WWYD I'm torn...

Posted By Message

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

WWYD I'm torn...

Depressing topic, but an important one. My DH & I have a will and we chose my brother to be responsible to care for our DC should anything happen to us. I know in my heart he would treat my children as his own. He is a wonderful father and I had no doubt he was the right person - until recently.

Late last year he announced to my family that he converted to a different religion. I'm not very religious, but he converted to a religion that I don't agree with at all and I feel strongly about NOT wanting my DC to be brought up with that religion. When I spoke to him about it, he said "thats what we do, that's where we go. If your children are young, they will go with us. I won't force them to convert or join, but if that's where I'm going - that's where they are going. I won't celebrate your holidays and I will share my beliefs with your DC. I won't lie and tell them what you want me to. "

I understand where he is coming from, but it really really bothers me knowing there's a possiblity (no matter how small) that it could happen.

He IS very religous and it's a BIG part of their lives - which is fine for them, but since it's not a religion I agree with at all, I'm turned off by it for MY DC.

Now I'm really hoping it's a null point - but what if??? Would you pick someone else you are less comfortable with over religious beliefs??? By less comfortable I don't mean there is any concern for my DC well being, but not sure if they would be treated the same as this other couples DC. KWIM???

Message edited 2009-01-24 22:59:10.900000.

Posted 1/24/09 10:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: WWYD I'm torn...

jmho-a good aprent I think I would let the religon thing slide...well of course also depending on the religon.
In the ends kids feel it and stay or find their own religon.
No way to askhim to teach both and give them a choice?

Posted 1/25/09 12:13 AM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: WWYD I'm torn...

I would pick someone else and then revise your will when your child is old enough to make his/her own decisions about religion, and would be able to tell your brother "no, I am not practicing that religion."

Posted 1/25/09 12:18 AM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: WWYD I'm torn...

I would pick someone else. Our pick doesn't thrill me, but it is better than DH's family who are somewhat strict Muslims. I don't want my children raised that way, even if I think my BIL and his wife are good parents.

Posted 1/25/09 4:39 AM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: WWYD I'm torn...

Personally, I would pick somebody else. I want religion to be a part of my DC's lives and I want them raised with the same beliefs that I have. Just as I wouldn't pick somebody who believed differently than I about other aspects of parenting, I woulnd't choose somebody who had religious beliefs that were THAT different than mine. Especially if you say that this new religion is a big part of your brother's life.

Posted 1/25/09 4:49 AM
 

missrock
Beautiful!!!!

Member since 5/06

3808 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: WWYD I'm torn...

Jod

I understand your point, of course. But your Bro will be great parents to Hannah and Jack regardless of their religion.

They will get used to the way your bro does things and after while they will adjust. Its more important to find someone to love and care for your DC unconditionally and to know that nothing bad would happen to them.

I have been thinking about this also. Dont know who I would get custody of them. My BIL is definitely not in the running.

GL in your decision, but Bill would be a good choice.

ETA: You never know if this is gonna be his way for life. My aunt had that religion and after a few years ditched it.

Message edited 2009-01-25 07:41:11.490000.

Posted 1/25/09 7:40 AM
 

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD I'm torn...

Posted by lastchance1222

jmho-a good aprent I think I would let the religon thing slide...well of course also depending on the religon.
In the ends kids feel it and stay or find their own religon.
No way to askhim to teach both and give them a choice?



I agree with you, but its not like we're christian and they are jewish - that wouldn't bother me at all.

Without insulting anyone or getting into a religious debate, IMHO this "religion" is a cult. I'm a pretty laid back person, but I'm having a hard time getting past this. My kids will never celebrate another birthday, Christmas, Easter, Halloween, New Years, etc.... I just feel sad that they would not only lose us, they would have to relocated and they would lose everything they are accustomed to. KWIM?? Also my DH is giving me a hard time about this. We don't have any other sibilings - just my cousins, his cousins and his BFF.

It's so hard because other than that - I find no fault with him. He is loving and truly a good person.

Posted 1/25/09 8:25 AM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD I'm torn...

Wow. What a hard decisionChat Icon

I think that I would probably not change my choice, since it seems there aren't a ton more options and he would be a good father and you are happy with him besides this one choice. If you had a good plan B option, then I would go for that.

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/25/09 8:36 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
. Rycois 12/28/08 30 Home
I Am Soooooo Torn - WWYD DancinBarefoot 11/26/08 21 Parenting
WWYD...IL situation jellybean78 2/2/07 6 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD? angel7 1/3/07 3 Infertility
WWYD....Long jellybean78 1/1/07 10 Infertility