what would you do?

Posted By Message

christy
Mommy of 2

Member since 5/05

6787 total posts

Name:
Christy

what would you do?

DD is 2.5 yrs old. We took her binky away 3 weeks ago. She cried for it, and still will ask from time to time. She used it for naps and bedtime. Well since I took it away her 2-3 hour daily nap has disappeared. I also have a 4 month old and I REALLY need her to nap! Would you give the binky back to get your toddler to nap again?

The fact that I am even asking this shows how desperate I am getting. Oh and bedtime is a nightmare too. I know have to lay in her bed with her to get her to fall asleep. If I don't stay in her bed all night she runs out and wakes all of us up.

Help a momma out!

Posted 4/30/10 8:08 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

dcl08
<3

Member since 4/07

3915 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

DD is 26 months and still using her binky for those reasons. She wont fall asleep without it and honestly i dont want to deal with the sleepless nights and fights over it. She only has it when shes sleepin so i dont see the harm. she falls asleep with it and once shes asleep she spits it out,

Posted 4/30/10 8:20 AM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

so glad you posted!! we are going through the same thing! DS will be 3 in june and we took the pacifier away 1.5 weeks ago. He has been fine with it and is still sleeping through the night, but his 2-3 hour naps are goneChat Icon so fustrating as i have a 10 week old too. the funny thing is, he goes to daycare 2 days a week and sleeps 2 hours without it b/c they never gave it to him for naps, so he got used to not having it their. but i guess at home it was a crutch fir naps. wish i had some advice for you! We wont give the paci back...I feel like he transitioned so well otherwise I dont want to go back and start over. so now i guess naps are over Chat Icon
good luckChat Icon

Message edited 2010-04-30 08:25:14.510000.

Posted 4/30/10 8:24 AM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

I would, because I value sleep over all else. Chat Icon

Posted 4/30/10 8:27 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: what would you do?

I wouldnt.....DS did the same thing when we took his away. It was TOUGH! He eventually went back to his regular napping schedule and is binky free. Hang in there!

Posted 4/30/10 8:36 AM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: what would you do?

Posted by eddiesmommy

I wouldnt.....DS did the same thing when we took his away. It was TOUGH! He eventually went back to his regular napping schedule and is binky free. Hang in there!



ITA- if you give in, she will never get rid of it! I know its hard..hang in there

Posted 4/30/10 9:54 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: what would you do?

I would not give her back her binky. She will learn to self soothe without it. You're already past the difficult stage.

As for the nap, it probably has less to do with the binky and more to do with her age.

Maybe introduce quiet time in her room - lights off, no sound, she can look at books.

I've been there with 2 under 2, it can be tough. Hang in there.Chat Icon

Posted 4/30/10 10:03 AM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: what would you do?

Dont give it back...otherwise she wont believe you next time you try to take it away for good...

I hate to tell you this...but when we took the binkie away at 2.5 we also said byebye to the naps!

She will only nap if she passes out on her own in the car or (rarely) on the couch!!!

But When I put my younger one down...My DD can sit through 10 Dora episodes if I let her...and she lays on the couch with a snack and her sippy cup of milk and she watches about 2 shows! This is down time for me, for her and quiet enough for her younger brother to sleep! It helps re-energize her without actually napping!

Does this sound like something your DD will do?

Posted 4/30/10 10:12 AM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: what would you do?

Dont give it back...otherwise she wont believe you next time you try to take it away for good...

I hate to tell you this...but when we took the binkie away at 2.5 we also said byebye to the naps!

She will only nap if she passes out on her own in the car or (rarely) on the couch!!!

But When I put my younger one down...My DD can sit through 10 Dora episodes if I let her...and she lays on the couch with a snack and her sippy cup of milk and she watches about 2 shows! This is down time for me, for her and quiet enough for her younger brother to sleep! It helps re-energize her without actually napping!

Does this sound like something your DD will do?

Posted 4/30/10 10:13 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: what would you do?

do not give it back, I know how hard it is when you are tired but I would not recommend that route

Posted 4/30/10 10:14 AM
 

btrflygrl
me and baby #3!

Member since 5/05

12013 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: what would you do?

don't give it back!!! My 4.5 and almost 3 yr old are STILL using it to fall asleep.

Alyson won't even try to fall asleep without her ba-ba.Chat Icon

Posted 4/30/10 10:46 AM
 

sugar-magnolia
Love my baby girls

Member since 6/07

2281 total posts

Name:
n

Re: what would you do?

DS had his till he was 3, and it never really bothered me. Maybe you can give it to her just for naps and bed? Meaning, Binky stays in the bed and only the bed or something like that.

Posted 4/30/10 9:56 PM