What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

Posted By Message

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

DD is nearly 4, goes to preschool. Class is mostly 3 & 4-year-olds.

Randomly, this morning DD tells me "don't talk to strangers." I agreed, said it was very true. She repeated it. I agreed again, and asked who told her that. She said "Miss XXX" (her teacher. Fine...very good.

Then, she tells me....

"because they (the stranger) will take children to their home and won't let them go"

Um, WHAT? I think to myself....must have been an older kid in the class who added that part....ask her who said that. She matter-of-factly repeated her teacher's name.

I asked her to repeat what the teacher said, and she repeated the above, word-for-word.

Now, I know the world we live in, I've briefly discussed Stranger Danger with DD. But don't you think that is VERY odd & inappropriate to tell a bunch of 3 & 4-year-olds?

I mean, I can see a time & place for scare tactics...older kids, not listening & running off, etc. But clearly NOT what was happening during CLASS at a PRESCHOOL.

Thoughts?

Posted 3/22/11 8:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

RobinG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/08

595 total posts

Name:
Robin

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

hmmm it does sound odd. I am a kindergarten teacher and we talk about strangers. A lot of times kids will say something like that and it is my job to kind of change the direction of the conversation. It can;t hurt to ask the teacher about it so you have a better idea of how they are teaching about stranger danger!

Posted 3/22/11 8:31 PM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

Yeah, I guess I consider that odd. As a teacher (granted, not of pre-schoolers), I would never go to that extreme.

However, just today my own almost 4 year old had some coins in her hand. I am PETRIFIED of her trying to give tiny objects to her 5 month old brother. So I told her, "Don't you ever, EVER give him money. Don't even show it to him. If you give it to him, he could put it in his mouth and choke. He could choke and die and then we'd have no more baby Patrick."

I wanted her to know it was THAT serious. And if it scared her, I am fine with that. As a teacher though, I wouldn't overstep my boundaries like that with someone else's kid.

Posted 3/22/11 8:49 PM
 

Eireann
Two ladies and a gentleman!

Member since 5/05

12165 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

I do want to add though, that I probably wouldn't mind if my DDs' teachers told them that. I certainly would not address it with the teacher. I would clarify those statements to my daughters though and hopefully start a conversation about the subject.

Message edited 2011-03-22 20:53:02.797000.

Posted 3/22/11 8:51 PM
 

BargainMama
LIF Adult

Member since 5/09

15660 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

Posted by Eireann

Yeah, I guess I consider that odd. As a teacher (granted, not of pre-schoolers), I would never go to that extreme.

However, just today my own almost 4 year old had some coins in her hand. I am PETRIFIED of her trying to give tiny objects to her 5 month old brother. So I told her, "Don't you ever, EVER give him money. Don't even show it to him. If you give it to him, he could put it in his mouth and choke. He could choke and die and then we'd have no more baby Patrick."

I wanted her to know it was THAT serious. And if it scared her, I am fine with that. As a teacher though, I wouldn't overstep my boundaries like that with someone else's kid.



I say stuff like this too. "If you run out into the street, you can get hit by a car and die". I also say not to talk to strangers because they might take you home and you will never see your family again. Yes it's extreme, but it gets the point across.

I personally wouldn't have an issue if my child's teacher said that. I don't like to sugar coat stuff like this. Especially since sooo many victims are lured by dogs, candy, etc.

Posted 3/22/11 8:55 PM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

Posted by Eireann

I do want to add though, that I probably wouldn't mind if my DDs' teachers told them that. I certainly would not address it with the teacher. I would clarify those statements to my daughters though and hopefully start a conversation about the subject.



You wouldn't bring it up to the teacher? I was seriously considering doing so tomorrow. Not in a confrontational way, but really just a "so DD told me you talked about stranger danger, which I am very appreciative of, and said XYZ, which caught me off guard a bit" or something like that. Totally not attacking the teacher, but I was definitely surprised that it was discussed like that to 3 & 4 year olds, you know?

Posted 3/22/11 8:56 PM
 

janedoe
3 GIRLS!!!!

Member since 8/09

3184 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

I honestly do not think the teacher said anything that bad. I know when DD is old enough to understand, I will definitely tell her something along the same lines.
I know when I have been out with my niece who is 4 and when she was 3, if she walked away from me - I would firmly get down to her level and tell her never ever to walk away from me because a stranger could come and take her and we would never ever see her again. Yes it is extreme but like others said it gets the point across.
If you want to ask the teacher exactly what was said just so you get the "entire" story straight ( 4 year old can leave out details) I would just ask her but I would not be upset with her (that is my opinion)

Posted 3/22/11 9:02 PM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

I wouldn't have a problem if the teacher said that. Yes, what she said could scare the kids, but why sugarcoat stranger danger? At home a parent can choose to discuss the subject further with the child, and clarify/reassure.

Posted 3/22/11 9:07 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

Eh...I dont know what is the right or wrong thing to tell them about stranger danger.

I've been telling TJ when we go to the stores that he has to stay by me otherwise someone is going to take him home and he will never see his mommy and daddy again. I dont know if its the right thing but I am trying to put a little fear in him so he stays by me, which he usually does anyway. But sometimes he likes to play hide and seek Chat Icon

Posted 3/22/11 9:08 PM
 

PhillyGirl
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/09

890 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

I personally wouldn't say anything to the teacher.

Posted 3/22/11 9:13 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

I've used scare tactics myself but in the circumstances that you described-DD ran away from me in an airport, tried to not hold my hand in a parking lot. So, I think there is a time and a place for it.

I would be curious what prompted that discussion and I would probably ask the teacher about it in the way you stated.

Message edited 2011-03-22 21:27:28.880000.

Posted 3/22/11 9:13 PM
 

Daisy07
Love my girls :)

Member since 7/05

1543 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

Hmm, this is a tough one. I totally agree that this is a discussion that definitely needs the scare tactics, but I also feel its a conversation that should be done by the parents. (the scare tactics portion).
That said, I don't think I'd say anything to the teacher.

Posted 3/22/11 9:17 PM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

Posted by Daisy07

Hmm, this is a tough one. I totally agree that this is a discussion that definitely needs the scare tactics, but I also feel its a conversation that should be done by the parents. (the scare tactics portion).
That said, I don't think I'd say anything to the teacher.



Yeah, that's the other thing...I feel like if anyone's going to use scare tactics it should be us, the parents.

Posted 3/22/11 9:19 PM
 

ME75

Member since 10/06

4563 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

i can understand why you feel the way your do...
my DD is very shy and reserved and is super good at staying by me etc...she is not a big people person as it is.
she is very people-shy and i don't know if she would be able to understand that the lady behind us on the Target line IS a stranger but is not out to harm her or take her...
she is definitely the type who might be literally freaked out by EVERY stranger we encounter...i could imagine talking about it with her all day long-trying to assure her that not everyone is bad.
so i can see how it can be hard with this age, as they are SO literal in what they hear.

Message edited 2011-03-22 21:36:41.267000.

Posted 3/22/11 9:36 PM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

That is definitely odd. It would not sit right with me at all. I can appreciate where the teacher was coming from (I think), but as others have said, I feel that such extreme "scare tactics" are YOUR responsibility as her parents, not the teacher's. That is your decision as to whether or not you want to use scare tactics with her. I completely agree that the teacher overstepped her bounds and I think you are completely justified in approaching her about it. Like you said, not confrontationally or in an accusatory way, just wanting to know exactly what was being discussed in the class. And I think it would be perfectly fine for you to voice your opinion on her using those type of scare tactics in the classroom.

Posted 3/22/11 9:40 PM
 

LAMGAJ28
.

Member since 10/05

6039 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this apparent conversation re: Stranger Danger

I'd not have a problem at all with this. The more they hear it in my opinion, the better.
But I feel that as a parent, you should speak to your DC's teacher and tell her what she said and you were wondering as to why she said that and take it from there since this is something that bothered you.
I got with my CC rewards a video about Stranger Safety by John Walsh. The audio is not the greatest so you have to keep lowering or putting up the volume because of the different situations that are presented in the video. I showed him when he was 3yrs old but I think he was still too young to understand. He's 4 now and I play it once a week so he starts understanding. It gives different scenarios and ask children what they'd do and then show them what they should do and whom are strangers, whom are safe and who are "kind of know" people but still strangers. I recently went to the pharmacy to pick up a medicine for him and he was with me. The technician said hi to him as he was trying to be friendly in a nice way. My DS did not say hi and look at me. I said to him that it was ok to say hi because mommy is right there with him otherwise is a no-no.
I don't see it as a scare tactic but trying to give them awareness. And for me personally like I said before, the more they hear it, the better.

Posted 3/22/11 9:53 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to Rachel's worry post... STRANGER DANGER?? 4monkeys 2/21/07 5 Parenting
What do you do when a complete stranger interrupts your conversation with a store clerk? curliegirl 6/5/07 5 Families Helping Families ™
elevator conversation at work with complete stranger wannabemom 8/21/08 6 Pregnancy
Stranger Danger - when to start having the talk. MsMBV 4/5/10 4 Parenting
Stranger danger pinkandblue 5/25/09 2 Parenting
Have to teach "Stranger danger" JenniferEver 4/2/08 8 Families Helping Families ™