What would you do?

Posted By Message

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

What would you do?

My SIL is 16. She is having some major problems at her high school and is having some major anorexia issuesChat Icon She is begging her mother to come and live with us and go to school out here. DH and I are SO torn, we really don't have the room (we'd turn our dining room into a bedroom for her) but on the flip side, Staten Island isn't the place for her and she promised she'd go to therapy if she moved in with us.

She just stayed with us for the past 3 days and it was kinda nice and she was SUPER helpful with Christopher, but are we ready for a teenager?

MY mom says we should do it so that her anorexia doesn't get worse, but tell her if she isn't going to therapy and isn't eating, then she will have to go back to her mom....

Posted 10/8/07 9:37 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do?

That's a tough one. I'd probably try it out and see if she improves. So sorry she is going through this. It's so tough being a teenager. Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/07 9:39 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: What would you do?

If you are ready to take on that responsibility I say go for it. What does her mother say? Would she be willing to allow her to do that? Is she well behaved otherwise?

Posted 10/8/07 9:41 PM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: What would you do?

hmmmm...this is a really sticky situation. You don't want to downplay her mom's authority, or hurt her feelings. I mean, let's face it, how would we feel if our children told us they would rather live with someone else?

On the other hand...I have been a teenager with issues as well (haven't we allChat Icon ) and it could be good for her.

But there would have to be lots of rules. And you guys would really have to enforce them. You couldn't be her "friend" at that point, you'd have to be an authority figure.

My opinion, for what it's worth, is to see what her mom says. And if her mom says it's OK with her, then I would sit down with your DH and consider it.

Good luckChat Icon

Posted 10/8/07 9:41 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do?

Posted by Summerrluvv

If you are ready to take on that responsibility I say go for it. What does her mother say? Would she be willing to allow her to do that? Is she well behaved otherwise?



Her mother is kind of for it if it will help. It is so bad right now, she weighes 98lbs and literally she disappears if she turns sideways.

She is a good kid, in honors at school, she is a homebody, which would be nice.

And DH kind of feels like he owes it to his step mother, she helped him out a lot after his father died.Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/07 9:43 PM
 

MamaNDaddyof3
:)

Member since 5/05

7267 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: What would you do?

I would take her in if it were me ........maybe you can really make a difference in her life
she will probably be on her BEST behavior if you tell her she will have to go back with her mom if she doesnt behave
good luck whatever you decide

Posted 10/8/07 9:43 PM
 

luvsun27
Check out my cool glasses

Member since 5/05

8135 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: What would you do?

I would do it...it seems like it would be good for her and maybe starting over in a place where she doesn't know anyone and nobody knows about her issues (friends and such) would put her on the right track to recovery. She needs some guidance at this point in her life and if she feels that you are able to help, then as long as she follows your rules, I would do it. It would also give you a babysitter Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/07 9:48 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: What would you do?

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by Summerrluvv

If you are ready to take on that responsibility I say go for it. What does her mother say? Would she be willing to allow her to do that? Is she well behaved otherwise?



Her mother is kind of for it if it will help. It is so bad right now, she weighes 98lbs and literally she disappears if she turns sideways.

She is a good kid, in honors at school, she is a homebody, which would be nice.

And DH kind of feels like he owes it to his step mother, she helped him out a lot after his father died.Chat Icon



I would do it then! New environment, new friends, it could be really good for her Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/07 9:52 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: What would you do?

Posted by pmpkn087

But there would have to be lots of rules. And you guys would really have to enforce them. You couldn't be her "friend" at that point, you'd have to be an authority figure.



I agree with this.

One rule would be if she doesn't go to therapy or gain weight, then she gets shipped home - no ifs, ands or buts.

I don't think it's fair to make you think that you can "save" her. You can certainly encourage her but, as someone who has been down a similar route as a teenager, I can tell you it is completely up to her.

Would you be going to therapy with her? I would say this needs to be an individual & group effort. She can't drive so that means you're taking her.

Good luck on your decision.Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/07 9:54 PM
 

avamamma
My Girl

Member since 7/06

3395 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: What would you do?

I am on the other side with this one.

You are a new Mom with a whole new life, with its own set of challenges. This girl needs to be an adults main focus right now.

Anorexia is a serious disease. I had an anorexic friend, and I can tell you that change of scenery will not cure her problem. Even if she promises to "be on her best behavior", this is a disease, and she cannot stop her behaviors that easily. IMHO, I would offer to let her visit as often as she wants, but I think that this is an issue best handled by the parents.

As much as we as women and Mothers want to help other people, I think that you would be helping your sister-in-law the most by encouraging her to start treatment and letting her parent(s)- parent her and you can continue to be a loving and supporting SIL. Good Luck!

Posted 10/8/07 10:16 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: What would you do?

I am on the other side with this one.



I agree with avamomma completely.

Why will she not stay home and attend therapy? Is there a problem at home with her parents that could be fueling the situation?

Anorexia is a disease and a mental disorder. You have your own family now and need to focus on them. And while living with you may make her happy for a few weeks, ultimately, living with you is not what is going to "make her better". I think you should be a support system for her and even offer to let her come as often as she would like, even maybe stay on the weekends and help with the baby, but I think she belongs at home with her parents unless it is an unhealthy environment for her.

Posted 10/8/07 10:31 PM
 

dooodles
When you wish upon a star

Member since 5/05

11997 total posts

Name:
Because 2 people fell in love

Re: What would you do?

Are there issues at home that she is not facing with her Mom that is the underlying problem maybe?

If you think you could handle the responsibility I think it would be wonderful of you to try it to help her out. If she is at a desperate place in her life I would think she would benefit from knowing you guys are supportive and hopefully she would flourish. BUT as the previous posters have mentioned, there should be ground rules especially since you do have a newborn at home. Do you think she was super helpful to butter you up or is she always like that?

Can you agree to it on a temporary basis or is that difficult to do with school? And if she does attend therapy on a regular basis and shows she is getting healthy then you know she is serious and can stay.

Good luck and please let us know the outcome

Posted 10/8/07 10:37 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: What would you do?

I think I would do it, as Im that type of person and I think you are too. It could really change her life.

I think you could at least "try" and keep everyone aware that its a trial run to see if it will work.

Worst that happens...she goes back and back to her school.

Best case scenario-it all works out great!

Good for you guys for even considering it! Chat Icon

Posted 10/8/07 11:24 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: What would you do?

I know I am in the minority here but I think she really needs a treatment center right now. Anorexia is one of the most difficult disorders to treat and even as a professional who deals with these issues I would be very hesitant to have her move in with me if she was my relative. I know this sounds horrible but this disorder tends to make the person extremely manipulative since the fear to eat can be so intense. Even if she is a wonderful person, the nature of the disorder makes it hard to set limits and rules and have them followed without her being closely monitored.

I would really sit down with my whole family and talk about the options with a family doctor to make sure this is the best senario for her and YOU.

Please FM if you need helpChat Icon

Posted 10/8/07 11:25 PM