Would you give a gift?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes, something small 29 49.15%
Yes, I would give a guft as if I were attending a regular party. 7 11.86%
No - my paying is a gift enough 23 38.98%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Engagement Party Question

Posted By Message

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Engagement Party Question

Just out of curiosity....
My brother was invited to an engagement party in which the guests are asked to pay for themselves (open bar and appetizers). Never heard of a situation like this myself.

Does he give a gift?

P.S. He is in the bridal party, if that matters. And they already went out the night of the engagement to celebrate at a bar/restaurant.

Thanks!

Posted 10/17/11 12:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

NextStopBabytown
TTC #2

Member since 11/08

3141 total posts

Name:
Lindsey

Re: Engagement Party Question

Wow I have never heard of this!

I would probably attend and not give a gift. I am really hoping that they meant to write "no gifts please" on the invitation but the printer forgot Chat Icon

That seems pretty b@llsy to me.

Posted 10/17/11 12:46 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Engagement Party Question

I would go and get something small like a picture frame or a GC to go out to eat.

Posted 10/17/11 12:48 PM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Engagement Party Question

I have never heard of this.

Anyway, I would go and bring a small gift for their engagement especially since he is in the bridal party.

Posted 10/17/11 12:50 PM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Engagement Party Question

I never heard of it for an engagement party - for a 30th birthday maybe, but, this is new.

I would give a small gift since he's in the wedding party.

Posted 10/17/11 12:50 PM
 

buttercup
St. Jude pray for us...

Member since 1/11

2951 total posts

Name:

Re: Engagement Party Question

Posted by GioiaMia

I would go and get something small like a picture frame or a GC to go out to eat.



I would do something like this as well.. never heard of this arrangement though..

Posted 10/17/11 12:53 PM
 

APT910
Let It Be

Member since 2/11

5021 total posts

Name:
Ashley

Re: Engagement Party Question

I've never heard of this for an e-party but DH's best friend's wife threw him a surprise 30th last month and we all had to pay for our selves. It was $40 a head so I told DH I thought that was enough of a gift.

It's totally up to your brother. If he really feels that he should give a gift that I wouldn't spend more that $50.

Posted 10/17/11 12:59 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Engagement Party Question

That's the tackiest thing I EVER heard of!!! An engagement party where the guests have to pay for themselves??!! Honestly, NO, I would NOT give a gift. That's crazy!

Posted 10/17/11 1:00 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Engagement Party Question

i'd give a gift regardless of if i had to pay to go to the party or not

Posted 10/17/11 1:05 PM
 

missfabulous
#mommyneedswine

Member since 6/09

10031 total posts

Name:
<font color=purple><b>Colleen</b>

Re: Engagement Party Question

I would do something small.

Posted 10/17/11 1:05 PM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Engagement Party Question

Posted by NextStopBabytown

Wow I have never heard of this!

I would probably attend and not give a gift. I am really hoping that they meant to write "no gifts please" on the invitation but the printer forgot Chat Icon

That seems pretty b@llsy to me.



Apparently the girl comes from a very wealthy family - they got an invite through facebook and then a few days later they got a save the date in the mail with a list of the THREE places tehy registered at - BBB, crate & barrel and William Sonoma. I agree with you.

Posted 10/17/11 3:27 PM
 

MrsO
Big Brothers to Be

Member since 1/07

4521 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Engagement Party Question

He is the wedding party so I think regardless of what type of party he should be giving them an engagement gift.

Posted 10/17/11 3:42 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Engagement Party Question

I wouldn't give a gift. I wouldn't even want to GO honestly.

ETA: That's really tacky to me. You don't need to have an engagement party!! Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-10-17 15:49:31.800000.

Posted 10/17/11 3:48 PM
 

ItsaJoya19
my cup runneth over

Member since 1/10

2949 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Engagement Party Question

Posted by JennB

Posted by NextStopBabytown

Wow I have never heard of this!

I would probably attend and not give a gift. I am really hoping that they meant to write "no gifts please" on the invitation but the printer forgot Chat Icon

That seems pretty b@llsy to me.



Apparently the girl comes from a very wealthy family - they got an invite through facebook and then a few days later they got a save the date in the mail with a list of the THREE places tehy registered at - BBB, crate & barrel and William Sonoma. I agree with you.



Knowing this I'd change my answer from "small gift" to NADA!

Sorry but that is totally tacky.

Posted 10/17/11 3:54 PM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Engagement Party Question

Posted by JennB

Posted by NextStopBabytown

Wow I have never heard of this!

I would probably attend and not give a gift. I am really hoping that they meant to write "no gifts please" on the invitation but the printer forgot Chat Icon

That seems pretty b@llsy to me.



Apparently the girl comes from a very wealthy family - they got an invite through facebook and then a few days later they got a save the date in the mail with a list of the THREE places tehy registered at - BBB, crate & barrel and William Sonoma. I agree with you.



wait the girl comes from a very wealthy family and still people are expected to pay on their own? No gift then.

Posted 10/17/11 3:56 PM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Engagement Party Question

Posted by Bella0701

Posted by JennB

Posted by NextStopBabytown

Wow I have never heard of this!

I would probably attend and not give a gift. I am really hoping that they meant to write "no gifts please" on the invitation but the printer forgot Chat Icon

That seems pretty b@llsy to me.



Apparently the girl comes from a very wealthy family - they got an invite through facebook and then a few days later they got a save the date in the mail with a list of the THREE places tehy registered at - BBB, crate & barrel and William Sonoma. I agree with you.



wait the girl comes from a very wealthy family and still people are expected to pay on their own? No gift then.



Yes! I think its totally tacky! They sent a message out on fb saying their engagement party would be $40 per person plus small appetizers and they would need to see how many people were coming first before they could give the grand total.
Aside from that, I thought it was weird bc they invited all of their friends and family to meet up at a bar in the city - he proposed outside and then they had a "gathering" with everyone there. So to me, they kind of had a little party already

Posted 10/17/11 8:57 PM
 

Sweetheart409
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

2219 total posts

Name:

Re: Engagement Party Question

Posted by Otherme

i'd give a gift regardless of if i had to pay to go to the party or not



me too

Posted 10/17/11 10:56 PM
 

Kate
*****

Member since 5/05

7557 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: Engagement Party Question

I'd give a small gift but I'd definitely be grumbling about it. Totally tacky.

Posted 10/17/11 11:19 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Engagement party gift question glinda-goodwitch 3/26/11 19 Families Helping Families ™
engagement party gift question MeeshkaMich 7/1/08 4 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff to engagement party question Mommy2Boys 9/7/07 0 Families Helping Families ™
Engagement party gift question MABLE03 8/14/06 4 Families Helping Families ™
Housewarming Party Question patti08 9/15/05 3 Home
question abt bachelorette party raken40 7/21/05 4 Families Helping Families ™