Cake????

Forum Opinion Poll
Large sheet cake-enough for everyone 5 16.67%
Small round vanilla cake and cupcakes 11 36.67%
Cupcakes only-thereby depriving Sydnie of a cake 0 0.00%
One very small fondant ladybug cake as a "smash cake" 9 30.00%
One large version of a cupcake for Sydnie with a ladybug top 4 13.33%
Other 1 3.33%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Birthday cake dilemma

Posted By Message

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Birthday cake dilemma

Invite: 48 adults, 16 kids Ladybug theme

Original plan- large round fondant ladybug cake-cannoli filling and about 5 dozen cupcakes, half chocolate half vanilla with red and black icing.

I called my favorite bakery and they said their largest round would serve 20. I realized- no round cake is going to be large enough for that many adults and I was set on the fondant ladybug.

So then I thought-just get a vanilla cake so it is esentially the same thing as the cupcakes and my sister and mom thought I was crazy to not have enough cake for everyone. Adults will want cake-not cupcakes.

So now- these are my choices. WWYD?

Message edited 2009-06-15 08:30:32.367000.

Posted 6/14/09 7:25 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

I say make enough cupcakes for everyone and have the bakery make a small 6 inch fondant ladybug cake for the birthday girl.

Posted 6/14/09 7:27 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

I agree- why wouldn't an adult want a cupcake? I LOVE cupcakes. Then you'll have a pretty little cake for her to smash.

Posted 6/14/09 7:30 PM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

Posted by Porrruss

I agree- why wouldn't an adult want a cupcake? I LOVE cupcakes.



I know!!! Chat Icon Me too!!!! My family tries to be so proper sometimes.

I feel like it's a 1st birthday, to he!! with proper Chat Icon

Posted 6/14/09 7:32 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

I have made cupcakes for both of Lily's birthdays so far. If someone doesn't like it - they can go without dessert!!
Cupcakes are the best!

Posted 6/14/09 7:34 PM
 

julz33
i run for bacon

Member since 5/05

20584 total posts

Name:
julz

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

Posted by Palebride

I say make enough cupcakes for everyone and have the bakery make a small 6 inch fondant ladybug cake for the birthday girl.



ITA!
We had Landon's b-day party yesterday. He had a small cake for himself and EVERYONE else got a cupcake. We also had cookies (sugar cookies and chocolate chip), brownies, fruit, and cannolis for dessert.

Posted 6/14/09 8:07 PM
 

sunflowerjesss
Mommy to 3!

Member since 10/05

20369 total posts

Name:
Jesss, duh.

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

I voted:

One very small fondant ladybug cake as a "smash cake"

while assuming everyone else would be enjoying a cupcake.

Although, if it would be easier to serve a sheet cake for the guests versus making 40 cupcakes, then I say go that route.

Posted 6/14/09 8:10 PM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

small fondant lady bug cake for your DD and then cucpakes for all the adults and kids! VERY CUTE!

Posted 6/14/09 8:15 PM
 

nancy6485
So in love

Member since 10/05

3363 total posts

Name:
Nancy

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

Posted by Palebride

I have made cupcakes for both of Lily's birthdays so far. If someone doesn't like it - they can go without dessert!!
Cupcakes are the best!



i agree! Who doesn't love cupcakes anyway & if they don't want them, oh well!

Posted 6/14/09 10:32 PM
 

wannabemom
look who's freshly baked!

Member since 12/07

7364 total posts

Name:
aka marriedinportjeff

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

get the vanilla fondant ladybug cake.....

you can always get a matching sheetcake for the rest of the guests... and then make cupcakes in a different flavor (chocolate?), so guests can choose Chat Icon

Posted 6/14/09 10:38 PM
 

junebride06
love my boys!

Member since 2/08

3181 total posts

Name:
Robin

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

cup cakes are my fave!!!! I say get Sydnie the small fondant lady bug cake and then do the cupcakes. i love the lady bug theme.

Posted 6/14/09 11:03 PM
 

Superkat
More a stranger than a friend

Member since 5/06

9730 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

I wouldn't give fondant as a smash cake. It tastes nasty to most adults, let alone as a first birthday cake for a child. Chat Icon

Posted 6/15/09 12:12 AM
 

LJSMommy
Love him!

Member since 10/07

3189 total posts

Name:

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

I voted other because that's what I am doing next week!!Chat Icon


What WE are doing is.....

LJ's "smash cake" will be a cupcake cake with white icing on top, blue on bottom with stars & moons on it!

A couple of dozen cupcakes for every one else with a stars & moons theme to them! (adults & kids alike!!)

Posted 6/15/09 12:26 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

Smash cake for the birthday girl. Cupcakes for everyone. It eliminates cutting too.

Posted 6/15/09 5:49 AM
 

mooshyboo
So Blessed!

Member since 11/07

6297 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

Posted by Palebride

I say make enough cupcakes for everyone and have the bakery make a small 6 inch fondant ladybug cake for the birthday girl.



I like this idea!!! Chat Icon

PS for my ds's bday I am planning on having a smash cake for DS and cupcakes for everyone. (possibly an ice cream cake 2 for all August birthday's we have a lot of other birthdays same month as my ds)

Message edited 2009-06-15 06:45:35.993000.

Posted 6/15/09 6:43 AM
 

mikeswife06
Drama Momma

Member since 9/06

9947 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Birthday cake dilemma

Thank you so much everyone. I was beginning to wonder if I was crazy to think that cupcakes are essentially the same as cake just a 1-serving size/shape and that adults like them too! Thank you so much. I think I will do the small ladybug cake just for Sydnie and cupcakes to everyone else. Chat Icon

Posted 6/15/09 8:32 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Does anyone want to see the cake I made for Emily's Birthday Party?? Melbernai 10/15/06 35 Parenting
What's your favorite kind of birthday cake? Diva 9/28/06 43 Families Helping Families ™
Want to see the cake I made for my nieces first birthday? sunny 9/18/06 30 Parenting
How much did you/would you pay for a 1st birthday cake for 60+ ppl? My2Boys 8/13/06 28 Parenting
Bakery Recommendation for 1st Birthday Cake MM2004 5/27/06 5 Parenting
Birthday Cake ??? mommy2Alex 3/7/06 3 Parenting