Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Posted By Message

rileysmama
needing a vacation..!

Member since 10/09

2162 total posts

Name:

Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Ok, so...DS has a puffy winter coat..is it true he can't wear it when he is in carseat? and i have to use blankets instead?

please advise.

Chat Icon

Posted 12/8/09 9:40 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Alex110879
craziness

Member since 8/06

3762 total posts

Name:
Alexandria

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

they say the puffy jackets mess with the 5 point harness... i agree... ds had a puffy snowsuit last year and you could see the harness not sitting correctly and moving all around

Posted 12/8/09 9:42 PM
 

Helene718
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/06

623 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Definitely unsafe. Sorry.

Posted 12/8/09 9:43 PM
 

Pooka
Oh Happy Day!!

Member since 11/06

5689 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

I've seen online that if you don't want to take the coat off, the best thing to do is un zip it and make sure the clip (that goes across the chest) is directly on the baby. Tuck the jacket to the baby's side. There is a demonstration of it online...let me see if I can find it.

Posted 12/8/09 9:48 PM
 

Pooka
Oh Happy Day!!

Member since 11/06

5689 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

ok I BUMP'd the post I saved from last year

Posted 12/8/09 9:49 PM
 

rileysmama
needing a vacation..!

Member since 10/09

2162 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Posted by Bubbs

I've seen online that if you don't want to take the coat off, the best thing to do is un zip it and make sure the clip (that goes across the chest) is directly on the baby. Tuck the jacket to the baby's side. Theres a demonstration of it online...let me see if I can find it.

i

ok , good..i feel better now...this is what i do already...thanks so muchChat Icon

Posted 12/8/09 9:53 PM
 

mspresscott
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/08

418 total posts

Name:
Fia&Joey'sMama

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

My DD have the Gap warmest jacket & I have no problems with the clip it is always at her arm pits. She is 2 1/2 I am not gonna fight w/ her to take off the jacket in the car seat & then put it on before we get out of the car.

Posted 12/9/09 10:24 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Posted by mspresscott

My DD have the Gap warmest jacket & I have no problems with the clip it is always at her arm pits. She is 2 1/2 I am not gonna fight w/ her to take off the jacket in the car seat & then put it on before we get out of the car.



It isn't the clip.

When a child is wearing a jacket like that the straps can compress against the jacket, therefore causing the child to be ejected from the seat as the straps are really holding the jacket, not the child in.

My DS is 2.5 too and he doesn't wear his heavy coat in the car

Posted 12/9/09 10:46 AM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

We don't do coats in the car. We take them on and off.

Posted 12/9/09 3:38 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

I wouldnt risk it.

It's such a small thing and not worth her safety.

that 'puff' on them (side or not) is what the seat belt is now compensating for and in an accident that 'space' is just enough to cause serious harm by ejecting the child instead of them being held securely to the seat.

Posted 12/9/09 3:41 PM
 

CarSeatSafety
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/09

689 total posts

Name:
CarSeatChris

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

The puffy jacket does not cause ejection. The problem with a puffy jacket is that the child is not being held down as securely and movement would occur that can increase the chances of injury.

When a child is rear facing we want the straps to be at a point at or below the shoulders so that the child is being held down into the seat. The rear facing seat is designed to bounce in case of a crash absorbing some of the forces of the crash. If the straps are at the proper position the child will be held in place and ride out the crash.

The problem with a snow suit or puffy jacket is that there now is space between the child and the strap such that when the seat bounces the child is actually not being held down in to the seat. The puffiness is being compressed and with the child movement there is an increased chance that the child will be injured. The child will not be ejected.

For forward facing, the child will have additional movement, again because of the compression of the coat. But again, ejection will not occur.

Dress the child comfortably, layered, and for rear facing just use a blanket. Again from other posts, do not use the Bundleme in a carrier.

Posted 12/10/09 9:57 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Posted by CarSeatSafety

The puffy jacket does not cause ejection. The problem with a puffy jacket is that the child is not being held down as securely and movement would occur that can increase the chances of injury.

When a child is rear facing we want the straps to be at a point at or below the shoulders so that the child is being held down into the seat. The rear facing seat is designed to bounce in case of a crash absorbing some of the forces of the crash. If the straps are at the proper position the child will be held in place and ride out the crash.

The problem with a snow suit or puffy jacket is that there now is space between the child and the strap such that when the seat bounces the child is actually not being held down in to the seat. The puffiness is being compressed and with the child movement there is an increased chance that the child will be injured. The child will not be ejected.

For forward facing, the child will have additional movement, again because of the compression of the coat. But again, ejection will not occur.

Dress the child comfortably, layered, and for rear facing just use a blanket. Again from other posts, do not use the Bundleme in a carrier.



I think you're doing a great service to these forums, but I've read postings over at carseat.org by numerous CPST's (including instructors) who disagree that there is no risk of ejection, and can cite one real life example of this happening with a snowsuit.

That article is here http://babyproducts.about.com/od/carseats/a/carseatcoat.htm

A Real Life Example
In order to become a certified CPS tech, Ellis had to take an extensive car seat safety course and pass both a written exam and hands-on car seat installation exams. "When I took my tech class we were shown a picture of an infant seat with a snowsuit under the harness," she says. "The seat was pulled out of a car that had just been in a crash. The infant was ejected from the seat and the car and was found some feet away from the car, but the snowsuit was left in the seat just as the baby was wearing it."



From http://www.carseat.org/Resources/FAQs.htm#coats

During cold weather, what is the best way to keep my child warm in his safety seat?

Clothing worn by children can present compression and harness routing problems. Bulky jackets and snowsuits can compress in a crash and leave the harness slack on a child, allowing excessive movement or even ejection. It is best to have children travel without coats, to put coats on backwards, or to add a blanket over the child after the harness has been buckled. Jackets that are worn the regular way should be no heavier than lightweight fleece fabric or be unfastened to allow contact between the child and the harness or vehicle belt. An option for an infant in an infant seat is a shower cap-style seat cover. This style of cover fits over the top of the infant seat, has an elastic band around the edge, and has no fabric behind or under the child. For more on this topic, go to Padded inserts, blankets, and bulky clothing.




Posted 12/10/09 2:17 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

I put the straps under his coat, so the coat is resting on his shoulders more or less, but the straps are against his clothing, not the jacket.

Honestly, I tried no coat, but DS has a habit of wiggling out of the seat very quickly once his straps are undone. And getting his coat back on in a parking lot is no picnic, and a safety hazard in itself. If he was a pretty quiet child and listened when I told him we needed to get his coat on, I would leave the coat off, but since he is not, this is the closest I can figure out dealing withthis safely.

Posted 12/10/09 2:24 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Posted by tarabelle99



I think you're doing a great service to these forums, but I've read postings over at carseat.org by numerous CPST's (including instructors) who disagree that there is no risk of ejection, and can cite one real life example of this happening with a snowsuit.







My husband says the same thing (he is an EMT)

Posted 12/10/09 2:27 PM
 

babyonthebrain
Brotherly Love!

Member since 1/08

6209 total posts

Name:
Rafaela

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

thanks for the post. I had no idea. I was actually thinking about getting him another coat. One thats not so bulky.

Posted 12/10/09 2:27 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

The fleece jackets sold by companies like Lands end, hanna andersson etc are very warm, yet are thin enough not to cause issues.

If you're unsure about the thickness of the coat, I've seen techs suggest this test:

Without the coat, have child sit in seat and do up the harness nice and snugly. WITHOUT loosening the straps, remove the child.

Put the coat on the child and put back into the seat, if you do not have to loosen it to put the child in, then the coat isn't too thick. If you have to loosen it to get the harness done up, it's too thick.

We have a fleece from Hanna Andersson, and we also unzip it, do the harness and then zip if it's cold enough. We also keep a blanket in the car.

Posted 12/10/09 2:42 PM
 

ruby
you rang?

Member since 6/08

5573 total posts

Name:

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Posted by monkeybride

We don't do coats in the car. We take them on and off.



us too

Posted 12/10/09 2:45 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Posted by mspresscott

My DD have the Gap warmest jacket & I have no problems with the clip it is always at her arm pits. She is 2 1/2 I am not gonna fight w/ her to take off the jacket in the car seat & then put it on before we get out of the car.



it really goes way beyond that. Like kate said, if you were ever, god forbid in an accident, since the straps are not able to hold your dd as tight as they should with a big jacket on, it could be disasterous

my dd is also 2 1/2 and I have to fight with her to put her jacket ON so we never have problems with the car seat Chat Icon

Posted 12/10/09 3:07 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Carseat - unsafe with puffy jacket?

Posted by mspresscott

My DD have the Gap warmest jacket & I have no problems with the clip it is always at her arm pits. She is 2 1/2 I am not gonna fight w/ her to take off the jacket in the car seat & then put it on before we get out of the car.



That is the same jacket we have but I do make her take it off and on every time we get in the car (she's 23 months and always ready to battle, lol). I can't buckle the straps with it on - I've tried!

But I've seen my daughter take her arms out of the straps of the carseat while I was driving on the highway Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon so I can't take any chances with my little Houdini.

Posted 12/10/09 3:20 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is the Gap Warmest Jacket too puffy for a carseat? Mommy2Boys 8/29/09 7 Parenting
Spinoff to jacket and carseat - was anyone ever told that it was dangerous to zip things around the straps - like the bundle me etc? itsbabytime 11/19/08 4 Parenting
Does your child fit in his carseat with his winter jacket??? NS1976 11/5/07 11 Parenting