Re: Idol 4/22

I heard on the radio this Am. David Cook has an album out already...that he put out himself and it is selling very well already. He put it out in 2006.

Re: Idol 4/22

Carly and David Cook were amazing. David A to me was boring as usual. The only time we have ever heard him sing an upbeat song was that weird song that nobody heard of that Simon said sounded like a theme park song and the Beatles song that he messed up. IMO David A should not win. He is a ballad singer only and will be boring as a winner.

Syesha actually did very well and this should buy her another week or 2. Brooke and Jason were just awful. It's a toss up as to which one of them will go.

Re: Idol 4/22

This is the point where I start to get really sad to see people go.

Syesha..tonight she was wonderful! Her stage presence, her song fit her, her voice. I think shes good for this week.

Jason..Doesnt matter to me that it wasnt "terrific." I LOVE him and anything he sings will have his Jason spin on it. I am terrified though that he may be in the bottom tomorrow night.

Brooke..I actually didnt think she was all bad once she started singing it the right way. I LOVE that song though. But I want her to go home tomorrow night..I think her time is up..although she is the vote for the worst.

David A..this is who I would REALLY like to see go home! Hes so boring!!!!!!!!!!!!! Same sound..ugh! And did u see him squint instead to try to keep his eyes open? LOL

Carly..Great tonight! Song fit her perfectly.

David C...I thought he was wonderful! Although I love Jason, David C. is my pick for american idol this year! I think tonight showed he can actually sing instead of just rock it out.

Paula annoyed me even more tonight than other nights..MY GOD! And I LOVE Andrew Lloyd Weber..but doesnt he look like a who from whoville?? LMAO

Re: Idol 4/22

Um...did any body see Paul Stanley from KISS when they panned the audience? My DH ...he is now a fan because of this!

Re: Idol 4/22

Posted by MrsFlatbread

Um...did any body see Paul Stanley from KISS when they panned the audience? My DH ...he is now a fan because of this!

Re: Idol 4/22

Re: Idol 4/22

Posted by MrsFlatbread

Posted by TaraGotHutched


Paul Stanley has a link to Lloyd Webber-

Yes...I am sure he does...in more ways than just Phantom!

Re: Idol 4/22

Just had to comment on the kids in the front of the audience CONSTANTLY swaying their arms back and forth throughout the WHOLE show! How Freakin' ANNOYING was that?

I found it very distracting and I can imagine it would be distracting to the contestants as well. I would think the producers would not allow that.

Can you imagine being at a Broadway show with those idiots? Would they be swaying their arms like that the whole time?
Come on already.... it's just so dumb!

Message edited 4/23/2008 9:06:27 AM.

Re: Idol 4/22

Re: Idol 4/22

I thought Syesha ROCKED the house last night. She was BY far the best--second would be Carly and I don't even like her.

I thought both David's were predictable. And David Cook a lil arrogant for rocking the ballad.


I also feel the judges have already decided it will be a David David one on one in the end. The remarks they made for both their mediocre performances should have been voiced to Carly and Syesha.


PS-I LOVE Syesha

Re: Idol 4/22

David Cook is by far the BEST and I hope he wins! He is simply amazing!

David A - he's cute and has an amazing voice, but I don't think he should win.

Carly and Brooke - I liked them both in the beginning. Brooke has begun to annoy me with the start and stop routine she's got going. I do believe she'll make in Country Music. Carly just annoys me with her "I know I'm good" attitude.

Syesha - was very very good tonight and I can totally see her rocking out Broadway. This is where she belongs.

Jason - well Jason he's adorable. He's got amazing eyes, but I'm not so sure he can really sing. I think his good looks are overshadowing the fact that he is just an average singer.

I just want DAVID COOK to win!

Re: Idol 4/22

Re: Idol 4/22

I don't know much about musicals , or Andrew Lloyd Webber (and apparently neither did msot of the contestants), but I just wanted to say that I think he was the best mentor! \

His bluntess cracked me up & he also actually really helped the contestants. Although, he told CArly to pick a differnt song, he shoudl have told Jason the same thing!

And, both davids & Carly are good, but I just can't get behind them--I don't know why. I used to like Brooke, but she's fading.

Re: Idol 4/22

I usually work Tuesday nights but I was home yesterday sick, so I saw last night's show. I thought Syesha (sp) and Carly did great. I was happy Andrew Lloyd Webber had Carly do a stronger song than her first choice.

I thought David A was ok but I do'nt think he should be the next AI because I think he doesn't have the personality for it. I think being AI is more than just the singing, it's the whole package. I know that it should just be about the voice but, he's so timid and quiet IMO. In a few years maybe but not now.

I didn't think Jason Castro did a great job. I thought Brooke was horrible and I think she'll go tonight. I didn't think David Cook was that great either but everyone else loved him so maybe it's just me.

Re: Idol 4/22

I thought Carly and both Davids did great. Syesha was also good. Brooke was ok and Jason was awful. I think Brooke, Jason and Syesha will be in the bottom 3. Brooke or Jason will go home.