Which kind of shade would you use in this room?

Forum Opinion Poll
#1 18 41.86%
#2 25 58.14%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted By Message

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

In our LR we now have this floor lamp in the corner, but it is brushed nickel and my new table lamps are bronze/iron.

External Image

Here is all three lamps in the room right now.
External Image
External Image

So which kind of floor lamp would you go with? These are just examples of the kind of lamps I'm thinking about, but probably not these exact lamps. It's more a question about the shade part of the lamp. We have no overhead lighting, so we need the extra light in the room until we can afford to put high hats in the room.

#1
External Image

#2
External Image

Posted 11/5/08 4:52 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Most people will probably say #1 since that lamp shade is similar to the lamps you have in the room now now, but I think it'll be too matchy. I voted for #2.

Posted 11/5/08 5:07 PM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

I voted for #2 b/c I can't see you ever using the arm.... Plus I like the shape better...

Posted 11/5/08 5:57 PM
 

SnickNNick
In our new house!!

Member since 8/08

2119 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

I think the shade on #1 would interfere with your drapery and make that not look as good....so I chose #2--it will blend in more Chat Icon

Posted 11/5/08 6:38 PM
 

lcherian
He is the reason!

Member since 2/06

2512 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by CaMacho

Most people will probably say #1 since that lamp shade is similar to the lamps you have in the room now now, but I think it'll be too matchy. I voted for #2.



i agree!

Posted 11/5/08 8:37 PM
 

strongisland
All you need is love

Member since 8/07

2474 total posts

Name:
T

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

i am probably going to be no help here! but i like #2 better but i think #1 looks better b/c it matches!!!!!

Posted 11/5/08 8:49 PM
 

Sneezy
Thankful for my miracle!

Member since 5/05

1939 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

It depends on how you need the light in the room. #1 will be better to read by because it illuminates downward. #2 will light the room better though.

Posted 11/5/08 10:15 PM
 

skew
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

6794 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

i prefer #2 but is there really a need for a floor lamp? if so, i would move the table lamp that is in front of the current floor lamp elsewhere in the room. they should not be next to one another.

Message edited 2008-11-06 08:58:21.690000.

Posted 11/6/08 8:57 AM
 

suvenR
designer mutt

Member since 5/05

4239 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

1. I love swivel lamps.

Message edited 2008-11-06 09:32:28.327000.

Posted 11/6/08 9:10 AM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by skew

i prefer #2 but is there really a need for a floor lamp? if so, i would move the table lamp that is in front of the current floor lamp elsewhere in the room. they should not be next to one another.



yes there is a need for the floor lamp. The two table lamps don't give off enough light and unfortunately there is no other place for any of the three lamps to go. LR is just to small. Chat Icon And we don't have hi-hats yet, so I need something.

I think I will go with #2 type lamp so that we get the most light out of it.Chat Icon

Posted 11/6/08 9:25 AM
 

CallaLily
Thank you, Saint Gerard!

Member since 10/07

4937 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by CaMacho

Most people will probably say #1 since that lamp shade is similar to the lamps you have in the room now now, but I think it'll be too matchy. I voted for #2.


I agree...I like the contrast and I feel that this kind of shade looks better on a taller lamp. Your house is beautiful btw!

Posted 11/6/08 10:31 AM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by Renee615

Posted by CaMacho

Most people will probably say #1 since that lamp shade is similar to the lamps you have in the room now now, but I think it'll be too matchy. I voted for #2.


I agree...I like the contrast and I feel that this kind of shade looks better on a taller lamp. Your house is beautiful btw!



Thank you! Chat Icon

Posted 11/6/08 2:45 PM
 

Mrs. Patticakes
SPREAD KINDNESS

Member since 9/06

17330 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

This is a tough one. I like #1 because it matches so well. BUT I do agree that it may be too matchy matchy. I really like #2 so I say go for it.

Posted 11/7/08 11:05 AM
 

Kris92
LIF Infant

Member since 5/08

298 total posts

Name:
Kris

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

I really like #1. I like that with the swivel lamp the base is not just straight up and down.

Posted 11/7/08 11:11 AM
 

MeNBobs
*****

Member since 4/07

3765 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

I like #2. It is actually very similiar to what you have there already. I like that it throws the light up.

If you don't have another spot for the current lamp have you considered spray painting it. I refinished a gold fireplace screen and a gold chandelier to bronze. I used Benjamin Moore spray paint. In the stores they have a sample of what the colors look like. Most of the them are not just a solid color they have specs of other color in it so it looks like metal not paint. It's hard to explain but if you check them out you will know what I mean. I think the paint was about $15.

Posted 11/7/08 11:33 AM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by MeNBobs

I like #2. It is actually very similiar to what you have there already. I like that it throws the light up.

If you don't have another spot for the current lamp have you considered spray painting it. I refinished a gold fireplace screen and a gold chandelier to bronze. I used Benjamin Moore spray paint. In the stores they have a sample of what the colors look like. Most of the them are not just a solid color they have specs of other color in it so it looks like metal not paint. It's hard to explain but if you check them out you will know what I mean. I think the paint was about $15.



That is a pretty good idea. I'll have to check out that kind of spray paint if I'm going to keep the floor lamp I already have. Great idea, because I don't think I will need this floor lamp in another room right now. Thanks for the great idea. Chat Icon

Posted 11/7/08 11:44 AM
 

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

#2 rocks!

Posted 11/7/08 2:46 PM
 

Geraldine
Lovin Life........

Member since 5/07

2388 total posts

Name:
Geraldine

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by JldDolphin

Posted by MeNBobs

I like #2. It is actually very similiar to what you have there already. I like that it throws the light up.

If you don't have another spot for the current lamp have you considered spray painting it. I refinished a gold fireplace screen and a gold chandelier to bronze. I used Benjamin Moore spray paint. In the stores they have a sample of what the colors look like. Most of the them are not just a solid color they have specs of other color in it so it looks like metal not paint. It's hard to explain but if you check them out you will know what I mean. I think the paint was about $15.



That is a pretty good idea. I'll have to check out that kind of spray paint if I'm going to keep the floor lamp I already have. Great idea, because I don't think I will need this floor lamp in another room right now. Thanks for the great idea. Chat Icon



I was going to suggest spray painting as well. I have sprayed a few different things bronze and they came out great.I bought it from HD,I think it was 5.99 a can. Also, I just saw a 4 piece bronze lamp set at Christmas Tree Shoppe for 49.99, incase you want all the lamps to match,it's a great price.There are pics in the online circular

Posted 11/7/08 3:13 PM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by Geraldine

I was going to suggest spray painting as well. I have sprayed a few different things bronze and they came out great.I bought it from HD,I think it was 5.99 a can. Also, I just saw a 4 piece bronze lamp set at Christmas Tree Shoppe for 49.99, incase you want all the lamps to match,it's a great price.There are pics in the online circular



Thanks Geraldine! Chat Icon I think I'm going to try the spray paint on the floor lamp I already have. This way I save some money and my DH will be happy. Chat Icon

Posted 11/7/08 4:04 PM
 

MeNBobs
*****

Member since 4/07

3765 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by JldDolphin

Posted by Geraldine

I was going to suggest spray painting as well. I have sprayed a few different things bronze and they came out great.I bought it from HD,I think it was 5.99 a can. Also, I just saw a 4 piece bronze lamp set at Christmas Tree Shoppe for 49.99, incase you want all the lamps to match,it's a great price.There are pics in the online circular



Thanks Geraldine! Chat Icon I think I'm going to try the spray paint on the floor lamp I already have. This way I save some money and my DH will be happy. Chat Icon



After this you will become a refinishing addict. I am looking at everything to see if I can sand it and fix it up. I have done a kitchen table, a desk black and the two I mentioned before bronze. If you find yourself ready to bronze-ify pinecones and leaves for a centerpiece you must put the paint down and walk away.

Posted 11/7/08 4:16 PM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

Posted by MeNBobs

Posted by JldDolphin

Posted by Geraldine

I was going to suggest spray painting as well. I have sprayed a few different things bronze and they came out great.I bought it from HD,I think it was 5.99 a can. Also, I just saw a 4 piece bronze lamp set at Christmas Tree Shoppe for 49.99, incase you want all the lamps to match,it's a great price.There are pics in the online circular



Thanks Geraldine! Chat Icon I think I'm going to try the spray paint on the floor lamp I already have. This way I save some money and my DH will be happy. Chat Icon



After this you will become a refinishing addict. I am looking at everything to see if I can sand it and fix it up. I have done a kitchen table, a desk black and the two I mentioned before bronze. If you find yourself ready to bronze-ify pinecones and leaves for a centerpiece you must put the paint down and walk away.


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I promise I will walk away from the paint if I have an itch to paint pincecones bronze. Chat Icon

Posted 11/10/08 11:32 AM
 

gforce
My other love!

Member since 5/08

1744 total posts

Name:

Re: Which Lamp? Poll & Pics

I voted for #2, I have one that looks just like it in my living room.

Posted 11/10/08 12:06 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
"Holy" lava lamp (pics) -Lisa- 5/16/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
Katie is 2 weeks old today and lost her umbilical cord w/pics - fixed pics MrsJ 5/12/06 17 Parenting
UPDATED - added more pics on page 2 - I had my 3D sonogram today - With Pics MrsJ 3/8/06 39 Pregnancy
John's first pics with Santa and his Christmas pics stayandjohn 11/15/05 23 Parenting
Some pics from my trip to AZ: UPDATED on bottom with link to all my pics Jax430 9/4/05 41 Families Helping Families ™
Finally....My 32 week belly pics...or should I say whale pics!! Dani00518 7/12/05 43 Pregnancy