Would you spank your DC for something like this?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes 2 4.76%
No 36 85.71%
Other(please explain) 4 9.52%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

What do you think about this?

Posted By Message

Karebaby
Precious

Member since 10/06

5304 total posts

Name:
Karyn

What do you think about this?

I have a little situation with my SIL. Let me explain and see what you think.

Okay. So my DD Jayde is 2 and a half almost, and she is in this stage where she is wanting to touch everyone. She hugs every kid she sees, and yes, sometimes she will push a little. Not shove or anything just a little push. SO, my niece is just over one, and walking well. We hang out with my SIL and their family almost every weekend, since we live so close. Well my DD being much bigger than my niece will try to hug my niece and half the time she knocks her down and my niece starts screaming. ANd my DD has pushed her over twice, and every time she does it, DH or I will pick her up and tell her it is not okay to push people or knock them down and we make her say sorry, which she does EVERY time. SO last time this happened, my SIL went off and said we don't watch DD well enough Chat Icon and said we need to start spanking her because she is the worst 2 year old she has ever seenChat Icon Chat Icon .

Basically, what I am asking you is, if you were me would you spank your 2 and a half year old for something like that? I really do not want to spank her, I don't feel comfortable with it(although I was spanked as a child), I just would like some honest feedback. Thanks.

Posted 12/13/07 2:49 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: What do you think about this?

I don't believe in the concept of hitting a child to teach them that it's not OK to hit..... Chat Icon

Kids that age are stronger than the realize, and they haven't figured out how to use their bodies. As long as it isn't vicious, or in anger, I would continue along the lines you are doing. You may want to implement time-outs, but I think you're doing the right thing. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/13/07 2:52 PM
 

bicosi
life is a carousel

Member since 7/07

14956 total posts

Name:
M

Re: What do you think about this?

Your SIL would be lucky that the kids are around or I'd fly on top of her so quick. How DARE she say such a thing.

IMO, what you just described is perfectly normal age appropriate behavior.

Anytime any of my kids have been pushed or hugged over by an older child, I UNDERSTAND that this is normal and that the child meant no harm in it, MUCH less if it's my neice/nephew.

This would so enrage me!

Chat Icon

Posted 12/13/07 2:53 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: What do you think about this?

Posted by bicosi

Your SIL would be lucky that the kids are around or I'd fly on top of her so quick. How DARE she say such a thing.

IMO, what you just described is perfectly normal age appropriate behavior.

Anytime any of my kids have been pushed or hugged over by an older child, I UNDERSTAND that this is normal and that the child meant no harm in it, MUCH less if it's my neice/nephew.

This would so enrage me!

Chat Icon



I agree completely!

Posted 12/13/07 2:54 PM
 

Smileyd17
kids

Member since 5/05

20997 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: What do you think about this?

No...you are doing what you feel is best for your DC and the way you put it to your DD seems like you are doing the right thing....and spanking is not always the best option!

I think it was a little wrong of her to even say such a thing!

I have nephews who are super rough with my dd. My SIL watches and just tries to teach them to be as easy as possible. I cant get mad at that...they are kids.

Posted 12/13/07 2:54 PM
 

MelToddJulia
Love my Family!

Member since 7/05

29064 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: What do you think about this?

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by bicosi

Your SIL would be lucky that the kids are around or I'd fly on top of her so quick. How DARE she say such a thing.

IMO, what you just described is perfectly normal age appropriate behavior.

Anytime any of my kids have been pushed or hugged over by an older child, I UNDERSTAND that this is normal and that the child meant no harm in it, MUCH less if it's my neice/nephew.

This would so enrage me!

Chat Icon



I agree completely!





I agree also! Hitting a child doesn't correct the problem!

Posted 12/13/07 2:57 PM
 

LInative
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

1977 total posts

Name:
Cassie

Re: What do you think about this?

I wouldn't spank if you're not comf. with it. I would pay closer attention though when the kids are together knowing there's an issue w/SIL.

Posted 12/13/07 2:58 PM
 

Belladonna219
HOT MAMA

Member since 2/07

2642 total posts

Name:
Belladonna219

Re: What do you think about this?

Your SIL was a little out of line. My 4yr niece and nephew are a little rough with my DS but if I dont like their behavior I remove my DS from the situation. I would never tell somebody how they need to reprimand or punish their child.

Posted 12/13/07 3:00 PM
 

Karebaby
Precious

Member since 10/06

5304 total posts

Name:
Karyn

Re: What do you think about this?

Posted by bicosi

Your SIL would be lucky that the kids are around or I'd fly on top of her so quick. How DARE she say such a thing.

IMO, what you just described is perfectly normal age appropriate behavior.

Anytime any of my kids have been pushed or hugged over by an older child, I UNDERSTAND that this is normal and that the child meant no harm in it, MUCH less if it's my neice/nephew.

This would so enrage me!

Chat Icon



Thank you. That is what I was thinking, its just the age she is at. It just really upset me b/c SIL has older children, so she should know that it is just a stage, it's not like my kid is rotten.

Posted 12/13/07 3:01 PM
 

Mrs. Patticakes
SPREAD KINDNESS

Member since 9/06

17330 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this?

You are absolutely doing the right thing. Spanking is NOT warranted here...nor do I really think it ever is. Your DC is not being malicious at all, she is just being loving and overzealous-perfectly normal for her age! What I would do is spend less of my weekend with SIL.

Posted 12/13/07 3:02 PM
 

vegalady
Love my family

Member since 6/06

4546 total posts

Name:
SNV

Re: What do you think about this?

I would not spank her for this reason. She is not trying to be violent she is just hugging but doesnt know her own strength. Now if she was pushing people down for no reason and kept doing it after saying no then I would say a little tap on the toosh would be ok. But it doesnt seem like this is the case.

Posted 12/13/07 3:11 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: What do you think about this?

Absolutely not! It certainly doesnt sound like your DD did it purposely anyway. Jeez! I understand nobody wants the baby to get hurt but it's not even like your DD is very big herself. I still wouldnt justify the spanking but if your DD was bigger - 5 or 7 and was knocking your niece over, it would be a totally different thing. I think what you and your DH are doing is fine. Please dont tell me your SIL suggested you should spank your DD??? How could she say that other stuff to you too about your DD being the worst 2 year old she's ever seen. (a) She's a 2 year old! (b) How can you even say that to someone? I have a 7 year old niece who is very high maintenence to say the least but I'd never never say those words to my SIL. If I had something to say - and really is it my business to tell her what to do (but that's another topic), I'd approach it nicer. (c) She must not get out a lot if an over excited and affectionate 2 year old is her idea of a "bad kid". This calls for a: Chat Icon

Believe me, I think kids need to be disciplined when doing something they shouldn't be doing or reigned in when over-excited and someone is at risk of getting hurt (happens a lot when my kids get together with their cousins too) but speak like that seriously peeves me....

Posted 12/13/07 3:24 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this?

I don't think it's anyone's place to tell a parent to spank a child. I would, however keep a better eye on her, even if it's to prove a point that you are.

From my own experience, spanking is for SEVERE things like running into a parking lot. Accidentally pushing someone over while hugging them is not a spankable offense.Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-12-13 15:31:27.053000.

Posted 12/13/07 3:30 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this?

Absolutely NOT! How is spanking a child going to teach that child NOT to be physical with others???Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/13/07 3:33 PM
 

2BEANS
wow time is going fast.

Member since 9/07

16106 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: What do you think about this?

If your dd did on purpose after you just told her not too then maybe a little spank, but that doesnt seem the case. So i say no to spanking her.

Posted 12/13/07 3:37 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this?

She is two. Thats what two year olds do to other children. She needs to get a grip!

Posted 12/13/07 3:39 PM
 

Karebaby
Precious

Member since 10/06

5304 total posts

Name:
Karyn

Re: What do you think about this?

Thnk you guys for your opinions. I think I am going to continue on as I am WITHOUT spanking. If my SIL says anything about it again, I am going to try to get up the nerve to tell her I don't need her parenting tipsChat Icon

Posted 12/13/07 3:40 PM
 

juanvi
Get Out!

Member since 10/06

4463 total posts

Name:
Christina

Re: What do you think about this?

i wouldn't spank her. she doesn't mean it

Posted 12/13/07 3:41 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this?

Your SIL is out of line.
My DS is almost 11 Months old. I have a 3 year old nephew who has been hugging DS all year..
If I see that my nephew is a little too rough, I simply remove DS from the situation and just tell my nephew, "Ok. That's enough. You have to go softer."
If he wants to hug him again, I sit on the floor with DS and remind my nephew to be "Gentle".

Spanking will not solve the problem.

Posted 12/13/07 4:35 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think about this?

Your SIL is SO out of line!

I have a very similar situation. My neice is 10 months older than my DD (20 months). Since DD was 8 months, she shares a babysitter wiht my neice. Well my neice has pushed DD, pulled her hair and hit her. When DD gets annoyed or frustrated, she takes it out on DD. My sister used to cry, yell at my neice, put her in time out. None of it worked. Its part of being a toddler, they get. frustrated and can't express themselves. I finally told my sister that its totally normal and she is helping to make DD a tougher cookie.

i can't imagine telling my sister to watch my neice more- what would that do? It happens in a split second. And spanking, you can't teach a toddler by spanking. That is just wrong. They don't always understand what they are doing wrong and why they are getting spanked. personally, I think its very cruel to spank a 2 year old .

And telling you that your daughter is the worst 2 year old she has ever seen is just mean. Wait until her DD turns 2! She'll learn.

Message edited 2007-12-13 17:24:27.200000.

Posted 12/13/07 5:23 PM