I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?)
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) First off I live in a very very affluent neighborhood here in San Antonio. |
|
Posted 11/17/09 11:17 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
| |
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) I dont want to agree with them because I think it is so wrong...but in my building we have the same thing. If a leak or something happens even if they are at fault we are expected to go through our own home owners or renters insurance. It is such BS. They forced everyone to get it after a basement flood destroyed many of the basement apartments and the building said it wasnt there problem, to go through insurance. |
|
Posted 11/17/09 11:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) As far as the heat goes in your daughters room ,I think they just need to be bled (sp?) ,but everything else is ridiculous ....Oh Man I would be PO'ED !!!! |
|
Posted 11/17/09 11:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Posted by Michi I dont want to agree with them because I think it is so wrong...but in my building we have the same thing. If a leak or something happens even if they are at fault we are expected to go through our own home owners or renters insurance. It is such BS. They forced everyone to get it after a basement flood destroyed many of the basement apartments and the building said it wasnt there problem, to go through insurance. :( WOW !! I lived in a co-op and they were liable for anything within the walls and the walls and ceilings !! That is insane !!
|
|
Posted 11/17/09 11:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Posted by My3girlsMylife Posted by Michi I dont want to agree with them because I think it is so wrong...but in my building we have the same thing. If a leak or something happens even if they are at fault we are expected to go through our own home owners or renters insurance. It is such BS. They forced everyone to get it after a basement flood destroyed many of the basement apartments and the building said it wasnt there problem, to go through insurance. :( WOW !! I lived in a co-op and they were liable for anything within the walls and the walls and ceilings !! That is insane !!A co-op is totally different from renting. To the OP, I wouldn't really think that an attorney here could help as they aren't probably admitted in Texas |
|
Posted 11/17/09 11:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Posted by My3girlsMylife Posted by Michi I dont want to agree with them because I think it is so wrong...but in my building we have the same thing. If a leak or something happens even if they are at fault we are expected to go through our own home owners or renters insurance. It is such BS. They forced everyone to get it after a basement flood destroyed many of the basement apartments and the building said it wasnt there problem, to go through insurance. :( WOW !! I lived in a co-op and they were liable for anything within the walls and the walls and ceilings !! That is insane !!Same with mine - they fix the walls & ceiling but they are not responsible for the things on the walls & ceilings like pictures, light fixtures, etc. If something like that gets damaged I am responsible for repairing or replacing it. |
|
Posted 11/17/09 11:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) We arent required to keep renters insurance (its not part of our lease) |
|
Posted 11/17/09 12:18 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Posted by Michi I dont want to agree with them because I think it is so wrong...but in my building we have the same thing. If a leak or something happens even if they are at fault we are expected to go through our own home owners or renters insurance. It is such BS. They forced everyone to get it after a basement flood destroyed many of the basement apartments and the building said it wasnt there problem, to go through insurance. :( I am actually drafting a nastygram to send to my landlord. Google "warranty of habitability". They are REQUIRED to correct these issues. If they don't, you can do the repairs yourself and withhold or deduct the repairs from the rent. |
Posted 11/17/09 12:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Posted by Xelindrya We arent required to keep renters insurance (its not part of our lease) Not to many leases require renters insurance. It is something that renters should get called contents insurance--this protects all the contents of the apartment/house. If something happened and the home was destroyed all your contents would not be covered under the landlords insurance. |
|
Posted 11/17/09 1:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Posted by Xelindrya We arent required to keep renters insurance (its not part of our lease) The damages were caused because they had cheap garage doors and very badly installed sprinkler systems. It is 100% the fault of the apt complex. I understand deductibles but all that means is that the INSURANCE company won't pay. It does not relieve them of responsiblity. The management says they dont know their insurance company .. they have to call regional office to find out more. They have done everything in their power to avoid giving me that information. I think my local management is trying to tell me they informed me back in Sept nothing would be paid because its probably procedure, thing is.. she didn't. Even if she did, I repeat, they are liable. If they keep this up, I'll take them to small claims court. I think I have that right since my insurance company won't pay. Maybe then I can break this lease. Ok I dont have the background on this so I have a few questions....how is the sprinkler system shoddy? Was there a problem with it before the garage door falling on it? Just because the garage door fell on it and the pipe broke doesnt make it shoddy. From the info you have given so far I have to say I think the damage to your belongs are you responsibility. |
|
Posted 11/17/09 1:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Posted by alli3131 Ok I dont have the background on this so I have a few questions....how is the sprinkler system shoddy? Was there a problem with it before the garage door falling on it? Just because the garage door fell on it and the pipe broke doesnt make it shoddy. From the info you have given so far I have to say I think the damage to your belongs are you responsibility. the system is incorrectly intalled (according to the fire dept). Let see if I can describe it. Imagine an L shape at the bottom right tip is a 6inch pipe hanging down with a sprinkler head which is protected with a wire cage type enclosure. The garage door rolls up and comes to a stop with the top of the garage door sitting over the bottom part of the L. Parallel with the bottom part of the L (hope that makes sense) and 6inches past the sprinkler head which is now BELOW the door. There is about a 1inch clearance between the bottom of that L and the garage door. Given that the door wasn't settled correctly in its track it tipped down (fell off its track) and caught the sprinkler head caged area. It got stuck pushing against that area. The stress quickly grew along the full L shape up to the Top tip of the L which was connected with an elbow to the long pipe running the full length of my garage lengthwise. As the garage tried to 'fix' itself by closing it pulled on the cage thingy and that was too much pressue for the joint at the top of the L, and It burst open. When the fireman showed up and they tried to figure out where the water was coming from in order to shut it off they indicated to the apt complex the pipe work was the main reason for this. The door opening, coming off tracks, etc should not have affected the sprinkler system. Hence I say shoddy job. They went to look at an unaffected garage next to mine and informed the apt complex ALL of them were done incorrectly and that given the age of the buildings (7yrs) they can expect this exact type of damage to occur again. You could see from the apt managers reaction that she was bummed by this news. Still nothing has been updated. area that I had to clear out (obviously I didnt take picture while I was desperately trying to clear out my stuff) Here's an idea of what was damaged tho. Does that answer the question (sorta) |
|
Posted 11/17/09 2:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Sorta but I have worked in commercial and highrise apt construction for about 15 yrs....and they would have had to pass an inspection for the apts to be opened....so the firemen may have said it was wrong but it clearly passed code if it was signed off (if it wasnt signed off on then no one would be living there) Was it maybe not the best design yes but I would find it very hard to prove the building owner was negligent and it wil be even harder to prove if you were the first this happened to. If its happened beofre then you might have a shot. I dont know the laws in TX so I would contact an atty there as real estate laws vary greatly from state to state. |
|
Posted 11/17/09 2:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?) Id say your damages are the result of an accident, not the negligence of the Complex. Those pipes could've been in a better spot I suppose, but still. Message edited 2009-11-17 20:35:47.717000. |
|
Posted 11/17/09 7:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: I am BEYOND furious *vent* apt - Long (any attorneys wanna help out?)
|
|
Posted 11/17/09 8:26 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vent: I wish I could move my old apt with me to TX (water drama long) | Xelindrya | 9/2/09 | 6 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Granite vent-So furious! | CallaLily | 12/6/08 | 8 | Home |





WOW !! I lived in a co-op and they were liable for anything within the walls and the walls and ceilings !! That is insane !!




