who is responsible??

Posted By Message

SJSM
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/09

764 total posts

Name:

who is responsible??

My ds bought himself and professional pool table. 9 feet- was$$ and it took over 8 hours for the guys to assemble and level it
Well, The idiot contractor moved-( pushed it down to the end of the room) to store materials ( doors, sheetrock, etc) the materials could have been stored somewhere else. My husband was so upset.

now the table has to be professionally leveled and it cost a couple of hundred dollars.
my ds says the contractor should pay for this
do you think my ds is right?

Posted 9/2/13 11:37 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: who is responsible??

Absolutely the contractor should pay for it.

Posted 9/2/13 11:38 PM
 

lazybug
LIF Adult

Member since 3/12

1013 total posts

Name:

who is responsible??

I agree with him. They should have to pay or knock off a certain amount from what you are paying them. They should have consulted with you before moving anything.

Posted 9/2/13 11:39 PM
 

ANR1211
My loves

Member since 2/11

2131 total posts

Name:
A

who is responsible??

If they damage it, they pay for it. I don't see why this would be any different than if he would have broken a window or something. He should definitely pay for it.

Posted 9/3/13 7:26 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

who is responsible??

Just putting myself in contractors shoes here.

I would assume that if I was a contractor and you hired me to do a lot of work in an area where such an item is, or any item of furniture for that matter, I would assume you would know I would have to move it to do work or room for work supplies. Like if I hired a painter.. If I didnt move the entertainment center, he would have to and I would expect it. Kwim?

It doesn't sound like he broke or damaged it... And it sounds like he didnt know it would have to be leveled (nor would I , for that matter) Yes pool tables need to be level obviously , but I don't know the exact measures or what have you.

In this instance, I feel you could have better prepared for this or had said something about it prior to the work or even moved it yourself (not sure if you did any of that - just goin by you original post).

So based on that.. No. I don't think he should have to pay. I'm not being snarky or anything. Just Tryin to see his side.

It's like if I had a fancy piano or something - unless you made it clear not to move it due to xyz, how would he have known? Sometimes you have to move things yourself if you need them down a certain way due to a products specifications. Not everyone would think of those things.

Message edited 2013-09-03 19:42:37.710000.

Posted 9/3/13 7:40 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: who is responsible??

Posted by MsSissy

Absolutely the contractor should pay for it.



ITA.

It is no different than moving a piano -- pianos need to be tuned and kept in a certain spot/way... if they are moved, it can screw up the tuning and everything else. You would need a professional to come in and fix it, tune it, and place it properly. So, absolutely.

Posted 9/3/13 8:24 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: who is responsible??

Posted by DaniRella

Posted by MsSissy

Absolutely the contractor should pay for it.



ITA.

It is no different than moving a piano -- pianos need to be tuned and kept in a certain spot/way... if they are moved, it can screw up the tuning and everything else. You would need a professional to come in and fix it, tune it, and place it properly. So, absolutely.



I guess I just think if you have something THAT special or $$$$, or specialized for that matter, you need to handle it yourself. Either move it before the work starts yourself or notify the contractor ASAP not to touch such an item, put materials elsewhere, etc..KWIM?

which maybe the OP did & he didn't listen and moved it anyway, but I'm just going by the post. And it didn't sound damaged per se..just needs a re-leveling or whatever.

Posted 9/3/13 8:28 PM
 

RubyWoo
Complete.

Member since 1/11

1357 total posts

Name:

Re: who is responsible??

The contractor is absolutely responsible and should pay to have the table fixed. In fact, I would be quite annoyed if a contractor touched or moved ANYTHING in my home without asking first.

I hope he does the right thing.

Posted 9/3/13 8:38 PM
 

SJSM
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/09

764 total posts

Name:

Re: who is responsible??




I guess I just think if you have something THAT special or $$$$, or specialized for that matter, you need to handle it yourself. Either move it before the work starts yourself or notify the contractor ASAP not to touch such an item, put materials elsewhere, etc..KWIM?

which maybe the OP did & he didn't listen and moved it anyway, but I'm just going by the post. And it didn't sound damaged per se..just needs a re-leveling or whatever.
___________________________________
the contractor had NO reason to use the living room as storage- no work was being done in that room- he had plenty of space in the foyer

he was being lazy and did not want to walk up and down all the stairs ( my living room is on its own floor.) As a matter of fact dh covered the table and put up plastic to block the doorway.

thanks for all the responses
dh is handing him the quote and deducting it from the money owed

Posted 9/3/13 10:01 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

who is responsible??

ahhhhhhhh I see. I thought the materials were kept in the same room as the work.

Posted 9/3/13 10:11 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Are we responsible for payment to the ambulance we called or do our taxes pay for it ??? babybugsmum 3/8/09 10 Parenting
Old claims is there a length of time that your no longer responsible for? 2BEANS 3/5/09 12 Families Helping Families ™
Are Politicians Responsible for Addressing Ugly Comments Made by Supporters? cjik 10/13/08 5 Families Helping Families ™
Now that is passed, who was responsible for the pork? Ophelia 10/3/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
do you think Jamie Lynn'' mom books should be cancelled? is she responsible for what happened? 04bride 12/20/07 19 Celebrities & Entertainment
Ebay ? - If something arrives damaged who's responsible? LIMOMx2 4/6/07 5 Families Helping Families ™