When do they really understand "lying"?

Posted By Message

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

When do they really understand "lying"?

Logan will tell me "No" when I ask if his diaper is dirty, but it obviously is.

And I know he knows it is, because I see the look on his face.

Is this truly "lying"?

When do they get that concept?

Message edited 2009-02-17 14:34:03.713000.

Posted 2/17/09 2:32 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: When do they really understand "lying"?

Um...my guess is 2-1/2-3. At least my lying kids started at 2 or 3.

Things like "I didn't eat any candy for breakfast."

"Ok, open your mouth."

or "Did you touch the remote control?"

"No"
Yell to DH "Honey, please stop throwing the remote controls in the garbage."

Posted 2/17/09 2:36 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: When do they really understand "lying"?

From what I have read, yes, they do get it and it's an important milestone for them too.

Posted 2/17/09 2:36 PM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: When do they really understand "lying"?

Posted by shamrock124

From what I have read, yes, they do get it and it's an important milestone for them too.



Do you think it is a time-out offense then?

I haven't been doing it, but I've considered it a couple of times.



Posted 2/17/09 2:45 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: When do they really understand "lying"?

Posted by leighla

Posted by shamrock124

From what I have read, yes, they do get it and it's an important milestone for them too.



Do you think it is a time-out offense then?

I haven't been doing it, but I've considered it a couple of times.






We went with the disappointment speech, the boy who cried wolf story. If it was a serious offense, definitely a time out.

Obviously my kids are still lying so I probably don't know what I'm doing. I assume they're going to lie at some point but we've told them that the punishment is worse if they lie.

I didn't punish them for lying about the camera but I did tell him if anything happened to it, I would take all of the money in his piggy bank (he counts it over & over again like Scrooge, so that hit home).

Posted 2/17/09 2:53 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: When do they really understand "lying"?

Posted by leighla

Posted by shamrock124

From what I have read, yes, they do get it and it's an important milestone for them too.



Do you think it is a time-out offense then?

I haven't been doing it, but I've considered it a couple of times.






Certainly not a time out offense when it comes to denying a dirty diaper. I would say little lies like "did you just hit the dog" when you kow they did would warrant a time out. In our house I reserve timeouts for more serious offenses like hitting or temper issues. I have seen DS lie, but I don't think he quite gets what a lie is yet, and it seems useless to punish him for something he doesn't fully understand. YKWIM?

Posted 2/17/09 2:54 PM
 

luvsun27
Check out my cool glasses

Member since 5/05

8135 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: When do they really understand "lying"?

Posted by leighla

Posted by shamrock124

From what I have read, yes, they do get it and it's an important milestone for them too.



Do you think it is a time-out offense then?

I haven't been doing it, but I've considered it a couple of times.






I wouldn't give a time-out for a dirty diaper...but I have given time outs for "lying". Did you touch the TV "no", etc.

Posted 2/17/09 2:55 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: When do they really understand "lying"?

When it comes to the diaper thing, no, I personally would not punish him for that because you don't want him to develop some sort of negative association with pooping. I only know because we made that mistake and then Ava was holding it in for days instead. I would try rewarding him if he does tell you.

As for the lying, I don't know when they're supposed to understand it, but Ava started to honestly lie to us at like 16 months. We would watch her do something she wasn't supposed to do, then when I'd say, "Ava, who ate the cookie on the table?" she would tell me that the cat ate it, meanwhile she had crumbs all over her face.Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/17/09 2:57 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: When do they really understand "lying"?

DS is already fake crying and that's like lying to me. I have major issues with being told lies. I know I will be harsh about it but I hope that doesn't backfire. Talking back or fresh talk would be more acceptable in my house!

Posted 2/17/09 7:21 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to Lying-Just a cute little story about me trying to get Jules to take accountability for her actions aliasPook 3/27/07 7 Parenting
I don't understand it...(long vent) Stefanie 3/7/06 58 Families Helping Families ™
We registered at BRU this weekend but what I don't understand... preciouslove 1/23/06 5 Pregnancy
I know you guys will understand rose825 1/21/06 9 Infertility
I don't understand... preciouslove 1/17/06 0 Families Helping Families ™
I don't understand. BaroqueMama 12/19/05 9 Families Helping Families ™