When does an opinion become a judgement?

Posted By Message

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

When does an opinion become a judgement?

Anyone who has ever uttered the word "judge" or "judgement" should be able to answer this question, don't you think?

I see it thrown around here all the time - don't judge - don't be judgemental - judgejudgejudge.

If you think that a judgement is simply a negative opinion on something, don't we all judge? Every single one of us? Are any of you saints that never, ever make judgements on people's habits, looks, choices?

Perhaps Jesus never judges. Chat Icon But I'm pretty sure you all probably have at one point in your life.

So define judging to me - what does it mean to you and when does an opinion become a judgement?

The last time I asked this, I got precious few replies. I'm wondering if that's because no one was interested in talking about it, couldn't really answer it because they didn't know, or just boycott my threads because they despise the hell out of me. Chat Icon

What say you, O wise women and men of LIF?

**eta: to clarify, I'm really not referencing a particular thread there. I see it a lot around here and always wondered. I hardly ever get into any debate here anymore and don't reply to threads that degrade into finger pointing or judgement statements.**

Message edited 2008-08-08 10:39:44.237000.

Posted 8/8/08 8:52 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

After the thread of last night, I find that going against the grain makes you apparently judgemental and close minded.

I thought it was indeed a different *opinion*. Apparently not!

ETA: I also find that the same people who tell you that you are judgemental, actually judge you. And they jump on their high horse when it's the other way around on a different topic. Interesting IMO!

Message edited 2008-08-08 08:56:04.420000.

Posted 8/8/08 8:54 AM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

I find that frequently people who have an opinion different from someone else or the norm are told that they are "judging" others - when they simply have a different opinion. I think sometimes people take what someone says that they feel for themselves and automatically turn it into a criticism of someone else rather than just what one person believes.

I think a judgement is when someone says "YOU are X" or "YOU are y". Not when someone says "I would or wouldn't do something"...then to me that is an opinion not a judgement.

Having multiple opinions on a topic to me is more interesting - as we all have different backgrounds and life isn't just on opinion.

Message edited 2008-08-08 09:03:09.337000.

Posted 8/8/08 9:02 AM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

Blanket statements and name calling.

And usually the addtion of one of these guys:

Chat Icon

Chat Icon

Posted 8/8/08 9:24 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

I think it gets to the point of "judging" when you actually say something direct about the person or continue on the tread with an argument

Posted 8/8/08 9:27 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

This is my humble opinion...

We all judge. Some more than others. I like to think that I reserve true "judgment" for those kind of behaviors that are unspoken truths for bad behavior - givens, like neglect, abuse, rape, murder, etc. Something that actually inflicts HARM against another being. That's when I outright judge.

Other than that, I may "disagree" with another person's perspective, or the way they live their life, but if it affects no one but themselves, then I recognize that it really is just a difference of perspective and opinion.

I'm fully aware, however, that everyone falls differently on the spectrum of judgment and some, or many, reserve judgment (as in, MY belief/opinion/perspective is the BEST/BETTER/ONLY belief/opinion/perspective) for behaviors that fall on a different part of the spectrum.

Posted 8/8/08 9:28 AM
 

BabyAvocado
Happy New Year

Member since 5/05

17334 total posts

Name:

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

You've posted exactly what was on my mind after reading only a portion of that thread.

When did "judge" become a curse word? You are supposed to "trust your judgement", "exercise good judgement" and hopefully be a "good judge of character". These are not bad things. Yet it seems like the trend is accept everything or you are a close-minded person. No judgement there. Chat Icon

I think we are confusing an opinion or a different belief, with a judgement of moral character. I am allowed to have different beliefs than another and it is not necessarily a judgement. I don't have to accept everything everyone else does with a "to each his own" shrug. No. When it did it become a crime to say "hey, I personally FEEL that is wrong"? Why am I wrong for feeling that way?

Good judgement got alot of us to good places in our lives. Poor judgement can account for some mistakes in our lives.

Also, I think that sometimes self-righteousness can cloud ones judgement. Chat Icon

Posted 8/8/08 9:39 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

we all judge all the time.

every second of every day, we are weighing something in our minds against our likes/beliefs/lifestyle/thoughts/truths/fallacies/opinions

I think we use the term "judgmental" when we feel that AFTER the judging is over, we feel "better than" or the different person is "less than"

but in reality, that is subjective.

the text book definition (literally, I am holding a dictionary in my hands Chat Icon ) is as follows

judgmental: 1 of or having to do with the exercise of judgment. 2 making or tending to make judgments as to value, importance etc often specif., judgments considered to be lacking in tolerance, compassion, objectivity etc

I feel the latter, bolded part of the definition is what gets peoples panties twisted.

Message edited 2008-08-08 09:46:59.840000.

Posted 8/8/08 9:46 AM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

i don't know which thread this is in reference to: been away from the computer a bit lately.

interesting question, interesting topic, interesting replies so far.

in my simpleton world:

opinion: what i think of a subject, but can be educated to see a different perspective

judgement: when i will not budge on my opinion and will "look down" on those who don't agree. FOR ME, these are usually the biggies (as stated previously: murder, rape, abuse of some sort)

eta: i also want to admit that i am human and have and will continue to judge on smaller scales... i'm just not vocal about most of it Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-08-08 09:50:18.833000.

Posted 8/8/08 9:49 AM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

Posted by BabyAvocado

You've posted exactly what was on my mind after reading only a portion of that thread.

When did "judge" become a curse word? You are supposed to "trust your judgement", "exercise good judgement" and hopefully be a "good judge of character". These are not bad things. Yet it seems like the trend is accept everything or you are a close-minded person. No judgement there. Chat Icon

I think we are confusing an opinion or a different belief, with a judgement of moral character. I am allowed to have different beliefs than another and it is not necessarily a judgement. I don't have to accept everything everyone else does with a "to each his own" shrug. No. When it did it become a crime to say "hey, I personally FEEL that is wrong"? Why am I wrong for feeling that way?

Good judgement got alot of us to good places in our lives. Poor judgement can account for some mistakes in our lives.

Also, I think that sometimes self-righteousness can cloud ones judgement. Chat Icon




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I could not have said it better. We all have different belief systems, opinions, thoughts. Unfortunately, on this site, it seems that someone is negatively judging someone when their opinion does not agree with the other(s).

Posted 8/8/08 9:53 AM
 

TheWhiteRabbit
Thru the rabbit hole!

Member since 7/06

4412 total posts

Name:

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

I think I agree with a PP who said it’s an “I” thing. When someone say “I feel this way, and it may not be correct but that’s how I feel” is an opinion, but saying “All of those people are this way” is judgmental. How do you know all people of a particular group are a certain way?

It gets heated when there is a person of that particular group being disparaged and they then feel they're being personally attacked.

Posted 8/8/08 9:56 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

I don't know what thread this is referencing, but I think an opinion becomes a judgment when it is said with distain or in a condescending manner, implying that the other person's opinion/action isn't just different but is wrong.

Posted 8/8/08 9:57 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

Posted by mrswask

Posted by BabyAvocado

You've posted exactly what was on my mind after reading only a portion of that thread.

When did "judge" become a curse word? You are supposed to "trust your judgement", "exercise good judgement" and hopefully be a "good judge of character". These are not bad things. Yet it seems like the trend is accept everything or you are a close-minded person. No judgement there. Chat Icon

I think we are confusing an opinion or a different belief, with a judgement of moral character. I am allowed to have different beliefs than another and it is not necessarily a judgement. I don't have to accept everything everyone else does with a "to each his own" shrug. No. When it did it become a crime to say "hey, I personally FEEL that is wrong"? Why am I wrong for feeling that way?

Good judgement got alot of us to good places in our lives. Poor judgement can account for some mistakes in our lives.

Also, I think that sometimes self-righteousness can cloud ones judgement. Chat Icon




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I could not have said it better. We all have different belief systems, opinions, thoughts. Unfortunately, on this site, it seems that someone is negatively judging someone when their opinion does not agree with the other(s).



I agree and I want to add that I *BELIEVE* it has something to do with self esteem and self confidence if you can't take hearing an opinion that is different than yours without pulling out the "judgment" card.

b/c part of that feeling is the way that opinion "makes" you feel and if it makes you feel less than....that is partially coming from YOU...not necessarily a reflection of the person disagreeing with you.

Posted 8/8/08 9:58 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

To me judgement is when someone makes a blanket negative statement about someone/something else.

For instance, "I wouldn't go to Paris" would be my preference or travel opinion.

"I don't know why anyone would go to Paris" would be a judgemental.

Posted 8/8/08 10:00 AM
 

oops123
LIF Adult

Member since 8/05

2509 total posts

Name:
michelle

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

I think we are all guilty of Judging-

unfortunately its human nature to automatically judge how another person is doing something if its different from our way.
I think its the level of judging-
or from the place its coming from-

like the "Im better than you" response
or
"you obviously dont know what the hell youre talking about"
response that makes it a negative thing.

After reading "The Seven Spiritual Laws of Success" by Deepak Chopra,(GREAT book btw)
I have tried to go an entire day w/out judgement- its like reconditioning your thoughts which isnt an easy task.

Posted 8/8/08 10:05 AM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

Posted by smdl

After the thread of last night, I find that going against the grain makes you apparently judgemental and close minded.

I thought it was indeed a different *opinion*. Apparently not!

ETA: I also find that the same people who tell you that you are judgemental, actually judge you. And they jump on their high horse when it's the other way around on a different topic. Interesting IMO!



ITA -- and that thread on parenting was a little out of control. I feel bad for the poster that spoke from her heart and disagreed with most and was attacked for it. (Yes, IMO, she WAS attacked).

Posted 8/8/08 10:38 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

Posted by KittyTheStray

I think I agree with a PP who said it’s an “I” thing. When someone say “I feel this way, and it may not be correct but that’s how I feel” is an opinion, but saying “All of those people are this way” is judgmental. How do you know all people of a particular group are a certain way?





I agree, I think the mass generalizations that occur are the problem

Posted 8/8/08 10:49 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

I don't want to judge anything. It is a goal I am striving for.

When I say I don't want to judge it simply means that I want to learn to accept that human beings all have different motivations and different experiences and different morals, etc.. and that I simply DO NOT KNOW where they are coming from or what circumstances are driving them - so I prefer not to decide who they are inside based on the actions and words I see or observe.

I do - however - have opinions. By having an opinion I acknowledge that based on MY experiences, morals, motivations and whatnot - someone elses actions or words do NOT resonate with ME. I KNOW I am not perfect. I am well aware that other people might find my words or actions to be wrong, bad, ridiculous - whatever. I accept that.

Maybe the difference is so subtle that I can't quite express it properly - but I know it when I feel it. When I feel that 'I am better than so and so' feeling start to creep up on me.. that sense of entitlement or self righteousness - I smack that down IMMEDIATELY because I know I am on the verge of judgement.

There I go rambling again.

Posted 8/8/08 11:30 AM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

I agree with the characterizations of what seems to feel "wrong" versus OK, but to me, objectionable behavior is one of those "you know it when you see it" things. In other words, blanket statements tend to be worse than "I wouldn't"'s BUT there'll always be some insecure person with lots to prove proclaiming "I would NEVER..." & you KNOW there's something pointed & insulting behind it, not just honest, intelligent conversation.

I lurked for a long time on here because I had lots to add to the conversation and didn't mind others' disagreement, but I didn't want to deal with some of the snarkiness you see occasionally. ...Got over that!

Posted 8/8/08 11:42 AM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C ♥'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

Posted by BabyAvocado

You've posted exactly what was on my mind after reading only a portion of that thread.

When did "judge" become a curse word? You are supposed to "trust your judgement", "exercise good judgement" and hopefully be a "good judge of character". These are not bad things. Yet it seems like the trend is accept everything or you are a close-minded person. No judgement there. Chat Icon

I think we are confusing an opinion or a different belief, with a judgement of moral character. I am allowed to have different beliefs than another and it is not necessarily a judgement. I don't have to accept everything everyone else does with a "to each his own" shrug. No. When it did it become a crime to say "hey, I personally FEEL that is wrong"? Why am I wrong for feeling that way?

Good judgement got alot of us to good places in our lives. Poor judgement can account for some mistakes in our lives.

Also, I think that sometimes self-righteousness can cloud ones judgement. Chat Icon



AMEN to that!

Posted 8/8/08 11:59 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

Greeny, you know I love you and I admire your brilliance, but damn you for making me THINK on a Friday afternoon when I am working on half my brain power.

It is my opinion that I cannot make a judgment about an answer.

How is that?

Posted 8/8/08 12:28 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

Posted by Ophelia

we all judge all the time.

every second of every day, we are weighing something in our minds against our likes/beliefs/lifestyle/thoughts/truths/fallacies/opinions

I think we use the term "judgmental" when we feel that AFTER the judging is over, we feel "better than" or the different person is "less than"






I agree with this...and I think we become "judgemental" when they become aggressive and stubborn regarding an issue.

Posted 8/8/08 1:57 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: When does an opinion become a judgement?

opinion: no, it's not my taste, sorry

judgement: I can't believe you're wearing that! Chat Icon

Posted 8/8/08 6:13 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What is your opinion? dandr10199 3/16/06 14 Parenting
which picture is the cutest in your opinion? MrsR 3/9/06 56 Parenting
Opinion needed RE: Fences - Rose vs. Consumer PiyoPika566 2/24/06 2 Home
Walker opinion Sp4747 2/13/06 7 Parenting
Which opinion stays with you longer Redhead 1/31/06 23 Families Helping Families ™
Opinion(Nixzmary Brown Case) LadyMaravilla 1/19/06 59 Families Helping Families ™