Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Posted By Message

LuvMyBoys
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

927 total posts

Name:
MOMMY

Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Okay I order my christmas photo card from both Winkflash and Shutterfly so that I would know for future references the quality of both.

I had ordered form Shtterfly in the past but had only used their designs so I was nervous about ordering using my own.

Well they both delivered very quickly I ordered on Tuesday morning and received my cards on Friday evening.

But the quality was so different, Shutterfly was great, the coloring, no cut offs, I was very happy.

Winkflash the colors were not the same as what Ihad uploaded everythign was a darker shade. For example, instead of a nice red background I had more of a burgendy background. I am not happy with the finished product and will not be orderign from their inthe future.

The one drawback from SHtterfly was that they do not include the envelopes because in essence you are odering ohoto prints not photocards, KWIM.

Also the price for winkflash was much cheaper thatn shutterfly, but to me the quality was so bad that i would not send those out.

Anyway I figure I would post this for those who were still trying to decide whre to order their christmas cards from. HTH



Posted 12/10/07 11:57 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Thanks for posting this. So far I have not heard back from Winkflash about the cards I sent back (I sent just a few to make my point) so I am glad that I mailed them out anyway (although I am unhappy about the color issue).

I think in the future I need to try another place or shutterfly. I am close to Paper Access in the city so I can get the envelopes on my own. Even though it's more expensive that way if it comes out perfect I would be willing to do it.

Thanks again for posting your experience!

Posted 12/10/07 12:02 PM
 

pugmama
April already?

Member since 3/06

5297 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

I ordered from winkflash a lot without any problems, but this year I was not happy with the coloring either. I wonder what the problem is - they got too big too fast or something?

Posted 12/10/07 12:36 PM
 

ABCiverson
<3 my family

Member since 1/06

7465 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

I ordered from winkflash and mine came out perfect! My red back ground looks the same as it did on the computer.

Posted 12/10/07 1:09 PM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

I ordered from Shutterfly and mine came with envelopes.

Posted 12/10/07 1:10 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

I finished putting together 2 calendars from shutterfly.
I hope I get them ordered tonight.
I have ordered from shutterfly before (a a desk organizer with DSs pic) and it came out awesome.

Posted 12/10/07 1:10 PM
 

SweetCin
My green-eyed boy

Member since 5/05

13499 total posts

Name:
Cin

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

I've always ordered from Shutterfly until this year & have been happy & usually always got envelopes.

This year I tried Winkflash & the first order was perfect & came w/ envelopes.

Then I realized I didn't order enough & placed a 2nd order...the 2nd order did not come w/ envelopes Chat Icon The color, however, was fine.

Posted 12/10/07 1:30 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Sunrise
Did you upload a 5x7 onto Shutterfly? If so how? I can only see where you can use their 4x8 or 5x7 premade designs. This is the only reason I am going with Winkflash. Chat Icon

Posted 12/10/07 1:53 PM
 

HillandRon
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2922 total posts

Name:
Hillary

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

My order from winkflash was great and the coloring was perfect...

Posted 12/10/07 1:55 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

I almost always use Shutterfly and have been super happy. Mpix is another great site for good quality. I got nervous with Winkflash this year after everyone had complaints, so I ordered from Snapfish (photocards) and Shutterfly (photo gifts and cards).

Posted 12/10/07 2:06 PM
 

LuvMyBoys
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

927 total posts

Name:
MOMMY

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Posted by monkeybride

Sunrise
Did you upload a 5x7 onto Shutterfly? If so how? I can only see where you can use their 4x8 or 5x7 premade designs. This is the only reason I am going with Winkflash. Chat Icon


Yeah I order print and then uploaed my photshop ddesign(which I saved as a Jpeg file) then I chose the 5X7 size

use this link

Shutterfly

FYI- my order did not come with envelopes.

Posted 12/10/07 2:11 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Posted by Sunrise813

Posted by monkeybride

Sunrise
Did you upload a 5x7 onto Shutterfly? If so how? I can only see where you can use their 4x8 or 5x7 premade designs. This is the only reason I am going with Winkflash. Chat Icon


Yeah I order print and then uploaed my photshop ddesign(which I saved as a Jpeg file) then I chose the 5X7 size

use this link

Shutterfly

FYI- my order did not come with envelopes.



Ah OK.
Where are you getting 5x7 envelopes? If I can get them easily I may cancel my winkfllash order.

Posted 12/10/07 2:14 PM
 

LuvMyBoys
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

927 total posts

Name:
MOMMY

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Posted by monkeybride

Posted by Sunrise813

Posted by monkeybride

Sunrise
Did you upload a 5x7 onto Shutterfly? If so how? I can only see where you can use their 4x8 or 5x7 premade designs. This is the only reason I am going with Winkflash. Chat Icon


Yeah I order print and then uploaed my photshop ddesign(which I saved as a Jpeg file) then I chose the 5X7 size

use this link

Shutterfly

FYI- my order did not come with envelopes.



Ah OK.
Where are you getting 5x7 envelopes? If I can get them easily I may cancel my winkfllash order.



I did not get envelpoes with my shutterfly order, but my winkflash order included them so I am using the envelopes from my winkflash order. But chelle just posted that she got envelopes with her order, so maybe she can tellyou how.

Posted 12/10/07 2:17 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

I agree with you about Winkflash. I am somewhat happy with my cards since I loved the design and my photo that I used, but the photo came out darker than what I uploaded and didn't pop like it did on the computer. The card was black with red accents so I wanted the pic a little brighter.
The quality was horrible- they were very flimsy- I compared them to other photo cards on my fridge and they were much cheaper.

However, for the price, I do see the difference. If I ordered the same amount of cards on Shutterfly, it would be double. For that reason, I would use them again but I would order one first and see what adjustments I would need to make.

Posted 12/10/07 2:24 PM
 

LuvMyBoys
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

927 total posts

Name:
MOMMY

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Posted by CkGm

I agree with you about Winkflash. I am somewhat happy with my cards since I loved the design and my photo that I used, but the photo came out darker than what I uploaded and didn't pop like it did on the computer. The card was black with red accents so I wanted the pic a little brighter.
The quality was horrible- they were very flimsy- I compared them to other photo cards on my fridge and they were much cheaper.

However, for the price, I do see the difference. If I ordered the same amount of cards on Shutterfly, it would be double. For that reason, I would use them again but I would order one first and see what adjustments I would need to make.



This is exactly what i thougth about my card, it did not pop like it did on the computer, the red on the computer really stands out but not on the card.

But on my shutterfly one it did pop it looked just like the computer.

I aslo agree the price difference is pretty big, I think Winkflash was about a third of the price of Shutterfly because I had a winkflash coupon code.

Message edited 2007-12-10 14:28:58.247000.

Posted 12/10/07 2:27 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Winkflash vs Shutterfly- my opinion

Posted by HillandRon

My order from winkflash was great and the coloring was perfect...




same here

Posted 12/10/07 3:20 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
SnapFish,Shutterfly,Winkflash dm24angel 10/8/07 23 Families Helping Families ™
Photobooks--from shutterfly or winkflash?? leap29 6/24/06 11 Families Helping Families ™
I knew I shouldn't have used Winkflash monkeybride 12/10/07 5 Parenting
What is your opinion? dandr10199 3/16/06 14 Parenting
which picture is the cutest in your opinion? MrsR 3/9/06 56 Parenting
Opinion needed RE: Fences - Rose vs. Consumer PiyoPika566 2/24/06 2 Home