When I say "NO", DS laughs!

Posted By Message

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

When I say "NO", DS laughs!

DS is 14 months old and every time I tell him "No" he laughs...I tell him "No" when he id really misbehaving or is doing something that can hurt him. I will remove him from the situation and say no in a firm voice and he laughs. He has been laughing at the word "no" for months. Chat Icon Chat Icon I now have to tell him "no-no" or "stop" and remove him from the situation. When he is throwing food or touching something that he shouldn't be, I find myself tapping the back of his hand when I am saying stop. It works sometimes...I don't like the idea of it, but it is the only thing that works. (most of the time) He is a stubborn little boy! I only do it when he can get hurt or is throwing his food. ( He does it when he is done eating.) I know he is young, but he needs to learn no means no!!!! Will it ever sink in!?Chat Icon

Posted 1/15/11 2:21 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: When I say "NO", DS laughs!

I never used the word "no" with my DD because she would do the same thing. They think it's a game. I feel like if you're constantly saying "no" all the time it simply loses its meaning. We save "no" for when she's doing something that is dangerous and we need her to stop asap. For example, if she went to touch the stove we'd say "NO!!" and then follow up with "We don't touch the stove. Too hot".

For everything else we just "explain" how to behave. "We don't throw food" or "We don't hit the dog" etc. Short and sweet but more effective I think then saying "no". My DD is 2 now and she's very well behaved. As she got older and was able to speak she would repeat back to us what we said which I think is helpful in them understanding how to behave and what's right and wrong. Now she says, "I sorry Mommy. No throw toys". Chat Icon

It really works well. I've never felt agitated with her or felt like I was a broken record with no, no, no, no. At a certain point we added time outs as well so we'd say "We don't throw food" and if she did it again we put her in time out and repeat what we said. After her time out was up we repeated what we said yet again and she would say sorry and give us a hug. That was the end of the unwanted behavior, she didn't usually go back and continue. She got the idea pretty quick that she was behaving poorly.

It's all trial and error. Different approaches work with different kids. Honestly, it's easier to get your point across when they are a little older. Sometimes at his age you're better off telling him, "We don't throw toys" and then redirecting him. If he's throwing food, take the plate away. He will get the idea eventually. Good luck! You will figure it out!! Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-01-15 14:43:09.413000.

Posted 1/15/11 2:40 PM
 

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

Re: When I say "NO", DS laughs!

Posted by Hofstra26

I never used the word "no" with my DD because she would do the same thing. They think it's a game. I feel like if you're constantly saying "no" all the time it simply loses its meaning. We save "no" for when she's doing something that is dangerous and we need her to stop asap. For example, if she went to touch the stove we'd say "NO!!" and then follow up with "We don't touch the stove. Too hot".

For everything else we just "explain" how to behave. "We don't throw food" or "We don't hit the dog" etc. Short and sweet but more effective I think then saying "no". My DD is 2 now and she's very well behaved. As she got older and was able to speak she would repeat back to us what we said which I think is helpful in them understanding how to behave and what's right and wrong. Now she says, "I sorry Mommy. No throw toys". Chat Icon

It really works well. I've never felt agitated with her or felt like I was a broken record with no, no, no, no. At a certain point we added time outs as well so we'd say "We don't throw food" and if she did it again we put her in time out and repeat what we said. After her time out was up we repeated what we said yet again and she would say sorry and give us a hug. That was the end of the unwanted behavior, she didn't usually go back and continue. She got the idea pretty quick that she was behaving poorly.

It's all trial and error. Different approaches work with different kids. Honestly, it's easier to get your point across when they are a little older. Sometimes at his age you're better off telling him, "We don't throw toys" and then redirecting him. If he's throwing food, take the plate away. He will get the idea eventually. Good luck! You will figure it out!! Chat Icon



When he throws food, I take the stuff away right away and tell him that we don't do that. He just looks at me. I usually take him out of the situation as I am saying no. Like right now, he is grabbing the computer. I say no, he does it again. As soon as I say stop and remove his hands, he walks away...I am thinking "NO" is never going to sink in...Thanks for the input.

Posted 1/15/11 3:25 PM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: When I say "NO", DS laughs!

Lucas was the same way...be would smile or laugh when he was younger.

The best advice was the advice I got here: keep at it and be consistent. Like Hofstra mentioned, it's best to explain why but continue to say no along with that. "No, we don't touch xyz"

Be consistent and don't give up...you are teaching him right now and he is learning. Eventually you will see that when you say no he will react and stop. Then you'll know that he understands.

At his age re-direction is important. Say no and explain what he should not be doing and then redirect his attention to something else. He'll learn.


Chat Icon

Posted 1/15/11 7:20 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: When I say "NO", DS laughs!

DD used to do the same, drove me crazy, now she is 3 and when I say no she says "mama, you can't say no, you have to say yes" Chat Icon

Posted 1/15/11 7:56 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: When I say "NO", DS laughs!

I reserve "NO" for immediate danger, I don't use it all day. I also believe words loose weight when they are repeated over and over.

article on Baby Discipline that might help you - it helped me a ton!

I posted this on another forum recently, after following this articles advice.


I am just floored at how easy it has been do discipline my now 10m old, following RIE principles. I used to get full fledged tantrums when I said "no!" now I come to his level, and say something like "this is not yours" and offer him choices of what he can have and he takes his time, thinks, is calm and usually makes a great choice! I cannot even believe it.

I had no confidence it would work the first time I did, he totally proved me wrong. He's also shown me how intelligent he is, I never knew he understood so much, that he knew so many words and could put ideas together like "if you put your coat, we can go outside" I never got so much cooperation when getting him dressed.

Posted 1/15/11 9:14 PM
 

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

Re: When I say "NO", DS laughs!

Posted by KartveliT

DD used to do the same, drove me crazy, now she is 3 and when I say no she says "mama, you can't say no, you have to say yes" Chat Icon



LOL...That is too funny...I can see DS doing that!Chat Icon

Posted 1/15/11 9:27 PM
 

BAM 2009
I am who I am!!!

Member since 5/09

6081 total posts

Name:

Re: When I say "NO", DS laughs!

I have tried to limit the word "no". But it is the first word that pops into my head. I have been using "stop" instead or "no-no". He doesn't laugh with them. I remove him from the situation and we get on with our day. My husband likes to use the word No and he gets pi$$ed when DS laughs and keeps doing whatever he is doing. I tell hubby over and over that he has to remove DS from the situation. But that is going to take a little more drilling into his head...I am firm with DS when the issue warrants it. He is a curious little boy who likes to see how things work. I know it takes time and I will keep working with him. Thanks for the information!

Posted 1/15/11 9:35 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
this board seems very quiet tonight so i am going to say goodnight luvsbob4603 5/17/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
Just wanted to say hi! mommy2Alex 5/14/05 3 Parenting
Just want to say hello to everyone! Jen110704 5/13/05 15 Families Helping Families ™
so what naughty words can we say here? Cocoa 5/12/05 15 Families Helping Families ™
Most annoying AND/OR Most Stupid things people say to me while TTC DebG 5/12/05 31 TTC
I just have to say.... NoStressMom 5/12/05 2 Pregnancy