LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

SpiceGirl
Dream big

Member since 1/06

2486 total posts

Name:
j

LCD vs. Plasma?

I want to purchase flat screens for our living room and den...can someone tell what is the better choice LCD or Plasma?

I've done some research online, but every article I've read seems to think they are BOTH good choices.

Thanks.

Posted 8/21/08 12:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

They are both good choices, as I have both.

If you are on a budget go plasma as you will get more for your money. If you have money to burn and can spend 2k go LCD.

Posted 8/21/08 12:44 PM
 

cindy104
This is my "Baby"

Member since 6/08

1522 total posts

Name:
Cindy

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

We have a 50" Panasonic Viera and it's a plasma. It's rated one of the best. We absolutely LOVE it. I know that DH did a TON of research on them before we made the purchase. We definitely prefer the plasma much more. It's a 'crisper' look.

Posted 8/21/08 12:47 PM
 

cindy104
This is my "Baby"

Member since 6/08

1522 total posts

Name:
Cindy

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by ave1024

They are both good choices, as I have both.

If you are on a budget go plasma as you will get more for your money. If you have money to burn and can spend 2k go LCD.



I think LCDs are more budget friendly

Posted 8/21/08 12:49 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

I think the biggest deciding factors are screen size (what size are you looking to get?), room light (is there a lot of sunlight in the room?), and primary usage (video games, movies, sports, game shows, etc)

Posted 8/21/08 12:50 PM
 

jbellis74
LIF Infant

Member since 7/08

149 total posts

Name:
Jason

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

LCD's are better than plasma tv for a few different reasons IMO.

I did extensive research on this....

1) Plasmas and LCD's both should give you 60,000 hrs of viewing pleasure

2) LCD tv's dont give off as much heat as plasma tv do

3) LCD TV are more cost effective as someone else noted

4) More LCD Tv's have the capability of you being able to hook up your PC to it

5) Plasma TV's are more likely to have "burn in" issues where the image is burnt into the screen

I bought a 40" Sony Bravia LCD 1080P for under $1000.00

There is also the DLP option if you dont want to hang a TV on a wall but use it with a stand DLP is the best way to go. I have a 55" DLP, a 40" LCD, and a 32" LCD

Message edited 2008-08-21 13:40:44.953000.

Posted 8/21/08 1:32 PM
 

mamallama
<3 <3 <3

Member since 9/07

5035 total posts

Name:

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by jbellis74

LCD's are better than plasma tv for a few different reasons IMO.

I did extensive research on this....

1) Plasmas and LCD's both should give you 60,000 hrs of viewing pleasure

2) LCD tv's dont give off as much heat as plasma tv do

3) LCD TV are more cost effective as someone else noted

4) More LCD Tv's have the capability of you being able to hook up your PC to it

5) Plasma TV's are more likely to have "burn in" issues where the image is burnt into the screen

I bought a 40" Sony Bravia LCD 1080P for under $1000.00




I agree Chat Icon

Posted 8/21/08 1:37 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

For larger displays, plasmas are more cost effective.

Here's Consumer Reports thoughts from March of this year:

LCD vs. Plasma TVs
Both are better than ever, and the best sets raise the bar for picture quality

Man looking at TVs on display

The vast majority of consumers are buying LCD and plasma flat panels rather than rear-projection sets or front projectors with separate screens. Neither LCD nor plasma is the clear winner for quality; there are excellent sets of both types in our Ratings of LCD TVs and Ratings of plasma TVs (both available to subscribers).

There are reasons to opt for one over the other, though. With LCDs, you'll have a wider choice of 1080p sets than with plasmas, and the price premium over a 720p TV is usually smaller. You'll also have more screen sizes to choose from, including sets smaller than 42 inches-typically the smallest size for a plasma. (See: Why buy an LCD TV?)

LCD TVs are generally a bit brighter than plasma, and their screens are less reflective, so many look better in bright rooms. They're also better for playing video games and for use as a computer monitor because they're not subject to burn-in from fixed images displayed for a long period, as plasma TVs can be. (Burn-in might have been more of a problem with early plasma sets. We've seen no evidence of permanent image retention in our short-term tests, and recent anecdotal evidence from our own staffers and online forum participants hasn't turned up any burn-in issues in typical long-term use at home.) LCD sets use less power, but the differences aren't that great. (See: Why buy a plasma TV?)

On the other hand, plasma TVs generally cost a bit less than LCD sets of comparable size and quality, though the price difference is shrinking. The best plasma TVs are better than LCD sets at displaying deep blacks and tend to have better contrast, which makes for rich, natural-looking images, especially in dim lighting. They're also better than LCDs at handling motion without blurring the image, though some new 120Hz LCDs are showing improvement in that area. (See: When either type is fine)

Another major advantage: Plasma TVs have a virtually unlimited viewing angle, so the picture quality doesn't deteriorate when you watch the screen from off-center. With most LCD sets (and rear-projection TVs), the picture loses some contrast, color, or brightness as you angle away from the center. You might not notice this too much with bright images and vivid colors like you'll see in a football game, but the degradation in quality can be obvious with other programs.

http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/electronics-computers/televisions/hdtv/tv-types/lcd-vs.-plasma-3-08/overview/lcd-vs-plasma-tvs-ov.htm

Posted 8/21/08 1:47 PM
 

jbellis74
LIF Infant

Member since 7/08

149 total posts

Name:
Jason

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

The viewing angle point is incorrect. My LCD Sony Bravia has a 178 degree viewing capability.


The picture from many previous LCD televisions deteriorates at extreme viewing angles. Sony BRAVIA television delivers a vibrant picture over a 178 degree viewing angle.


Slow response can add unwanted blur to moving objects. Sony's 8-millisecond response renders crisp, clear picture in many fact action scenes. 178 degree viewing angle. Plasma flat panels and conventional LCDs typically fall well short of the ideal viewing angle approaching 180 degrees. In contrast, Sony's 7th Generation panel has an internal Liquid Crystal structure that increases viewing angle to a phenomenal 178 degrees, so the picture remains vibrant when view ed from almost anywhere in the room.

P.S. The key to buying anything electronic is to go to a PC Richard and haggle. You cant haggle as much with anyone else. The main objective of the salesperson is to get you to purchase their protection plan which is always a good idea imo.

All you need to do is bring up this point and he or she will most likely do anything to get the price of the TV lowered as long as you agree to get their protection plan which is where there commissions are...

I was in sales for 15 years...

Message edited 2008-08-21 14:02:34.087000.

Posted 8/21/08 1:50 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

I've seen several manufacturers mention really high viewing angles, but honestly, at 178 degrees, you can't watch the TV..... it looks about 3 inches wide. I'm not sure what the point of having that extreme of an angle is.

I believe that Sony has a 178 degree viewable angle, but I don't believe that it is actually usable anywhere even close to that angle.

At this point, there really isn't a real difference between LCDs as a technology and Plasma as a technology. It's really down to individual screens. LCDs have gotten blacker blacks lately, sizes are about the same, Plasmas are getting faster, etc.

Posted 8/21/08 3:12 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by cindy104

Posted by ave1024

They are both good choices, as I have both.

If you are on a budget go plasma as you will get more for your money. If you have money to burn and can spend 2k go LCD.



I think LCDs are more budget friendly




LCD's are definitely NOT cheaper than Plasmas. Where did you get this info from?

I can get a 50" Panasonic Plasma for $1099 for no tax and shipped free. There is no way you can touch that price in LCD for that size.

Posted 8/21/08 3:15 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by jbellis74

LCD's are better than plasma tv for a few different reasons IMO.

I did extensive research on this....

1) Plasmas and LCD's both should give you 60,000 hrs of viewing pleasure

2) LCD tv's dont give off as much heat as plasma tv do

3) LCD TV are more cost effective as someone else noted

4) More LCD Tv's have the capability of you being able to hook up your PC to it

5) Plasma TV's are more likely to have "burn in" issues where the image is burnt into the screen

I bought a 40" Sony Bravia LCD 1080P for under $1000.00

There is also the DLP option if you dont want to hang a TV on a wall but use it with a stand DLP is the best way to go. I have a 55" DLP, a 40" LCD, and a 32" LCD



DH just researched this and I remember him telling me he choose an LCD for these reasons. We didn't get a huge screen, 42 inches.

Posted 8/21/08 3:18 PM
 

jbellis74
LIF Infant

Member since 7/08

149 total posts

Name:
Jason

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

You really dont need anything bigger than 42" unless you have a large LR or movie theater in your house and if you had a MT in your house you would most likely just have a DLP projector and a screen instead of a normal TV

Message edited 2008-08-21 15:36:16.980000.

Posted 8/21/08 3:32 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by jbellis74

Unless your room is at least 400 sq feet you really dont need anything bigger than 42" imo




Well I disagree with that.

I have a 10x10 bedroom that has a 50" plasma hanging on the wall. It is so awesome. My viewing distance is about 9 feet.

I also have a 52" in my living room that's 12x20' and my viewing distance on that TV is about 10-11'.

So say nothing bigger than a 42" for a 400square foot room. Do you realize how big a 400 square foot room is?

That's like a 16x25' room!

Posted 8/21/08 3:35 PM
 

jbellis74
LIF Infant

Member since 7/08

149 total posts

Name:
Jason

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Ummm yeah I have a room thats 20X20 so I do know how big it is

To have a 50" TV in a room thats 10X10 is a bit much....

I had a 62" and it was just over kill

But back to the point of this thread LCD's are better than Plasmas IMO.....

Plus I didnt say nothing bigger than a 42" for a 400square foot room.
I said unless you have a room that is at least 400 sq feet

Message edited 2008-08-21 15:46:03.047000.

Posted 8/21/08 3:37 PM
 

SuzyQ
Mama to 3!?!?!?

Member since 7/06

8069 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

We went with the LCD because our living room at the time has a TON of windows. There is definitely less glare on the LCD.

Posted 8/21/08 3:39 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by jbellis74

To have a 50" TV in a room thats 10X10 is a bit much....





It may be a bit much to you... but if you happen to read any HDTV hobbyist sites and forums you would see recommended viewing distances similar to what is in this link.

http://www.tech-evangelist.com/2007/09/08/ideal-hd-viewing-distances/

I also don't think you can just come out and say "LCDs are better than Plasma" because that's not always the case.

Plasmas have their advantages over LCDs. They are cheaper so you can go larger for less. They are less prone to dead pixels. LCDs can have more motion blur than plasmas.

The Pioneer Kuro plasma is without a doubt the best television on the market currently. Better than any LCD.

Message edited 2008-08-21 15:49:10.727000.

Posted 8/21/08 3:48 PM
 

jbellis74
LIF Infant

Member since 7/08

149 total posts

Name:
Jason

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

I disagree........there is def some doubt. The best TV right now is the Samsung LN52A650 or the Sony KDL-52W4100 and they are both bigger and at least 1000.00 less than your plasma... :)

52" Samsung LN52A650 - 2800.00
52" Sony KDL-52W4100 - 2999.99
50" Pioneer Kuro PDP-5020FD - 3999.99

Message edited 2008-08-21 16:02:35.050000.

Posted 8/21/08 3:54 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by jbellis74

I disagree........the best TV right now is the Samsung LN52A650 and its roughly half the price of your plasma... :)




Actually I own the LN52A750 which is one model up from yours. Chat Icon

The Kuro is rated better than the Sammy. And I don't even own the Kuro.

If you can find a review that says the Sammy has a better rated picture than the Kuro, i'd be more than happy to read it. Chat Icon

Posted 8/21/08 4:02 PM
 

rkoenke
my little piggys

Member since 3/08

4315 total posts

Name:
rachel

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

when i was buying a tv two years ago, LCDs were cheaper than plasma, but the Consumer Reports article states that LCD is more expensive. Could the industry have flip-flopped in the past two years?

I have LCD because of too many windows in the room it's in, plasma would not have worked for us.

Posted 8/21/08 4:48 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by rkoenke

when i was buying a tv two years ago, LCDs were cheaper than plasma, but the Consumer Reports article states that LCD is more expensive. Could the industry have flip-flopped in the past two years?

I have LCD because of too many windows in the room it's in, plasma would not have worked for us.




LCDs have been historically more expensive than Plasmas... when you compare apples to apples. Recently the price difference has gotten less, but LCDs are still more.

There are exceptions, like I said above with the Pioneer Kuro plasma which is more expensive than anything on the market.

But compare models with the same feature sets and the same size, and especially with the same manufacturer, plasmas are cheapers than LCDs.

For instance the 52" Sammy LCD (650 series) goes for around $2299. The comparable 50" Sammy Plasma (650 series) goes for around $1699. Both 1080p sets.

The main thing to realize is the sizes are different between LCD and Plasma when you go past 42". LCD is sold in 46/47" and 52" while Plasma is sold in 50".

Posted 8/21/08 4:56 PM
 

jbellis74
LIF Infant

Member since 7/08

149 total posts

Name:
Jason

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by ave1024

Posted by jbellis74

I disagree........the best TV right now is the Samsung LN52A650 and its roughly half the price of your plasma... :)




Actually I own the LN52A750 which is one model up from yours. Chat Icon

The Kuro is rated better than the Sammy. And I don't even own the Kuro.

If you can find a review that says the Sammy has a better rated picture than the Kuro, i'd be more than happy to read it. Chat Icon




I will see what I can dig up for ya.....I'm a big sony fan so ill see what I can find :)

Posted 8/21/08 5:10 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by jbellis74

I will see what I can dig up for ya.....I'm a big sony fan so ill see what I can find :)




No problem. The Sammy LCDs are better than the Sonys. But the Kuros blow everything out of the water when it comes to picture. Sorry but i'm not a fan of Sony TVs. Way overhyped.

I wish I had the money to burn to get the Kuro. But the Sammy 750 LCD is good enough. Chat Icon

Here is a little tidbit for you. Look at CNET Editor's top five highest rated HDTVs.

The three highest rated HDTVs are plasmas. Chat Icon


http://reviews.cnet.com/televisions/?tag=promo.tv

Posted 8/21/08 5:26 PM
 

megsm3
Life is Good!!

Member since 8/06

3867 total posts

Name:
M

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

We went to to a bunch of stores and spoke to countless salespeople and friends and ended up with a LCD. We are very happy with it.

Posted 8/21/08 5:42 PM
 

jbellis74
LIF Infant

Member since 7/08

149 total posts

Name:
Jason

Re: LCD vs. Plasma?

Posted by ave1024

Posted by jbellis74

I will see what I can dig up for ya.....I'm a big sony fan so ill see what I can find :)




No problem. The Sammy LCDs are better than the Sonys. But the Kuros blow everything out of the water when it comes to picture. Sorry but i'm not a fan of Sony TVs. Way overhyped.

I wish I had the money to burn to get the Kuro. But the Sammy 750 LCD is good enough. Chat Icon

Here is a little tidbit for you. Look at CNET Editor's top five highest rated HDTVs.

The three highest rated HDTVs are plasmas. Chat Icon


http://reviews.cnet.com/televisions/?tag=promo.tv



I have a 40" Sony and a 32" Samsung....The Sony has a better picture IMO.

Posted 8/21/08 6:24 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I've asked before, but I'm asking again...can you post pictures of your lcd/plasma tv situation? MissJones 12/2/07 14 Home
How do you clean your LCD or Plasma flat panel TV? SweetestOfPeas 8/16/07 10 Home
Plasma vs LCD ~Colleen~ 7/30/07 24 Home
PLASMA or LCD TV? smdl 5/27/07 13 Families Helping Families ™
Those with LCD or Plasma TVs that you mounted Blu-ize 12/23/06 11 Families Helping Families ™
Plasma/LCD Redhead 11/26/06 15 Families Helping Families ™