What would you do? Shower related

Posted By Message

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

What would you do? Shower related

Okay, I just realized as I spoke to my mom last night that I have a dilemma.

What would you do?

Here is the situation. My brother was dating a lovely girl a few years back. We really hit it off, spent time together and she was in my wedding. They broke up last July Chat Icon, and my brother doesn't know, but we still speak and when I was in NY, we went out together.

Almost a year ago, he started dating another girl, who I also really like, although I don't really know her as well because my brother didn't tell my family about her until they were dating 6 months. I met her in person once and spoke to her on the phone a few times. She is a sweetie but I don't know her as well because I live in Florida and they live in NY. My brother is very serious with her and they are moving in together soon.

Here is the dilemma. My shower. I of course want to have my brother's girlfriend there who I have a feeling might be my SIL one day. However, I want to invite his ex as well who is still my friend. My mother said no, especially because of the awkwardness (she does like her a lot, as does my whole family-they broke up amicably) and because it could upset my brother.

What would you do? We are also FB friends (myself and my bro's ex, as well as myself and my bro's girlfried), so I know they probably know about each other. I know people post baby shower pics and things on FB and I don't want to offend my friend, but I think she would understand.

I am really sad about this. Do I speak to my brother and admit that I still speak to his ex? Do I talk to his ex and mention that I want her there but it might be odd. I have some time to do this

HELP!!! What do I do? Chat Icon I don't want to hurt anyone and I want to celebrate with everyone I love!

Posted 8/29/09 10:50 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Shelleybean11
Mommy of 2!

Member since 12/08

11013 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? Shower related

I think you should talk to his ex and tell her that while you would love to have her there, you don't want to make you possible future SIL uncomfortable or there to be any awkwardness. I'm sure she will understand if you are truly friends. HTH Chat Icon

Posted 8/29/09 11:00 AM
 

mommyago
&hearts; Lucas and Layla

Member since 8/08

2979 total posts

Name:
Jenise

Re: What would you do? Shower related

I think u should mention to your brother that u still keep in touch here and there and were thinking about inviting her but didnt want it to be weird or awkward so you wanted to know what he thinks about it

Posted 8/29/09 11:03 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: What would you do? Shower related

Posted by Shelleybean11

I think you should talk to his ex and tell her that while you would love to have her there, you don't want to make you possible future SIL uncomfortable or there to be any awkwardness. I'm sure she will understand if you are truly friends. HTH Chat Icon



i agree with this. a good friend would understand.

the issue (for me) is that you were not friends with her first. they dated and you became friends. if i were the other way around i would not hesitate to invite her, but in this case, i would not. even though she is an ex, it will probably make the current GF uncomfortable, and if she does become your SIL, it could become a bigger issue down the road.

Posted 8/29/09 11:26 AM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: What would you do? Shower related

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by Shelleybean11

I think you should talk to his ex and tell her that while you would love to have her there, you don't want to make you possible future SIL uncomfortable or there to be any awkwardness. I'm sure she will understand if you are truly friends. HTH Chat Icon



i agree with this. a good friend would understand.

the issue (for me) is that you were not friends with her first. they dated and you became friends. if i were the other way around i would not hesitate to invite her, but in this case, i would not. even though she is an ex, it will probably make the current GF uncomfortable, and if she does become your SIL, it could become a bigger issue down the road.



Agree with the above posters! Chat Icon

Posted 8/29/09 11:34 AM
 

Sunday
In love with a boy named Luca

Member since 6/09

1799 total posts

Name:
`

Re: What would you do? Shower related

My husband's sister is friends with his ex and my husband absolutely hates it. It has seriously diminished their relationship. So far, the ex has not been invited to anything- which is a really good thing b/c he has firmly stated that he would skip his own sister's wedding if the ex were invited- and I would feel really sad for everyone if that happened. And I don't think he and the ex really broke up on bad terms- it's more like they just grew apart. So, there's really no reason why he would hate her, like cheating etc. But he views his sister's friendship w/ the ex as the ultimate disrespect to him. Also, you have to consider that by inviting her you MAY be jeopardizing any future relationship with what sounds like a new sil, depending on how she reacts. IMO it is not worth it and your friend the ex should understand why her presence would be inappropriate.

Posted 8/29/09 11:54 AM
 

kms717
St Philomena Protect My Son

Member since 2/06

2747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: What would you do? Shower related

I would probably not invite ex and explain to her that you would love to have her there, but you don't want to make things uncomfortable for the new gf. Chat Icon

Posted 8/29/09 11:57 AM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: What would you do? Shower related

I would not invite the ex-gf. I agree with the above posters. Like the other girls, I would talk to the ex-gf and explain why. If she really is your friend, she should understand. I would also be upfront with your brother and tell him that you are still in contact with his ex-gf.

Posted 8/29/09 11:58 AM
 

RobinG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/08

595 total posts

Name:
Robin

Re: What would you do? Shower related

My best friend was in this position, except she was the ex girlfriend. She went to bridal shower, wedding and baby shower, even though the new girl (who was married to her ex by the time the baby shower came) was obviously there too. I can't tell you how the new wife felt, but my friend just steered clear of her at the events. It was a little awkward, but she was glad to be there for her friend.

Posted 8/29/09 12:04 PM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: What would you do? Shower related

I would talk to your friend and explain that as much as you'd love to have her there its just not going to work out that way. I dated (and was eventually engaged) a guy for 10 yrs. He had 4 sisters, I never had any. I was really, really close with One of his sisters and to this day (7 yrs later) talk to them all on FB. His one sister that I was closest to got married a couple years after we broke up and I knew going to the shower and wedding weren't an option. Even if she had invited me I would have had to decline. We found our own ways to celebrate and it was completely fine. Good luck. Hope you can work it out.

Posted 8/29/09 12:37 PM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: What would you do? Shower related

does the new gf know that is his ex? If she is your friends, then I think she should be invited. If you feel awkward I would talk to your brotehr to see hwo he feels about it

Posted 8/29/09 1:51 PM
 

spa118
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

2157 total posts

Name:
Shari

Re: What would you do? Shower related

I think your brother's feelings should come before the ex's feelings, even if she is your friend. I wouldn't hide the fact that you are friends with her from your brother - I think you should let him know about that - secrets are never good. But as far as the shower, I think she would understand why she wasn't invited.

ETA: you can ask people not to post pics on facebook if you are worried about that. I really don't like posting anything too personal on facebook, since there are people I'm friends with that are not really my friends, like coworkers and such.

Message edited 2009-08-29 14:11:41.240000.

Posted 8/29/09 2:10 PM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: What would you do? Shower related

I don't think you could possibly invite the ex at this point. If your brother was aware all along that you had remained friends with her, then maybe it would have been ok. But given that you kept your friendship quiet, I don't think your shower is the appropriate time to spring this on your brother and his new girlfriend. I would just be completelu honest with the ex, I'm sure she would understand that akwardness of it all.

Posted 8/29/09 3:57 PM
 

HighHopes
U are my best Christmas gift!

Member since 3/09

1267 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: What would you do? Shower related

I would start by talking to your brother. Then based on the conversatino and his reaction you go from there.

I'm sure his ex already knows there is a chance she will not be invited.

G/L!

Posted 8/29/09 4:13 PM
 

MrsList
Sweet cheeks

Member since 4/09

1696 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do? Shower related

Since they broke up amicably, I would say just invite her. I would mention it to your brother and tell him that you're inviting her and that he should maybe give his GF the heads up. Everyone is an adult and your brother and the new GF should be mature and deal with it. At this point, this woman has nothing to do with them - she's YOUR friend.

If this other woman is your good friend, then will this be a problem at your DC's christening, first birthday, etc? Are you NEVER going to invite your friend to anything because she once dated your brother?

Posted 8/29/09 4:43 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: What would you do? Shower related

Thank you ladies. What most of you ladies suggested is what thought I should do, which is tell my friend/the ex that as much as I really wanted her to be there, it is a weird situation because of my brother.

Oh and so I don't sound like a bad sis-my mom and dad made me swear I wouldn't say anything to him. Weird thing is that they are still FB friends, not that I think that means much. But I agree that I should probably tell him that I am still friends with her. I actually don't think that she would come to the shower anyway because she is very respectful of my family.

Posted 8/29/09 4:44 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Am I a brat? Shower related, disappointed... karacg 3/15/07 34 Pregnancy
Sorry..wedding related. Shower question. danielleandscott 3/2/07 11 Families Helping Families ™
Grrr, can I vent?? (Family/Shower related) Ambersmom 2/26/07 16 Families Helping Families ™
Wedding related sorry...Shower locations in Nassau beautyq115 2/7/07 14 Families Helping Families ™
shower related issue please read...LONG 04bride 7/5/06 5 Pregnancy
Sorry...Bridal Shower related luvsun27 6/2/06 21 Families Helping Families ™