Why 'Caylee's Law' Is A Bad Idea

Posted By Message

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Why 'Caylee's Law' Is A Bad Idea

Just read this on HuffPost.

Here's an excerpt that basically explains the author's point:

Laws named after crime victims and dead people are usually a bad idea. They play more to emotion than reason. But they're disturbingly predictable, especially when they come after the death of a child. So it's really no surprise that activist Michelle Crowder is now pushing "Caylee's Law," a proposed federal bill that would charge parents with a felony if they fail to report a missing child within 24 hours, or if they fail to report the death of a child within an hour. What's surprising is just how quickly the Change.org petition for Caylee's Law has gone viral. As of this writing it has more than 700,000 signatures, and is now the most successful campaign in the site's history. For reasons of constitutionality and practicality, it seems unlikely that Caylee's Law will ever be realized at the federal level. But according to the AP, at least sixteen state legislatures are now considering some version of the law. That's troubling.

This is a bad way to make public policy. In an interview with CNN, Crowder concedes that she didn't consult with a single law enforcement official before coming up with her 24-hour and 1-hour limits. This raises some questions. How did she come up with those cutoffs? Did she consult with any grief counselors to see if there may be innocuous reasons why an innocent person who just witnessed a child's death might not immediately report it, such as shock, passing out, or some other sort of mental breakdown? Did she consult with a forensic pathologist to see if it's even possible to pin down the time of death with the sort of precision you'd need to make Caylee's Law enforceable? Have any of the lawmakers who have proposed or are planning to propose this law actually consulted with anyone with some knowledge of these issues?

Here's the full article.

Posted 7/12/11 3:52 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Why 'Caylee's Law' Is A Bad Idea

I think that's a really interesting perspective. I don't necessarily "agree" or "disagree" with the point of the article though. I think that it's important for people to have a voice, and I signed the petition for Caylee's Law.

I agree that careful considerations have to be made in the wording. For example, instead of reporting the death of a child one hour after it happens, it would really need to state one hour after the child is found dead or something to that effect.

However, I think the article is taking it to an extreme. I would imagine - and hope - that legislators would take these wording issues into consideration before making a law. What I'd like to know is if there is any precedent. Have any petitions been formed, in this manner, where the legislators did not consider the wording and ensnared innocent people?

Posted 7/12/11 4:15 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Why 'Caylee's Law' Is A Bad Idea

Posted by JAAMS

I think that's a really interesting perspective. I don't necessarily "agree" or "disagree" with the point of the article though. I think that it's important for people to have a voice, and I signed the petition for Caylee's Law.

I agree that careful considerations have to be made in the wording. For example, instead of reporting the death of a child one hour after it happens, it would really need to state one hour after the child is found dead or something to that effect.

However, I think the article is taking it to an extreme. I would imagine - and hope - that legislators would take these wording issues into consideration before making a law. What I'd like to know is if there is any precedent. Have any petitions been formed, in this manner, where the legislators did not consider the wording and ensnared innocent people?



You said it better than I could think of it in my head.

Basically, if the people don't saying anything, things won't change. This petition is one way of getting the government to do something.

And like this poster said, I'm sure that the government would change wording around, after speaking to all of these specialists that the article refers to.

Posted 7/12/11 4:19 PM
 

CouponKT
Our family is complete

Member since 6/06

16494 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Why 'Caylee's Law' Is A Bad Idea

Sadly, there are so many loopholes to get around. Think about it, MURDER is against the law too, but somehow Casey "got away" with it. No matter what you get charged with when arrested, you still go to trial. So, in my opinion, these secondary laws to try to prevent the same thing may not help in the future either Chat Icon

Posted 7/12/11 5:07 PM
 

emilylives
biking

Member since 12/09

2163 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: Why 'Caylee's Law' Is A Bad Idea

Posted by JAAMS

I think that's a really interesting perspective. I don't necessarily "agree" or "disagree" with the point of the article though. I think that it's important for people to have a voice, and I signed the petition for Caylee's Law.

I agree that careful considerations have to be made in the wording. For example, instead of reporting the death of a child one hour after it happens, it would really need to state one hour after the child is found dead or something to that effect.

However, I think the article is taking it to an extreme. I would imagine - and hope - that legislators would take these wording issues into consideration before making a law. What I'd like to know is if there is any precedent. Have any petitions been formed, in this manner, where the legislators did not consider the wording and ensnared innocent people?



I understand your point, and I totally see why people are pushing for the law. I'm just not sure if it's actually feasible. As the author asks, can you really believe what a parent tells you about when he/she found the body if he/she knows a felony charge hinges on his answer?

Posted 7/12/11 5:10 PM
 

memi7206
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2355 total posts

Name:
Due Dec 29th!!!!!

Re: Why 'Caylee's Law' Is A Bad Idea

I thought the exact same thing, and its why I havent signed the petition. I didnt think it was well thought out at all. I thought it came from a good place with good intentions, but it left to many variables in place and was far too vague.

Posted 7/12/11 6:36 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Why 'Caylee's Law' Is A Bad Idea

I think that the article makes a number of good points. We have give lots of thought to any legislation and not just react to emotion.

Posted 7/12/11 9:43 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is this a bad idea? Charly 1/7/07 16 Parenting
bad idea?? ~Melissa~ 10/9/06 7 Home
Is this a bad idea? BaroqueMama 10/2/06 2 Parenting
Is this a bad idea? TiggerBounce 9/23/06 6 Pregnancy
Bad Idea.. yankinmanc 8/20/06 2 Parenting
well...that was a bad idea... CowgirlChick97 3/17/06 26 Families Helping Families ™