Where to move on LI?

Posted By Message

CanThsBit
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/10

451 total posts

Name:
Kina

Where to move on LI?

We are looking to move to LI- The only neighborhood I know is Westbury & thats bc of the mall. Can you give me other areas I can search for a home- I prefer to be as close as possible to the LIE bc I will need to drive my DD into Queens everyday & then go into the city for work. And obviously an area that has good schools. Thanks!

Posted 3/30/12 12:03 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Leb
LIF Adult

Member since 12/09

4166 total posts

Name:

Re: Where to move on LI?

If you will have to drive to Queens then you definitely need Nassau County. And depending on where in Queens I would look more toward North-Mid shore.

I like Floral Park.

Posted 3/30/12 12:05 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Where to move on LI?

If you can afford it... I'd go to Stewart Manor...

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE that neighborhood and its close to the city via LIRR

Posted 3/30/12 12:48 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Where to move on LI?

where in queens do you have to go? b/c depending where you might want to look more north shore

Posted 3/30/12 12:49 PM
 

MrsS1976
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/11

534 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Where to move on LI?

New Hyde Park, Floral Park, East Williston, Williston Park, Roslyn and Garden City (depending on budget, the first 2 are slightly more affordable than the rest).

Posted 3/30/12 12:56 PM
 

CanThsBit
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/10

451 total posts

Name:
Kina

Re: Where to move on LI?

great thanks for the suggestions!

I have to drop her off ay my in laws and they are in Long Island City (literally the tip of queens lol)

Posted 3/30/12 1:06 PM
 

mylovesX3
LIF Infant

Member since 3/09

132 total posts

Name:
k

Re: Where to move on LI?

That's a hard question to answer given we don't know your budget. You won't find a house in Westbury for 2K and change. KWIM? Not to mention taxes. Long Island has all different neighborhoods, with all different price ranges and taxes.

Posted 3/30/12 1:10 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Where to move on LI?

Posted by CanThsBit

great thanks for the suggestions!

I have to drop her off ay my in laws and they are in Long Island City (literally the tip of queens lol)



Yikes! Where do you work? Are you planning to take public transportation or drive? What are your hours?

I can see a commute like that being very stressful, especially coming from LI, in traffic in the AM. And it's a b!tch coming back at night, you can't forget that.

I know a few people who have actually opted to stay in nicer neighborhoods in Queens & Brooklyn because of childcare issues.

I'd need more info too!!!

Posted 3/30/12 1:18 PM
 

CanThsBit
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/10

451 total posts

Name:
Kina

Re: Where to move on LI?

My ideal location would be Brooklyn/Queens but the prices of homes are ridic-- example decent house $600K but needs work and no backyard - maybe enough space for a BBQ. Alot of the houses are shared driveway or street parking and then you have to move for street cleaning.

So then I just started randomly checking LI and you can get a whole lot more compared to Queens/Bklyn, yes the taxes are higher but your getting more for your $ I feel.

I work 9-4 in Midtown so my "plan" would be my husband take LIRR to work in the AM, I drive to in laws drop DD & leave my car there and then my husband would pick DD up and the 2 of them drive home and I take LIRR? This is stressful even thinking about it lol

Posted 3/30/12 1:41 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Where to move on LI?

I actually don't know anyone who has bought a house, but have gone the co-op route in the boros.

I know it's still not a lot of space though. Chat Icon

Posted 3/30/12 1:49 PM
 

CanThsBit
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/10

451 total posts

Name:
Kina

Re: Where to move on LI?

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I actually don't know anyone who has bought a house, but have gone the co-op route in the boros.

I know it's still not a lot of space though. Chat Icon



I know we own our Condo now and space is not on our side- lol

Posted 3/30/12 1:50 PM
 

Leb
LIF Adult

Member since 12/09

4166 total posts

Name:

Re: Where to move on LI?

If you and DH work in Manhattan and DD has to go to her Grandparent's in LIC, I would NOT try to move to LI.

Taxes are mostly insane and you are limited to certain neighborhoods due to the commute. The closest north shore nassau neighborhoods are super expensive.

Plus are you familiar with the nightmare of traffic that LI can be?

Can you find alternative childcare on LI, and then you and DH commute via LIRR?

Posted 3/30/12 1:55 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Where to move on LI?

getting a little off topic here but could your inlaws come get your LO and you could take care of the travel expenses for them? This way you are not closed to different locations and you don't have to stress about dropping off, picking up and the commute. You could still have DH pick up but the drop off would be easier if they did the reverse commute to get her.

Posted 3/30/12 2:01 PM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Where to move on LI?

Posted by CanThsBit

I work 9-4 in Midtown so my "plan" would be my husband take LIRR to work in the AM, I drive to in laws drop DD & leave my car there and then my husband would pick DD up and the 2 of them drive home and I take LIRR? This is stressful even thinking about it lol



I think you would also need to factor in the cost of the LIRR ticket. You are each traveling during peak times. You can't share a monthly ticket only bc they punch out an indicator about gender. Buying separately every day is expensive too. Maybe you can do a ten-trip. Price it out bc aside from the LIRR being unreliable, it can get expensive.

Posted 3/30/12 2:06 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Where to move on LI?

Posted by Blu-ize

getting a little off topic here but could your inlaws come get your LO and you could take care of the travel expenses for them? This way you are not closed to different locations and you don't have to stress about dropping off, picking up and the commute. You could still have DH pick up but the drop off would be easier if they did the reverse commute to get her.




Related to that, we know someone whose MIL lives in the Bronx. I think she stays with them for a few days each week to watch their son in Seaford.

I drop my own son off at my ILs in Seaford, and then head back to Babylon most days and then pick him up there at night. This can be stressful with the traffic alone on Merrick Rd, I'd want to poke my eyes out if I had to go to LIC.

If you have a decent relationship with them, I think this is a much better option. Just make sure you get a big enough house. Chat Icon

Posted 3/30/12 2:09 PM
 

CanThsBit
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/10

451 total posts

Name:
Kina

Re: Where to move on LI?

hahahaaha Ok you girls brought me back to my senses- LI is out. The hunt is on again.... in Queens.

Chat Icon

Posted 3/30/12 2:09 PM
 

marianne13
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/10

887 total posts

Name:

Re: Where to move on LI?

Posted by pnbplus1

Posted by CanThsBit

I work 9-4 in Midtown so my "plan" would be my husband take LIRR to work in the AM, I drive to in laws drop DD & leave my car there and then my husband would pick DD up and the 2 of them drive home and I take LIRR? This is stressful even thinking about it lol



I think you would also need to factor in the cost of the LIRR ticket. You are each traveling during peak times. You can't share a monthly ticket only bc they punch out an indicator about gender. Buying separately every day is expensive too. Maybe you can do a ten-trip. Price it out bc aside from the LIRR being unreliable, it can get expensive.



I was just going to say this. If you are going to drop off DD with your inlaws, one person should travel by LIRR and the other person should drop off DD with the car and pick her up with the car. You will be wasting money on the LIRR this way. Out of curiousity, why would your husband take your car home? Does he leave work before 4 PM?

If you drop off your DD, park your car at the inlaws and pick her up, it may not be that bad. What subway line are your inlaws near? Are they in LIC or Astoria? And where in midtown do you work? If they are in Astoria, the ride from the 1st stop in Astoria (Ditmars Blvd) to 59th Street/Lexington Ave is 20 minutes. If the inlaws live in LIC near the #7 train, the ride from Vernon Boulevard to Grand Central is probably less than 5 minutes (1 stop). It depends on where you live in LI, how close the inlaws are to the subway, and the length of the ride from their subway station to yours at work.

So I wouldn't completely drop the idea of buying in LI. I should note that I don't drive to work so I can't comment on the traffic on the LIE in the morning and I don't have kids so maybe some of the parents would be able to give better advice as to the hassle of driving a toddler from Nassau to Queens everyday. HTH

Posted 3/30/12 2:19 PM
 

marianne13
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/10

887 total posts

Name:

Re: Where to move on LI?

Are you opposed to have your inlaws stay with you for a few days? Or are they opposed to it? What if you did the commute to LIC Monday-Wednesay and drove them back home with you on Wednesday night so they can stay with DD at your house Thursday and Friday??

Posted 3/30/12 2:22 PM
 

sultana
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

1455 total posts

Name:
Bridget

Re: Where to move on LI?

maybe also ask on the city-data forum in the Queens section

Posted 3/30/12 3:06 PM
 

BeachGal
LIF Adult

Member since 2/10

2827 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Where to move on LI?

My commute into midtown from Nassau is 1.5 hours so your drive to LIC and commute from there may be just as long depending where in Nassau you live. I dont think it sounds horrible to be honest! When I lived in Queens my commute was an hour via express bus so not much different! I think a 1.5 commute is worth it to be in the suburbs!!! I grew up in Queens and besides the fact that complete gut job houses were 700k when we were looking in 2007, I am glad to be in Long Island!!

Posted 3/30/12 3:58 PM