Law against spanking?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Law against spanking? Has anyone heard about the bill being proposed in California to make spanking a child under 3 illegal and punishable with jail time? I personally don't think there's ever a need to spank a child, and DW and I have never spanked or smacked our DC, but I also don't think there should be a law dictating how others can deal with their kids. I do understand that she is trying to protect kids from abuse, but there should be a better way of going about this, I think. No Spanking Bill (New Proposed California Law) FOX 40 KTXL ^ | 11 Jan 07 | KTXL Posted on 01/14/2007 6:13:46 AM PST by gobucks SACRAMENTO — A new bill wants to outlaw parents from spanking their children. The assemblywoman sponsoring the measure wants to protect those who can't defend themselves, but is it taking governing too far? Spanking is a touchy issue for many people. Some use it. Others don't. An assemblywoman wants to ban all forms, even a slap on the hand. Speaker Pro Temp Sally Lieber plans to introduce a bill that would ban any form of spanking on kids less than three years old. That's includes spanking hands, faces or bottoms. Lieber said, "That would include slapping spanking smacking hitting punching, any striking of a child." Lieber said, "The borders begin to blur and there ought to be a bright line in the law that says no hitting a child 3 years or under." We found parents on both sides of the spanking issue, but many, whether they agreed with spanking or not, felt the government shouldn't tell parents how to parent. Karen Fontaine is both a parent and grandparent. She said, "What else are they going to do next, are they going to take over and raise our children?" Kary Mansu is also a parent, "I think it's a moral issue, how do you put a moral issue into no law and law, how do you control it?" Article about the proposal |
|
Posted 1/20/07 11:43 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Law against spanking? I don't believe in EVER spanking... but I think that passing a law against it could be a little difficult. |
|
Posted 1/20/07 12:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Law against spanking? Posted by JennChris I don't believe in EVER spanking... but I think that passing a law against it could be a little difficult. I agree. |
|
Posted 1/20/07 12:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Law against spanking? How would that ever be enforced? |
|
Posted 1/20/07 1:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Law against spanking? When my 2 year old ran into a parking lot, I should have sat him down & reasoned with him rather than spank his butt because I would have been arrested? |
|
Posted 1/20/07 2:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Law against spanking? No child deserves to be hit. But I'm not sure how they would enforce this. |
|
Posted 1/20/07 2:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Law against spanking? It's hard - one one hand, I think a parent should be able to discipline a child w/o having to fear the law, but the thing is, maybe that law is needed because people go over the line in disciplining their children. I think the media (tv, movies) have desensitized us in certain ways and this is one of them, that hitting is a way of getting anger out. Spanking isn't about how the adult is mad and wants to hit something and hits the child. Its' about doing something to the child that will remind them "it's not good to do what you did". That said, I'm not going to spank my child. DH thinks otherwise but I also think he's read enough in some of the books and magazines I have brought home to change his mind, as well. He says he thinks "time outs" are "stupid", I don't and will use that. |
|
Posted 1/20/07 5:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Law against spanking? I don't agree with spanking but at the same time I dont think that the government has a right to tell parents how to displine their children. |
|
Posted 1/21/07 8:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Law against spanking? That's a little extreme. Slapping of hands included? I've had to slap DS' hands to get him to stop touching things that otherwise would have hurt him far worse...so by protecting him, I'm abusing him? I'd be arrested for it? It's not like I do it on a daily basis and I've only used it as a last resort and it's not like I wailed on him and made him cry. I just think it's a little much. Plus, I'd love to know how they'd enforce it. I mean, I can see, if you're beating on your kid in public and it's blatent child abuse, but a little slap on the wrist doesn't call for arrest, IMO. |
|
Posted 1/21/07 8:23 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| My Mother in Law... | CheeChee | 3/20/06 | 12 | Parenting |
| x | MommyofG | 3/17/06 | 19 | TTC |
| Law & Order fans | Shanti | 3/12/06 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Anyone know criminal law? | Shanti | 3/11/06 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Anyone thinking about Law School?? | charon54 | 3/10/06 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| In law b-day acknowldgements | PrincessP | 3/9/06 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |











