Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4

siffleuse319
LIF Infant

Member since 8/08

189 total posts

Name:

Marital Property and Foreclosure?

I'm hoping to get some guidance on this one. I own a very, very small house for 2 years. And then I got married this June. We need to move. I owe $55,000 more than I can sell it for. And, I can't rent it because I can only do so for about $11-1200 and my mortgage is $1750...can't afford to pay the difference each month, despite it being an awesome write-off.
Here's the question: We are considering purchasing a new home that is potentially our forever home. It's a fantastic price, gorgeous 4Br 2Ba in the area that we wanted. I'm considering defaulting on my mortgage for the 1Br and short selling it. I'll chalk it up to a bad investiment and won't need the credit rating once I'm in the new house. Can they go after DH OR the new house to get money from me? What are the legal ramifications? Please share any of your ideas or experiences.....TIA!!!

Posted 8/25/08 8:15 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

First let me say, I don't agree with your plan as a morally good decision but I'll answer your question. To the best of my knowledge NY is a non-recourse state meaning they cannot go after your assets. In order to do a short sale you'll need to miss SEVERAL mortgage payments which wil destroy your credit to the point that you will not get credit cards or car loans in the near future. You are probably counting on your DH's credit for the future. If you put his name on your deed that *might* be a problem. Not all mortgage companies are allowing short sales, you'll have to do your homework to see if yours will.
Your timing in buying the new house & defaulting on this one is critical. If the house doesn't sell in a short sale-which it may not, 1 bedrooms are a VERY hard sell at any price- the mortgage company can start foreclosure proceedings within the amount of time allowed by NYS, again if things don't work out perfectly you could be royally screwed. On the up side the government has decided to allow people like you to not be responsible for the income tax that you would have paid last year if you defaulted on your mortgage.
I think its really effed up that people that made bad choices are receiving a free ride from Uncle Sam so they can move on to greener pastures.
just my two centsChat Icon

Posted 8/25/08 8:46 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by KellyFG

On the up side the government has decided to allow people like you to not be responsible for the income tax that you would have paid last year if you defaulted on your mortgage.
I think its really effed up that people that made bad choices are receiving a free ride from Uncle Sam so they can move on to greener pastures.
just my two centsChat Icon



I think it's equally effed up that people take such little personal responsibility for themselves and the financial decisions they freely made. Seriously, I couldn't live with myself if I made such a choice just so I could move to a bigger house.

That aside, if you want legal advice (which is what you are asking for), hire a lawyer.

Posted 8/25/08 8:55 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by Kara

Posted by KellyFG

On the up side the government has decided to allow people like you to not be responsible for the income tax that you would have paid last year if you defaulted on your mortgage.
I think its really effed up that people that made bad choices are receiving a free ride from Uncle Sam so they can move on to greener pastures.
just my two centsChat Icon



I think it's equally effed up that people take such little personal responsibility for themselves and the financial decisions they freely made. Seriously, I couldn't live with myself if I made such a choice just so I could move to a bigger house.

That aside, if you want legal advice (which is what you are asking for), hire a lawyer.




Agreed. Why do you NEED to move?

You shouldn't be using the government to bail out your bad financial decisions.

Your credit is going to be trashed if you do this (500s most likely) so there are one of two scenarios that will happen:

- If you buy this new house before selling, you will have to report this house as debt so it is unlikely a bank will finance a new house while you are holding this piece of property (they will want to see a signed contract to sell this house). And if they see a signed contract for a short sale, then they probably won't approve you anyways.

- You can trash your credit by foreclosing on this house and the bank won't approve a loan for a new house anyways because of your credit scores.

Either scenario won't be good. I would live with the decision you made and work to payoff this house.

Also how can you NOT rent this house for at least $1200 if it's a 2br? What kind of house is this and where is it located? I think renting is the best option here (even if you can't rent it for more than what your mortgage is).


ETA: just noticed it's a 1BR. How did you find a 1BR house? I didn't even think those existed and I never would have even considered looking at a 1br since 2brs are hard enough to sell.

Message edited 2008-08-25 09:31:21.513000.

Posted 8/25/08 9:28 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

I'm hoping to get some guidance on this one. I own a very, very small house for 2 years. And then I got married this June. We need to move. I owe $55,000 more than I can sell it for. And, I can't rent it because I can only do so for about $11-1200 and my mortgage is $1750...can't afford to pay the difference each month, despite it being an awesome write-off.
Here's the question: We are considering purchasing a new home that is potentially our forever home. It's a fantastic price, gorgeous 4Br 2Ba in the area that we wanted. I'm considering defaulting on my mortgage for the 1Br and short selling it. I'll chalk it up to a bad investiment and won't need the credit rating once I'm in the new house. Can they go after DH OR the new house to get money from me? What are the legal ramifications? Please share any of your ideas or experiences.....TIA!!!



I also want to correct you, you don't "own" anything, if you owned it as you say you probably would not be willing to sell it for 55k less than you paid for it. Why is ok for the bank that lent you the money to take the hit?
Do you realize that we all pay for these actions through loss in property value, locals governments are losing property tax dollars with no way to make up the difference, lending standards are tightening because of short sales shutting more qualified first home buyers out. Believe me I have no real pity for the mortgage industry but there are thousands of people of of work & with no alternative career path.
the bailout train you hope to ride costs all of us.

Posted 8/25/08 9:39 AM
 

siffleuse319
LIF Infant

Member since 8/08

189 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Wow....while I appreciate your input..please lay off the moral proselytizing and negative judgments. You have made such a harsh claim on very limited information about me and my situation. I made a poor financial investment. I didn't defraud anyone or cause harm in any way. This is more about business and investing than it is about failing to take responsibility. Also, I'm willing to absorb some of the loss and take responsibility for misjudging the market...but I'm unable to incur ALL of the costs to this. The bank also entered into a risky agreement with me...and as such, there are consequences for both parties. Ease up on your self-righteousness, for the good of us all. It's a matter of business, not morality. I know when the two interact with each other...and this is not the case. I'm sorry that you lack the intelligence to perceive it from any other perspective. But, Good luck finding your moral utopia....but first GO DIRECTLY TO JAIL, DO NOT PASS GO. Your harsh criticism and scorn just violated one of the founding priniciples.

Message edited 2008-08-25 09:46:46.463000.

Posted 8/25/08 9:43 AM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

If you wanted us to have all of the information so we could base our opinions on the "business end" of it, I'd assume you would have given it to us.
Call me what you'd like but I'd venture to say I have far more first hand RE investing experience than you (or most people for that matter) and buying a ONE BEDROOM at the HEIGHT of an RE bubble is never wise. You're going to have a hard time convincing me now that you are just looking at this from a business point of view. Good luck to you, we will all enjoy a bite of the $hit sandwich you and Uncle Sam serve us!

Posted 8/25/08 9:49 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

You have made such a harsh claim on very limited information about me and my situation.

I'm sorry that you lack the intelligence to perceive it from any other perspective.




Wow. What situation is there? You are asking the government for a bailout for your bad decisions.

And then you feel entitled to go ahead and make ANOTHER bad financial decision by buying this 4br house.

And you say WE lack the intelligence?

Just... WOW.

Posted 8/25/08 9:51 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by KellyFG

we will all enjoy a bite of the $hit sandwich you and Uncle Sam serve us!




OMG Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/08 9:52 AM
 

LulaBell
:)

Member since 1/06

3508 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

I rarely post judmental opinions on this site but I'll make an exception today!

I clearly see this as an intersection of business and morality - with you selecting business over morality.

I too bought my home when the RE market was higher. If I tried to sell today I would most likely take a loss on my home, however like you I would purchase a larger more comfortable home. I will not do it, I will stay in my smaller home for the time being because I don't want to lose money on my investment. It has never crossed my mind that it's okay - morally, financially, however you look at it - to default on my mortgage agreement to get what I want.

That's just me.

Posted 8/25/08 9:55 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

I'm hoping to get some guidance on this one. I own a very, very small house for 2 years. And then I got married this June. We need to move. I owe $55,000 more than I can sell it for. And, I can't rent it because I can only do so for about $11-1200 and my mortgage is $1750...can't afford to pay the difference each month, despite it being an awesome write-off.
Here's the question: We are considering purchasing a new home that is potentially our forever home. It's a fantastic price, gorgeous 4Br 2Ba in the area that we wanted. I'm considering defaulting on my mortgage for the 1Br and short selling it. I'll chalk it up to a bad investiment and won't need the credit rating once I'm in the new house. Can they go after DH OR the new house to get money from me? What are the legal ramifications? Please share any of your ideas or experiences.....TIA!!!




Ummm, I can see you are in a tough spot with the market fall but I think it might be a very big risk to do this. That messes up your credit for at least 10 years and what happens if you want or have to buy a car or take out credit somewhere, etc. You never know what will happen in the next 10 years. IMO, your credit is everything at this point in your life. IMO, just wanting a bigger house doesn't justify putting myself or my husband at risk - financially or criminally. There are criminal charges for when people laspe on their mortgages for no real reason. I see it in my job alot. I hope you work everything out. Good Luck!!

Posted 8/25/08 9:57 AM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by Lake0703

Ummm, I can see you are in a tough spot with the market fall but I think it might be a very big risk to do this. That messes up your credit for at least 10 years and what happens if you want or have to buy a car or take out credit somewhere, etc. You never know what will happen in the next 10 years. IMO, your credit is everything at this point in your life. QUOTE]

ITA.

Posted 8/25/08 9:58 AM
 

siffleuse319
LIF Infant

Member since 8/08

189 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

IMO, your credit is everything at this point in your life. IMO, just wanting a bigger house doesn't justify putting myself or my husband at risk - financially or criminally. There are criminal charges for when people laspe on their mortgages for no real reason. I see it in my job alot. I hope you work everything out. Good Luck!!



Thanks for being non-judgmental and offering some insight and information. I never heard of the criminal charges..but will be sure to look into that. I know that my credit will be adversely affected, and as part of playing in this game, I may have to be o.k. with it. At this time, the benefits of having a larger home may outweigh the risks (unless of course, there's criminal implications!!). I need a place for my parents to stay and my current mortgage increased drastically due to taxes and insurance going up. The increase, unfortunately, is more than the mortgage will be on the new house. I'll definitely consider your points though...and thanks again for your courtesy and input!

Posted 8/25/08 10:12 AM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

I need a place for my parents to stay and my current mortgage increased drastically due to taxes and insurance going up. The increase, unfortunately, is more than the mortgage will be on the new house. I'll definitely consider your points though...and thanks again for your courtesy and input!



Where do you live that the tax and insurance increase on a 1br home is more than a mortgage for a 4br home?

Posted 8/25/08 10:18 AM
 

siffleuse319
LIF Infant

Member since 8/08

189 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Where do you live that the tax and insurance increase on a 1br home is more than a mortgage for a 4br home?



Less than .5 mile from the bay in a depressed economic neighborhood. Like I said earlier....I am coming to terms with making a really poor financial investment (yes at the height of the bubble a couple years ago). The full mortgage payment (PITI) on the 1BR house is now slightly more than the Principle and Interest of the 4Br in the better school district. Because the taxes and deductible, I'm not so worried about them increasing the overall monthly payment. But to answer your question....my insurance increase was the real kicker. It more than tripled causing my escrows to increase.

Posted 8/25/08 10:25 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

Where do you live that the tax and insurance increase on a 1br home is more than a mortgage for a 4br home?



Less than .5 mile from the bay in a depressed economic neighborhood. Like I said earlier....I am coming to terms with making a really poor financial investment (yes at the height of the bubble a couple years ago). The full mortgage payment (PITI) on the 1BR house is now slightly more than the Principle and Interest of the 4Br in the better school district. Because the taxes and deductible, I'm not so worried about them increasing the overall monthly payment. But to answer your question....my insurance increase was the real kicker. It more than tripled causing my escrows to increase.



Wow! I feel for ya - my HO insurance just tried to double our coverage last week. Needless to say, we are shopping around for a new company. Definitly look into everything that you could do first, making the default your last resort (and even then make sure you research all the consequences - I would assume that if it was that easy more people would do it).

Posted 8/25/08 10:29 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

I want to know where this person is coming up with a down payment for a 4br house.

Because if this person has the money for a down payment on the house, they should have the money to pay down the 1BR and not expect the government to bail them out.

Posted 8/25/08 10:31 AM
 

siffleuse319
LIF Infant

Member since 8/08

189 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

not expect the government to bail them out.


Again...Miss Angry, this transaction I'm considering is not government regulated at all. It's a deal that myself and the bank will enter into together to acknowledge the current situation, relative to the past. It will be between me and the lien holder. Where you get your notions that the government is involved in this private mortgage interaction is beyond me. But please direct your anger and hostility elsewhere. I came on here looking for words of wisdom and advice. I'm in a really difficult and crummy situation because of the down-turn that the market took. I'm not a bad person. I'm looking to do what's best for me and my family. And if that means possibly sacrificing my own credit score..I may be willing to do that. Please stop being so mean.

Posted 8/25/08 10:40 AM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

You need an attorney to answer your questions on the legal aspects of foreclosure.

As for the moral aspect, all I have to say is Karma is a b*tch.

your credit will be ruined, and you are putting all your eggs in your husbands basket. You wont be albe to get a credit card, car loan, etc.

your exising credit card interest rates will skyrocket, even if you dont miss a payment- they will check your credit report and see the foreclosure.

With the divorce rate at 50%, and as much as I love my DH, there is no way I would ruin my credit now, who knows what could happen in a few years.

Posted 8/25/08 10:51 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

not expect the government to bail them out.


Again...Miss Angry, this transaction I'm considering is not government regulated at all. It's a deal that myself and the bank will enter into together to acknowledge the current situation




The government is not involved at all?

Where do you think the bank gets the money from in order to incur this kind of a loss? The money tree?

I'll tell you where the government WILL get involved. Tax time.

I sure hope you realize that after the bank takes the hit on a short sale, the difference that the bank forgives you WILL be taxed as income on your yearly tax form.

So while Uncle Sam will not be happy with this type of bailout, expect him to stick his hand out come tax time.

Posted 8/25/08 10:54 AM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

so this is becoming quite the trend lately

it's going to be hard to get approved for another house- when you own one already

and second- as soon as you miss one payment - you credit is done

so you might be stuck with no house and no credit

too risky for me- but that's why I waited and didn't make decesions that I couldn't live with for ever

Posted 8/25/08 11:01 AM
 

Tabitha

Member since 2/07

2029 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

Please share any of your ideas or experiences.....TIA!!!



My idea would be for you to take responsibility for your actions. You made an adult decision to buy a house. Be a big girl and follow through with your decision.

Maybe not the "idea" youre looking for, but it is certainly the right thing to do.

Posted 8/25/08 11:16 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

Wow....while I appreciate your input..please lay off the moral proselytizing and negative judgments. You have made such a harsh claim on very limited information about me and my situation. I made a poor financial investment. I didn't defraud anyone or cause harm in any way. This is more about business and investing than it is about failing to take responsibility. Also, I'm willing to absorb some of the loss and take responsibility for misjudging the market...but I'm unable to incur ALL of the costs to this. The bank also entered into a risky agreement with me...and as such, there are consequences for both parties. Ease up on your self-righteousness, for the good of us all. It's a matter of business, not morality. I know when the two interact with each other...and this is not the case. I'm sorry that you lack the intelligence to perceive it from any other perspective. But, Good luck finding your moral utopia....but first GO DIRECTLY TO JAIL, DO NOT PASS GO. Your harsh criticism and scorn just violated one of the founding priniciples.



Get over it. You posted this on a public BB and guess what, you're going to get opinions and advice on the matter - even if it's not specifically what you asked for or specifically what you want to hear. I assume you've read enough of this boards to know that ahead of time. If you think morality and ethics play no role in business, then I gather you are not a terribly experienced businessperson. And if you think this is NOT a place where ethics and business intersect, then I'd be really interested to know where you draw the line.

BTW, I agiain reiterate my suggestion to hire a lawyer. You may think what you're doing is totally legal, but I would venture a guess that you are treading in some very grey areas. Like, gee, I don't know - possible fraud.

But what could I possibly know from way up here on my moral high ground, what without all that intelligence you tell me I'm lacking. Chat Icon I'll go back to searching for my moral utopia now.

Posted 8/25/08 11:16 AM
 

Tabitha

Member since 2/07

2029 total posts

Name:

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by Kara

Posted by siffleuse319

Wow....while I appreciate your input..please lay off the moral proselytizing and negative judgments. You have made such a harsh claim on very limited information about me and my situation. I made a poor financial investment. I didn't defraud anyone or cause harm in any way. This is more about business and investing than it is about failing to take responsibility. Also, I'm willing to absorb some of the loss and take responsibility for misjudging the market...but I'm unable to incur ALL of the costs to this. The bank also entered into a risky agreement with me...and as such, there are consequences for both parties. Ease up on your self-righteousness, for the good of us all. It's a matter of business, not morality. I know when the two interact with each other...and this is not the case. I'm sorry that you lack the intelligence to perceive it from any other perspective. But, Good luck finding your moral utopia....but first GO DIRECTLY TO JAIL, DO NOT PASS GO. Your harsh criticism and scorn just violated one of the founding priniciples.



Get over it. You posted this on a public BB and guess what, you're going to get opinions and advice on the matter - even if it's not specifically what you asked for or specifically what you want to hear. I assume you've read enough of this boards to know that ahead of time. If you think morality and ethics play no role in business, then I gather you are not a terribly experienced businessperson. And if you think this is NOT a place where ethics and business intersect, then I'd be really interested to know where you draw the line.

BTW, I agiain reiterate my suggestion to hire a lawyer. You may think what you're doing is totally legal, but I would venture a guess that you are treading in some very grey areas. Like, gee, I don't know - possible fraud.

But what could I possibly know from way up here on my moral high ground, what without all that intelligence you tell me I'm lacking. Chat Icon I'll go back to searching for my moral utopia now.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/25/08 11:18 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Marital Property and Foreclosure?

Posted by siffleuse319

Wow....while I appreciate your input..please lay off the moral proselytizing and negative judgments. You have made such a harsh claim on very limited information about me and my situation. I made a poor financial investment. I didn't defraud anyone or cause harm in any way. This is more about business and investing than it is about failing to take responsibility. Also, I'm willing to absorb some of the loss and take responsibility for misjudging the market...but I'm unable to incur ALL of the costs to this. The bank also entered into a risky agreement with me...and as such, there are consequences for both parties. Ease up on your self-righteousness, for the good of us all. It's a matter of business, not morality. I know when the two interact with each other...and this is not the case. I'm sorry that you lack the intelligence to perceive it from any other perspective. But, Good luck finding your moral utopia....but first GO DIRECTLY TO JAIL, DO NOT PASS GO. Your harsh criticism and scorn just violated one of the founding priniciples.



I am not going to judge you or your decisions but what I will ask is if you cannot pay the ~$500 difference between what it would cost to rent your current home and the mortgage..how will you pay for a new one that is more than double the size and (I assume) with a higher payment?

Posted 8/25/08 11:35 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4