely wrong but depending on your company policy, what you post on FB is subject to scrutiny.

As I've posted before employers can & do have social media policies. First thing I'd do is take any references to my company off FB & the photo album & block your co-workers & your boss.



That was the first thing I did, but thank you for the advice. I only posted some of my more "artistic" photos (if you can call them that! lol!) of things and of people who specifically requested it. I thought my privacy settings were water tight, but I suppose not! I'm going through them, but the way facebook is now does not make it easy to stay private.

ETA: My company also does not have any information about social networking in our handbook, I just double checked. But oh well, my pictures are my own, and that was what really bothered me.

ETAA: And thank you all again!!! Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-02-08 16:53:36.063000.

Posted 2/8/12 4:52 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by retrochick

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

The photographer owns the photos.



Despite the fact that the photos were taken on company property by an employee on company time?



Absolutely.

I'll try to find the legalease to back me up. Ah, con calls...so much gets done during them Chat Icon



Haha legalese would be fantastic since it is a law firm I work for! Chat Icon It's not important and trust me, I agree with you wholeheartedly, but I just want to know that I'm right. I even questioned my boss when she said that and cited my wedding photos and the release Duet signed giving me rights to print and post the photos where I chose and she still disagreed. I just smiled and said "Then we can agree to disagree."




were they pictures of her or someone else who maybe didn't want them up on the web? It's all fuzzy, bc if it was done during working hours they can say that you acted as an employee of the company etc and were technically paid. I think they're just being pains in the asses



Even if you pay a photographer, the photographer owns the rights to the photo.

I hate using Wiki but I'm leaving for a train :)

Private property
Photography may be prohibited or restricted within an area of property by the property owner.[38] At the same time, a property owner generally cannot restrict the photographing of the property by individuals who are not located within the bounds of the property.[38]
Photography on private property that is generally open to the public (e.g., a shopping mall) is usually permitted unless explicitly prohibited by posted signs. Even if no such signs are posted, the property owner or agent can ask a person to stop photographing, and if the person refuses to do so, the owner or agent can ask the person to leave the property. In some jurisdictions, a person who refuses to leave can be arrested for criminal trespass, and many jurisdictions recognize the common-law right to use reasonable force to remove a trespasser; a person who forcibly resists a lawful removal may be liable for battery, assault, or both.[39]
Entry onto other private property usually requires permission from the property owner.
Some jurisdictions have laws regarding filming while in a hospital or health care facility. Where permitted, such filming may be useful in gathering evidence in cases of abuse, neglect, or malpractice.

here you go:
It's all nicely spelled out in the Copyright Act of 1976 (found in Title 17, US Code, Section 100) and while I am not an attorney and would not presume to offer legal advice (or even pretend to understand such weighty matters without benefit of counsel) I have bumped up against this particular nettle enough times to know whereof I speak. According to the Act, any original creative work is protected from the moment it assumes tangible form. An author (or creator) does not have to register his copyright, nor does the work have to display that little circular "c." Protection is automatic and exists from the moment of inception. Registering the copyright with the U.S. Copyright office and displaying the little "c" only serves public notice of the copyright; it does nothing to enhance or even legitimize it.http://www.copyright.gov/title17/circ92.pdf

Posted 2/8/12 4:53 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by retrochick

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by nrthshgrl

The photographer owns the photos.



Despite the fact that the photos were taken on company property by an employee on company time?



Absolutely.

I'll try to find the legalease to back me up. Ah, con calls...so much gets done during them Chat Icon



Haha legalese would be fantastic since it is a law firm I work for! Chat Icon It's not important and trust me, I agree with you wholeheartedly, but I just want to know that I'm right. I even questioned my boss when she said that and cited my wedding photos and the release Duet signed giving me rights to print and post the photos where I chose and she still disagreed. I just smiled and said "Then we can agree to disagree."




were they pictures of her or someone else who maybe didn't want them up on the web? It's all fuzzy, bc if it was done during working hours they can say that you acted as an employee of the company etc and were technically paid. I think they're just being pains in the asses



Even if you pay a photographer, the photographer owns the rights to the photo.

I hate using Wiki but I'm leaving for a train :)

Private property
Photography may be prohibited or restricted within an area of property by the property owner.[38] At the same time, a property owner generally cannot restrict the photographing of the property by individuals who are not located within the bounds of the property.[38]
Photography on private property that is generally open to the public (e.g., a shopping mall) is usually permitted unless explicitly prohibited by posted signs. Even if no such signs are posted, the property owner or agent can ask a person to stop photographing, and if the person refuses to do so, the owner or agent can ask the person to leave the property. In some jurisdictions, a person who refuses to leave can be arrested for criminal trespass, and many jurisdictions recognize the common-law right to use reasonable force to remove a trespasser; a person who forcibly resists a lawful removal may be liable for battery, assault, or both.[39]
Entry onto other private property usually requires permission from the property owner.
Some jurisdictions have laws regarding filming while in a hospital or health care facility. Where permitted, such filming may be useful in gathering evidence in cases of abuse, neglect, or malpractice.

here you go:
It's all nicely spelled out in the Copyright Act of 1976 (found in Title 17, US Code, Section 100) and while I am not an attorney and would not presume to offer legal advice (or even pretend to understand such weighty matters without benefit of counsel) I have bumped up against this particular nettle enough times to know whereof I speak. According to the Act, any original creative work is protected from the moment it assumes tangible form. An author (or creator) does not have to register his copyright, nor does the work have to display that little circular "c." Protection is automatic and exists from the moment of inception. Registering the copyright with the U.S. Copyright office and displaying the little "c" only serves public notice of the copyright; it does nothing to enhance or even legitimize it.http://www.copyright.gov/title17/circ92.pdf



Don't worry about it, this is great! I can look up more info from here if I feel it's necessary, but really it's more for my peace of mind. Thanks again! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-02-08 17:04:49.300000.

Posted 2/8/12 5:04 PM
 

KLSbear
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

1908 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Photo Ownership Question

The one point overlooked here is that many companies have a policy that creative works, inventions, etc. created while at work on company time by an employee are the property of the company, not the employee. If I take photos of my company's product for use in a brochure it would be considered part of my job and their property, not mine just because I clicked the shutter. I think the example of the wedding photographer is different because you're hiring the services of someone that is not an employee so the photographer retains the rights.

The grey area here is that you started by taking photos for personal pleasure and use and they took advantage and turned it into an extension of your job by asking you to take the pictures at a later party. I would think that because they asked you to perform a function at a company event on company time they would have a claim on the photos despite the fact that you used your personal camera. I've brought my camera to work to take pictures because I'm more comfortable with it's functions and I like it better than the camera they have in the office, but I'm still functioning in the capacity of an employee when on company time.

Next time you can always decline, telling them your camera is out for repair, or ask if "company photographer" is being added to your job description and say you'd be happy to and ask what camera they are providing.

Posted 2/8/12 9:26 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by KLSbear

The one point overlooked here is that many companies have a policy that creative works, inventions, etc. created while at work on company time by an employee are the property of the company, not the employee. If I take photos of my company's product for use in a brochure it would be considered part of my job and their property, not mine just because I clicked the shutter. I think the example of the wedding photographer is different because you're hiring the services of someone that is not an employee so the photographer retains the rights.

The grey area here is that you started by taking photos for personal pleasure and use and they took advantage and turned it into an extension of your job by asking you to take the pictures at a later party. I would think that because they asked you to perform a function at a company event on company time they would have a claim on the photos despite the fact that you used your personal camera. I've brought my camera to work to take pictures because I'm more comfortable with it's functions and I like it better than the camera they have in the office, but I'm still functioning in the capacity of an employee when on company time.

Next time you can always decline, telling them your camera is out for repair, or ask if "company photographer" is being added to your job description and say you'd be happy to and ask what camera they are providing.



I don't think this falls under work product. She has nothing in her job description, is using her own personal camera, her own personal memory card & not reimbursed as a photographer.For her law firm to insist it owns her photos is a leap.

I don't think this would even qualify as a work for hire as she hasn't been compensated for her work as a photographer. She's being paid for her current job.

For tax purposes, that camera is considered an expense that you were not reimbursed for so a portion of it should be tax deductible. If anything were to happen to her camera at the event, would they replace or repair it or claim it was her personal property that she was responsible for?

Next time they ask, I'd decline. It's become more aggravating. If they want a photographer, let me know & I'll help her with figure out how much event photographers cost so she can charge them a proper rate.

Message edited 2012-02-08 21:57:50.267000.

Posted 2/8/12 9:57 PM
 

KLSbear
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

1908 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Posted by nrthshgrl

I don't think this falls under work product. She has nothing in her job description, is using her own personal camera, her own personal memory card & not reimbursed as a photographer.For her law firm to insist it owns her photos is a leap.

I don't think this would even qualify as a work for hire as she hasn't been compensated for her work as a photographer. She's being paid for her current job.

For tax purposes, that camera is considered an expense that you were not reimbursed for so a portion of it should be tax deductible. If anything were to happen to her camera at the event, would they replace or repair it or claim it was her personal property that she was responsible for?

Next time they ask, I'd decline. It's become more aggravating. If they want a photographer, let me know & I'll help her with figure out how much event photographers cost so she can charge them a proper rate.



The first photos I'd agree, she was taking them for personal use. Once they asked her to take photos of the event and she accepted it probably could be construed as part of her job since it was a work function and it was during working hours in which she was paid. Once she was asked to perform a function by her boss and she accepted then it's possible that they are considering it part of her job description. It was her choice to use her own equipment and not request that they supply the equipment.

I'd also agree too - next time I'd decline - not worth the hassle.

Posted 2/9/12 12:00 AM
 

architectnycity
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

2592 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

Thank you for posting this. I'm interested in reading the responses too. My sister's company recently sent an email stating pictures taken while on a business trip are property of the company and can not be posted on Facebook. I don't know if it's legal but that's their policy.

Posted 2/9/12 12:27 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Photo Ownership Question

i have to say since i live in two worlds of photographer it depends on the agreement. In general photographers own the rights of their photos since its their creative materials. However when your hired specifically by a company you sometimes do not have the rights to those photographs since the company owns it.

Ex, I do not own the rights to any of the photographs I take at the college I work for. I can't sell them, can't put my own watermark on them, etc. If i go to anything that deals with the college and its paid by state funds its the states property. My own business is strictly my art, my photos, etc.

As far as taking photos at a party or company event. Unfortunately it becomes a gray area since your not professional and there is no agreement (written.) Many companies ask because A. they are cheap and don't want to hire a pro with insurance and B. they know they can abuse you. Remember if you hurt someone while taking photos you can sued and since your not officially a photographer the company has no liability its all on you. It is one thing to bring a personal camera and click for fun and another thing when people are asking you to take photos as part of your job.


As far as FB/social media and images at a company event. I completely agree- the company is protecting itself and its coworkers. You don't need the boss bombed or hitting on his mistress all over the walls of fb. Its a smart policy to have in order.

Posted 2/9/12 9:36 AM
 

marieSand
Hello LIF!!!

Member since 8/10

1224 total posts

Name:
marie

Re: Photo Ownership Question

I have to say the company here, as much as that sux. I work in a creative and anything I design or photograph when I am on company time belongs to the company. I think that is the policy at most companies.

edit: Any freelance photographers I hire, the photos belong to the photographer.

Message edited 2012-02-09 13:00:25.263000.

Posted 2/9/12 12:58 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

She was not hired to be a photographer and her job description for the company does not involve photography (i'm making an assumption here)

so in this case, the photographer owns the photos

the company can ask her to remove them from her fb page, that's a different issue.. but it's not because they own the photos.
She owns them

Posted 2/9/12 2:22 PM
 

acm1899
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

1085 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

I say the photgrapher owns the photos. She may have given authorization (verbal or written) for her employer to use the photos in the office or on a website, but she didn't hand over ownership of the photos.

Posted 2/9/12 2:32 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Photo Ownership Question

I just asked our attorney at the office. He said it was a gray area - and wondered where the photos were taken (at the office? at an off-site meeting?). But he agrees with me that work product is defined by the scope of your job.

So we are back to what is your job?

Posted 2/9/12 5:19 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Question for photo buffs MrsProfessor 6/14/06 5 Families Helping Families ™
Photoshop/Photo/Design question (again) Shorty 6/8/06 21 Families Helping Families ™
photo question emc 4/7/06 5 Parenting
Photo Question NJmom 4/5/06 3 Parenting
Oh...photo question regarding announcements btrflygrl 1/11/06 8 Parenting
A Holiday Photo Card Etiquette Question... Calla 12/7/05 10 Parenting