Grill
LIF Adult
 Member since 4/09 994 total posts
Name: J
|
Intentional Forclosure: Sound Investment or Unethical, Amoral Action?
Please read the articles before commenting. I thought they presented an interesting take on the housing debacle and how homeowners can bail themselves out the way the government bailed out the banks. Anyway, would love to hear your opinions. Walking Away IS the Moral Imperative NYTimes: Companies Do It All The Time; Why Can't An Individual?
|
Beth
The Key to your new home....
 Member since 2/06 24849 total posts
Name: Beth
|
Re: Intentional Forclosure: Sound Investment or Unethical, Amoral Action?
I can see why people do it- but I really don't agree with it
the article doesn't address short sales- which is a viable option for people that need to sell but owe more then the house is worth - and banks should really find away to make this process easier for buyers and sellers- as a real estate agent I wont even show a short sale b/c the banks take forever to approve the price
real estate used to be a long term investment- not a get rich quick scheme
HELOC where used as ATMs to buy boats, cars and vacations- so if you pulled all the equity out of your house and then intentional walk away- that's fraud IMO
the long term effects on your credit are real- I know many people in foreclosure who have all their credit cards canceled, can't get an auto loan, car insurace and of course you have to wait 2 years to get another mortgage- and that is possible if and only if you have perfect credit since the foreclosure
they are also cracking down on people that try to buy a second house- only to foreclose on the first afer closing
the idea of intentionally foreclosing really doesn't sit well with me- and I make most of my living selling bank owned houses
|
LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!
Member since 5/05 19461 total posts
Name: L
|
Re: Intentional Forclosure: Sound Investment or Unethical, Amoral Action?
I skimmed both articles. The difference in my mind is that an individual is not like a company. Another company will absorb the market share that the defaulting company left. This will make the remaining companies stronger because there is less competition.
The inverse is true for individuals. When a person defaults on their mortgage, their neighbors, bank shareholders, and the government will have to absorb the loss. There is no net gain for the former neighbors. Rather, their homes will be worth a lot less due to a foreclosure in their neighborhood. The bank does not want the property and frankly it does nothing for the government either as it looses tax revenue from unpaid property taxes.
So yes, you can call it a morality issue but when it boils down to it, you are doing much greater harm for instant individual gratification which is what got us in this position in the first place. It really is a few bad apples that spoil the bunch.
|
|
|
Re: Intentional Forclosure: Sound Investment or Unethical, Amoral Action?
Posted by Beth
- and banks should really find away to make this process easier for buyers and sellers- as a real estate agent I wont even show a short sale b/c the banks take forever to approve the price
It would help a lot if the banks were able to get going on things like this.
I think about these issues a lot and I don't see a simple answer and I don't think that anyone can generalize about what is going on morally with any particular person. I do think that some people just wanted fancy houses that were over their heads but home ownership is the American dream so it is easy to get caught up in it. I have had so few clients surrender their homes but anyone who did put a lot of thought into what they were doing and why and how to avoid being right back there in the future.
|
munchkinfacemama
LOVE
 Member since 11/07 15800 total posts
Name: <FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>
|
Re: Intentional Forclosure: Sound Investment or Unethical, Amoral Action?
Very interesting articles. While I see why someone would do it, I don't think it is right by any means. Heck, I don't think it is right when corporations do it.
However, as a homeowner in a state where foreclosures are very high, even in my own HOA community (FL), nothing irks me more than this. If you genuinely can no longer pay, it is one thing. But to intentionally do that? All you do, let's say in an area such as mine where you would be in a HOA, is 1. drop all of the other surrounding home prices in the area because you are now a foreclosure; 2. Drive up the HOA dues for homeowners such as DH and I because banks will only pay 7 months of maintenance; and 3.The home often falls to waste, especially in an area such as mine where central AC is not a luxury-it costs 200 a month in a 1500 sq. ft. house to keep it on, and it is not an option because the whole house will become worthless if mold grows on the sheetrock, once again killing the home values for surrounding homes. When people do things like this, all it does is effect the homeowners surrounding them-it makes our values go down and we have to pay for these "strategic" foreclosures. This also effects every day consumers, because banks are smart-they are not going to take the hit without passing it on to other consumers. So, in turn, they will raise fees to recoup the money. I also think, in the end, it will affect home buyers who will have an even harder time securing financing. Forget it in communities such as mine. I see the HOA board holding up approving people with mortgages until deals fall through (this I am sure happened in my community where the older generation cannot fathom how many of the younger people don't own outright without a mortgage).
I find this interesting because our HOA just wrote about the same issue in our monthly newsletter and pled with homeowners not to default on their mortgages because it becomes a misery to the rest of us who are stuck with depreciated homes and picking up the slack when the banks stop paying the HOA. Whether this is true or not, I don't know, but our HOA president said the attorney that represents us mentioned this is becoming a huge problem in HOA communities in my area.
However, I know at least a few people that stop paying their mortgages in an attempt to try to get banks to modify the terms of their mortgage-the house across the street is doing this-they have an A.R.M.-the house is listed as a short sale for 275K (homes comparable are selling at 180K max) and word is that they are attempting to negotiate a modification with the bank.
|