Which do you think is safest?

Forum Opinion Poll
Front mounted bike seat 1 4.76%
Rear mounted bike seat 12 57.14%
bike trailer 7 33.33%
other? 1 4.76%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Which do you think is safest?

Posted By Message

sasha96
lovin' my 2 little ladies!

Member since 5/05

7401 total posts

Name:
Julianne

Which do you think is safest?

I want to get DH a bike seat/trailer (and child helmet) for Father's Day but I'm so unsure of which one to get! He would only be taking her on paved roads around the house (not a lot of traffic) or paved trails. I just want her to be safe but don't want her to get too much sun. She'll be 1 y.o. then. If you have one, which one do you have? What do you think of it?

Posted 5/12/09 9:25 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Which do you think is safest?

I have no idea which one is actually safe. The bike trailers are probably easier to balance and cause less issues with falling, however they make me nervous as I'm afraid a car might not see them. Depends on where you are riding, maybe?

Posted 5/12/09 9:59 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Which do you think is safest?

I haven't used any, but I would think that if you're not on public roads, the trailer would be safest. They are low to the ground, so if the bike tips over, they don't have far to go. A front-mounted one has the best view, but is also the first thing to hit stray branches, spider webs, etc. The back seat has a terrible view, and it's high, so if the bike takes a tumble, DC has farther to fall.

On public roads, the trailer has the disadvantage of being very low, so drivers may not see it...

Posted 5/12/09 10:02 AM
 

NJmom
.

Member since 8/05

4987 total posts

Name:

Re: Which do you think is safest?

I think the trailer is the safest. If you fall the baby won't tip over. Also more comfortable for the baby and keeps them shaded. I'd be so afraid of falling with a baby on a seat.

Posted 5/12/09 12:00 PM
 

LoveBeingMrsT
Love my Boys!

Member since 12/05

4648 total posts

Name:

Re: Which do you think is safest?

the guy in the bike shop said back seat so that's what we got.

Posted 5/12/09 12:49 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Which do you think is safest?

Consumer Reports basically says what I mentioned:

Bicycle-mounted seats are mounted behind or in front of a cyclist's seat and can transport one child age 1 to 5 or so. In both seats, the child faces forward. They're potentially less safe than trailers, which have two bicycle-type wheels and a long hitching arm that fastens to a bicycle from behind and rides low to the ground. In an accident, a child would fall about three feet from a mounted bike seat, compared with a fall of about a half a foot from a trailer. With the added weight of a little passenger at the back or front, a bicycle with a mounted seat might be harder to handle, which can be unnerving or just annoying, depending on your cycling experience. Getting on and off a bike with a baby in a mounted seat can also be difficult.

Trailers attach to the rear axle or frame of a bike, and can carry children from age 1 through 6 or so. They provide some protection to passengers since children are seated, strapped in, and usually enclosed in a zippered compartment. Trailers have a rigid frame enclosed in durable fabric, which offers some protection for young passengers if the unit rolls over. But children still must wear a bike helmet. (See our helmet Ratings.) As we mentioned, because a trailer is closer to the ground, it's potentially safer than a bicycle-mounted seat in a fall. Some designs have a hitching arm that allows the bike to fall without affecting the trailer.

Still, trailers pose safety problems because their low profile makes them difficult for motorists to see, especially in limited light. They should have a 3½- to 7-foot-tall, high-visibility orange flag. Trailers are also wider than the bike, so they take up more of the roadway. If you're riding on the shoulder, the trailer can stick out into the road if you're not careful. And trailers can tip over if you turn abruptly or turn when one wheel is going over a bump. As you speed up, braking becomes harder, especially on wet surfaces. Trailers can become snagged on bushes or other objects.

Posted 5/12/09 12:54 PM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: Which do you think is safest?

We have both the trailer and I have the rear bike seat on my bike. DD LOVES the bike seat. She refused to go into the trailer....but my nephews absolutely LOVED it. So...depends with that one.

IMO....I think the front seat is WAY TOO dangerous. It's hard enough maneuvering with the rear bike seat on (you have to test drive it and get used to the new balance)...I can't imagine having something blocking my view of what's in front of me, on the ground, be it sand, a puddle, a jump, a side walk, etc etc.

I would never feel safe with the front seat.

I love the rear seat. It's cushioned and protected and has a great 5 pt harness. and a bar across the front.

The one I have...
External Image

Posted 5/12/09 12:54 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Which do you think is safest?

We just got my DS the rear mounted one. We got it at Rocky Point Cycles.

You can go to www.climbonline.org - they have a list of bike shops and you can also post on the forum and see what the mountain bikers say.

Posted 5/12/09 1:05 PM
 

sasha96
lovin' my 2 little ladies!

Member since 5/05

7401 total posts

Name:
Julianne

Re: Which do you think is safest?

thanks for all these posts...really good info....keep it coming!

Posted 5/12/09 1:17 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Which door locks are the safest? Dani00518 12/1/08 8 Home
safest spot to place car seats runlikethewind 5/29/08 9 Multiple Births
Where is the safest place to put car seat? nancygrace 4/19/08 9 Parenting
itkocak 3/19/08 3 Parenting
Does anyone know what the safest Infant-Toddler car seat is supposed to be?? munchkinbugs 8/7/07 5 Pregnancy
safest place for car seat......... nancygrace 12/29/06 5 Parenting