Who would you pick?

Forum Opinion Poll
Frankie 0 0.00%
Michael 38 100.00%
Other....explain please 0 0.00%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Which would you pick?

Posted By Message

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Which would you pick?

Dh has 3 younger brothers 23, 17, 13.

I have one brother 20.

Jiavana's godparents are my brother and DH's aunt.

We are deciding on Aiden's godparents. We picked my aunt, and we need to pick one of his brothers. The younger one isn't old enough so its between the two. Which would you pick.

Frankie - 23 (almost 24) works full time, *smokes weed/drinks/parties....
*very lazy
*came to Jiavana's baptism w/o a card/gift.
*Came to the hospital when Aiden was born w/o card/gift. Didn't even "pay" attention to him. Basically came to the room and sat there.
*DH's best man in our wedding

Michael - 17
*Will be a senior in HS
*Comes over all the time
*"Plays" with both children

I mean looking at the list Michael looks the best, but DH and I feel that it should be frankie since he was the best man and the oldest brother. We are 99.99999% we aren't having anymore kids.

Posted 7/10/07 3:50 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Which would you pick?

michael definitely

Posted 7/10/07 4:00 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

Posted by stephanief

michael definitely



ITA

Posted 7/10/07 4:01 PM
 

JessieQ
Rest in Peace baby Rogan

Member since 6/07

1122 total posts

Name:
Jessica

Re: Which would you pick?

I wouldn't use the fact that he was best man to choose the godfather, those are two different choices and you really use different reasoning to decide those roles- I think if Michael spends more time with the kids he sounds like a perfect choice.

Actually, it's probably better anyway that he has honored two different brothers with two important roles in his life, instead of honoring the older brother twice.

Posted 7/10/07 4:02 PM
 

-Laurie-
Hi!

Member since 5/05

2536 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

Dh's brother was bent out of shape he was his best man when he wasen't picked for our son.
Instead we went the route of my only brother and my SIL (dh's only sister, he was three brothers)

I think for this child we might go with his youngest who is now older but was way too young at our wedding 5 years ago for a big roll. So I'd say the younger brother

Posted 7/10/07 4:05 PM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Which would you pick?

Posted by JessieQ

I wouldn't use the fact that he was best man to choose the godfather, those are two different choices and you really use different reasoning to decide those roles- I think if Michael spends more time with the kids he sounds like a perfect choice.

Actually, it's probably better anyway that he has honored two different brothers with two important roles in his life, instead of honoring the older brother twice.




he was just always closer to frankie. i think he is a loser and can't stand him. he lived with us for a few mths and did not respect my no smoking in the house wishes

Posted 7/10/07 4:06 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

Without question Michael.

I would want a godparent that would be involved with the kids for a lifetime. Michael is already stepping up to the plate.

Frankie sounds like he's shown no interest.

Posted 7/10/07 4:07 PM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

From an outsider's perspective...
Frankie is a grown man acting like a child. This doesn't seem like a person worthy of such a high honor of being named godfather. Isn't the real "point" of being a godparent to teach the baby/child to follow in the faith, or at the very least, to be a good example and role model--religious or otherwise?

Frankie was already honored by being the best man and being the oldest has nothing to do with anything really. It would be nice for Michael to have a special honor and it seems he deserves it!

Good luck with your choice...
Chat Icon

Posted 7/10/07 4:13 PM
 

snuggleupagus
I'm a rolling machine.

Member since 9/06

2064 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

I voted Michael. No brainer.

Posted 7/10/07 4:15 PM
 

snuggleupagus
I'm a rolling machine.

Member since 9/06

2064 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

Posted by JessieQ

I wouldn't use the fact that he was best man to choose the godfather, those are two different choices and you really use different reasoning to decide those roles- I think if Michael spends more time with the kids he sounds like a perfect choice.

Actually, it's probably better anyway that he has honored two different brothers with two important roles in his life, instead of honoring the older brother twice.



I agree with a lot of this...to add: DH was the best man in a wedding 2 years ago, to be honest, aside from our wedding a year ago, we haven't seen the couple (solo or together) ONCE since their wedding. In the 3 years I've lived on LI, we've seen the guy ONCE and the couple not at all. If somehow they chose DH to be the godfather of any possible children I'd be SHOCKED considering we and they are obviously not vital parts of each other's lives.

Posted 7/10/07 4:18 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

Posted by JessieQ

I wouldn't use the fact that he was best man to choose the godfather, those are two different choices and you really use different reasoning to decide those roles- I think if Michael spends more time with the kids he sounds like a perfect choice.

Actually, it's probably better anyway that he has honored two different brothers with two important roles in his life, instead of honoring the older brother twice.



ITAChat Icon

Posted 7/10/07 4:22 PM
 

Michelle
My Little Yankee Fans

Member since 1/06

4018 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

Michael, mention that you picked him because he wasn't the Best Man, you can play it off as that so noone would be mad.

Posted 7/10/07 4:22 PM
 

ziamaria
I love this boy!

Member since 4/07

3372 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

Posted by Michelle

Michael, mention that you picked him because he wasn't the Best Man, you can play it off as that so noone would be mad.



I agree...he is the better man IMO

Posted 7/10/07 4:27 PM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Which would you pick?

i definitely think michael. Dh feels bad not picking frankie. I hope I can get him to come to his senses!!

Thanks everyone!!

Posted 7/10/07 4:32 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

Posted by Michelle

Michael, mention that you picked him because he wasn't the Best Man, you can play it off as that so noone would be mad.



No

Tell Michael you picked him because of his dedication & warmth toward your children & how much you value him

Tell Frankie he was the best man the wedding so Michael is the godfather.Chat Icon

Posted 7/10/07 4:32 PM
 

2003fallwedding
SISTERS!!!

Member since 5/05

4317 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: Which would you pick?

Frankie was your best man, give his other brother the honor of being a godfather...not to mention Michael takes more of an interest in your kids...besides, you don't have to give them a reason why you picked 1 over the other.

Posted 7/10/07 6:01 PM
 

Moehick
Ready for the sun!

Member since 5/05

30339 total posts

Name:
Properly perfect™

Re: Which would you pick?

Micheal no doubt....it would mean more to him then to Frankie

Posted 7/10/07 6:02 PM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Which would you pick?

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by Michelle

Michael, mention that you picked him because he wasn't the Best Man, you can play it off as that so noone would be mad.



No

Tell Michael you picked him because of his dedication & warmth toward your children & how much you value him

Tell Frankie he was the best man the wedding so Michael is the godfather.Chat Icon



PErfect ! I totally agree. Michael for sure.Follow your heart, not "what everyone is going to think is right".

Chat Icon

Posted 7/10/07 6:03 PM
 

pinky
Twin Moms Do Everything Twice

Member since 5/05

9612 total posts

Name:

Re: Which would you pick?

I would definitely pick Michael.

Posted 7/10/07 6:04 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
spinoof to pick up lines.. where did he use this pick up line? where did you meet? 04bride 10/6/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Help Me Pick My 30th Vacation Trip w/ Alex!!!!!!! (& the hubby too ;) AndreaLMT 8/8/06 19 Parenting
G2G TRAIN INFO!!!who can pick up at train stations,who will need to be picked up at trains janet 6/28/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
So, what name will you NOT name your children? **No offense to anyone whose names may be mentioned-you didn't pick it** MissJones 2/25/06 90 Families Helping Families ™
If you could live someone elses life for a day? whose would you pick? Michi 12/28/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
If you had to pick... which one would you choose? AJsMommy122 8/15/05 28 Families Helping Families ™