What do you think?

Posted By Message

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

What do you think?

Hypothetical, for a friend...

She's 27, dating a guy who is 31. They met 2 weeks before my daughter was born, so just a little over 11 months now. This is her first serious relationship, and she's head over heels.

They moved in together a little over 2 months ago, and before he moved in she told him she wasn't comfortable with him moving in unless he proposes shortly thereafter.

Last week she freaked out, asked him if he's "thinking" about the proposal, and he said, honestly, no. He says he has too much on his plate now to even think about a proposal - he has a very stressful job with long hours and his father's health is failing. She's convinced he's making excuses and that means he'll never propose to her.

I told her she's being a little unreasonable, and that demanding a proposal after only 11 months of dating is expecting a little too much... now, granted, DH and I were engaged within a year of dating, but I know that we moved VERY quickly, and we were also older at the time...

What do you think?

Message edited 2006-08-21 09:13:12.773000.

Posted 8/21/06 9:12 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Wendy
Wheeee!

Member since 5/05

13736 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

I think it's kinda ridiculous that after 9 months in her first serious relationship she moved in and gave an ultimatum.

Message edited 2006-08-21 09:14:22.223000.

Posted 8/21/06 9:14 AM
 

Elbee
Zanzibar

Member since 5/05

10767 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: What do you think?

I think she needs to enjoy the relationship and relax a bit. But from the other side of the coin, if she told him this before they moved in, maybe she should think about what her limit is (6 months? a year?) to be living with someone without being engaged.

Posted 8/21/06 9:17 AM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: What do you think?

if she was really that uncomfortable with him moving in before an engagement, she never should have let him move in, IMO.

hubby and I were engaged within 6 months of knowing each other, so I really can't comment on the timing.

Posted 8/21/06 9:17 AM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: What do you think?

I think giving anyone an ultimatum is bad news for the relationship. Tell her to back off a little...if its meant to be...it will happen!

Posted 8/21/06 9:17 AM
 

islandersgirl74
Love Being A Mommy!

Member since 6/06

5804 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: What do you think?

IMO..I dont think she should have moved in just because "he said he was going to propose". Feelings can change and sometimes guys will say anything at the time just to make you happy. Its an awkward situation. Sometimes you just have to let things happen. Demanding a proposal just beacuse she wants one may make things worse in the end.

Posted 8/21/06 9:18 AM
 

dandr10199
Grace is growing up too fast!

Member since 10/05

11561 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: What do you think?

Posted by Karen

if she was really that uncomfortable with him moving in before an engagement, she never should have let him move in, IMO..



I completely agree.

Posted 8/21/06 9:19 AM
 

BabyAvocado
Happy New Year

Member since 5/05

17334 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

She shouldn't have moved in with him with the condition that he'd propose soon after unless she was willing to accept that "soon after" in her mind could potentially be way different than "soon after" in his mind.

Given what he's going through (if he's not just making excuses) she should try to be more patient and understanding with him. It's too soon for ultimatums - if that's what she leaning towards.

Posted 8/21/06 9:19 AM
 

janet
WITH LOVE MY ANGEL MISS YOU!!!

Member since 5/05

12823 total posts

Name:
janet

Re: What do you think?

Posted by Karen

if she was really that uncomfortable with him moving in before an engagement, she never should have let him move in, IMO.
QUOTE]

this i have to agree withChat Icon

Posted 8/21/06 9:19 AM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

I think she is alsot being unreasonable. Maybe she should give some time to get adjusted with living with him. Its a big step and even though she might be comforable with it, it might be difficult for him and I am sure that a proposal might be the last thing on his mind right now if his father is ill and I think she should be understanding of that. Just because she hasnt proposed doesnt mean that he doesnt love her.

Posted 8/21/06 9:20 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: What do you think?

Ok, thanks... that's exactly what I was thinking, that she was really pushing the issue too hard and that it isn't at all unreasonable for a proposal to wait for more time than just 11 months, but I have a feeling she wasn't very happy with my response. She called me totally frantic, like "can you BELIEVE what he's doing?" and my response was, um, yes, I think what he's asking is reasonable... if he has given you eveyr assurance (which he has) that he does want to spend the rest of his life with you, but that this just isn't the right time, then you have to have the faith and trust in him that he's telling you the truth, and if you don't, then THAT'S a problem that should absolutely be addressed before there's any talk of a proposal...

I think she's a little overwhelmed because all of her friends are now married or engaged, and her two closest friends were engaged within a year (myself included)...

Posted 8/21/06 9:28 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: What do you think?

I think she's being unreasonable. If she didn't want to move in w/o a proposal, she should have waited to move in. I understand they're not young kids, but 9 months of dating is definitely not in the range where an ultimatum is in order. Also, if the man is having a difficult time at his job and his father is ill, why does she even expect it from him right now? At least he's being honest with her by saying "no, I have too much on my plate to think of that." It's her fault that she moved in with him without the proposal, you can't control another person. I think the dad being ill is a good enough reason to not be an "excuse."

Also, for all she knows, he's just saying he hasn't thought about it but he does have ideas and a plan.

I'm a little younger, but I was dating FH for more than 4 years before we got engaged, and I didn't even really expect it bcause we both had a lot going on and he was in Sr year of college, etc.

After 9 months, you don't always really completely know a person, and I don't think it's time to pull out the ultimatum. She's being unreasonable.

Posted 8/21/06 9:30 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: What do you think?

I think if you have to DEMAND something from your significant other, something is off.....especially a marriage proposal....that is something he will do if and when he wants to.

Posted 8/21/06 9:32 AM
 

Tah-wee-ZAH
Kisses

Member since 5/05

15952 total posts

Name:

Re: What do you think?

Posted by Karen

if she was really that uncomfortable with him moving in before an engagement, she never should have let him move in, IMO.

hubby and I were engaged within 6 months of knowing each other, so I really can't comment on the timing.



I agree. DH and I were engaged about 15 months after meeting but it would have been sooner. He wanted to wait until his divorce (that was years in the making) was official.

I was 33 when I got engaged and NEVER lived with anyone. My motto has always been...
"No tickey, no shirty". DH knew... no ring, no date... no roomate!

JMO, but this happens a lot... when people live together one person always wants to get married and sometimes the other just doesn't.

Posted 8/21/06 9:35 AM