Wishing well

Forum Opinion Poll
Traditional wishing well 13 29.55%
Book wishing well 31 70.45%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Wishing well

Posted By Message

HighHopes
U are my best Christmas gift!

Member since 3/09

1267 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Wishing well

So I orginally wanted to do a book wishing well where folks bring a book instead of a card, but now I am having second thoughts.

Do you think folks would prefer the traditional wishing well or book wishing well? I added a poll to make it easier.

TIA!

Posted 2/18/10 12:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bigspender
Back to school

Member since 4/07

1385 total posts

Name:
Irene

Re: Wishing well

I kind of like the book wishing well idea.

Posted 2/18/10 12:52 PM
 

mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!

Member since 3/09

8585 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Wishing well

I think both idea's are nice. It really depends on what you want. Do you want books or would your rather the odd and ends you get in a traditional wishing well.

Posted 2/18/10 12:54 PM
 

JennCo
My greatest joy is my baby boy

Member since 1/07

2772 total posts

Name:

Re: Wishing well

i think both are nice as well. I'm going to have a traditional wishing well but that is only b/c my SIL gave us a TON of books from when my nephews were little. You can't go wrong with either, IMO

Posted 2/18/10 1:25 PM
 

babybear
LIF Toddler

Member since 8/09

474 total posts

Name:
Meghan

Re: Wishing well

i requested the book wishing well..i feel with regular wishing well, its always like small silly things..at least thats what i got for bridal wishing well! But its a matter of preference...

Posted 2/18/10 1:34 PM
 

julz33
i run for bacon

Member since 5/05

20584 total posts

Name:
julz

Re: Wishing well

We did books for mine... my son is 20 months now and I still haven't had to buy him a book. We read the books from the shower all of the time!

Posted 2/18/10 1:48 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Wishing well

I did a book wishing well for my sister's shower last summer Chat Icon it was fun!

Posted 2/18/10 1:49 PM
 

Sunday
In love with a boy named Luca

Member since 6/09

1799 total posts

Name:
`

Re: Wishing well

My book wishing well did not go over well. Only like 12 people did it- out of 75 guests- and to be honest (I know this is gonna sound bratty but I'm just tellin' it how it is) the books were the worst like random unknown dollar store books. So, no I would not recommend it, lol.

Posted 2/18/10 2:20 PM
 

NotOnLI
LIF Infant

Member since 2/09

344 total posts

Name:

Re: Wishing well

My one request for my shower was for books instead of cards--and honestly, you can go to TJ MAxx or Marshalls and get a book for $3.99, which is the price of a card these days!

My girlfriend just did it for her shower and I thought it was really cute.

Posted 2/18/10 2:23 PM
 

chickiemom
LOVE my boys!!

Member since 10/09

1473 total posts

Name:
Leanne

Re: Wishing well

I absolutely love the book wishing well idea.. I just mentioned that to my mom the other day..

Posted 2/18/10 2:25 PM
 

BellaRock
I am all the Me I will ever Be

Member since 5/06

9746 total posts

Name:
She who shall remain nameless

Re: Wishing well

We are going with a traditional wishing well because DS has tons of books that I can pass down to the new baby.

Posted 2/18/10 2:29 PM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: Wishing well

Kath - the book wishing well is a great idea!!!!!! Go for it!!

Posted 2/18/10 2:39 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Wishing well

I think you can do a traditional wishing well and still manage to ask everyone to bring a book. That's what I had - I added a poem to the invitation asking people to bring a book, but not in lieu of a wishing well.

I really LIKE sifting through all the crap you get in a baby wishing well. It's a great way to try new products without shelling out the $$$ for them yourself. I think DD was 8 months old the first time I *had* to buy soap for her. I have a friend whose DD is 2 and she hasn't had to buy lotion YET, but she had a lot of people at her shower.

Posted 2/18/10 2:59 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Wishing well

I love the idea of giving books!!!

I gave my cousin a huge basket of books at her shower. Im a teacher (first grade) so I figured I knew what books were cute and just had to get them for her baby!

I dont know if i would do it as a wishing well, but at work we do that book poem and instead of a card people buy te baby a book

Posted 2/18/10 3:01 PM
 

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

Re: Wishing well

We did books...Got a book shelf as a gift and when everyone came they put a book on the shelf...

Posted 2/18/10 4:49 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
X-Post from NWR: Wishing Well/Shower Question... Thoughts? randella 6/2/07 2 Pregnancy
Wishing you and your class good luck this week on the ELA!! ggt08 1/7/07 3 Teachers
When do you stop wishing a "Happy New Year"? Smileyd17 1/2/07 7 Families Helping Families ™
Is or did everyone have a wishing well at their baby shower? MommyofG 9/12/06 21 Pregnancy
Need ideas for a bridal shower, other then a "wishing well, honeymoon basket" What other things have you done or seen? BigB 6/2/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
Well, back to the grind! Wishing everyone a really good day! MissJones 9/6/05 9 Families Helping Families ™