WWYD- Please help me with this.

Posted By Message

Smileyd17
kids

Member since 5/05

20997 total posts

Name:
Mommy

WWYD- Please help me with this.

My DD who is a very bright 3 1/2yr old is pulling this "lying" thing and I dont like it.

She and my niece are very close, they spend a lot of time togther. DAILY!

Anyways, she was over on Sun, she pushed her, niece fell and DD refused and I mean REFUSED to admit what she did. Sent to room, punished her. Made her say sorry.
Even after apologizing to her, she refused to admit it.

I just got a call from mom that she did the same today, hit her and refused to admit it, and was caught doing it.
Put in time out.
Came out. Refused to admit it, says she didnt hit her.

WHISPERS in my nieces ear, sorry I hit you.

My mom then said, ok..you admitted it so you know not to hit, She then says, I didnt hit her.
O.M.G Chat Icon

So does she get LYING? How would you correct this behavior?
She knows that she cant hit, of course but this lying. ugh something I cant stand.

Posted 11/18/10 3:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

I have the same trouble getting her to understand "lying". I just keep asking her the same question until she admits she is lying (because I know better)

Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: are you lying?
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: I think you are lying
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: are you lying?
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: you are lying
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: yes
Ok, now go say you are sorry

Posted 11/18/10 3:18 PM
 

Smileyd17
kids

Member since 5/05

20997 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

Posted by CouponKT

I have the same trouble getting her to understand "lying". I just keep asking her the same question until she admits she is lying (because I know better)

Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: are you lying?
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: I think you are lying
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: are you lying?
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: you are lying
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: yes
Ok, now go say you are sorry



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Uh, you at least get YES I DID!

Posted 11/18/10 3:25 PM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

In the class we are taking now, they suggest asking "what happened BEFORE so&so cried (I wouldn't say "before you hit her" because you are tryiong to get her to tell you what happened)? Then what happened? How did that make you feel? How did she feel? What do you think might be a better idea?" etc (it's an 8 week class so I am overly-simplifying). Her problem is different than yours - her problem is that so&so did SOMETHING that made her want to hit her. You need to find out what it was, and how it made her feel. Empathize with her. Then from there move on to the hitting part.... It's hard to explain but this book Raising a Thinking Child is a huge huge help -- with lying, acting out, tantrums, etc. All the typical 3 year old behavior....

ETA - and the idea of making children say they are sorry when they aren't is somewhat counter-productive. You want to help them realize how their behavior hurt someone else, and then they can feel empathy, and THEN feel truly apologetic...

Message edited 2010-11-18 15:59:36.963000.

Posted 11/18/10 3:58 PM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

What if you explain what lying is? DS tries to pull it and I tell him he needs to tell me the truth or I will not be a happy mommy and it usually works. Then I tell him it makes me sad if he hit sister and doesn't tell me. If I know for a fact that he did it because I heard it, he has until I count to 3 to come clean. If not he goes to his room (he HATES that) and when he is done thinking of what he has done I take him out and he will tell me what he did and apologize for it. If he still has an attitude about it, he goes back in. Now, DS is a whole year older than G is but, like you said she is bright and I think she will get it.

Posted 11/18/10 3:59 PM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

Posted by Smileyd17

Uh, you at least get YES I DID!




True. But I just make the point to her that I know what she did and she better fess up!

Can you punish her until she admits it? Stay in timeout?

Posted 11/18/10 4:00 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

Posted by CouponKT

I have the same trouble getting her to understand "lying". I just keep asking her the same question until she admits she is lying (because I know better)

Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: are you lying?
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: I think you are lying
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: are you lying?
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: no
Me: you are lying
Her: no
Me: did you hit your brother?
Her: yes
Ok, now go say you are sorry





I'm sorry this cracks me up Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/18/10 4:06 PM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

Posted by jellybean1420


I'm sorry this cracks me up Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



this exact scenario happened like 2 days ago Chat Icon

Chat Icon

Posted 11/18/10 4:08 PM
 

FelAndJon
needs to update her avatar pic

Member since 6/05

10212 total posts

Name:
Felice (aka LuckyBride2004)

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

Posted by karacg

In the class we are taking now, they suggest asking "what happened BEFORE so&so cried (I wouldn't say "before you hit her" because you are tryiong to get her to tell you what happened)? Then what happened? How did that make you feel? How did she feel?



This is what I do with DS1. I want him to understand consequences. I also remind him that HE will get in trouble for hitting someone back, because hitting is never the answer to anything. I do find asking "timing" type questions (like AP said, what happened before so & so started crying) is my best bet Chat Icon

Posted 11/18/10 4:08 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: WWYD- Please help me with this.

DH and I heard a really good show on NPR about children lying and how to deal with it. In a nutshell, the expert basically said that if you punish your child for lying, they will only become more creative with their lies. Instead, focus on positive reinforcement for telling the truth. DH and I have been doing this with Alex and it's working SOOOOO well. I will ask her a question and before she answers, I tell her that the most important thing is to tell the truth and that I will be most happy and proud if she does that. If she DOES tell the truth, I will reward her with a big hug and kiss. Sometimes she's still disciplined for the underlying behavior she's lying about, but I always make a big deal out of rewarding her with lots of extra hugs, kisses and attention for telling the truth.

Here is an excerpt from the article online:

"Bronson and Merryman also tackle the subject of why children lie — and what parents can do about it. Lying, Bronson says, is a normal part of development.

"Almost all kids will experiment with lying at least by the age of 4," he explains. "We should expect all children to attempt lying. The question is, 'What do we do with it over time?' "

Bronson advises parents not to threaten lying children with punishment: "It turns out that increasing the threat of punishment only turns kids into better and more frequent liars," he says.

"We're raised on this idea that 'no must mean no' ... but when [children] are older, we need to see that some arguing with parents is actually a good thing — not a bad thing.

Instead, he recommends that parents pause children in the moment before they suspect a lie may be coming and say, "You make me really happy if you tell me the truth."

As for teenagers, Bronson says the best way to discourage lying is to set consistent rules, but to leave the door open to some negotiation.

"We're raised on this idea that 'no must mean no' ... but when [children] are older, we need to see that some arguing with parents is actually a good thing — not a bad thing," he says.

"[Teenagers often feel that] they have two choices: telling you the truth and leading to an argument, or just outright lying. Arguing over the actual rules is a better alternative and a very different thing than arguing over your authority as a parent to set rules," Bronson says."

Posted 11/18/10 4:12 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
JUST my luck! (with a WWYD- Postpartum checkup related) NervousNell 8/3/10 8 Parenting
WWYD- DH and rest of the family really ANNOYED And UPSET, REALLY UPSET.... princess99 1/10/08 19 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD...Not IF related for a change jellybean78 2/2/07 6 Infertility
WWYD? angel7 1/3/07 3 Infertility
WWYD....Long jellybean78 1/1/07 10 Infertility
Furniture: WWYD? lcherian 12/20/06 5 Home