Would You Be Upset About This? UPDATED

Posted By Message

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Would You Be Upset About This? UPDATED

I posted about my husband's pneumonia and Noah's anxiety over it.

Yesterday I sent Noah to school with a note for the teacher. I had a few items I wanted to make her aware of including that Noah might need some extra care because he'd slept poorly and was overwrought because his father was sick. I also had an action item for her in that Noah apparently borrowed lunch money and needed to pay it back so he would need her guidance as to who he should give the money too.

I got home yesterday and noticed that my note and his money to pay the cafeteria back - was still in his backpack. There was no response from the teacher. I asked him if he had given the items to the teacher and he burst into tears and said that he tried to give it to her but that she yelled at him and told him she wasn't going to take it and that he was supposed to put it in her mailbox.

It's my fault that he insisted on handing it to her because I impressed upon him that he was to make 100% certain that his teacher got the note. I felt really awful that his already rotten day was made worse by being chastised. So I wrote a new note for today and asked him to put it in her mailbox. I explained why he was so insistant on her reading the note and asked for her assistance and response with regard to the other items.

My husband - is more angry. He wanted me to take the teacher to task for snapping at Noah (I am sure she didn't 'YELL'). He thinks that refusing to read the note shows a lot of disrespect. He feels like her reaction just caused more stress for our already stressed out child. He thinks she is completely out of line for refusing to read the note that we took the time to craft. I thnk he probably didn't put it in her mailbox as asked and she forgot about it. Rob thinks it would be difficult to forget the note since Noah had been so insistant about it. But hey ... she's got 25 kindergarten kids all day!

I guess I just feel like she is a human being and she had another 5 year old not following the clearly established rule of the classroom and told him that he needed to follow the protocol.

So.. do you think I should have been more annoyed by this incident?

UPDATE:

I spoke with his teacher - and I was right! She did not yell at Noah - she asked him to put his paperwork in her mailbox so it would not get lost. He put it in his backpack instead and she just lost track. Like I said - 25 little kids running around unpacking their bags and settling in! She's a very nice lady and I don't think she meant any harm at all. Noah's been extra sensitive lately. I'm glad I didn't waste my energy getting angry at nothing!

Thank you all for your input!Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-11-13 11:35:07.430000.

Posted 11/13/08 9:20 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

2BEANS
wow time is going fast.

Member since 9/07

16106 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Would You Be Upset About This?

Does the teacher know in any other way what Noah is going through right now? or was the note the first time she would have heard of it? If she had some awarness then I would be upset, if no then I wouldnt be upset, b/c she may have thought the note was just something that might not have need to be addressed right then. I hope she didnt yell at him b/c thats just uncalled for.

Posted 11/13/08 9:26 AM
 

Lucky
Growing up fast!

Member since 4/07

12683 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: Would You Be Upset About This?

I would cut her a little slack, although I think she should at some point throughout the day have gotten the note from him. As you said though, she is only human. It would be hard to tell the way in which she responded to your son; what some people see as yelling, others do not. I do understand that it would upset both you and your husband, even if it was Noah's perspective that she was harsh.

Sticky situation but I think give her another chance. You addressed it today so see what comes of it.

Posted 11/13/08 9:28 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Would You Be Upset About This?

Yes, I would be annoyed. What if that note had some serious info in it that needed to be addressed immediately?

Posted 11/13/08 9:42 AM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Would You Be Upset About This?

Just based on your son's side, I'd be upset that she didn't get across to him that if he put the note in her mailbox she'd read it. I can't imagine this is the first time she's had a little kid who is trying to follow his mom's directions and hand deliver a note to her. I'd expect that she would have a calm way to express to the child that sometimes our moms don't know the class rules, blah, blah.

I'm sorry your son was upset. I hate when my kids are sad when I pick them up. Chat Icon

Posted 11/13/08 9:55 AM
 

Summersalwaysinseason
I'm finally able to write here

Member since 1/06

2044 total posts

Name:

Re: Would You Be Upset About This?

Posted by 1stimemom

Yes, I would be annoyed. What if that note had some serious info in it that needed to be addressed immediately?



I agree...

Yes, teachers are human...occasionally it's tough to leave your mood at the door and if children break the rules it can get annoying..

With that said, it is her job to TEACH the rules...even if you "snap" a little, you need to bring yourself back to Earth and explain the rules once again to the children...that is why they are the TEACHER.

From what I gathered from your post, your son is 5...and being a good boy by following his mommy's instructions. Even if she snapped, she should have read that letter. Period.

BTW, I am a school librarian, so I've been there with students not following the rules. If I don't explain them to students over and over again, I'm simply not doing my job. And it's not like he stood on a table and shouted on the top of his lungs...

Posted 11/13/08 10:10 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Would You Be Upset About This?

I know that a lot of teachers are trying to impress responsibility onto kids at an early age. My kindergartner would have reacted the same way.

She had a crying fit because I said "Make sure you don't come home without your lunchbox." and she forgot her lunchbox - so her translation was that she couldn't come home.Chat Icon Also the story I get is their interpretation of how things happened.

Posted by 1stimemom

Yes, I would be annoyed. What if that note had some serious info in it that needed to be addressed immediately?



I thought the same thing. It's not disrespectful that she didn't read the note. It's irresponsible. However she may have interpreted a note as being not as important & figured if it was you'd call.

I try to avoid calling the teacher because I know they have 17 other kids in the class whose parents think nothing of calling. In this case, I would say learn from your (and her) mistake. Call the school & request that she call you back during a break. Use that with anything important that you need to get across. If he's still having a hard time with it ask to speak to a school counselor so they are aware of it.
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

eta. also ask for an email as I find that the best way so there is no room for miscommunication.

Message edited 2008-11-13 10:15:41.887000.

Posted 11/13/08 10:13 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Would You Be Upset About This? UPDATED

Glad your confidence in the teacher has been restored. Hope you DH is on the mend and gets better soon, and that your little one feels less stressed too!

Posted 11/13/08 10:14 AM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Would You Be Upset About This? UPDATED

Wow. You are really good. I would have been totally inapporpriate, as usual, and probably attacked her right off the bat. Then felt so badly when I found out the real sequense of events. Chat Icon

I'm sorry to hear about your DH. Hope he gets better soon! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/13/08 10:54 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I am so upset and nervous- sorry if TMI. UPDATE...... need some hugs........... princess99 8/11/06 4 Families Helping Families ™
Nervous and upset... NYC school related , DH is a teacher.... princess99 6/9/06 22 Families Helping Families ™
UPDATED!! I dont know where else to post this ......(if you get upset easily dont read this) MamaNDaddyof3 4/5/06 28 Pregnancy
What would u do? UPSET! DOCTORS OFFICE RELATED! princess99 3/20/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
how many of you would be upset or not? go to page 2 and read letter what do you think MommyofG 2/9/06 38 Families Helping Families ™
Really Upset and DH is just annoyed with me.. (long) randella 12/6/05 9 Home