WWYD-cake question

Posted By Message

orchid24
PARTY OF FIVE PLEASE!

Member since 3/06

2018 total posts

Name:
D

WWYD-cake question

my DS #2's christening is coming up and i would love to have a nice cake, but can't afford to have "two nice cakes" one for the christening and one for his 1st b-day. so i've decided to have a simple sheet cake from whole foods for one (cheaper) and a nicer, more $$$, more theme-y cake for the other. can't decide if the nicer cake should be for the christening (more people coming) or for his 1st b-day in march (don't know the theme yet.)

thought? thanks!

Posted 8/28/11 2:56 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Hopeless Romantic
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/11

403 total posts

Name:
GoodGirl13

Re: WWYD-cake question

I would always go for the nice bday cake. To me, the cake is a staple of the birthday experience- no matter how old the bday boy/girl is or how many people will be eating/seeing it.

I spent $200 on 2 cakes (one chocolate, one yellow)for my dd's 2nd bday and there were only 5 adults and 4 kids including my dd. Needless to say, there were tons of leftovers!

I spent $100 on 50 cupcakes for her christening (big regret-I coulee made them myself- nothing special!) and there were at least 40 people at that party.

Posted 8/28/11 3:12 PM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: WWYD-cake question

i'd go with the nicer cake for the bigger/ more special event.

Posted 8/28/11 3:44 PM
 

TheNextStep
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/08

773 total posts

Name:
S

Re: WWYD-cake question

I would get the white sheet cake with a cross/congrats for the christening and a theme cake for his birthday.

Posted 8/28/11 4:07 PM
 

CloudNine
My Baby Boy is Here!

Member since 2/09

2831 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: WWYD-cake question

i would do the nice one for the birthday

Posted 8/28/11 6:05 PM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: WWYD-cake question

I agree, I'd do the "nicer", more "theme-y" cake for the birthday. I think a sheet cake is fine for a Christening. I think it is fine for a birthday too if that is what you can afford. But at a Christening, the whole party won't be gathered around the cake singing. At the birthday party, the cake is more the center of the party than it is for the Christening.

Posted 8/29/11 2:08 AM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD-cake question

Posted by pharmcat2000

I agree, I'd do the "nicer", more "theme-y" cake for the birthday. I think a sheet cake is fine for a Christening. I think it is fine for a birthday too if that is what you can afford. But at a Christening, the whole party won't be gathered around the cake singing. At the birthday party, the cake is more the center of the party than it is for the Christening.



ITA! The Christening focus is on the event represented at the church and the birthday focus is on the child turning 1 which is really only represented by the cake, KWIM? Maybe I'm not wording it right.

Posted 8/29/11 11:21 AM