which culture should "dominate?"

Posted By Message

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

which culture should "dominate?"

i know that this is a group of people from all over the world, so i think your thoughts would be great.

if you come from a country/culture where there is a specific practice and you move... make your life somewhere else, where that practice is viewed quite differently (maybe seen as "rude"), which do you think should prevail?

should those around you accept that you come from a different place (and do things differently) or should you adapt to your new surroundings?

i hope i'm being clear enough... i can't come up with a good example

Posted 6/4/13 10:17 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

I understand what's you're asking. I think it depends on where the new "homeland" is. If I were visiting or moving to say a remote area of South America or a small city in Asia I would do things as they do and learn what acceptable etiquette is there. However, this part of the USA where we live is an exception. I am very sensitive to others practices here in Queens NY and really only expect "outsiders" to follow our laws.

Posted 6/4/13 10:23 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

While you should always maintain your customs and beliefs as they make you the person you are, I do think (to some degree) you need to adapt to your new surroundings as well. You should learn what's customary of the area you now live in and what is considered appropriate and conduct yourself accordingly while still maintaining who you are. It would seem only natural, at least to me, to want to try and "fit in" so to speak in your new environment. Hope that makes sense. Chat Icon

Message edited 2013-06-04 10:33:16.890000.

Posted 6/4/13 10:32 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

I think it depends.

For example.. if your family says grace before each meal, it is not unacceptable to ask your dinner guests to refrain from eating before you complete your prayer. IT IS – however – unacceptable to go to someone else’s home and insist that everyone say grace before they eat.

I guess what I’m saying is that it’s fine and good to keep your cultural and religious beliefs and customs alive and well in your own home – but it is not cool to insist that other people adapt to your ‘ways’ in order to make you feel more comfortable.

Posted 6/4/13 10:34 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

I think if you are visiting, or choosing to live in another part of the world, one with a significantly different culture, it's appropriate to adapt to that culture when you are out in society - within your home with your family or your own circle is one thing to maintain your 'former' culture - but when you're in a professional or social environment .......I feel it's extremely disrespectful to insist on maintainng your own customs, particularly if they clash with those of your new home.

And IMO you don't get a pass b/c this is America and there are 5 million different cultures here - People should be treated with respect regardless of your own cultural beliefs that you have brought with you from wherer you have immigrated from ......

Posted 6/4/13 10:41 AM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

Posted by Hofstra26

While you should always maintain your customs and beliefs as they make you the person you are, I do think (to some degree) you need to adapt to your new surroundings as well. You should learn what's customary of the area you now live in and what is considered appropriate and conduct yourself accordingly while still maintaining who you are. It would seem only natural, at least to me, to want to try and "fit in" so to speak in your new environment. Hope that makes sense. Chat Icon




I agree. If I was living in a muslim country, I'd make sure to cover my hair and dress modestly outside my home. I won't wear short skirts and have my arms uncovered just because that's how I've always dressed.

Posted 6/4/13 10:43 AM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

Posted by MarisaK

I think if you are visiting, or choosing to live in another part of the world, one with a significantly different culture, it's appropriate to adapt to that culture when you are out in society - within your home with your family or your own circle is one thing to maintain your 'former' culture - but when you're in a professional or social environment .......I feel it's extremely disrespectful to insist on maintainng your own customs, particularly if they clash with those of your new home.

And IMO you don't get a pass b/c this is America and there are 5 million different cultures here - People should be treated with respect regardless of your own cultural beliefs that you have brought with you from wherer you have immigrated from ......



Can you give an example of people insisting on maintaining their own customs in a professional or social environment?

Where do you think people are being disrespectful or "getting a pass"?

Posted 6/4/13 10:45 AM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

which culture should

You have to assimilate a little IMO
But should still keep your culture (if that makes sense)

Interesting you ask this... Recently a friend I know from Whitestone/flushing was saying how a bunch of Korean restaurants and such opened up.. But that they are all in Korean and not English. Person felt that it was a shame because they had trouble going to certain new places because of the language barrier.


Another thought - some cultures have men that find it ok to leer at women publicly and make comments. I find that wrong.. Even if its accepted in their culture.. And I'm pretty openminded.

Message edited 2013-06-04 10:49:15.153000.

Posted 6/4/13 10:46 AM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

You have to assimilate a little IMO
But should still keep your culture (if that makes sense)

Interesting you ask this... Recently a friend I know from Whitestone/flushing was saying how a bunch of Korean restaurants and such opened up.. But that they are all in Korean and not English. Person felt that it was a shame because they had trouble going to certain new places because of the language barrier.



They are all in Korean because they CAN be if that is the dominant customer. I see this as fear of the unknown. If your friend is interested in eating there she should not be afraid to go in and ask what the menu items are! I doubt that there is not one employee that does not speak English. Your friend may be making an assumption in this case.

Posted 6/4/13 10:50 AM
 

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

The one you are inserting yourself into.

That doesn't mean you should change your beliefs or ideals but if something is considered very rude in other culture- for example, showing a lot of skin- I think it would be pretty wrong to move to an area like that and walk around in daisy dukes and a bra. It's disresfectful.

Posted 6/4/13 10:51 AM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

Posted by stinger

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

You have to assimilate a little IMO
But should still keep your culture (if that makes sense)

Interesting you ask this... Recently a friend I know from Whitestone/flushing was saying how a bunch of Korean restaurants and such opened up.. But that they are all in Korean and not English. Person felt that it was a shame because they had trouble going to certain new places because of the language barrier.



They are all in Korean because they CAN be if that is the dominant customer. I see this as fear of the unknown. If your friend is interested in eating there she should not be afraid to go in and ask what the menu items are! I doubt that there is not one employee that does not speak English. Your friend may be making an assumption in this case.



I asked the same - if it was Korean cuisine. My friend is not at all against anyone - I think one place was a French cafe or pastry shop. I think it's better for businesses in melting pot areas to have menus and such in a few languages. That way everyone can go and enjoy.

Posted 6/4/13 10:58 AM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

Posted by stinger

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

You have to assimilate a little IMO
But should still keep your culture (if that makes sense)

Interesting you ask this... Recently a friend I know from Whitestone/flushing was saying how a bunch of Korean restaurants and such opened up.. But that they are all in Korean and not English. Person felt that it was a shame because they had trouble going to certain new places because of the language barrier.



They are all in Korean because they CAN be if that is the dominant customer. I see this as fear of the unknown. If your friend is interested in eating there she should not be afraid to go in and ask what the menu items are! I doubt that there is not one employee that does not speak English. Your friend may be making an assumption in this case.



I asked the same - if it was Korean cuisine. My friend is not at all against anyone - I think one place was a French cafe or pastry shop. I think it's better for businesses in melting pot areas to have menus and such in a few languages. That way everyone can go and enjoy.



From a business standpoint they should have the menu in English. However maybe they are not losing any business so they don't care.

Posted 6/4/13 11:01 AM
 

AScottWolf
I <3 our squish!

Member since 11/10

2237 total posts

Name:
Adriana

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

Posted by Hofstra26

While you should always maintain your customs and beliefs as they make you the person you are, I do think (to some degree) you need to adapt to your new surroundings as well. You should learn what's customary of the area you now live in and what is considered appropriate and conduct yourself accordingly while still maintaining who you are. It would seem only natural, at least to me, to want to try and "fit in" so to speak in your new environment. Hope that makes sense. Chat Icon



This.

Posted 6/4/13 11:58 AM
 

Jugglemom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/12

809 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

I think it is a difficult question because each culture has so many idiosyncrasies and social norms that sometimes it is difficult to know that something that you may consider "normal" may be considered rude or offensive in another culture.

For instance, we know about the headscarf thing in Muslim countries but many people may not know that showing the soles of your shoes is considered an insult. So if you cross your legs a certain way and show the soles you have insulted others.

So, if you are an immigrant to the U.S. for example and live in a diaspora then you may not really learn or know that certain particularities of your culture may be rude here.

Posted 6/4/13 2:20 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

Posted by Hofstra26

While you should always maintain your customs and beliefs as they make you the person you are, I do think (to some degree) you need to adapt to your new surroundings as well. You should learn what's customary of the area you now live in and what is considered appropriate and conduct yourself accordingly while still maintaining who you are. It would seem only natural, at least to me, to want to try and "fit in" so to speak in your new environment. Hope that makes sense. Chat Icon



Yep as a military brat you just learn to go with the flow. I think the biggest for me were coming OUT of the military, California vs Houston and Houston to San Antonio were pretty big as was San Antonio to NYC. Coming back to TX has been interesting LOL but Im getting better at it.

Stupid things like folks know if its foggy in the morning we'll be sweating by lunch or the water restrictions. We take water conservation VERY seriously here. I forgot how much and hubby had no idea until he we came here. You only water your grass once a week. To do so outside of that schedule is BEYOND rude and can form some serious hate in a neighborhood. We just do such things like that here. ha! Weddings? Please dont get me started! But its also cultural. SA has a lot of bases and lots of religious and outside country cultures because of it. So we just don't blink when we see fatigues or anything religious specific. Multi languages dont seem to bother us either but tourists will come here and make assumptions. Still everyone just makes do with eachother and their things. We find a middle ground.


TICKS us all off when some tourists came into town tho and Killed George the Duck on the San Antonio river. Took that poor duck by the throat and strangled it then carried it off like a prize only to toss it back into the river. So sad! (sorry for the side rant)

Message edited 2013-06-04 17:36:52.260000.

Posted 6/4/13 5:33 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

I think preserving culture is important. However it really does depend. for example If you come from cuba or haiti where santeria is/was widely practiced...you should probably not cut chicken heads off in your yard for neighbors to see...they will get the wrong idea. But if it's a more tame custom and it doesn't harm anyone...then I think it should be maintained. You shouldn't have to water yourself or your culture for anyone else...but on the flip side I can see how some things could go to the extreme end of the spectrum.

Message edited 2013-06-04 17:42:50.687000.

Posted 6/4/13 5:41 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: which culture should "dominate?"

I too think it depends. If the custom does not harm/infringe on anyone else, i.e. wearing a yarmulka/headscarf it is fine. But to put up stickers (like in London, UK) that say Sharia law zone enforced is taking it too far. I do think some assimilation into the new culture is necessary. Just like I would have the same respect for someone else's culture/customs by following them where they live I would expect them to have the same respect for me. No one is forcing you to move to a new country. You can get another job. You don't have to go to school at X. By moving somewhere else, I do feel you need to adapt to the cultural norms of that location. If it is too uncomfortable for you to do so, perhaps it would be better for you to look for another place to live. I am not saying people should not be tolerant of differences, but there must be a give and take of cultural norms. It can't be all one way, nor should the person moving to the new location expect it to be exactly like where they are from.

Posted 6/4/13 6:12 PM
 

Eagermom3
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/13

448 total posts

Name:

which culture should

depends what it is but in general I think everyone should stick to who they are and not change their culture for people.

Posted 6/5/13 9:08 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Kind of a strange question having to do with culture, I think? SweetTooth 8/15/08 11 Families Helping Families ™
I am so fascinated at the culture we have somehow created... lipglossjunky73 4/10/08 49 Families Helping Families ™
SPINOFF TO Small Office-What do you hate about coporate culture? ChattyKathy 1/17/08 10 Families Helping Families ™
FINALLY we went to the culture club last night! julz33 4/1/07 25 Families Helping Families ™
I need something to wear to the culture club... julz33 3/26/07 1 Fashion & Beauty!
How do you explain to a child (race/culture)... LIMOMx2 4/20/06 18 Families Helping Families ™